{ "protocol": "Assignments permute real frozen text states; hidden pairs are used only to place the true assignment in the ranking. The energy terms are the cross-modal relation MSE and conditional KL; the language-only terms of the falsified free-particle energy are permutation-invariant on this space.", "meta": { "dataset": "flickr30k", "split": "test", "samples": 1000, "text_mode": "orbit_mean", "rows": [ 25, 34, 51, 89, 97, 124, 133, 134, 137, 199, 219, 222, 228, 246, 259, 279, 304, 318, 340, 395, 434, 472, 487, 520, 539, 565, 615, 654, 661, 670, 734, 748, 754, 760, 828, 856, 887, 906, 917, 972, 973, 1023, 1030, 1044, 1072, 1117, 1196, 1202, 1206, 1284, 1305, 1306, 1310, 1343, 1358, 1390, 1401, 1417, 1480, 1576, 1594, 1610, 1646, 1723, 1771, 1821, 1833, 1895, 1981, 1983, 1984, 1987, 2044, 2054, 2103, 2112, 2113, 2124, 2130, 2131, 2139, 2161, 2180, 2197, 2260, 2265, 2319, 2330, 2410, 2412, 2429, 2433, 2458, 2523, 2551, 2572, 2600, 2615, 2678, 2690, 2788, 2803, 2848, 2851, 2906, 2909, 2955, 2956, 3008, 3078, 3082, 3087, 3097, 3109, 3130, 3162, 3245, 3412, 3437, 3451, 3459, 3476, 3500, 3539, 3648, 3701, 3703, 3724, 3771, 3774, 3826, 3834, 3951, 3972, 4007, 4027, 4028, 4041, 4313, 4317, 4343, 4367, 4402, 4452, 4501, 4510, 4556, 4562, 4663, 4686, 4748, 4801, 4816, 4879, 4881, 4882, 4902, 4942, 4981, 5016, 5056, 5160, 5171, 5240, 5261, 5327, 5330, 5343, 5441, 5541, 5580, 5581, 5595, 5618, 5621, 5701, 5724, 5743, 5760, 5763, 5767, 5807, 5835, 5854, 5867, 5881, 5947, 5964, 5970, 5989, 6002, 6005, 6008, 6031, 6067, 6068, 6078, 6127, 6192, 6242, 6250, 6258, 6283, 6300, 6306, 6334, 6376, 6486, 6532, 6549, 6645, 6661, 6694, 6733, 6781, 6796, 6830, 6921, 7153, 7170, 7263, 7492, 7507, 7542, 7549, 7581, 7584, 7597, 7631, 7639, 7682, 7702, 7739, 7750, 7791, 7874, 7881, 7909, 7912, 7921, 7962, 7973, 7986, 7996, 8015, 8023, 8054, 8070, 8079, 8084, 8175, 8185, 8199, 8225, 8267, 8274, 8280, 8322, 8337, 8362, 8364, 8412, 8427, 8486, 8519, 8528, 8554, 8561, 8611, 8631, 8654, 8674, 8708, 8740, 8766, 8776, 8811, 8831, 8870, 8872, 8903, 8940, 8982, 8993, 9013, 9039, 9042, 9058, 9065, 9074, 9088, 9223, 9241, 9242, 9266, 9274, 9285, 9308, 9323, 9328, 9342, 9354, 9492, 9502, 9506, 9519, 9531, 9572, 9579, 9592, 9598, 9609, 9673, 9736, 9776, 9797, 9803, 9885, 9888, 9908, 9911, 9959, 9978, 9979, 10005, 10010, 10088, 10097, 10106, 10124, 10171, 10235, 10239, 10242, 10287, 10330, 10376, 10379, 10390, 10469, 10490, 10499, 10575, 10577, 10620, 10629, 10663, 10666, 10691, 10692, 10693, 10732, 10788, 10858, 10920, 10925, 11086, 11124, 11137, 11152, 11207, 11219, 11234, 11239, 11278, 11283, 11363, 11374, 11400, 11423, 11466, 11514, 11516, 11618, 11624, 11656, 11747, 11890, 11897, 11906, 11914, 11939, 11963, 11979, 12030, 12053, 12058, 12077, 12084, 12133, 12178, 12184, 12212, 12245, 12293, 12305, 12334, 12356, 12366, 12375, 12402, 12417, 12427, 12441, 12475, 12486, 12508, 12542, 12706, 12757, 12782, 12813, 12853, 12865, 12902, 12927, 12947, 12949, 12969, 12994, 13085, 13135, 13170, 13197, 13276, 13302, 13388, 13417, 13516, 13543, 13566, 13580, 13629, 13648, 13650, 13724, 13744, 13770, 13785, 13837, 13916, 13977, 13990, 13992, 14042, 14048, 14072, 14117, 14134, 14164, 14221, 14231, 14260, 14316, 14332, 14333, 14337, 14434, 14453, 14479, 14490, 14495, 14558, 14570, 14582, 14596, 14599, 14626, 14690, 14721, 14736, 14773, 14786, 14796, 14832, 14841, 14941, 14974, 14989, 15004, 15020, 15047, 15061, 15067, 15077, 15138, 15176, 15186, 15219, 15309, 15358, 15374, 15410, 15412, 15448, 15457, 15556, 15588, 15592, 15650, 15674, 15759, 15774, 15792, 15809, 15834, 15875, 15878, 15974, 16004, 16010, 16018, 16048, 16049, 16063, 16070, 16090, 16124, 16191, 16199, 16347, 16381, 16395, 16416, 16421, 16455, 16458, 16532, 16600, 16631, 16638, 16715, 16739, 16773, 16810, 16871, 16880, 16888, 16938, 16989, 16992, 16996, 17031, 17037, 17045, 17057, 17071, 17109, 17121, 17177, 17194, 17202, 17208, 17250, 17338, 17346, 17347, 17376, 17468, 17483, 17497, 17510, 17533, 17573, 17603, 17615, 17630, 17652, 17655, 17661, 17669, 17673, 17708, 17714, 17731, 17733, 17750, 17772, 17822, 17823, 17903, 17933, 17940, 17945, 17963, 17978, 17983, 17997, 18028, 18061, 18146, 18155, 18250, 18310, 18318, 18418, 18419, 18425, 18426, 18448, 18499, 18532, 18584, 18666, 18723, 18731, 18764, 18820, 18979, 18994, 18998, 19005, 19027, 19037, 19071, 19075, 19122, 19162, 19174, 19247, 19263, 19277, 19348, 19354, 19356, 19373, 19384, 19435, 19471, 19478, 19508, 19523, 19545, 19555, 19609, 19624, 19639, 19643, 19724, 19738, 19772, 19830, 19834, 19838, 19857, 19867, 19896, 19910, 19929, 20005, 20016, 20071, 20103, 20139, 20154, 20229, 20240, 20248, 20297, 20302, 20390, 20448, 20457, 20459, 20507, 20562, 20592, 20640, 20656, 20682, 20709, 20740, 20821, 20832, 20858, 20891, 20898, 20932, 20934, 20946, 20981, 21067, 21105, 21121, 21127, 21187, 21219, 21222, 21301, 21335, 21381, 21423, 21498, 21510, 21530, 21544, 21580, 21597, 21635, 21696, 21725, 21764, 21778, 21799, 21900, 21996, 22042, 22067, 22078, 22098, 22115, 22118, 22145, 22163, 22193, 22223, 22254, 22258, 22317, 22327, 22334, 22339, 22341, 22383, 22387, 22389, 22419, 22425, 22440, 22476, 22478, 22548, 22554, 22594, 22613, 22651, 22678, 22751, 22755, 22776, 22778, 22788, 22835, 22847, 22860, 22865, 22870, 22886, 22892, 22953, 22956, 22968, 22994, 22998, 23006, 23065, 23070, 23091, 23098, 23099, 23107, 23115, 23128, 23144, 23164, 23205, 23240, 23252, 23280, 23345, 23346, 23351, 23502, 23509, 23560, 23617, 23686, 23713, 23724, 23756, 23758, 23790, 23827, 23850, 23863, 23957, 23965, 23986, 24043, 24071, 24095, 24145, 24169, 24181, 24244, 24271, 24277, 24315, 24327, 24350, 24425, 24457, 24476, 24495, 24517, 24521, 24535, 24545, 24624, 24777, 24806, 24829, 24836, 24846, 24863, 24974, 25058, 25069, 25133, 25149, 25188, 25235, 25315, 25316, 25376, 25456, 25470, 25479, 25494, 25516, 25525, 25541, 25554, 25583, 25626, 25637, 25753, 25763, 25776, 25795, 25819, 25820, 25918, 25952, 25986, 25987, 26015, 26039, 26049, 26050, 26084, 26094, 26133, 26142, 26160, 26256, 26352, 26366, 26370, 26377, 26393, 26407, 26411, 26419, 26440, 26446, 26512, 26536, 26598, 26615, 26618, 26645, 26682, 26697, 26806, 26843, 26846, 26906, 26922, 26946, 26969, 26982, 26984, 26998, 27025, 27048, 27168, 27238, 27240, 27250, 27303, 27321, 27391, 27457, 27495, 27636, 27671, 27682, 27726, 27733, 27804, 27817, 27830, 27863, 27872, 27988, 28005, 28026, 28041, 28042, 28057, 28063, 28066, 28067, 28068, 28113, 28123, 28139, 28142, 28240, 28246, 28328, 28389, 28470, 28480, 28570, 28582, 28605, 28661, 28662, 28694, 28767, 28819, 28827, 28873, 28879, 28885, 28893, 28923, 28955, 28966, 28978, 29010, 29043, 29084, 29087, 29108, 29177, 29185, 29197, 29250, 29301, 29323, 29352, 29354, 29357, 29364, 29380, 29424, 29480, 29489, 29508, 29608, 29629, 29632, 29636, 29754, 29772, 29791, 29830, 29862, 29916, 29944, 29952, 30065, 30105, 30111, 30201, 30236, 30283, 30285, 30384, 30456, 30480, 30494, 30503, 30542, 30549, 30557, 30619, 30652, 30660, 30664, 30665, 30674, 30781, 30843, 30893, 30942, 30943 ] }, "args": { "dataset": "flickr", "text_orbits": "artifacts/text_orbits_qwen0p5b.pt", "text_mode": "orbit_mean", "vg_vision": "artifacts/vg_5k/vision_features.pt", "vg_text": "artifacts/vg_5k/text_features.pt", "vg_ground_truth": "artifacts/vg_5k/ground_truth.private.jsonl", "vg_bundle_channels": false, "split": "test", "samples": 1000, "subset_seed": 0, "random_perms": 1000, "derangement_samples": 200, "descent_restarts": 2, "descent_max_steps": 200000, "descent_objective": "m30_total", "descent_verify_top": 64, "device": "cpu", "seed": 20260729, "output": "artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_test1000_orbit.json", "trajectory_output": null }, "channel_names": [ "mean" ], "gate_a_global_ranking": { "true": { "mse": 1.4181541165023395, "mse_channels": [ 1.4181541165023395 ], "mse_channel_mean": 1.4181541165023395, "conditional_kl": 7.303621430403564, "m30_total": 4.297032519085391 }, "similarity_shift": { "mse": 1.7524232502697978, "mse_channels": [ 1.7524232502697978 ], "mse_channel_mean": 1.7524232502697978, "conditional_kl": 8.055903734465232, "m30_total": 5.116027247432642 }, "random": { "mse": { "mean": 1.9993809461593628, "std": 0.02299228124320507, "min": 1.9282969236373901, "true_z": 25.27921485900879, "true_rank_among_random": 0, "count": 1000 }, "mse_channel_mean": { "mean": 1.9993809461593628, "std": 0.02299228124320507, "min": 1.9282969236373901, "true_z": 25.27921485900879, "true_rank_among_random": 0, "count": 1000 }, "conditional_kl": { "mean": 8.068471908569336, "std": 0.015005611814558506, "min": 8.015178680419922, "true_z": 50.970970153808594, "true_rank_among_random": 0, "count": 1000 }, "m30_total": { "mean": 5.612456798553467, "std": 0.04651624709367752, "min": 5.462587833404541, "true_z": 28.27881622314453, "true_rank_among_random": 0, "count": 1000 } } }, "gate_b_transpositions": { "pairs": 499500, "improving_pairs": 36354, "improving_fraction": 0.07278078078078078, "delta_mean": 0.0018503485803867197, "delta_min": -0.010426752737885799, "identity_is_local_min_mse": false, "worst_improving_swaps": [ { "pair": [ 7, 887 ], "delta_mse": -0.010426752737885799, "text_cosine": 0.9112697119287383, "visual_cosine": 0.012999432491695342, "captions": [ "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi", "A small white car is stuck on the track, while the train car that hit it at a slow speed, " ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 912 ], "delta_mse": -0.009977160226987076, "text_cosine": 0.9186392206840316, "visual_cosine": 0.12189675787950585, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A mother in blue and child walk down a sidewalk next to a brick street." ] }, { "pair": [ 7, 620 ], "delta_mse": -0.009572153312812727, "text_cosine": 0.9091739942624605, "visual_cosine": 0.11518513167659843, "captions": [ "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi", "A young man wearing a blue, yellow, and white striped polo plays rugby on a green grass fi" ] }, { "pair": [ 119, 887 ], "delta_mse": -0.00951008419037142, "text_cosine": 0.8583824651899804, "visual_cosine": 0.03486489149216182, "captions": [ "Two brown dogs run across a large snowy yard.", "A small white car is stuck on the track, while the train car that hit it at a slow speed, " ] }, { "pair": [ 112, 119 ], "delta_mse": -0.009373189141166026, "text_cosine": 0.9037848844166759, "visual_cosine": 0.10057322407848752, "captions": [ "Black dog paddles through the water with a bright ball in its mouth.", "Two brown dogs run across a large snowy yard." ] }, { "pair": [ 124, 353 ], "delta_mse": -0.009337327585576254, "text_cosine": 0.9356184031383584, "visual_cosine": 0.04395308917744514, "captions": [ "A man in a brown jacket holding a red bag is speaking to another man with a white beard an", "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant." ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 711 ], "delta_mse": -0.009309806487737143, "text_cosine": 0.9353961651998521, "visual_cosine": 0.21049132984996302, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A woman in a red shirt raising her arm to the passing crowd below." ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 814 ], "delta_mse": -0.009302473701978911, "text_cosine": 0.9503749750376366, "visual_cosine": 0.05902332143098782, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "View of a Victorian building in the background with various people walking in the foregrou" ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 598 ], "delta_mse": -0.009187930982977965, "text_cosine": 0.9253927632361363, "visual_cosine": -0.04472085752883089, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A group of five dark-skinned people sitting at what looks to be a farmer's market right be" ] }, { "pair": [ 139, 353 ], "delta_mse": -0.009184219843979989, "text_cosine": 0.9368068986190529, "visual_cosine": 0.06421594963687959, "captions": [ "A man dressed in all black is wearing shades and standing in snow and there is a red vehic", "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant." ] }, { "pair": [ 38, 353 ], "delta_mse": -0.009107006232139244, "text_cosine": 0.9287309606348609, "visual_cosine": 0.03619221265132004, "captions": [ "A girl wearing a black t-shirt is holding a small pizza in a kitchen setting.", "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant." ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 485 ], "delta_mse": -0.008928643513675345, "text_cosine": 0.9169712791076585, "visual_cosine": 0.09770033346759531, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A woman in a blue shirt is walking across the street of an older looking district." ] }, { "pair": [ 7, 814 ], "delta_mse": -0.008705416038757248, "text_cosine": 0.8594920467806633, "visual_cosine": 0.06152192565965657, "captions": [ "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi", "View of a Victorian building in the background with various people walking in the foregrou" ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 637 ], "delta_mse": -0.008698074602965674, "text_cosine": 0.9204155751797897, "visual_cosine": 0.18417737911640408, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "Man taking picture of church while the american flag blows in the wind" ] }, { "pair": [ 857, 912 ], "delta_mse": -0.008630598677762053, "text_cosine": 0.9485110774745427, "visual_cosine": 0.15742457821032282, "captions": [ "A man wearing a red t-shirt sweeps the sidewalk in front of a brick building.", "A mother in blue and child walk down a sidewalk next to a brick street." ] }, { "pair": [ 173, 353 ], "delta_mse": -0.00834796133748083, "text_cosine": 0.9055003896110118, "visual_cosine": -0.03926777550622213, "captions": [ "A well-dressed man plays a grand piano during an art exhibit.", "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant." ] }, { "pair": [ 139, 857 ], "delta_mse": -0.008312040922027506, "text_cosine": 0.9478876890190026, "visual_cosine": 0.034838581189204694, "captions": [ "A man dressed in all black is wearing shades and standing in snow and there is a red vehic", "A man wearing a red t-shirt sweeps the sidewalk in front of a brick building." ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 620 ], "delta_mse": -0.008310476299143216, "text_cosine": 0.9211233763419764, "visual_cosine": -3.737601427457512e-05, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A young man wearing a blue, yellow, and white striped polo plays rugby on a green grass fi" ] }, { "pair": [ 280, 353 ], "delta_mse": -0.008292779368278127, "text_cosine": 0.9360765627588535, "visual_cosine": 0.11861060016570629, "captions": [ "A group of people sit near a large red brick building in the grass.", "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant." ] }, { "pair": [ 353, 545 ], "delta_mse": -0.008242990152866564, "text_cosine": 0.9297933809347412, "visual_cosine": 0.1354597419537468, "captions": [ "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.", "A man smiles, while clinking ale bottles, with an unseen person, at a public establishment" ] } ] }, "derangement_curve": [ { "k": 2, "delta_mean": 0.0020294501446187496, "delta_std": 0.0019611273892223835, "improving_fraction": 0.065 }, { "k": 4, "delta_mean": 0.0037164243403822184, "delta_std": 0.00235636904835701, "improving_fraction": 0.02 }, { "k": 8, "delta_mean": 0.007854697294533253, "delta_std": 0.0033502227161079645, "improving_fraction": 0.005 }, { "k": 16, "delta_mean": 0.01491572055965662, "delta_std": 0.0056511457078158855, "improving_fraction": 0.005 }, { "k": 32, "delta_mean": 0.029481416568160057, "delta_std": 0.007464383728802204, "improving_fraction": 0.0 }, { "k": 64, "delta_mean": 0.05770965665578842, "delta_std": 0.010395304299890995, "improving_fraction": 0.0 }, { "k": 128, "delta_mean": 0.11144812405109406, "delta_std": 0.013801022432744503, "improving_fraction": 0.0 }, { "k": 256, "delta_mean": 0.2150510996580124, "delta_std": 0.018227186053991318, "improving_fraction": 0.0 }, { "k": 512, "delta_mean": 0.383868932723999, "delta_std": 0.021471111103892326, "improving_fraction": 0.0 } ], "gate_c_descent_from_true": { "start_accuracy": 1.0, "final_accuracy": 0.11, "final_objective": 3.405150311192098, "final_energy": { "mse": 0.9789151563996484, "mse_channels": [ 0.9789151563996484 ], "mse_channel_mean": 0.9789151563996484, "conditional_kl": 7.236599991964006, "m30_total": 3.405150311192098 }, "accepted_moves": 1068, "moved_fraction": 0.89, "mse_local_min_certificate": false, "trajectory": [ { "step": 0, "objective": 4.277498153865173, "accuracy": 0.998 }, { "step": 50, "objective": 3.919446604438576, "accuracy": 0.898 }, { "step": 100, "objective": 3.7878258677339405, "accuracy": 0.799 }, { "step": 150, "objective": 3.7133583802543875, "accuracy": 0.709 }, { "step": 200, "objective": 3.658219070149186, "accuracy": 0.63 }, { "step": 250, "objective": 3.6174599672729513, "accuracy": 0.555 }, { "step": 300, "objective": 3.58595309307303, "accuracy": 0.497 }, { "step": 350, "objective": 3.559678032582238, "accuracy": 0.446 }, { "step": 400, "objective": 3.5348517578172833, "accuracy": 0.399 }, { "step": 450, "objective": 3.5145857169628534, "accuracy": 0.358 }, { "step": 500, "objective": 3.498124476262949, "accuracy": 0.325 }, { "step": 550, "objective": 3.4831418374605816, "accuracy": 0.291 }, { "step": 600, "objective": 3.4679514945606065, "accuracy": 0.262 }, { "step": 650, "objective": 3.4581062516765226, "accuracy": 0.235 }, { "step": 700, "objective": 3.4484287599269337, "accuracy": 0.214 }, { "step": 750, "objective": 3.4398340133968057, "accuracy": 0.193 }, { "step": 800, "objective": 3.4332483430785663, "accuracy": 0.173 }, { "step": 850, "objective": 3.428467211382965, "accuracy": 0.155 }, { "step": 900, "objective": 3.4233100283625335, "accuracy": 0.146 }, { "step": 950, "objective": 3.416486796112691, "accuracy": 0.13 }, { "step": 1000, "objective": 3.4107746547593427, "accuracy": 0.123 }, { "step": 1050, "objective": 3.406421229045149, "accuracy": 0.113 } ], "final_permutation": [ 236, 263, 778, 3, 135, 302, 96, 933, 208, 170, 918, 552, 832, 88, 218, 227, 49, 661, 346, 50, 57, 446, 712, 998, 530, 423, 657, 100, 605, 601, 988, 79, 845, 247, 237, 35, 847, 37, 75, 4, 40, 41, 42, 492, 631, 999, 46, 47, 84, 278, 883, 872, 767, 488, 741, 939, 116, 334, 548, 507, 45, 61, 770, 813, 64, 822, 285, 67, 627, 69, 70, 194, 72, 452, 213, 497, 749, 77, 269, 541, 823, 82, 172, 11, 993, 838, 20, 87, 24, 250, 852, 284, 43, 641, 94, 95, 728, 710, 98, 174, 256, 866, 899, 472, 708, 785, 80, 971, 66, 972, 862, 737, 119, 29, 923, 707, 293, 280, 588, 454, 962, 925, 368, 123, 784, 421, 564, 510, 147, 760, 375, 474, 326, 133, 620, 874, 350, 304, 549, 214, 232, 141, 846, 849, 282, 108, 146, 344, 983, 433, 746, 340, 559, 430, 154, 450, 156, 10, 332, 776, 160, 249, 573, 618, 994, 230, 442, 161, 850, 169, 764, 171, 656, 694, 981, 132, 397, 519, 144, 149, 411, 574, 365, 165, 196, 865, 400, 812, 188, 201, 317, 331, 362, 984, 90, 292, 487, 880, 676, 740, 168, 461, 763, 644, 607, 733, 206, 207, 536, 859, 594, 882, 876, 182, 53, 468, 473, 81, 702, 873, 150, 869, 801, 223, 224, 765, 151, 493, 766, 191, 528, 966, 184, 274, 731, 48, 751, 483, 186, 688, 257, 241, 769, 388, 730, 345, 868, 950, 727, 112, 609, 376, 692, 253, 679, 412, 456, 299, 806, 525, 772, 788, 262, 167, 105, 427, 758, 696, 589, 71, 343, 842, 272, 596, 234, 36, 562, 273, 74, 162, 926, 1, 220, 393, 91, 369, 267, 301, 755, 674, 447, 92, 811, 391, 110, 295, 296, 99, 934, 720, 624, 777, 789, 717, 235, 560, 904, 370, 932, 638, 372, 311, 848, 478, 114, 335, 494, 504, 550, 744, 915, 377, 684, 324, 911, 830, 9, 553, 314, 387, 527, 275, 126, 27, 6, 19, 187, 18, 338, 300, 175, 211, 222, 279, 33, 76, 243, 669, 885, 289, 242, 626, 561, 451, 664, 355, 356, 209, 97, 930, 690, 619, 251, 470, 364, 479, 286, 836, 863, 579, 309, 181, 956, 373, 30, 357, 480, 979, 402, 380, 569, 672, 308, 974, 628, 735, 386, 961, 277, 221, 390, 210, 312, 341, 967, 992, 523, 233, 860, 288, 964, 781, 809, 819, 794, 405, 406, 106, 179, 705, 990, 283, 965, 951, 102, 415, 597, 199, 825, 419, 648, 600, 913, 695, 131, 183, 491, 153, 608, 671, 291, 643, 32, 722, 815, 255, 663, 437, 313, 245, 217, 726, 428, 637, 444, 270, 861, 800, 410, 449, 495, 713, 462, 453, 166, 895, 545, 457, 828, 408, 606, 216, 738, 463, 352, 354, 466, 378, 103, 469, 140, 152, 383, 698, 396, 195, 706, 783, 176, 155, 498, 603, 204, 63, 851, 353, 113, 750, 668, 840, 824, 379, 351, 15, 699, 310, 485, 616, 424, 604, 349, 782, 759, 856, 425, 481, 621, 796, 508, 989, 935, 512, 413, 636, 318, 514, 987, 465, 996, 662, 44, 521, 101, 85, 524, 417, 107, 121, 622, 857, 774, 739, 532, 645, 816, 581, 122, 361, 982, 576, 58, 647, 659, 414, 104, 86, 557, 28, 486, 407, 328, 700, 490, 716, 761, 177, 650, 853, 460, 884, 163, 180, 276, 646, 439, 958, 854, 797, 31, 633, 614, 612, 834, 826, 501, 817, 459, 542, 578, 238, 977, 158, 582, 52, 143, 2, 348, 754, 39, 821, 921, 591, 592, 593, 117, 623, 509, 254, 805, 757, 125, 271, 572, 516, 499, 189, 68, 294, 762, 780, 384, 540, 467, 613, 654, 893, 148, 595, 363, 65, 359, 709, 666, 687, 55, 59, 190, 464, 130, 818, 327, 839, 139, 366, 203, 398, 945, 496, 897, 244, 115, 506, 786, 431, 976, 239, 729, 520, 420, 513, 178, 858, 917, 653, 23, 374, 336, 963, 611, 888, 747, 877, 949, 436, 947, 792, 808, 634, 901, 202, 670, 367, 83, 673, 266, 678, 448, 677, 129, 563, 940, 34, 434, 305, 701, 685, 787, 215, 924, 908, 587, 401, 120, 937, 128, 721, 890, 697, 630, 844, 555, 118, 319, 795, 704, 240, 489, 229, 952, 978, 124, 252, 986, 927, 714, 814, 775, 929, 718, 719, 137, 665, 831, 571, 535, 54, 145, 625, 683, 577, 640, 281, 568, 438, 734, 639, 78, 768, 127, 551, 347, 632, 655, 743, 193, 745, 752, 56, 748, 997, 219, 342, 403, 753, 138, 537, 791, 173, 159, 136, 689, 889, 441, 798, 17, 385, 829, 691, 912, 502, 290, 771, 539, 575, 725, 711, 471, 886, 246, 779, 458, 265, 371, 916, 615, 920, 14, 973, 531, 810, 790, 773, 649, 793, 723, 157, 742, 803, 389, 799, 642, 534, 26, 878, 418, 0, 922, 198, 894, 5, 533, 567, 62, 337, 938, 802, 404, 598, 682, 500, 602, 879, 260, 570, 995, 941, 526, 900, 429, 395, 518, 667, 835, 833, 185, 475, 330, 93, 248, 435, 959, 358, 323, 936, 566, 287, 529, 329, 142, 556, 867, 980, 681, 25, 225, 843, 503, 322, 13, 8, 231, 841, 660, 855, 864, 546, 522, 804, 617, 586, 870, 871, 339, 515, 268, 875, 599, 756, 258, 212, 333, 543, 675, 360, 426, 325, 580, 7, 21, 192, 73, 891, 892, 409, 60, 321, 953, 484, 827, 22, 898, 394, 303, 903, 943, 905, 455, 307, 629, 511, 910, 89, 583, 422, 914, 948, 477, 259, 703, 919, 955, 820, 445, 12, 505, 658, 482, 228, 590, 887, 909, 200, 736, 538, 381, 226, 896, 724, 51, 440, 715, 432, 942, 985, 944, 610, 392, 517, 320, 652, 38, 584, 807, 315, 954, 382, 16, 957, 565, 547, 960, 881, 476, 837, 205, 680, 416, 399, 585, 969, 970, 261, 109, 111, 928, 975, 554, 264, 946, 306, 906, 907, 732, 298, 316, 968, 134, 197, 686, 297, 544, 991, 931, 651, 164, 902, 443, 693, 558, 635 ] }, "gate_c_descent_from_random": [ { "start_accuracy": 0.0, "final_accuracy": 0.007, "final_objective": 3.4390894907477456, "final_energy": { "mse": 0.9895618197693262, "mse_channels": [ 0.9895618197693262 ], "mse_channel_mean": 0.9895618197693262, "conditional_kl": 7.2998292560454665, "m30_total": 3.4390894907477456 }, "accepted_moves": 1570, "moved_fraction": 0.997, "mse_local_min_certificate": false, "trajectory": [ { "step": 0, "objective": 5.597609347319356, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "step": 50, "objective": 4.946372313171372, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "step": 100, "objective": 4.654184850246987, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 150, "objective": 4.463813106952113, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 200, "objective": 4.314262503480761, "accuracy": 0.003 }, { "step": 250, "objective": 4.195773832430993, "accuracy": 0.003 }, { "step": 300, "objective": 4.0941040480389015, "accuracy": 0.004 }, { "step": 350, "objective": 4.01164989296559, "accuracy": 0.004 }, { "step": 400, "objective": 3.935606736377906, "accuracy": 0.006 }, { "step": 450, "objective": 3.871490581163375, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 500, "objective": 3.8127381772193747, "accuracy": 0.008 }, { "step": 550, "objective": 3.7651033285919775, "accuracy": 0.008 }, { "step": 600, "objective": 3.721924656197852, "accuracy": 0.008 }, { "step": 650, "objective": 3.683580682424319, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 700, "objective": 3.651839503301641, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 750, "objective": 3.624898919721512, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 800, "objective": 3.598634243046188, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 850, "objective": 3.5762127826221315, "accuracy": 0.006 }, { "step": 900, "objective": 3.5567511336898123, "accuracy": 0.005 }, { "step": 950, "objective": 3.5407558065949307, "accuracy": 0.006 }, { "step": 1000, "objective": 3.5260970845329753, "accuracy": 0.008 }, { "step": 1050, "objective": 3.513192698733376, "accuracy": 0.01 }, { "step": 1100, "objective": 3.5014664336230354, "accuracy": 0.01 }, { "step": 1150, "objective": 3.4898559480379627, "accuracy": 0.009 }, { "step": 1200, "objective": 3.480066425914335, "accuracy": 0.009 }, { "step": 1250, "objective": 3.471920968021096, "accuracy": 0.009 }, { "step": 1300, "objective": 3.465659972450599, "accuracy": 0.009 }, { "step": 1350, "objective": 3.4593446393329126, "accuracy": 0.009 }, { "step": 1400, "objective": 3.452995267194754, "accuracy": 0.008 }, { "step": 1450, "objective": 3.4486890076891026, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 1500, "objective": 3.4452994916715776, "accuracy": 0.007 }, { "step": 1550, "objective": 3.4403541330265277, "accuracy": 0.008 } ] }, { "start_accuracy": 0.0, "final_accuracy": 0.003, "final_objective": 3.415587757343612, "final_energy": { "mse": 0.9780128775843049, "mse_channels": [ 0.9780128775843049 ], "mse_channel_mean": 0.9780128775843049, "conditional_kl": 7.29781001087501, "m30_total": 3.415587757343612 }, "accepted_moves": 1533, "moved_fraction": 0.999, "mse_local_min_certificate": false, "trajectory": [ { "step": 0, "objective": 5.552746933395847, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "step": 50, "objective": 4.932615684601798, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "step": 100, "objective": 4.622246346984176, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "step": 150, "objective": 4.429738094320414, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 200, "objective": 4.280313440567166, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 250, "objective": 4.159440750123266, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 300, "objective": 4.049590289624388, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 350, "objective": 3.955685464731336, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 400, "objective": 3.8767857344026937, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 450, "objective": 3.8111240445779524, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 500, "objective": 3.757118912041849, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 550, "objective": 3.710246848387948, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 600, "objective": 3.669528231884107, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 650, "objective": 3.6320682331077636, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 700, "objective": 3.601386190719876, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 750, "objective": 3.576336842533314, "accuracy": 0.003 }, { "step": 800, "objective": 3.5562407748493827, "accuracy": 0.003 }, { "step": 850, "objective": 3.5360567539121037, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 900, "objective": 3.520007579076145, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 950, "objective": 3.5036578191686054, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1000, "objective": 3.4908761959728194, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1050, "objective": 3.478616327847004, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1100, "objective": 3.467597011450415, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1150, "objective": 3.458198373072019, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1200, "objective": 3.4502041312846305, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1250, "objective": 3.442524855805853, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 1300, "objective": 3.43552730001292, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1350, "objective": 3.4309810567793724, "accuracy": 0.001 }, { "step": 1400, "objective": 3.42582373008698, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 1450, "objective": 3.421249800948337, "accuracy": 0.002 }, { "step": 1500, "objective": 3.419015840292782, "accuracy": 0.002 } ] } ], "verdict": { "true_m30_total": 4.297032519085391, "identity_is_local_min_mse": false, "descent_from_true_stays": 0.11, "on_manifold_counterfeit_found": true, "best_random_descent_m30_total": 3.415587757343612 } }