{ "analysis": "digital_coupled_ladder_scaling_pilot_analysis", "confirmatory": false, "bootstrap": { "unit": "task; component draws averaged within task", "task_clusters": 5, "replicates": 20000, "seed": 20260829, "interval": "percentile 95%" }, "sizes": [ 4, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32 ], "summaries": { "4": { "learnable_edges": 32, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.013333333333333332, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.005416666666666667, 0.025833333333333337 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.015, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.004583333333333333, 0.03458333333333334 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.5, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.5, 0.5 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.4929166666666666, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.48708333333333337, 0.49874999999999997 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.03479166666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.005416666666666667, 0.08770833333333335 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.013333333333333332, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.005416666666666667, 0.025833333333333337 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0 } }, "8": { "learnable_edges": 128, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.028750000000000005, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.008333333333333335, 0.059583333333333335 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.03916666666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.011666666666666665, 0.08666666666666666 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.625, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.625, 0.625 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.6131249999999999, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.6027083333333334, 0.6189583333333333 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.04645833333333333, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.014583333333333334, 0.07833333333333332 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.028333333333333332, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.008333333333333333, 0.05916666666666666 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 1.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 1.0, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0 } }, "12": { "learnable_edges": 288, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.052500000000000005, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.011458333333333334, 0.12458333333333334 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.05, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.15 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.12062500000000001, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.034791666666666665, 0.240625 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.525, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.5, 0.575 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.5458333333333332, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.5177083333333334, 0.5841666666666667 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.06458333333333334, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.011875, 0.16041666666666665 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.052500000000000005, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.011458333333333334, 0.12458333333333334 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0 } }, "16": { "learnable_edges": 512, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.06312500000000001, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.015833333333333335, 0.14104166666666668 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.1, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.3 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.14416666666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.04958333333333333, 0.24500000000000002 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.475, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.425, 0.5 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.47354166666666664, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4247916666666667, 0.5 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.05, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.1 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.08458333333333334, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0125, 0.15666666666666668 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.6, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.2, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.06562500000000002, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.015833333333333335, 0.14729166666666668 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0 } }, "24": { "learnable_edges": 1152, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.10354166666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0375, 0.18895833333333334 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.175, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.05, 0.35 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.20979166666666665, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.12270833333333334, 0.30374999999999996 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.2, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.6 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.5, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.5, 0.5 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.5, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.5, 0.5 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.1, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.3 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.12249999999999998, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.025416666666666664, 0.27999999999999997 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.075, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.175 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.10687500000000001, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0375, 0.195625 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.6, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.2, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 0.8947368421052632 } }, "32": { "learnable_edges": 2048, "methods": { "clean": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.24520833333333333, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.196875, 0.29208333333333336 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "matched_noise": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.225, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.075, 0.4 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.29729166666666673, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.2029166666666667, 0.39625000000000005 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.2, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.6 ] } }, "raw": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.375, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.375, 0.375 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.4189583333333333, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.40145833333333325, 0.44104166666666667 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "constant": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.3, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.15, 0.45 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.3404166666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.19916666666666666, 0.48166666666666663 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.0, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "sdil": { "classification_error": { "mean": 0.025, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.0, 0.075 ] }, "classification_error_auc": { "mean": 0.25604166666666667, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.21416666666666667, 0.2979166666666666 ] }, "reached_stable_zero_error": { "mean": 0.8, "task_bootstrap_95ci": [ 0.4, 1.0 ] } }, "sdil_raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0 } } }, "excess_error_scaling": { "x_axis": "log10 learnable edges", "y_axis": "classification error excess over clean", "static_calibration_slope": 0.10415531736549301, "static_calibration_slope_95ci": [ 0.04974245841148715, 0.15874290021804183 ], "sdil_slope": 0.012408970306003462, "sdil_slope_95ci": [ -0.005786890644846146, 0.03349827657927614 ], "paired_slope_difference": 0.09174634705948954, "paired_slope_difference_95ci": [ 0.03579940349500067, 0.1523636911664971 ], "relative_slope_reduction_percent": 88.08609044657896, "relative_slope_reduction_95ci": [ 61.78973473646105, 106.06115922736782 ], "relative_reduction_valid_bootstrap_fraction": 1.0 }, "largest_grid_learning_curves": { "clean": [ { "epoch": 0, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 10, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 20, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 30, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 40, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 50, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 60, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 70, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 80, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 90, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 100, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 110, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 120, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 130, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 140, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 150, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 160, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 170, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 180, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 190, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 200, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 210, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 220, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 230, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 240, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 250, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 260, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 270, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 280, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 290, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 300, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 310, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 320, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 330, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 340, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 350, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 360, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.03952847075210474 }, { "epoch": 370, "mean_classification_error": 0.2, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 380, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 390, "mean_classification_error": 0.125, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 400, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957946 }, { "epoch": 410, "mean_classification_error": 0.075, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 420, "mean_classification_error": 0.075, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 430, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 440, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 450, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 460, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 470, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 480, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 490, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 500, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 510, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 520, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 530, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 540, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 550, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 560, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 570, "mean_classification_error": 0.0, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 580, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 }, { "epoch": 590, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 }, { "epoch": 600, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 } ], "matched_noise": [ { "epoch": 0, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 10, "mean_classification_error": 0.6, "standard_error": 0.09999999999999999 }, { "epoch": 20, "mean_classification_error": 0.55, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 30, "mean_classification_error": 0.55, "standard_error": 0.10155048005794949 }, { "epoch": 40, "mean_classification_error": 0.55, "standard_error": 0.11592023119369628 }, { "epoch": 50, "mean_classification_error": 0.45, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 60, "mean_classification_error": 0.425, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 70, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.06846531968814576 }, { "epoch": 80, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 90, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 100, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556625 }, { "epoch": 110, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 120, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.03952847075210474 }, { "epoch": 130, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556625 }, { "epoch": 140, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.11592023119369628 }, { "epoch": 150, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 160, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 170, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09999999999999999 }, { "epoch": 180, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 190, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 200, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.075 }, { "epoch": 210, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 220, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.075 }, { "epoch": 230, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.06846531968814576 }, { "epoch": 240, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556626 }, { "epoch": 250, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.06846531968814576 }, { "epoch": 260, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 270, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.06373774391990981 }, { "epoch": 280, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556625 }, { "epoch": 290, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.06846531968814576 }, { "epoch": 300, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 310, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 320, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.075 }, { "epoch": 330, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 340, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556625 }, { "epoch": 350, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 360, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 370, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 380, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 390, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 400, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 410, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556626 }, { "epoch": 420, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 430, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.06373774391990981 }, { "epoch": 440, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.09354143466934853 }, { "epoch": 450, "mean_classification_error": 0.15, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436917 }, { "epoch": 460, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.09354143466934853 }, { "epoch": 470, "mean_classification_error": 0.2, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906584 }, { "epoch": 480, "mean_classification_error": 0.125, "standard_error": 0.03952847075210474 }, { "epoch": 490, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 500, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 510, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.075 }, { "epoch": 520, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.09354143466934853 }, { "epoch": 530, "mean_classification_error": 0.2, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906584 }, { "epoch": 540, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.114564392373896 }, { "epoch": 550, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.114564392373896 }, { "epoch": 560, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.1 }, { "epoch": 570, "mean_classification_error": 0.15, "standard_error": 0.09999999999999999 }, { "epoch": 580, "mean_classification_error": 0.15, "standard_error": 0.09999999999999999 }, { "epoch": 590, "mean_classification_error": 0.15, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436917 }, { "epoch": 600, "mean_classification_error": 0.225, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 } ], "raw": [ { "epoch": 0, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 10, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 20, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 30, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 40, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 50, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 60, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 70, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 80, "mean_classification_error": 0.45, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 90, "mean_classification_error": 0.45, "standard_error": 0.049999999999999996 }, { "epoch": 100, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 110, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 120, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 130, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 140, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 150, "mean_classification_error": 0.45, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 160, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 170, "mean_classification_error": 0.425, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 180, "mean_classification_error": 0.425, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 190, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 200, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 210, "mean_classification_error": 0.475, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999998 }, { "epoch": 220, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 230, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 240, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 250, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 260, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 270, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 280, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 290, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 300, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 310, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 320, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 330, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 340, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 350, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 360, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 370, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 380, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 390, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 400, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 410, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 420, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 430, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 440, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 450, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 460, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 470, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 480, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 490, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 500, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 510, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 520, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 530, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.024999999999999994 }, { "epoch": 540, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 550, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 560, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 570, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 580, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 590, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 600, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.0 } ], "constant": [ { "epoch": 0, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 10, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.10897247358851683 }, { "epoch": 20, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.12247448713915891 }, { "epoch": 30, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.12247448713915891 }, { "epoch": 40, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.12247448713915891 }, { "epoch": 50, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.12247448713915891 }, { "epoch": 60, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.10897247358851683 }, { "epoch": 70, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.10897247358851683 }, { "epoch": 80, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09999999999999999 }, { "epoch": 90, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 100, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.10897247358851683 }, { "epoch": 110, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 120, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 130, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 140, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 150, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 160, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 170, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 180, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.09185586535436918 }, { "epoch": 190, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 200, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 210, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.07905694150420949 }, { "epoch": 220, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 230, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 240, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 250, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 260, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 270, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 280, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 290, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 300, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 310, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 320, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 330, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 340, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 350, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.07288689868556625 }, { "epoch": 360, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 370, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 380, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 390, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 400, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 410, "mean_classification_error": 0.325, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 420, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 430, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 440, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 450, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 460, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 470, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 480, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 490, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 500, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 510, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 520, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 530, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 540, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 550, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 560, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 570, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 580, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 590, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 }, { "epoch": 600, "mean_classification_error": 0.3, "standard_error": 0.08477912478906585 } ], "sdil": [ { "epoch": 0, "mean_classification_error": 0.5, "standard_error": 0.0 }, { "epoch": 10, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 20, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 30, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 40, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 50, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 60, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 70, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 80, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 90, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 100, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 110, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 120, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 130, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 140, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 150, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 160, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 170, "mean_classification_error": 0.375, "standard_error": 0.05590169943749474 }, { "epoch": 180, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 190, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 200, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 210, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 220, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 230, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 240, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 250, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 260, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 270, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 280, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 290, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 300, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 310, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 320, "mean_classification_error": 0.4, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 330, "mean_classification_error": 0.35, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 340, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 350, "mean_classification_error": 0.275, "standard_error": 0.06123724356957944 }, { "epoch": 360, "mean_classification_error": 0.25, "standard_error": 0.03952847075210474 }, { "epoch": 370, "mean_classification_error": 0.2, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 380, "mean_classification_error": 0.15, "standard_error": 0.046770717334674264 }, { "epoch": 390, "mean_classification_error": 0.175, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478972 }, { "epoch": 400, "mean_classification_error": 0.125, "standard_error": 0.03952847075210474 }, { "epoch": 410, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 }, { "epoch": 420, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 }, { "epoch": 430, "mean_classification_error": 0.1, "standard_error": 0.025000000000000005 }, { "epoch": 440, "mean_classification_error": 0.075, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 450, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 460, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 470, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 480, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 490, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 500, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 510, "mean_classification_error": 0.05, "standard_error": 0.03061862178478973 }, { "epoch": 520, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 530, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 540, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 550, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 560, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 570, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 580, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 590, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 }, { "epoch": 600, "mean_classification_error": 0.025, "standard_error": 0.025 } ] }, "sources": [ "results/coupled_ladder/p1_imperfection_pilot.json", "results/coupled_ladder/p1_bias_baseline_pilot.json" ] }