|
Tables filled with real values:
Table 1: 5-method audit (3-seed mean ± std for acc, headline Γ, verdict)
Table 2: 4-condition mode 2 validation (cos and ρ values from existing
checkpoint measurements)
Table 3: protocol thresholds (50×, 1e-7, 0.30, 2pp)
Figures generated from existing data:
fig2_decision_utility.pdf: 5×7 verdict heatmap from
results/protocol_audit/ablation_decision_utility.json
fig4_penalty_rescue.pdf: 3-panel — trajectory + cos/ρ bars + 2×2 acc
from snapshot_evolution_v2 + dfa_residual_penalty + bp_with_penalty
fig5_cross_arch_summary.pdf: 5×4 BP/DFA verdict matrix across
architectures
Compiles to 8 pages with all tables/figures rendered. §1-§7 main body
still has only paragraph topic sentences (TODO: per-section prose
filling via codex). Figure numbering is wrong (codex put figures in
section order not numerical order — need fixing).
|
|
Round 24's skeleton had 3 deviations from round 23 redo:
- Made §3 'Diagnostic Protocol' instead of 'Failure Mode 1'
- Collapsed Mode 1 + Mode 2 into one §4
- Added §6 'Reference Implementation' (was supposed to be dropped)
Round 25 fixed all three. New §3-§7 match round 23 redo exactly:
§3 Failure Mode 1: Measurement Degeneracy
§4 Failure Mode 2: Low Intrinsic Credit-Direction Quality
§5 Intervention and Cross-Architecture Evidence
§6 Recommended FA Evaluation Protocol
§7 Discussion, Limits, Conclusion
Also added:
- In-line bibliography with 12 \bibitem entries (Paleka, O'Bray, Jordan
+ FA literature) — citations resolve correctly now
- Appendices A-G with actual prose content (not just headers)
- 7-pitfall catalog with descriptions
- Walk-back chain methodology paragraph
- 7-validation summary table
Compiles to 9 pages with figures 1+3 inline (existing PNGs) and figures
2/4/5 as placeholder text PDFs (TODO: regenerate). Tables 1/2/3 still
have TODO placeholders for numerical values.
Next: fill in tables 1-3 with existing JSON data, generate figures 2/4/5
from existing data, then consult codex per-section for prose filling.
|
