{ "analysis": "physical_measured_state_dependent_surrogate_p1", "confirmatory": false, "physical_hardware_demonstration": false, "autodiff_used": false, "source_analysis": "results/physical_bias/p0_state_dependence.json", "protocol": { "minimum_cycles": 120, "total_nominal_time_seconds": 6.0, "periods_seconds": [ 0.002, 0.005, 0.01, 0.02, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "methods": [ "raw", "same_rms_noise", "frozen_constant", "frozen_sdil", "online_constant", "overclamp", "oracle" ], "overclamp_scope": "leading-order Appendix-F analogue; not the published classification endpoint" }, "pairs": { "experiment_1": { "calibration": { "epochs": 30, "learning_rate": 0.2, "states": 22, "neutral_observations_each": 660, "constant_rmse": 0.6092862026373747, "sdil_rmse": 0.00022387993784781475, "constant_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ], "sdil_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, "noise_standard_deviation_v_per_s": [ 3.069815200619905, 4.678340465344394 ], "period_sweep": [ { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.8092950610197422, 2.7801625927089715 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00010132868475959094, "std_combined_error": 1.3552527156068805e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.012124201610815623, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4348008741467715, 2.3914423248582395 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.8492752386031335e-08, "std_combined_error": 2.8226404709445005e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.001980552372751122, "std_cycle_span": 0.0010148528512669655, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.3483393122116025, 2.296572194967358 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.153264153456787e-06, "std_combined_error": 8.470329472543003e-22, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0032048623473235746, "std_cycle_span": 4.336808689942018e-19, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314547564137823, 2.387155458484078 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.357314677519754e-12, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 1.3508054197714377e-06, "std_cycle_span": 2.117582368135751e-22, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892734493, 2.387197231833999 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.140770454804554e-30, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 3.1401849173675502e-15, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 6000, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.1636571024018956 ], [ 3.844278964067793 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733636, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.031753401590313146, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892734493, 2.387197231833999 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.140770454804554e-30, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 3.1401849173675502e-15, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.8157189778542713, 2.7745905776153856 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00010199355355150576, "std_combined_error": 1.3552527156068805e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.029105116820791088, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.443926854020796, 2.4076596115844797 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.4181655343656334e-07, "std_combined_error": 7.224475537035746e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0027930688106144923, "std_cycle_span": 0.0012869103694595587, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.346707000455192, 2.2981034295135827 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.214734003252294e-06, "std_combined_error": 8.470329472543003e-22, "mean_cycle_span": 0.007692475077109321, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431454123493791, 2.387156147013957 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.3673238256676707e-12, "std_combined_error": 2.0194839173657902e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 3.2419331160020885e-06, "std_cycle_span": 4.235164736271502e-22, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273448, 2.3871972318339947 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.61942121885893e-30, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 7.536443801682121e-15, "std_cycle_span": 1.5777218104420236e-30, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 2400, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.163657102401891 ], [ 3.8442789640677892 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273364, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03175469628805606, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273448, 2.3871972318339947 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.61942121885893e-30, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 7.536443801682121e-15, "std_cycle_span": 1.5777218104420236e-30, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.829137596724204, 2.765695325601806 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00010468365735072873, "std_combined_error": 1.3552527156068805e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.06069482777522618, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4348145889966357, 2.3907868242683947 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 8.028745097576818e-08, "std_combined_error": 6.12766613433568e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.004359354310386148, "std_cycle_span": 0.002949089530150418, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.3433128217321104, 2.3005860749982743 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.463848041630655e-06, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.016032761228693466, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.43145280599553, 2.3871572783847346 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.4078218456206076e-12, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 6.754028213225775e-06, "std_cycle_span": 8.470329472543003e-22, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733254, 2.387197231833879 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 8.397054557528348e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 1200, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.1636571024017908 ], [ 3.8442789640677173 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733636, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03175859291984668, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733875, 2.3871972318339405 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.888609052210118e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.86041773979248, 2.7537847011829983 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00011521059490045322, "std_combined_error": 1.3552527156068805e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.12184926735735116, "std_cycle_span": 1.3877787807814457e-17, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.43486212016216, 2.390381459087656 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.7506885005100094e-07, "std_combined_error": 1.3600797927093883e-07, "mean_cycle_span": 0.006769875807616741, "std_cycle_span": 0.0034511326501450923, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.335463918674156, 2.3040622548784158 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 8.444831514408495e-06, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.03211797946499549, "std_cycle_span": 6.938893903907228e-18, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431449760564751, 2.387158923466784 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5663008198711989e-12, "std_combined_error": 2.0194839173657902e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 1.3508063288864665e-05, "std_cycle_span": 3.3881317890172014e-21, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273368, 2.3871972318338974 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 8.829618423037722e-31, "std_combined_error": 6.368804265876902e-32, "mean_cycle_span": 8.881784197001253e-17, "std_cycle_span": 3.8714799753065e-16, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 600, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.163657102401808 ], [ 3.844278964067742 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273363, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03176676920855227, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733875, 2.3871972318339405 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.888609052210118e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.997349031378711, 2.7560615550386856 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00019054762008641855, "std_combined_error": 9.244675222610997e-16, "mean_cycle_span": 0.3125016255415446, "std_cycle_span": 8.400902749285477e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.437208185576708, 2.39142169352168 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.9515584814923498e-07, "std_combined_error": 1.7634282210639652e-07, "mean_cycle_span": 0.010388750288987723, "std_cycle_span": 0.005462496446466231, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.3018625017984506, 2.3049553752688 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.573409373032438e-05, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.08117759729854893, "std_cycle_span": 1.3877787807814457e-17, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431436893766853, 2.3871599934589325 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.69962879231075e-12, "std_combined_error": 4.0389678347315804e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 3.377027255632158e-05, "std_cycle_span": 6.776263578034403e-21, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487614311821, 2.3871970285098962 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.69473107681078e-15, "std_combined_error": 1.9675422661411047e-15, "mean_cycle_span": 7.375974614382561e-07, "std_cycle_span": 4.723544418725612e-07, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.163656688805505 ], [ 3.8442822176345444 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487889273363, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03177473827091023, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733875, 2.3871972318339405 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.888609052210118e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.364095082798542, 2.863858140999168 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00047738371762902387, "std_combined_error": 5.421010862427522e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.678341055788438, "std_cycle_span": 1.1102230246251565e-16, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.415853646830911, 2.383944446107968 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.284170183249626e-07, "std_combined_error": 3.663912605977088e-07, "mean_cycle_span": 0.01645254240734324, "std_cycle_span": 0.006714250532846139, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.217657716584461, 2.2817475250102337 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 4.6960587863687746e-05, "std_combined_error": 6.776263578034403e-21, "mean_cycle_span": 0.16783822717153069, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314062868891466, 2.387152306257588 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.962180538140995e-12, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 6.754123450716741e-05, "std_cycle_span": 1.3552527156068805e-20, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431487732570713, 2.387197118645531 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.0402571186271138e-15, "std_combined_error": 1.2382518634320076e-15, "mean_cycle_span": 7.024009057970519e-07, "std_cycle_span": 4.631954102213817e-07, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.1636558358249895 ], [ 3.844281524644432 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733636, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03177520231889655, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733875, 2.3871972318339405 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.888609052210118e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 4.690236335935761, 3.3986961942246574 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.0018000468460461258, "std_combined_error": 6.268050226983288e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 1.78741571052108, "std_cycle_span": 4.8714886040487515e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.452310046781332, 2.3945189106070064 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.453687156062093e-07, "std_combined_error": 6.680922284342304e-07, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0249177070035543, "std_cycle_span": 0.011391443518562177, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 1.9862402321993025, 2.190959339656071 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.0002306141403267977, "std_combined_error": 2.710505431213761e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.36609667263607126, "std_cycle_span": 5.551115123125783e-17, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.680657432007967 ], [ 5.076732410928136 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.431331914351697, 2.3871234133188963 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.483834916974681e-11, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0001350861087249672, "std_cycle_span": 2.710505431213761e-20, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.6533297670019302, 1.8846356629906003 ], [ 4.543569954617925, 1.2256020448180966 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314879320244738, 2.387197210808737 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.255565466427137e-16, "std_combined_error": 2.5702906872208766e-16, "mean_cycle_span": 4.1624257419200855e-07, "std_cycle_span": 2.5507665702156565e-07, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ 2.1636552501266073 ], [ 3.8442809550164565 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733636, 2.3871972318339174 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.274080905458301e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.03177520526850427, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.4314878892733875, 2.3871972318339405 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.888609052210118e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null } ], "summary": { "sdil_beats_frozen_constant_all_periods": true, "median_raw_to_oracle_gap_closed_by_sdil": 0.9999999864048891, "overclamp_beats_sdil_all_periods": true, "online_constant_neutral_observations_by_period": [ 6000, 2400, 1200, 600, 240, 240, 240 ], "frozen_sdil_neutral_observations_by_period": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, "experiment_2": { "calibration": { "epochs": 30, "learning_rate": 0.2, "states": 68, "neutral_observations_each": 2040, "constant_rmse": 0.3335551554014055, "sdil_rmse": 2.192388102797653e-06, "constant_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ], "sdil_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, "noise_standard_deviation_v_per_s": [ 0.4218300293576763, 2.0616027304234703 ], "period_sweep": [ { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.176531959717122, 3.9390092336660687 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.957371367511765e-05, "std_combined_error": 2.767656425223995e-15, "mean_cycle_span": 0.005070816704448247, "std_cycle_span": 4.1053612840121085e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.966230900449063, 3.6329395631130024 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.309315045502897e-09, "std_combined_error": 1.6826583274247304e-09, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0006750258186158052, "std_cycle_span": 0.0006049739423524212, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.979065145785647, 3.654103430880535 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.3538567866487397e-07, "std_combined_error": 5.762675161018651e-18, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0004005873201374974, "std_cycle_span": 1.0896774870155784e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533383368455, 3.6303166883990974 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.628573830176422e-19, "std_combined_error": 2.2483300014744642e-24, "mean_cycle_span": 1.1520884141532123e-09, "std_cycle_span": 1.486414608333225e-15, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936661133, 3.630316742082591 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.931269832241446e-28, "std_combined_error": 4.197039051139412e-29, "mean_cycle_span": 2.52478247881128e-14, "std_cycle_span": 1.1733564156075178e-15, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 6000, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.4096138759565473 ], [ 2.213187313789102 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.01413443259744131, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.002, "cycles": 3000, "half_steps": 5, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253393666265, 3.630316742082775 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 5.262216557415797e-28, "std_combined_error": 5.594464262246296e-29, "mean_cycle_span": 2.922397051978476e-14, "std_cycle_span": 1.610423795018914e-15, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.1792619353532885, 3.936756053914711 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.9646470671690832e-05, "std_combined_error": 1.6888927163362493e-14, "mean_cycle_span": 0.012171175618583796, "std_cycle_span": 5.989147116649013e-12, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9700354721887097, 3.6370679415086054 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.4462136678271593e-08, "std_combined_error": 8.309248298984371e-09, "mean_cycle_span": 0.001582775700256443, "std_cycle_span": 0.0008049379867913901, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9792691518821868, 3.6539143712803246 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.3588613108188043e-07, "std_combined_error": 4.350849321850363e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0009614752233830148, "std_cycle_span": 1.972728586978365e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533376238918, 3.630316688802258 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.669779508030872e-19, "std_combined_error": 1.856395820837115e-23, "mean_cycle_span": 2.7648542667100643e-09, "std_cycle_span": 2.7958509530774352e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253393667424, 3.630316742084126 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.89364054277892e-27, "std_combined_error": 7.369116159769359e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 1.6343894148704521e-13, "std_cycle_span": 2.094557663874815e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 2400, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.40961387595487614 ], [ 2.2131873137887244 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.01398740069769411, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.005, "cycles": 1200, "half_steps": 12, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936685473, 3.6303167420854257 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.367176174770757e-27, "std_combined_error": 1.5925201331071837e-27, "mean_cycle_span": 2.416855484135761e-13, "std_cycle_span": 3.0289709200763395e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 5.7600000000033065, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.1848610835073123, 3.933175774521425 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.9940803657707882e-05, "std_combined_error": 1.969022990071133e-14, "mean_cycle_span": 0.025366845329081584, "std_cycle_span": 1.432983327119186e-11, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9662902295955997, 3.6327888368612915 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 5.422781795471078e-09, "std_combined_error": 4.521418008163007e-09, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0017510872536162798, "std_cycle_span": 0.000908326551390631, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9796882348645752, 3.6536091927695766 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.3791142522237858e-07, "std_combined_error": 4.5378679236239257e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 0.002003625870996928, "std_cycle_span": 4.2131266342481465e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533361817702, 3.6303166894187515 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.841438267223092e-19, "std_combined_error": 1.820369867746918e-23, "mean_cycle_span": 5.76035992722468e-09, "std_cycle_span": 5.644789281414016e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936655098, 3.6303167420818547 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.2621972854320462e-28, "std_combined_error": 6.715716366905685e-29, "mean_cycle_span": 6.882162419836761e-14, "std_cycle_span": 1.8664261041976768e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 1200, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.40961387595692217 ], [ 2.2131873137891827 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.013987476025233779, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.01, "cycles": 600, "half_steps": 25, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253393666416, 3.6303167420828686 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.4843898779267577e-27, "std_combined_error": 7.561051799375225e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 2.352362569495467e-13, "std_cycle_span": 6.119277922394014e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.1975697969457184, 3.928478949922958 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.1091928677703137e-05, "std_combined_error": 7.408420918385458e-14, "mean_cycle_span": 0.05081326173431949, "std_cycle_span": 1.0189414300386609e-10, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.966382328890066, 3.6327744115680476 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.620024496179272e-08, "std_combined_error": 1.546368000002186e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0024337779581857124, "std_cycle_span": 0.0012269652618947826, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9806413447254876, 3.6531888857104304 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.458437241513648e-07, "std_combined_error": 2.054432720285989e-16, "mean_cycle_span": 0.004011547784602845, "std_cycle_span": 3.565009874503914e-12, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533330081595, 3.6303166901572124 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.0508008569722728e-18, "std_combined_error": 8.687113950617191e-23, "mean_cycle_span": 1.1520155201956403e-08, "std_cycle_span": 5.016834562953646e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936655973, 3.630316742081905 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 4.922919219840778e-28, "std_combined_error": 4.272260719650653e-28, "mean_cycle_span": 2.4006870467148263e-13, "std_cycle_span": 1.0959565513441156e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 600, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.4096138759572491 ], [ 2.2131873137892812 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.01398797679940297, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.02, "cycles": 300, "half_steps": 50, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936669624, 3.6303167420833438 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.871444814590853e-27, "std_combined_error": 9.299414080521215e-27, "mean_cycle_span": 1.0836956880419996e-12, "std_cycle_span": 5.450016010478752e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.250950849312841, 3.9310464437485537 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.93110837511962e-05, "std_combined_error": 3.0687604349048204e-12, "mean_cycle_span": 0.12840654696041115, "std_cycle_span": 7.615564138367519e-09, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.966860681643815, 3.632687706921391 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5137351959154617e-08, "std_combined_error": 1.3223270145000082e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.003492894585600989, "std_cycle_span": 0.0017844315068364142, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9846492965900473, 3.6531987886779493 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.029886103778275e-07, "std_combined_error": 1.970328054838896e-14, "mean_cycle_span": 0.010102835203733236, "std_cycle_span": 5.825192133491712e-10, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533204425123, 3.630316688957864 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5147217416747773e-18, "std_combined_error": 1.0173963506700801e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 2.8707525774118444e-08, "std_cycle_span": 1.008211211346341e-10, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533232749066, 3.630316745461578 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 7.627832375710677e-17, "std_combined_error": 8.907999183187963e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 9.340505301936189e-08, "std_cycle_span": 7.0279956013451e-08, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.40961218298891705 ], [ 2.213185887579869 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.01398819495276491, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.05, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 125, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253393681474, 3.630316742095593 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.549258815097925e-23, "std_combined_error": 6.209461805765814e-23, "mean_cycle_span": 1.0367440195878089e-10, "std_cycle_span": 1.0965298829349936e-10, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 6.000000000003813, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.3882768221995287, 3.9847125473836953 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.065163347074931e-05, "std_combined_error": 7.11544194994956e-16, "mean_cycle_span": 0.2661768713085517, "std_cycle_span": 1.7761504262354212e-12, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964751067934781, 3.621874878697866 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.84718500823959e-08, "std_combined_error": 1.4277851709520875e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.006844039282168616, "std_cycle_span": 0.003189052088983512, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9948827337270805, 3.656967588425128 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 4.2783429730822625e-07, "std_combined_error": 1.249236399827717e-18, "mean_cycle_span": 0.020703809998703283, "std_cycle_span": 3.397826570547046e-14, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253290923972, 3.630316677267772 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 3.2820004315345595e-18, "std_combined_error": 1.4267738435327517e-25, "mean_cycle_span": 5.760577929980747e-08, "std_cycle_span": 1.2105734719707505e-15, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.96425338685285, 3.630316785982766 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 4.2695914896844e-17, "std_combined_error": 4.438713773983293e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 1.1348019564361219e-07, "std_cycle_span": 6.109442246241253e-08, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.4096124585637328 ], [ 2.213185988465957 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.01398819591109883, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.1, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 250, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936652082, 3.6303167420815114 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.506390205495396e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 11.99999999999871, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "raw", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.8237890439877713, 4.2322590657718075 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 0.00020745009918461807, "std_combined_error": 1.3414351419184588e-16, "mean_cycle_span": 0.6003387233585882, "std_cycle_span": 2.345558964216802e-13, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "same_rms_noise", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964099481543456, 3.6319122591676485 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 2.206579663654022e-08, "std_combined_error": 2.2474838335593827e-08, "mean_cycle_span": 0.007024101768689795, "std_cycle_span": 0.00310757766930167, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "frozen_constant", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 3.025804072284264, 3.6743278033788007 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5706092974008448e-06, "std_combined_error": 9.215762501224779e-20, "mean_cycle_span": 0.04480377417319827, "std_cycle_span": 1.1877108307227618e-15, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.33502087152139154 ], [ 1.996528756755168 ] ] }, { "method": "frozen_sdil", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642532144996294, 3.630316633618741 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.076305364663816e-17, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 1.1521161904577788e-07, "std_cycle_span": 2.6469779601696886e-23, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.2839866529869272, 1.4140559020638932 ], [ 2.0992982944920144, -0.1862355096516429 ] ] }, { "method": "online_constant", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.964253404793115, 3.6303167944322667 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 6.331430267398849e-17, "std_combined_error": 6.545416707926297e-17, "mean_cycle_span": 2.3644399541514118e-07, "std_cycle_span": 1.3174095406631684e-07, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 240, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": [ [ -0.4096124578308895 ], [ 2.2131859838848285 ] ] }, { "method": "overclamp", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936651647, 3.630316742081457 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 1.5792625543975334e-32, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 0.013988195910677756, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null }, { "method": "oracle", "period_seconds": 0.2, "cycles": 120, "half_steps": 500, "initial_gates": [ 4.0, 4.0 ], "final_gates": [ 2.9642533936652082, 3.6303167420815114 ], "bias_strength": 1.0, "mean_combined_error": 9.506390205495396e-31, "std_combined_error": 0.0, "mean_cycle_span": 0.0, "std_cycle_span": 0.0, "neutral_observations_during_learning": 0, "learning_on_time_seconds": 23.999999999970743, "clipped_updates": 0, "final_predictor_coefficients": null } ], "summary": { "sdil_beats_frozen_constant_all_periods": true, "median_raw_to_oracle_gap_closed_by_sdil": 0.9999999999999502, "overclamp_beats_sdil_all_periods": true, "online_constant_neutral_observations_by_period": [ 6000, 2400, 1200, 600, 240, 240, 240 ], "frozen_sdil_neutral_observations_by_period": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } } }, "summary": { "sdil_beats_frozen_constant_both_pairs": true, "median_gap_closed_by_pair": { "experiment_1": 0.9999999864048891, "experiment_2": 0.9999999999999502 } } }