From 1359b7e7a96ab57be0bb24ebdf842a793ce01223 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: YurenHao0426 <Blackhao0426@gmail.com>
Date: Tue, 31 Mar 2026 10:36:02 -0500
Subject: Add naive state prediction baseline for A1 and A2
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

A1: 240 rows (3 alpha × 2 depth × 4 methods × 10 seeds)
A2: 30 rows (3 methods × 10 seeds)
naive_StateErr = ||h_{L//2} - h_L|| / ||h_L||

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
---
 results/confirmatory/A1_naive_state_err.csv | 241 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 results/confirmatory/A2_naive_state_err.csv |  31 ++++
 2 files changed, 272 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 results/confirmatory/A1_naive_state_err.csv
 create mode 100644 results/confirmatory/A2_naive_state_err.csv

(limited to 'results/confirmatory')

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A1_naive_state_err.csv b/results/confirmatory/A1_naive_state_err.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..6ddcfe7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A1_naive_state_err.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,241 @@
+alpha,depth,method,seed,naive_StateErr
+0.0,4,bp,42,0.26068803668022156
+0.0,4,dfa,42,0.7258815169334412
+0.0,4,state_bridge,42,0.7580535411834717
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,42,0.23254971206188202
+0.0,4,bp,123,0.24781781435012817
+0.0,4,dfa,123,0.6604026556015015
+0.0,4,state_bridge,123,0.5317853689193726
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,123,0.17576289176940918
+0.0,4,bp,456,0.2476104348897934
+0.0,4,dfa,456,0.6199116110801697
+0.0,4,state_bridge,456,0.863245964050293
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,456,0.12035267055034637
+0.0,4,bp,789,0.2656460106372833
+0.0,4,dfa,789,0.7435265779495239
+0.0,4,state_bridge,789,0.6364812850952148
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,789,0.2562270164489746
+0.0,4,bp,1024,0.2501564025878906
+0.0,4,dfa,1024,0.6919815540313721
+0.0,4,state_bridge,1024,0.6960811018943787
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,1024,0.2409060299396515
+0.0,4,bp,2048,0.24213725328445435
+0.0,4,dfa,2048,0.8119536638259888
+0.0,4,state_bridge,2048,1.0384111404418945
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,2048,0.29382896423339844
+0.0,4,bp,3000,0.25653713941574097
+0.0,4,dfa,3000,0.7727931141853333
+0.0,4,state_bridge,3000,0.7795010805130005
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,3000,0.1640912890434265
+0.0,4,bp,4000,0.2790989279747009
+0.0,4,dfa,4000,0.6488389372825623
+0.0,4,state_bridge,4000,0.8933002948760986
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,4000,0.129751056432724
+0.0,4,bp,5000,0.23482249677181244
+0.0,4,dfa,5000,0.5603621006011963
+0.0,4,state_bridge,5000,0.7118808031082153
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,5000,0.1876041740179062
+0.0,4,bp,6000,0.2366245985031128
+0.0,4,dfa,6000,0.7504462003707886
+0.0,4,state_bridge,6000,0.8727204203605652
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,6000,0.18112479150295258
+0.0,8,bp,42,0.07397101819515228
+0.0,8,dfa,42,0.5621968507766724
+0.0,8,state_bridge,42,0.816449761390686
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,42,0.15379583835601807
+0.0,8,bp,123,0.07488589733839035
+0.0,8,dfa,123,0.6059672832489014
+0.0,8,state_bridge,123,0.5263348817825317
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,123,0.12262149155139923
+0.0,8,bp,456,0.07783643156290054
+0.0,8,dfa,456,0.7705618143081665
+0.0,8,state_bridge,456,0.4180244505405426
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,456,0.19311878085136414
+0.0,8,bp,789,0.09013043344020844
+0.0,8,dfa,789,0.5577319860458374
+0.0,8,state_bridge,789,0.8297959566116333
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,789,0.05089893937110901
+0.0,8,bp,1024,0.0830039381980896
+0.0,8,dfa,1024,0.5080844163894653
+0.0,8,state_bridge,1024,0.39521247148513794
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,1024,0.06527997553348541
+0.0,8,bp,2048,0.07513846457004547
+0.0,8,dfa,2048,0.6275949478149414
+0.0,8,state_bridge,2048,0.6864550113677979
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,2048,0.08002562075853348
+0.0,8,bp,3000,0.10901156067848206
+0.0,8,dfa,3000,0.6083968281745911
+0.0,8,state_bridge,3000,0.8938897848129272
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,3000,0.38711249828338623
+0.0,8,bp,4000,0.09766732156276703
+0.0,8,dfa,4000,0.5503160357475281
+0.0,8,state_bridge,4000,0.39751216769218445
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,4000,0.13849811255931854
+0.0,8,bp,5000,0.07875370979309082
+0.0,8,dfa,5000,0.5541619658470154
+0.0,8,state_bridge,5000,0.6255663633346558
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,5000,0.07148516178131104
+0.0,8,bp,6000,0.07798311114311218
+0.0,8,dfa,6000,0.5998473167419434
+0.0,8,state_bridge,6000,0.5577906370162964
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,6000,0.18784484267234802
+0.5,4,bp,42,0.2670668959617615
+0.5,4,dfa,42,0.78990238904953
+0.5,4,state_bridge,42,0.7565754055976868
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,42,0.28575778007507324
+0.5,4,bp,123,0.26157334446907043
+0.5,4,dfa,123,0.8240824937820435
+0.5,4,state_bridge,123,0.5587974786758423
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,123,0.18487781286239624
+0.5,4,bp,456,0.26119792461395264
+0.5,4,dfa,456,0.5580360889434814
+0.5,4,state_bridge,456,0.6804043650627136
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,456,0.10438685864210129
+0.5,4,bp,789,0.2688371241092682
+0.5,4,dfa,789,0.7619737386703491
+0.5,4,state_bridge,789,0.5724117755889893
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,789,0.2902269661426544
+0.5,4,bp,1024,0.2626464068889618
+0.5,4,dfa,1024,0.7350623607635498
+0.5,4,state_bridge,1024,0.7774407863616943
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,1024,0.2907182276248932
+0.5,4,bp,2048,0.25887274742126465
+0.5,4,dfa,2048,0.8292539119720459
+0.5,4,state_bridge,2048,0.6785949468612671
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,2048,0.23325428366661072
+0.5,4,bp,3000,0.2686220407485962
+0.5,4,dfa,3000,0.7964614033699036
+0.5,4,state_bridge,3000,0.6747612953186035
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,3000,0.15331298112869263
+0.5,4,bp,4000,0.27715128660202026
+0.5,4,dfa,4000,0.834259033203125
+0.5,4,state_bridge,4000,0.6629055738449097
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,4000,0.09292227774858475
+0.5,4,bp,5000,0.25511646270751953
+0.5,4,dfa,5000,0.8486669063568115
+0.5,4,state_bridge,5000,0.6432816386222839
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,5000,0.08898796141147614
+0.5,4,bp,6000,0.25425827503204346
+0.5,4,dfa,6000,0.7771180868148804
+0.5,4,state_bridge,6000,0.8868570327758789
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,6000,0.28548482060432434
+0.5,8,bp,42,0.08691950142383575
+0.5,8,dfa,42,0.5566835403442383
+0.5,8,state_bridge,42,0.5521173477172852
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,42,0.026307538151741028
+0.5,8,bp,123,0.08442661166191101
+0.5,8,dfa,123,0.6884247064590454
+0.5,8,state_bridge,123,1.1720242500305176
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,123,0.09352543950080872
+0.5,8,bp,456,0.0845673531293869
+0.5,8,dfa,456,0.7805156707763672
+0.5,8,state_bridge,456,0.564720630645752
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,456,0.04183648154139519
+0.5,8,bp,789,0.09304642677307129
+0.5,8,dfa,789,0.5289106965065002
+0.5,8,state_bridge,789,1.1913974285125732
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,789,0.0811903178691864
+0.5,8,bp,1024,0.08988181501626968
+0.5,8,dfa,1024,0.5268670320510864
+0.5,8,state_bridge,1024,0.38997870683670044
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,1024,0.0551433339715004
+0.5,8,bp,2048,0.08537864685058594
+0.5,8,dfa,2048,0.6378879547119141
+0.5,8,state_bridge,2048,0.8929705619812012
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,2048,0.05500475689768791
+0.5,8,bp,3000,0.10150086879730225
+0.5,8,dfa,3000,0.6010029315948486
+0.5,8,state_bridge,3000,0.6921526193618774
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,3000,0.0750318169593811
+0.5,8,bp,4000,0.09839055687189102
+0.5,8,dfa,4000,0.5477902889251709
+0.5,8,state_bridge,4000,0.4617120325565338
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,4000,0.0474717952311039
+0.5,8,bp,5000,0.09180224686861038
+0.5,8,dfa,5000,0.5527122616767883
+0.5,8,state_bridge,5000,0.5788565874099731
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,5000,0.08813595771789551
+0.5,8,bp,6000,0.08880583941936493
+0.5,8,dfa,6000,0.5930142402648926
+0.5,8,state_bridge,6000,0.5428022742271423
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,6000,0.1234222799539566
+1.0,4,bp,42,0.37005650997161865
+1.0,4,dfa,42,0.869762659072876
+1.0,4,state_bridge,42,0.87589430809021
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,42,0.2053530365228653
+1.0,4,bp,123,0.36214226484298706
+1.0,4,dfa,123,0.8254338502883911
+1.0,4,state_bridge,123,0.8833000659942627
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,123,0.21273687481880188
+1.0,4,bp,456,0.3626979887485504
+1.0,4,dfa,456,0.7873569130897522
+1.0,4,state_bridge,456,0.8605778217315674
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,456,0.21030157804489136
+1.0,4,bp,789,0.37471723556518555
+1.0,4,dfa,789,0.7885147929191589
+1.0,4,state_bridge,789,0.8968838453292847
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,789,0.18812689185142517
+1.0,4,bp,1024,0.36623838543891907
+1.0,4,dfa,1024,0.8550044894218445
+1.0,4,state_bridge,1024,0.8468506932258606
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,1024,0.32974082231521606
+1.0,4,bp,2048,0.3584083914756775
+1.0,4,dfa,2048,0.823596715927124
+1.0,4,state_bridge,2048,0.8956995010375977
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,2048,0.1712440550327301
+1.0,4,bp,3000,0.37105458974838257
+1.0,4,dfa,3000,0.8486852645874023
+1.0,4,state_bridge,3000,0.9403642416000366
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,3000,0.15761351585388184
+1.0,4,bp,4000,0.384659081697464
+1.0,4,dfa,4000,0.8266894817352295
+1.0,4,state_bridge,4000,0.8737555742263794
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,4000,0.0490226186811924
+1.0,4,bp,5000,0.3479670286178589
+1.0,4,dfa,5000,0.7952747344970703
+1.0,4,state_bridge,5000,0.8428233861923218
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,5000,0.2047322541475296
+1.0,4,bp,6000,0.35523170232772827
+1.0,4,dfa,6000,0.850082516670227
+1.0,4,state_bridge,6000,0.8412976264953613
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,6000,0.18619702756404877
+1.0,8,bp,42,0.20174872875213623
+1.0,8,dfa,42,0.5564329028129578
+1.0,8,state_bridge,42,0.6702669262886047
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,42,0.11915956437587738
+1.0,8,bp,123,0.20575112104415894
+1.0,8,dfa,123,0.7708055973052979
+1.0,8,state_bridge,123,0.6753015518188477
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,123,0.12676304578781128
+1.0,8,bp,456,0.20126384496688843
+1.0,8,dfa,456,0.789068341255188
+1.0,8,state_bridge,456,0.5630311965942383
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,456,0.0718986764550209
+1.0,8,bp,789,0.21950820088386536
+1.0,8,dfa,789,0.801855206489563
+1.0,8,state_bridge,789,0.5838653445243835
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,789,0.1493334174156189
+1.0,8,bp,1024,0.2049655318260193
+1.0,8,dfa,1024,0.7054224014282227
+1.0,8,state_bridge,1024,0.564822793006897
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,1024,0.0481550358235836
+1.0,8,bp,2048,0.2031216025352478
+1.0,8,dfa,2048,0.6300236582756042
+1.0,8,state_bridge,2048,0.584318995475769
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,2048,0.22037747502326965
+1.0,8,bp,3000,0.22935035824775696
+1.0,8,dfa,3000,0.712699294090271
+1.0,8,state_bridge,3000,0.7996810674667358
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,3000,0.09546110779047012
+1.0,8,bp,4000,0.22556602954864502
+1.0,8,dfa,4000,0.5526505708694458
+1.0,8,state_bridge,4000,0.5007961392402649
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,4000,0.04477586969733238
+1.0,8,bp,5000,0.2003089338541031
+1.0,8,dfa,5000,0.777186393737793
+1.0,8,state_bridge,5000,0.3940466642379761
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,5000,0.1061391606926918
+1.0,8,bp,6000,0.20401637256145477
+1.0,8,dfa,6000,0.5910547971725464
+1.0,8,state_bridge,6000,0.6176798343658447
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,6000,0.10662685334682465
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A2_naive_state_err.csv b/results/confirmatory/A2_naive_state_err.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..fcb5f01
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A2_naive_state_err.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+method,seed,naive_StateErr
+dfa,42,0.8608599968910218
+state_bridge,42,1.1073074493408204
+credit_bridge,42,0.18549979393482208
+dfa,123,0.6620678688049316
+state_bridge,123,1.157683981513977
+credit_bridge,123,0.5449653492927551
+dfa,456,0.862576175403595
+state_bridge,456,0.5174413678169251
+credit_bridge,456,0.02991231045126915
+dfa,789,0.5742178151130676
+state_bridge,789,0.32427600870132445
+credit_bridge,789,0.34830747079849245
+dfa,1024,0.7317259416580201
+state_bridge,1024,1.1036756999969481
+credit_bridge,1024,0.5166968782424927
+dfa,2048,0.29954994792938233
+state_bridge,2048,0.4312982501029968
+credit_bridge,2048,0.8699032402038575
+dfa,3000,0.7138990812301635
+state_bridge,3000,0.08414710862636567
+credit_bridge,3000,0.07805714750289917
+dfa,4000,0.6306101009368896
+state_bridge,4000,0.9965199737548828
+credit_bridge,4000,0.4791879728317261
+dfa,5000,0.9650134473800659
+state_bridge,5000,0.9529169537544251
+credit_bridge,5000,0.6871149513244629
+dfa,6000,0.8224315113067627
+state_bridge,6000,0.14781150970458984
+credit_bridge,6000,0.5449538031578064
-- 
cgit v1.2.3