From a002f03804fb67ed2489eb4c1229db41e0126514 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: YurenHao0426 Date: Wed, 1 Apr 2026 09:27:33 -0500 Subject: Recompute BP and DFA Gamma with near-zero gradient filtering BP Gamma: raw~0.99, filtered=1.000 (confirms self-cosine artifact from zero grads) DFA Gamma (synth): raw~0.01-0.16, filtered~0.01-0.17 (minimal filtering effect) DFA Gamma (CIFAR): raw=0.107, filtered=0.466 (99.7% samples have near-zero BP grad!) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) --- results/confirmatory/A1_gamma_filtered.csv | 121 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ results/confirmatory/A2_gamma_filtered.csv | 21 +++++ 2 files changed, 142 insertions(+) create mode 100644 results/confirmatory/A1_gamma_filtered.csv create mode 100644 results/confirmatory/A2_gamma_filtered.csv (limited to 'results') diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A1_gamma_filtered.csv b/results/confirmatory/A1_gamma_filtered.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..82bfcec --- /dev/null +++ b/results/confirmatory/A1_gamma_filtered.csv @@ -0,0 +1,121 @@ +alpha,depth,method,seed,Gamma_raw,Gamma_filtered,pct_filtered +0.0,4,bp,42,0.9943465143442154,0.9999999850988388,3.173828125 +0.0,4,dfa,42,0.16397126764059067,0.16952853673137724,4.736328125 +0.0,4,bp,123,0.9905796051025391,0.9999999850988388,2.24609375 +0.0,4,dfa,123,0.0927834395552054,0.09708107495680451,5.76171875 +0.0,4,bp,456,0.9902564138174057,0.9999999701976776,2.685546875 +0.0,4,dfa,456,0.15473487228155136,0.1606844263151288,4.736328125 +0.0,4,bp,789,0.969575822353363,0.9999999701976776,6.298828125 +0.0,4,dfa,789,0.08899577707052231,0.10008535534143448,11.81640625 +0.0,4,bp,1024,0.9798289835453033,0.9999999552965164,3.90625 +0.0,4,dfa,1024,0.11752147623337805,0.12484493129886687,6.8359375 +0.0,4,bp,2048,0.9954205006361008,0.9999999850988388,2.1484375 +0.0,4,dfa,2048,0.0844344599172473,0.08939440315589309,7.03125 +0.0,4,bp,3000,0.9908440113067627,0.9999999701976776,2.490234375 +0.0,4,dfa,3000,0.07774155493825674,0.08208044292405248,5.419921875 +0.0,4,bp,4000,0.9780610948801041,1.0,4.736328125 +0.0,4,dfa,4000,0.1380532570183277,0.1433043866418302,5.712890625 +0.0,4,bp,5000,0.9902169704437256,0.9999999850988388,2.197265625 +0.0,4,dfa,5000,0.16786469984799623,0.1727045844309032,4.19921875 +0.0,4,bp,6000,0.9828903675079346,0.9999999850988388,3.41796875 +0.0,4,dfa,6000,0.0775699713267386,0.08204521564766765,6.982421875 +0.0,8,bp,42,0.990789882838726,0.9999999925494194,2.2216796875 +0.0,8,dfa,42,0.11711220210418105,0.1202137126820162,4.9560546875 +0.0,8,bp,123,0.9927243292331696,0.999999962747097,1.5625 +0.0,8,dfa,123,0.10032691940432414,0.10278976701374631,3.466796875 +0.0,8,bp,456,0.998046875,1.0,0.87890625 +0.0,8,dfa,456,0.1290463749319315,0.13145412132143974,2.734375 +0.0,8,bp,789,0.9744870215654373,0.9999999552965164,3.7841796875 +0.0,8,dfa,789,0.10469985322561115,0.10865372465923429,5.95703125 +0.0,8,bp,1024,0.9878761023283005,1.0,2.24609375 +0.0,8,dfa,1024,0.13066718610934913,0.13418272126000375,4.3212890625 +0.0,8,bp,2048,0.9916786998510361,1.0,2.24609375 +0.0,8,dfa,2048,0.11559897055849433,0.11950591625645757,5.3466796875 +0.0,8,bp,3000,0.9727944806218147,0.9999999925494194,5.3955078125 +0.0,8,dfa,3000,0.08027624036185443,0.08708090824075043,8.642578125 +0.0,8,bp,4000,0.9678075313568115,0.9999999925494194,5.6884765625 +0.0,8,dfa,4000,0.12470060039777309,0.13133385905530304,5.95703125 +0.0,8,bp,5000,0.9950796142220497,0.9999999925494194,1.513671875 +0.0,8,dfa,5000,0.10216906224377453,0.1046885505784303,5.5419921875 +0.0,8,bp,6000,0.9838539287447929,0.9999999701976776,2.5390625 +0.0,8,dfa,6000,0.1281466654036194,0.13152842584531754,4.8828125 +0.5,4,bp,42,0.998613178730011,0.9999999552965164,2.099609375 +0.5,4,dfa,42,0.10113468579947948,0.10526007856242359,4.931640625 +0.5,4,bp,123,0.9969976395368576,1.0,1.220703125 +0.5,4,dfa,123,0.06561636610422283,0.06818913633469492,4.345703125 +0.5,4,bp,456,0.9952942878007889,1.0,1.220703125 +0.5,4,dfa,456,0.10633720364421606,0.10912510193884373,4.931640625 +0.5,4,bp,789,0.9894595146179199,0.9999999552965164,4.248046875 +0.5,4,dfa,789,0.06021472532302141,0.06550494115799665,9.228515625 +0.5,4,bp,1024,0.9879738390445709,0.9999999850988388,2.392578125 +0.5,4,dfa,1024,0.10198775480967015,0.10647175554186106,5.56640625 +0.5,4,bp,2048,0.998046875,1.0,1.07421875 +0.5,4,dfa,2048,0.06458619609475136,0.06715680193156004,5.615234375 +0.5,4,bp,3000,0.9915173500776291,1.0,1.513671875 +0.5,4,dfa,3000,0.0758723842445761,0.07809044560417533,4.638671875 +0.5,4,bp,4000,0.9886979162693024,0.9999999850988388,3.271484375 +0.5,4,dfa,4000,0.09265811927616596,0.09831060282886028,6.396484375 +0.5,4,bp,5000,0.9962077885866165,1.0,1.416015625 +0.5,4,dfa,5000,0.10978322755545378,0.11408493993803859,5.126953125 +0.5,4,bp,6000,0.9934713393449783,0.9999999403953552,2.587890625 +0.5,4,dfa,6000,0.06366614857688546,0.06695562065578997,5.859375 +0.5,8,bp,42,0.9958874434232712,1.0,1.2451171875 +0.5,8,dfa,42,0.11749712377786636,0.11851775867398828,2.4169921875 +0.5,8,bp,123,0.9983495622873306,1.0,0.8544921875 +0.5,8,dfa,123,0.08902639808366075,0.09037158073624596,3.80859375 +0.5,8,bp,456,0.9968671426177025,1.0,1.0498046875 +0.5,8,dfa,456,0.1387098478153348,0.14036038517951965,3.7109375 +0.5,8,bp,789,0.9900642931461334,0.999999962747097,3.5400390625 +0.5,8,dfa,789,0.10460902474005707,0.10786171490326524,4.58984375 +0.5,8,bp,1024,0.9922044798731804,1.0,1.7822265625 +0.5,8,dfa,1024,0.12873894562653732,0.1308163675821561,4.0283203125 +0.5,8,bp,2048,0.9957709237933159,1.0,1.2939453125 +0.5,8,dfa,2048,0.11070786253549159,0.11215631279628724,2.8564453125 +0.5,8,bp,3000,0.9906003624200821,0.9999999776482582,2.734375 +0.5,8,dfa,3000,0.07616681582294405,0.0812908245716244,7.12890625 +0.5,8,bp,4000,0.9902862906455994,0.9999999850988388,4.1015625 +0.5,8,dfa,4000,0.13387534522917122,0.13662076788023114,4.4921875 +0.5,8,bp,5000,0.9981022626161575,1.0,0.5859375 +0.5,8,dfa,5000,0.10677944461349398,0.10856987698934972,3.5400390625 +0.5,8,bp,6000,0.9949909299612045,0.999999962747097,1.6357421875 +0.5,8,dfa,6000,0.13941069366410375,0.1408631979720667,1.7333984375 +1.0,4,bp,42,0.9977240115404129,1.0,1.953125 +1.0,4,dfa,42,0.014768859604373574,0.014857993926852942,0.87890625 +1.0,4,bp,123,0.9951963126659393,1.0,1.171875 +1.0,4,dfa,123,0.007468017443898134,0.007428951532347128,0.634765625 +1.0,4,bp,456,0.9924752563238144,1.0,1.07421875 +1.0,4,dfa,456,0.014762257924303412,0.014785600476898253,0.634765625 +1.0,4,bp,789,0.9876697361469269,0.9999999850988388,3.955078125 +1.0,4,dfa,789,0.011572644347324967,0.011563383974134922,0.390625 +1.0,4,bp,1024,0.9840876907110214,1.0,3.02734375 +1.0,4,dfa,1024,0.04770335368812084,0.0478831788059324,0.634765625 +1.0,4,bp,2048,0.997810423374176,0.9999999850988388,1.513671875 +1.0,4,dfa,2048,0.029419597703963518,0.029332666657865047,0.537109375 +1.0,4,bp,3000,0.9915245622396469,0.9999999850988388,1.7578125 +1.0,4,dfa,3000,0.015566933434456587,0.015666541876271367,0.390625 +1.0,4,bp,4000,0.9844929128885269,0.9999999701976776,3.41796875 +1.0,4,dfa,4000,0.031991692492738366,0.032047547865659,1.07421875 +1.0,4,bp,5000,0.9945698976516724,1.0,1.3671875 +1.0,4,dfa,5000,0.018907817779108882,0.019101449055597186,1.318359375 +1.0,4,bp,6000,0.9942085295915604,0.9999999701976776,2.587890625 +1.0,4,dfa,6000,0.023041230102535337,0.023000332876108587,0.29296875 +1.0,8,bp,42,0.9944821447134018,0.9999999925494194,1.7578125 +1.0,8,dfa,42,0.10421321238391101,0.10421321238391101,0.0 +1.0,8,bp,123,0.9945217221975327,1.0,0.9765625 +1.0,8,dfa,123,0.045444203773513436,0.04563941957894713,0.732421875 +1.0,8,bp,456,0.9977533891797066,1.0,1.123046875 +1.0,8,dfa,456,0.11844528885558248,0.11844528885558248,0.0 +1.0,8,bp,789,0.992664523422718,0.9999999850988388,2.83203125 +1.0,8,dfa,789,0.057530249236151576,0.05781287141144276,0.9033203125 +1.0,8,bp,1024,0.9934414252638817,0.9999999552965164,1.7578125 +1.0,8,dfa,1024,0.06273052864708006,0.0629427726380527,1.6357421875 +1.0,8,bp,2048,0.9961903020739555,0.9999999925494194,1.5380859375 +1.0,8,dfa,2048,0.09943909256253392,0.09943909256253392,0.0 +1.0,8,bp,3000,0.9905251041054726,0.9999999925494194,2.7587890625 +1.0,8,dfa,3000,0.05188894923776388,0.052624015137553215,2.9052734375 +1.0,8,bp,4000,0.988343745470047,1.0,3.90625 +1.0,8,dfa,4000,0.13513747323304415,0.13513747323304415,0.0 +1.0,8,bp,5000,0.9962444230914116,1.0,0.830078125 +1.0,8,dfa,5000,0.05460122806834988,0.05544306503725238,1.904296875 +1.0,8,bp,6000,0.9938885420560837,0.9999999701976776,2.0263671875 +1.0,8,dfa,6000,0.11661046743392944,0.11661046743392944,0.0 diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A2_gamma_filtered.csv b/results/confirmatory/A2_gamma_filtered.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..52207ee --- /dev/null +++ b/results/confirmatory/A2_gamma_filtered.csv @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +method,seed,Gamma_raw,Gamma_filtered,pct_filtered +bp,42,1.0,1.0,1.7578125 +bp,123,1.0,1.0,1.26953125 +bp,456,1.0,1.0,1.26953125 +bp,789,1.0,1.0,1.171875 +bp,1024,1.0,1.0,1.3671875 +bp,2048,1.0,1.0,1.171875 +bp,3000,1.0,1.0,1.5625 +bp,4000,1.0,0.9999999403953552,4.00390625 +bp,5000,1.0,1.0,0.78125 +bp,6000,1.0,1.0,1.46484375 +dfa,42,0.10694382028304972,0.46623945236206055,99.70703125 +dfa,123,0.1159980409356649,0.4727255403995514,99.12109375 +dfa,456,0.10121512111800257,0.6547019481658936,99.90234375 +dfa,789,0.09877482711453922,0.4263691306114197,99.4140625 +dfa,1024,0.10779351543169469,0.35740774869918823,99.8046875 +dfa,2048,0.1068261276523117,0.4386606812477112,99.70703125 +dfa,3000,0.0968668432396953,0.4958714544773102,99.8046875 +dfa,4000,0.09991190600339905,0.35034725069999695,99.4140625 +dfa,5000,0.10964107220206643,0.4115568697452545,99.31640625 +dfa,6000,0.09807751054177061,0.36501646041870117,99.90234375 -- cgit v1.2.3