# Victoria 3 Alternate History Mod - Worldbuilding Document ## Core Premise Northern Song Dynasty avoids the Jingkang Incident (1127). Emperor Huizong's northern expansion succeeds. Song recovers the Sixteen Prefectures (Yan region) and expands into Manchuria. These sparsely populated northern territories, combined with Song's already advanced proto-industrial economy (coal-based industry, commodity economy, paper money), create the labor scarcity conditions that drive mechanization and industrialization. The result: by 1836 (V3 start date), an industrialized Eastern power exists, and the global order is fundamentally different from our timeline. --- ## Divergence Point: ~1120s Song Huizong's northern campaigns succeed instead of ending in the Jingkang disaster. Song absorbs significant Liao/Jin territory. The Jin Dynasty is weakened, later finished off by the Mongols. ### Song's Internal Development - Northern territories (Manchuria, Yan region) are sparsely populated -> labor scarcity drives mechanization - Southern Song heartland remains labor-intensive agriculture and commerce - Over centuries, a North-South economic divide develops: - **North**: Industrial economy, coal/iron, early mechanization, multi-ethnic frontier society - **South**: Traditional commodity economy, dense population, agriculture and handicrafts - Military pressure from Mongols empowers military officials (similar to jiedushi/Tang dynasty military governors) - The civilian bureaucracy can no longer fully constrain military officials - Eventually: Southern uprising or equivalent of North-South civil war - Northern military officials likely suppress it (legitimacy argument, similar to Eastern Jin restoration) - Result: intensified social contradictions but technologically advanced Song - Imperial power further weakened - Governance becomes: hereditary military officials + civilian government (dual power structure) - Song's existing institutions (keju examination, censorate, prime ministerial system) evolve toward something resembling constitutional governance ### Song by 1836 - The most industrialized nation in the world - Controls China proper + northern territories (Manchuria south) + likely South China Sea / Southeast Asian colonial possessions - Political system: evolved from Song's civil-military dual structure, possibly constitutional monarchy or some form of representative government evolved from the keju-scholar-official class - Key V3 gameplay tensions: North-South divide, colonial management, relationship with Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) --- ## The Mongol Conquests (Alternate Timeline) ### What Stays the Same - Genghis Khan unifies Mongol tribes (~1206) - First Western Campaign against Khwarezm (1219-1224) - Khwarezm destroyed - Mongol military genius and organizational ability ### What Changes - **Mongols cannot conquer Song** - Song's industrial base, fire weapons, and fortified northern frontier are too strong - Mongols purchase fire weapons/military equipment from Song through trade - Mongol armies become: fewer in number but more elite, equipped with early firearms - Eastern front becomes a stalemate -> all expansion energy redirected westward ### First Western Campaign (Revised, ~1219-1230s) - Khwarezm destroyed (same as historical) - Volga Bulgaria destroyed (historically happened during Batu's campaign, moved earlier in this timeline) - Black Sea region conquered earlier - Golden Horde established earlier (Kiev/Kuban/North Caucasus) - **Nicaea (Byzantine successor state) becomes a Mongol vassal** during this phase - Nicaea offers submission in exchange for Mongol support to recapture Constantinople from the Latin Empire - Fits Byzantine diplomatic tradition of using external powers ### Second/Third Western Campaigns (~1236-1250s) - Batu's campaign conquers Rus directly (not just vassalage - direct rule) - Mongols equipped with Song-manufactured fire weapons - **Central European castles no longer effective** against fire weapons - Campaign pushes along the North European Plain through Poland, Prussia, into the Holy Roman Empire - **Teutonic Order destroyed** (in the path of the Mongol advance) - HRE feudal structure shattered - Mongol advance stops at the Low Countries (logistical limit) - Northern France (Flanders, Picardy) raided but not occupied - Alps and Carpathians prevent effective southward expansion into Italy **Key difference from history**: Ogedei does not stay in the east (no Chinese population/production to manage). He moves to Rus, eventually establishing the imperial center on the Volga River. ### Constantinople (~1261) - Nicaea, as a Mongol vassal, recaptures Constantinople from the weakened Latin Empire with Mongol support - **Byzantine Empire restored as a Mongol vassal state** - Byzantium becomes the Mongol Empire's "administrative contractor" for the Balkans and Anatolia: - Provides bureaucratic expertise - Provides limited naval capability (Mongol weakness) - Manages intelligence and diplomacy with European states - Controls the Bosphorus trade route (Silk Road goods -> Black Sea -> Constantinople -> Mediterranean) - Balkans organized through Byzantine indirect management - Role similar to Han Chinese bureaucrats under the Qing Dynasty ### Hulagu's Middle Eastern Campaign (~1256-1265) - Assassins destroyed (same as historical) - Abbasid Caliphate destroyed, Baghdad falls 1258 (same) - **Mamluks defeated** (unlike historical Ain Jalut) - Hulagu's forces have fire weapons - No recall due to succession crisis (eastern front is not a priority) - Byzantine logistical support available from Mediterranean - Ilkhanate expands to include Syria, Palestine, possibly Egypt - Crusader states: likely become Byzantine vassals or are absorbed - Crusader states and Mongols historically attempted alliances against Mamluks - Contested between Byzantium and Ilkhanate (potential V3 event chain) --- ## Mongol Empire Structure at Peak (~1260s-1270s) ### Great Khan's Domain (Ogedei's line -> merges with Jochi's line after succession crisis) - **Capital**: New city on the Volga River (near historical Sarai) - **Direct territory**: Volga region, Rus settled territories (Kiev, Novgorod, Moscow as major cities), Ukrainian steppe, Galicia-Volhynia, Moldavia, Transylvania, Hungarian Plain, Wallachia - The core forms an "L-shape": - Horizontal axis: Mongol steppe -> Kazakhstan -> Ukrainian steppe -> Black Sea coast - Western extension: Moldavia -> Transylvania (through Carpathian passes) -> Hungarian Plain ### Golden Horde (Jochi's line) - Black Sea steppe, Kuban, North Caucasus - Eventually merges with the Great Khan's domain after succession crisis ### Chagatai Khanate - Central Asia (Transoxiana), Xinjiang, parts of Afghanistan - Capital: Samarkand area - Nominally submits to Great Khan, but practically independent - Closer to the Volga-based Great Khan than historically (Karakorum was much further) ### Ilkhanate (Hulagu's line) - Persia, Iraq, Syria, Palestine, Egypt - Capital: Tabriz (northwestern Persia/Azerbaijan) - Eventually independent after succession crisis - **Already substantially Islamicized by ~1300** (historical pattern: Ghazan Khan converted 1295) - Persian bureaucrats are the administrative backbone (mirror of Byzantium's role in Great Khanate) - Culturally evolving into a Mongol-dynasty Persian-Islamic empire - **Egypt**: governed by Mongol military governor (replacing Turkic Mamluk elite). Mongol hereditary military aristocracy replaces the non-hereditary Mamluk slave-soldier system. Arab/Coptic administrative class retained. Al-Azhar and Islamic institutions preserved. Tendency toward autonomy over time (Egypt always separates eventually — Tulunids, Fatimids, Muhammad Ali pattern). - **Governor's double game**: Mongol-blooded governor exploits Sunni-Shia tension to build local power base. Protects Sunni institutions (Al-Azhar) against Tabriz's Shia centralization → gains loyalty of local Egyptian elites. Plays both sides: loyal Ilkhanate vassal to Tabriz, protector of Sunni faith to Cairo. Secret contacts with Hafsid Tunisia (Sunni center). - Libya (Tripolitania/Cyrenaica): gray zone between Shia Egypt and Sunni Tunisia. Neither fully controls it. - By V3 era: likely fully independent Arabicized dynasty maintaining fiction of Ilkhanate membership. ### Mongol Khanate (Mongol Ulus) (Far East) - **Mongol homeland** (now the imperial periphery, not the center) - Northern Manchuria (Jianzhou/Jurchen tribal areas north of Song border) - Siberia and Russian Far East (nominally - actually scattered tribes) - Very sparse population (hundreds of thousands at most), extremely poor - **Excluded from ALL major trade routes** — Silk Road passes through Song (Hexi) and Chagatai, not Mongolia - Economy: pastoral nomadism + limited Jianzhou agriculture + undeveloped mineral resources (copper, gold, coal, later oil) - Analogous to modern Mongolia: geographically large, economically marginal - Cannot raid Song (industrial military) or Great Khanate (overwhelming force) or Chagatai (too far, defended) - Cannot reach Korea (Song-controlled southern Manchuria blocks access) - Little Ice Age hits pastoral economy hard — dzud (white disaster) frequency increases - **Long-term trajectory**: mineral wealth attracts Song and Great Khanate economic colonization (foreign capital extracts resources, profits flow out). By V3 era, may be economically semi-colonized. - **V3 playable faction** — extreme difficulty, but multiple gameplay paths: - "Mongol Restoration": claim Great Khanate during instability - "Mandate of Heaven": exploit Song internal crisis to invade south, recreating the Qing scenario - "Far Eastern Balancer": play Song and Great Khanate against each other - "Mining Modernization": leverage mineral resources for industrialization (requires foreign investment/technology) --- ## Succession Crisis and Empire Split (~1270s-1300s) Ogedei dies (alcoholism, historical pattern). Succession crisis ensues, but fundamentally different from our timeline: ### Why It's Different - Almost all claimants are concentrated in the Rus core (not spread across Eurasia) - No Chinese theater to fight over - Crisis plays out more like Ottoman fratricide than historical Mongol cross-continental civil wars - Resolved faster (proximity) but more violently ### Outcome: Possibility B (Rus core consolidates, periphery separates) - **Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus)**: Ogedei/Jochi lines merge. Controls Rus + Golden Horde territories + Hungary + direct corridor. Strongest successor state. - **Chagatai Khanate**: Central Asia becomes fully independent - **Ilkhanate**: Middle East becomes fully independent, Islamicizes - **Mongol Khanate (Mongol Ulus)**: Retains Mongol homeland + Far East, becomes a peripheral power - Volga capital's geographic advantage: close enough to maintain stronger authority over Golden Horde and Central Asia than historical Karakorum, but still loses control of distant Ilkhanate --- ## The Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) (Post-Split, ~1300 onward) ### Nature: Between Ottoman Empire and Qing Dynasty - Not as many radically different ethnic groups as the Ottomans - Not as unified a subject population as the Qing's Han Chinese - Slavic majority population with no single unified identity (Novgorod republic tradition vs. Kiev tradition vs. northeast forest principalities) - Mongol ruling minority can exploit these divisions ### Qing Dynasty Parallels | Qing Dynasty | Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) | |---|---| | Manchu minority rules Han majority | Mongol minority rules Slavic majority | | Adopts keju examination system | Adopts Orthodox Church + Slavic civil service | | Eight Banners maintain Manchu military privilege | Mongol cavalry nobility maintains military privilege | | Manchu language gradually dies, elite sinicizes | Mongol language gradually yields to Slavic | | Late Qing Manchu-Han tensions explode | By V3 era: Mongol-Slavic tensions as event chain | ### Capital and Major Cities - **Capital**: New city on Volga River (similar to historical Sarai's location) - **Kiev**: Major city, symbolic importance (spiritual capital of Rus civilization) - **Novgorod**: Northern trade hub, gateway to Baltic, retains some republican self-governance traditions - **Moscow**: Major city in the forest zone ### Post-Black Death Economic Transformation (~1350s-1400s) - Black Death devastates Rus urban population → economic crisis - Great Khanate responds with: increased tribute on vassals, increased Silk Road transit fees, currency inflation - **Consequence**: merchants abandon northern Silk Road route for Chagatai/Ilkhanate southern routes - Northern Silk Road effectively dies → Novgorod's economic basis collapses - **Forced agricultural pivot**: Mongol nobility become landed gentry/estate owners in Ukraine and Hungarian Plain (best farmland in Europe) - Rus and other subject peoples forcibly resettled as agricultural serfs on these estates - Empire transforms from trade-military state to **agricultural serfdom empire** - Parallels historical Russian serfdom but arrived at through different path - By V3 era: serfdom is the core obstacle to industrialization (same as historical Russia) ### Internal Fractures (V3 Event Chain Material) #### Rus Identity Fragmentation The "Rus" people never unify into a single identity (no Moscow to force unification). By V3 era, at least 5 distinct groups: 1. **Novgorod Rus** — Former merchant republic, Western-oriented (Hanseatic ties), traditional Constantinople Orthodoxy. ~1360s: attempts autonomy → Great Khanate crushes it, abolishes veche, installs Mongol prince as ruler. Veche bell removed (symbol of republican death). Hanseatic trading posts closed. City downgraded to Mongol princely fief. Resentment goes underground. By V3 era: culturally distinct, harbors separatist sentiment but politically suppressed. 2. **Kiev-Dnieper Rus** — Around Great Khanate's administrative centers. Most Mongolized, accepts Volga Orthodox sect. Urban, bureaucratic. 3. **Northeast Forest Rus** (Moscow, Vladimir) — Agricultural, isolated, most "Old Rus" traditions preserved. Under direct Mongol rule but less culturally penetrated than Kiev. 4. **Ukrainian Steppe Rus** — Newly resettled serf communities on Mongol-owned estates. Mixed origins (drawn from across the empire). Developing unique identity from shared oppression. 5. **Hungarian Rus** — Serfs forcibly relocated to Hungarian Plain. Mixed with Mongol, Kipchak, remnant Magyar populations. Completely distinct identity forming. #### Religious Schism: Volga Orthodoxy vs. Constantinople Orthodoxy - Great Khan baptized ~1325-1350, develops Mongolized Orthodox sect (Tengri/shamanic elements fused with Orthodox theology) - Independent patriarchate on the Volga, rejects Constantinople's primacy - Novgorod and some western Rus communities **refuse** Volga Orthodoxy, align with Constantinople - Religious divide becomes ethnic/political divide: "true Orthodoxy" vs. "Mongol heresy" - Parallels: historical Ukrainian Greek Catholic vs. Russian Orthodox split, but earlier and more radical #### Other V3 Tensions - **Mongol-Slavic ethnic tension**: Mongol military aristocracy vs. Slavic serf majority - **Serfdom reform pressure**: Industrial Song's example creates pressure for modernization - **Novgorod autonomy movement**: economic reorientation toward Germany, demands for self-governance - **Polish independence movement**: Catholic/Western identity under Orthodox Mongol suzerainty - **Hungarian integration problems**: multi-ethnic agricultural zone with unresolved Magyar minority - Combined: vanilla V3's Russia + Austria + Ottoman problem sets, all in one country ### Key Characteristics for V3 - Enormous territory, relatively low GDP (agricultural serfdom economy) - Multi-ethnic stability problems (worse than vanilla Austria/Ottoman — 5+ Rus sub-identities + Mongol elite + Polish/Lithuanian/Baltic vassals) - Industrialization reform as main storyline (serfdom must be abolished first) - Lost position as Silk Road transit power → economically isolated, dependent on grain exports - Relationship with Song: former trade partner, now economic periphery - Internal Mongol identity vs. Slavic identity conflict accelerating --- ## Vassal and Neighbor States ### Hungary: Absorbed into Great Khanate Core - Hungarian Plain = western terminus of the Eurasian Steppe - Directly incorporated, not vassalized - Mongol/Kipchak/Cuman nomads settle the eastern plain - Magyar population pushed to margins (Transdanubia, northern mountains/Slovakia) - By 1836: ethnically mixed region (Mongol/Turkic/Slavic/Magyar), core province of Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) - Magyar identity possibly extinct or reduced to minority status (like historical Avars) ### Poland: "Korean Model" Vassal - **Territory**: Greater Poland (Poznan), Lesser Poland (Krakow), Masovia (Warsaw), Kuyavia - Lost Silesia to Greater Germany (already Germanizing) - Lost Galicia to Mongol direct control (Rus territory, strategic corridor) - Lost Pomerania to German/Novgorod Baltic sphere - Piast dynasty (or successor) retains throne - Mongol darughachi (resident overseer) stationed in Krakow - Polish szlachta (nobility) retains local power - Catholic Church allowed to operate (Mongol religious tolerance) - Must pay tribute, provide troops, defer on foreign policy - **Core V3 tension**: Catholic/Western cultural identity under Eastern/Orthodox Mongol suzerainty - Strong potential for independence movement event chains ### Bulgaria (Bulgar Khanate): Mongol Vassal - Balkan region north of Byzantine territory, south of Danube - Danube serves as boundary between Mongol direct territory (Wallachia, north bank) and Bulgarian vassal (south bank) - Mongol vassal from the first western campaign ### Byzantine Empire: Mongol Vassal / Indirect Manager - Restored in Constantinople (1261) with Mongol support - Manages Balkans and Anatolia on behalf of the Mongol system - Controls Bosphorus strait - Provides: administration, navy, diplomacy, trade management - Various smaller Balkan entities under Byzantine indirect management - Seljuk Sultanate of Rum remains as vassal under Byzantine oversight - Similar to Han Chinese bureaucrats serving the Qing ### Lithuania: Mongol Military District - Too small to resist Mongols in the 1250s - Incorporated as a directly-administered border military zone - Lithuanian people serve as border military caste (similar to Mongol Banners for ethnic minorities) - Guards the western frontier against Germany ### Baltic Region (Estonia, Latvia, Old Prussia) - Teutonic Order destroyed by Mongol advance - German colonization of Prussia interrupted -> Prussian Germans remain a small minority - Teutonic Order remnant: submits to some power for protection, eventually becomes a German-minority autonomous district (parallel to historical Livonian Order fate) - Region managed by Novgorod as the Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus)'s Baltic proxy - Baltic tribal peoples (Latvians, Estonians, Old Prussians) persist without German colonization pressure - Denmark may retain northern Estonia --- ## Western Europe ### Greater Germany (Grossdeutschland) - **Formation**: Mongol destruction of HRE feudal structure -> accelerated German national consciousness -> unification - **Led by**: Hanseatic League cities (least damaged, strongest economy, bourgeois/civic nationalism) - **Territory**: From the Low Countries (Dutch-speaking areas, pre-separate identity) to Switzerland and Austria - **Excludes**: Poland (Mongol vassal), Prussia (destroyed/Mongol sphere), Bohemia (independent) - **Relationship with Mongols**: Initially loose vassal/tribute, gradually asserts independence as Mongol grip weakens - **V3 status**: Major European power, commercially strong, but lacking overseas colonies (?) - **Includes Silesia**: absorbed from Poland due to existing Germanization ### Bohemia - **Status**: Independent kingdom, allied with but not merged into Greater Germany - **Protected by**: Mountain basin geography (Sudetes, Ore Mountains, Bohemian Forest) - **Possibly bypassed** by main Mongol thrust along the northern plain - Czech national identity too strong for absorption into German nationalism - Silver mining wealth, industrial potential - Strategically positioned between Greater Germany and Great Khanate sphere - In V3: mid-tier independent power ### The Partition of France and the Plantagenet Kingdom Mongol raids into northern France (Flanders, Picardy, ~1240s-1250s) weaken the Capetian dynasty. England exploits this rather than allying (medieval political logic). The result is not "England conquering France" but the **Plantagenet dynasty reclaiming and unifying its continental and insular domains**. #### Why England Claims the French Crown - The English court already speaks Anglo-Norman French - The Plantagenet kings are originally French nobles (Anjou, Normandy) - Losing continental territories (1204, King John) was the anomaly; reclaiming them is "going home" - Population ratio ~4:1 (France:England) means the continental territory is the real center of power #### Capital: Paris - Paris (~200,000) dwarfs London (~40-50,000) - An English king who gains France would move the capital to Paris - same logic as any peripheral conqueror moving to the richer core (Norman -> England in 1066, but in reverse now) - England becomes an "overseas province" of a Paris-centered kingdom - Over time, French identity absorbs English identity at the elite level #### Plantagenet France Territory (~1300) - **Core**: Île-de-France (Paris), Normandy (recovered), Anjou/Maine/Touraine (recovered), Picardy, Champagne - **Original English holdings**: Aquitaine/Gascony (Bordeaux region) - **Insular**: England, possibly Wales, contested Scotland/Ireland - **Vassal**: Brittany (semi-independent, in Plantagenet sphere) - English Channel becomes an internal waterway #### Contested with Burgundy - Plantagenet king claims all of France -> includes sovereignty over Burgundy - Burgundian duke (Capetian cadet branch) may claim to be the true French heir - Creates a **legitimacy war**: two "Frances" competing for the Capetian inheritance - Disputed territories along the Burgundy-Île-de-France border #### Long-term Implications - French language remains elite/court language (English court already French-speaking) - English language persists on the islands as commoner language, developing independently - England/Scotland/Ireland may develop distinct identities resisting continental French elite - By 1836: Atlantic power centered on Paris, controlling northern/western France + British Isles. French-speaking court, English-speaking island populace. ### Duchy of Burgundy (Independent) - **Formation**: Capetian cadet branch declares independence as France collapses - **Territory**: Duchy of Burgundy (Dijon) + County of Burgundy / Franche-Comté (Besançon) - **Language**: Almost entirely French-speaking (~100%). The Franco-German linguistic border runs along the Vosges Mountains; Burgundy is fully on the French side. Franche-Comté was in the HRE but linguistically Romance. - **Relationship with Greater Germany**: Strategic ally but NOT part of German unification. German ethnic nationalism cannot absorb a purely French-speaking state. Alliance based on shared threats (Plantagenet France to the west, Great Khanate to the east). - **Claims**: May claim to be the legitimate successor to the French crown (Capetian blood vs. Plantagenet usurpers) - **V3 role**: Mid-tier independent French-speaking state, buffer between Plantagenet France and Greater Germany ### Iberian Peninsula (Divided) - Reconquista effectively complete by ~1270 (only Granada remains as Castilian tributary) - **Castile and Aragon do NOT merge** (unlike historical 1469 marriage union) #### Crown of Aragon (Mediterranean Power) - **Territory**: Catalonia, Aragon, Valencia, Majorca, **Languedoc** (reclaimed from collapsed France - Occitan/Catalan cultural affinity) - **Possibly also**: Provence, Mediterranean islands (Sicily, Sardinia - historical Aragonese expansion) - **Absorbed Navarre**: France's collapse removes Navarre's protector; too small to survive independently; culturally/geographically closer to Aragon - **Orientation**: Mediterranean, facing Italy and North Africa - **Language zone**: Catalan-Occitan continuum across Pyrenees #### Kingdom of Castile-León (Atlantic Power) - **Territory**: Central and western Iberia (largest Iberian state) - **Orientation**: Atlantic, facing Africa and potentially the open ocean - **Granada**: Emirate survives as Castilian tributary - without Aragon's help, Castile may never muster the political will to finish the Reconquista. Granada could survive to V3 era as a small Muslim vassal state. - **Competitor**: Portugal for Atlantic expansion #### Kingdom of Portugal - **Territory**: Western Iberian coast, Reconquista completed 1249 - **Orientation**: Atlantic, historically the pioneer of maritime exploration - **Competitor**: Castile for Atlantic routes - **Small but independent**, may punch above its weight in exploration/colonization #### Emirate of Granada (Surviving Muslim State) - Last remnant of Al-Andalus - Castilian tributary/vassal - Without united Spain, may survive to 1836 as a small but culturally significant Muslim enclave in Europe - V3: interesting minor power, potential flashpoint ### Scandinavia / Kalmar Union - Mongols don't reach Scandinavia (too cold, too forested, too poor) - **Kalmar Union will form** (even more pressure than historical): - Anglo-French union across the Channel - Earlier unified Greater Germany - Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) with Novgorod buffer - Denmark may lose northern Estonia to Great Khanate sphere - Sweden continues Finnish expansion unopposed - Norway maintains Atlantic possessions (Iceland, Greenland, Faroe Islands) - No Great Northern War equivalent (Great Khanate doesn't prioritize Baltic access - their window is Black Sea/Constantinople) ### Italy (~1300: No significant divergence yet) - Protected by Alps from Mongol invasion - no direct impact - City-states continue as in our timeline (Venice, Genoa, Florence, Papal States, Naples/Sicily, etc.) - Northern Italian economic connections to Germany weakened by Mongol destruction of HRE, but butterfly effects have not yet materialized by 1300 - Status at 1300: essentially same as our timeline's Italy. Divergence will come later. - **Post-1300 evolution: TO BE DETERMINED** --- ## Key Trade Routes ### Hexi Corridor: Song-Controlled - Western Xia destroyed by Genghis Khan (1227) — territory reverts to vacuum - Song fills the vacuum: Hexi Corridor (Gansu) is easily reached and defended from the Chinese heartland, historically Han-populated - **Song controls the eastern terminus of the Silk Road** — not just a goods supplier but the gateway manager ### Land Silk Road (post-Timur revision, ~1420+) Song (Guanzhong) → Hexi Corridor (Song) → Song Western Protectorate (eastern Xinjiang) → Eastern Chagatai remnant (western Xinjiang) → Khoqand Khanate / River-Between Khanate (Samarkand) → Ilkhanate (Khorasan → Persia) → Syria → Mediterranean - **Northern route through Great Khanate: DEAD** (post-1350 trade collapse, never recovered) - Great Khanate regained Kazakhstan steppe but NOT the Silk Road cities - Ilkhanate expanded to absorb Khorasan/western Afghanistan after Timur's death → controls longest segment ### Third Land Route (Burma Road, operational ~1375+) Song (Yunnan) → Burma (Song province) → Bengal / Eastern India → connects to maritime network - Reaches Ilkhanate via Indian Ocean (Persian Gulf / Red Sea) - Bypasses Central Asian middlemen entirely - Burma incorporated as Song province to secure this route ### Maritime Silk Road Song → South China Sea → Malacca Strait → Indian Ocean → two endpoints: 1. **Persian Gulf** (Hormuz → Ilkhanate): major trade terminus 2. **Red Sea** (Aden → Egypt/Ilkhanate): connects to Mediterranean via Cairo - **Ilkhanate profits from BOTH land and sea routes** — sits on two of three trade paths - Song Southeast Asian colonies serve as waypoints and resource extraction sites ### Song Southeast Asian Empire (evolved structure, ~1400) #### Tier 1: Direct Provinces (直辖) - **Vietnam**: Re-incorporated ~1300s. Historical precedent of 1000 years of Chinese rule. Industrial Song overwhelms resistance. - **Burma corridor**: Incorporated ~1300s-1400s to secure the Burma Road (Third Silk Road). At minimum the Irrawaddy corridor. - **Malacca**: Direct fortress/naval base — controls the strait chokepoint. Non-negotiable. #### Tier 2: Xuanweisi (宣慰司, military-administrative districts) - Champa coast, Sumatra east coast (Palembang), north Java coast ports - Key resource extraction zones (tin mines, spice production areas) - Song-appointed officials + local auxiliary administration #### Tier 3: Autonomous Chinese Polities - **Borneo**: Chinese mining republics (gold, diamonds). Lanfang-style kongsi governance. Self-governing but pay tribute to Song. - **Sumatra interior**: Plantation-based Chinese kingdoms - **Philippines (partial)**: Chinese merchant-dominated port city-states - These emerged from post-Black Death Chinese settlement filling the demographic vacuum - Song recognizes their legitimacy without direct governance - Long-term trend: gradual absorption into Tier 2 as Song extends formal control #### Tier 4: Tributary Kingdoms - **Siam**: Largest surviving independent local kingdom. Inland, hard to conquer. Pays tribute. - **Khmer remnant**: Angkor declining but still exists. Tributary. - **Java interior kingdoms**: Majapahit remnants. Coastal cities under Song, interior kingdoms pay tribute. #### Tier 5: Frontier/Trading Posts - **Moluccas** (Spice Islands): Trading posts, not territorial control - **Southern Philippines**: Moro Muslim areas, loose trade relations - **Northern Australia** (~1400: newly discovered): Sea cucumber fishing stations, earliest coastal contact with Aboriginal peoples. Vast continent, arid interior. No significant settlement yet. #### Decision Logic Strategic chokepoint → Direct province. Extractable resources → Xuanweisi. Chinese already governing well → Recognize autonomy, collect tax. None of the above → Tributary is sufficient. Long-term trend: Tiers creep upward (Tier 3→2, Tier 2→1). #### Australia (discovered ~1400) - ~400km from Timor to northern Australia coast — natural extension of SE Asian maritime expansion - Initial contact: sea cucumber fishing, Aboriginal trade - Northern coast settlements develop slowly (~1400-1500s) - Interior exploration begins ~1500s+ - **Major mineral deposits** (iron ore, coal, gold) discovered over following centuries - By V3 era (~1836): resource colony with Chinese coastal cities, interior still largely Aboriginal - **Iron ore exports will eventually impact Song's domestic northern iron industry** — creating new economic tensions (but this is a V3-era issue, not a 1400 issue) ### Japan: Silver Island - No Mongol invasions (1274, 1281) → less national cohesion, Kamakura shogunate's legitimacy basis differs - Japanese gold/silver output (Iwami Ginzan etc.) is globally critical — **without New World silver, Japan is the world's primary precious metal supplier** - Song merchants active in Hakata, Hirado; Japan integrated into Song trade network - But no external threat → less motivation for centralization or technology adoption - V3 era: pre-industrial but wealthy from silver, capable of rapid industrialization if stimulated (Black Ships equivalent scenario) ### Korea (Goryeo): Song Tributary - Mongol Khanate cannot reach Korea (Song controls southern Manchuria, blocks land approach) - Korea defaults to traditional tributary relationship with Chinese dynasty (Song) - Purchases Song industrial goods, maintains internal autonomy - Culturally influenced by Song but politically independent ### Song Western Protectorate (西域都护府) — established ~1400s - Song controls eastern Xinjiang from Hexi Corridor westward (Dunhuang → Turfan → Korla) - **Used as fiefdoms for northern military officials** — redirects ambitious generals to the frontier - Solves internal problem: northern wumen (武官) too powerful → give them western frontier to manage - Parallels Tang Dynasty's Anxi/Beiting Protectorates - Song court aware of An Lushan precedent → implements checks (civilian inspectors, rotation, troop limits) - Short-term: relieves North-South tension. Long-term risk: frontier warlords may become independent power center - Military governor fiefdoms manage Silk Road security and collect transit taxes - Eastern Chagatai remnant (Kashgar, Khotan, Yarkand) remains independent to the west but under heavy Song economic influence ### Trade Route Summary (post-1420) | Route | Song share | Middlemen | Endpoint | |---|---|---|---| | ~~Northern Silk Road~~ | ~~Dead~~ | ~~Collapsed post-1350~~ | ~~Great Khanate excluded~~ | | Southern Silk Road | Hexi + W. Protectorate | E. Chagatai → Khoqand → Ilkhanate | Mediterranean | | Burma Road | Yunnan + Burma (province) | India | Ilkhanate (Persian Gulf/Red Sea) | | Maritime | SE Asian empire | Indian Ocean | Ilkhanate (Hormuz/Aden) | | **Great Khanate** | **Cut off from all routes** | Grain export via Black Sea only | Economic isolation | | **Mongol Khanate** | **None** | **None** | Subsistence + Song/GK economic colonization | ### Post-Timur Central Asian Partition (~1410-1430) After Timur's death (~1405), his empire fragments. Combined with Great Khanate's eastern campaign: | Territory | Goes to | Notes | |---|---|---| | Kazakhstan steppe | Great Khanate (recovered) | Open steppe, easy for GK cavalry. Pushes to Syr Darya line. | | Western Siberia | Great Khanate (recovered) | GK's backyard, no resistance | | Transoxiana (Samarkand, Bukhara, Fergana) | **Khoqand Khanate** (Timurid remnant) | Two-river zone protected by natural barriers. Cultural golden age continues. | | Khorasan + western Afghanistan (Herat) | Ilkhanate (expanded) | Ilkhanate fills vacuum south of Amu Darya. Persian cultural zone unified. | | Eastern Afghanistan (Kabul) + N. India | **Timurid-Indian dynasty** (proto-Mughal) | Timurid prince establishes independent Indian kingdom | | Eastern Xinjiang (Turfan, Korla) | Song Western Protectorate | Military governor fiefdoms | | Western Xinjiang (Kashgar, Khotan) | **Eastern Chagatai remnant** | Independent, Song economic vassal | | Mongolia + N. Manchuria + E. Siberia | Mongol Khanate (re-independent) | Back to poverty and isolation | --- ## Manchuria / Jianzhou ### Division - **Southern Manchuria** (Liao River corridor, southern Jilin): Song-controlled - Site of Song's northern industrial expansion - Jurchen minority gradually sinicized - Key to Song's industrialization story (labor scarcity -> mechanization) - **Northern Manchuria** (Heilongjiang, outer Manchuria): Mongol Khanate (Mongol Ulus) sphere - Forest/tundra, very sparse population - Jianzhou and other Jurchen tribes maintain semi-independent hunting/fishing lifestyle - Too cold and poor for Song expansion, too marginal for Mongol attention ### Why Manchu/Qing Never Happens - Historical Manchu unification required: weak Ming control of northeast + space for Jurchen consolidation - In this timeline: Song industrial control in south + Mongol sphere in north = two strong powers squeezing Jurchens - Jurchens never unify into a single state - By 1836: minority ethnic group split between Song (assimilated) and Mongol Khanate (Mongol Ulus) (tribal) --- ## India (~1300-1325) ### Delhi Sultanate (Dominant North Indian Power) - Khalji dynasty (1290-1320), then Tughluq dynasty (1320+) - Alauddin Khalji (1296-1316): peak power, repelled historical Mongol invasions, conquered Deccan - In this timeline: Chagatai Khanate (with fire weapons) poses greater threat from the northwest via Afghanistan - But Delhi can acquire fire weapons through Song maritime trade and Burma road → threat is manageable - India's production capacity far exceeds Chagatai's despite being agricultural/pre-industrial - **Emerging threat**: Song industrial textiles entering Indian coastal markets via maritime trade - India is the world's largest textile producer - Song cheap factory-made cloth will undercut Indian handloom textiles - Effect similar to British Industrial Revolution's destruction of Indian industry — but 500 years earlier - By ~1375-1400: serious economic disruption in Indian textile-producing regions ### South India - Pandya, Hoysala, Kakatiya kingdoms being conquered by Delhi - Vijayanagara Empire will form ~1336 as resistance to Delhi - Coastal cities increasingly integrated into Song maritime trade network ### India's Long-term Role - Sits on the Burma Road (third Silk Road) between Song and the Ilkhanate - Major market for Song industrial goods AND supplier of spices, gems, cotton - Politically fragmented → vulnerable to Song economic penetration - Not colonized (too large, too populated) but economically dependent on Song trade --- ## Tibet (~1300) - Historical Sakya-Mongol alliance (1240s) depended on Yuan Dynasty patronage — no Yuan in this timeline - Tibet is **effectively independent**, fragmented among Buddhist monastic schools/sects - Song does not prioritize Tibet: high altitude, low economic value, difficult logistics - Song expansion priorities: Southeast Asia (rich) > Burma Road (strategic) > Tibet (not urgent) - Tibet may come under loose Song cultural/religious influence over time - Long-term: Song may eventually assert control to prevent Chagatai or Mongol Khanate from using it as staging ground --- ## North Africa / Maghreb ### Status at 1425: Calm Before the Storm - **Morocco (Marinid dynasty)**: Declining. Wattasid regents gaining power. Lost Ceuta to Portugal (1415). - **Algeria (Zayyanid dynasty)**: Weak, squeezed between Morocco and Tunisia. Often vassalized by one neighbor. - **Tunisia (Hafsid dynasty)**: Golden age under Abu Faris (1394-1434). Mediterranean trade hub. **Rising as Sunni Islam's spiritual capital** (Hafsid caliphate claim increasingly recognized). - Trans-Saharan gold trade (from Mali/Songhai) continues unchanged — North Africa's most stable revenue source ### Coming Threats (not yet materialized by 1425) - **Portugal**: Will continue pressing Moroccan coast from Ceuta base - **Aragon**: Future North African coastal outposts likely, but not yet established - **Portuguese West African exploration**: Once sea route to West African gold coast is established (~1440s+), it bypasses Saharan caravan routes → undermines North African middleman economy - **No Ottoman Empire to rescue them**: Historically, Ottomans conquered North Africa (1500s) and protected it from Spanish invasion. In this timeline, North Africa must face European pressure alone. ### Sunni-Shia Fault Line - Runs through Libya (Tripolitania/Cyrenaica) between Sunni Tunisia and Shia-ruled Egypt - Sunni scholars fleeing Egypt's Shia rulers migrate to Tunis and Fez → boosts Maghreb's Islamic scholarly prestige - Tunisia-Egypt relations tense: religious rivalry + Egyptian governor's double game (courting Sunni support while nominally Shia) --- ## Religion in This World ### Eastern Orthodoxy - Becomes the dominant religion of the Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) - Great Khan baptized ~1325-1350, but **rejects Constantinople's religious authority** - Develops a distinctive **Mongolized Orthodox sect**: fuses Orthodox Christian theology with Mongol/Tengri cultural traditions - Possibly independent patriarchate on the Volga, refusing Constantinople's primacy - Parallels: Ethiopian Orthodox Church (independent from broader Orthodoxy), or Moscow's "Third Rome" doctrine but earlier and more radical - Mongol shamanic elements incorporated into ritual and imagery - Constantinople remains the spiritual center for Byzantine/Balkan Orthodoxy only - Creates a religious split within the Orthodox world: Volga Orthodoxy vs. Constantinople Orthodoxy ### Catholicism - Survives in: Western Europe (Germany, France, England, Iberia, Italy, Scandinavia) - Poland: Catholic enclave under Orthodox Mongol suzerainty (major tension source) - Bohemia: Catholic - Papacy: survives in Rome (Italy protected by Alps) ### Islam: Three-Way Split #### Shia Islam (Ilkhanate sphere) — wealthiest, most organized - **Core**: Persia, Iraq, Khorasan, western Afghanistan - **Expansion via trade**: Ilkhanate merchants (Persian + Gujarati Muslims) carry Shia Islam along maritime Silk Road - **Southeast Asian Shia**: ~1300s-1400s, Shia Islam reaches northern Sumatra (Aceh) via Indian Ocean trade - Aceh becomes **Shia**, not Sunni (unlike our timeline) — because the richest Muslim merchants are from the Shia Ilkhanate - Spreads to: Malay Peninsula coasts (non-Song controlled areas), Sumatra west coast, parts of island SE Asia periphery - Creates Ilkhanate-aligned Muslim polities in Song's backyard - **Aceh as Ilkhanate proxy**: sits at Malacca Strait entrance, potential to harass Song shipping. Song may need to confront this eventually. - **Egypt**: Mongol ruling class follows Ilkhanate Shia, but local population (Al-Azhar tradition) is Sunni → internal religious tension (parallels Great Khanate's Volga Orthodoxy vs. Constantinople Orthodoxy) - **India**: Shia influence spreading via Ilkhanate trading posts on western Indian coast #### Sunni Islam (North Africa + Central Asia) — independent but fragmented - **North Africa (Maghreb)**: Last fully independent Sunni region - Morocco (Marinid dynasty): independent - Algeria (Zayyanid dynasty): independent - **Tunisia (Hafsid dynasty): Sunni spiritual center** — Hafsid sultans recognized as caliphs. In this world, Tunis replaces Istanbul/Cairo as Sunni Islam's capital. - **Central Asia**: Khoqand Khanate, Eastern Chagatai — Sunni but squeezed between Song and Ilkhanate - **No single Sunni power capable of matching Shia Ilkhanate's wealth or military** #### Islamic Decentralization Consequences - Sufi orders gain importance as trans-political religious networks (bridge Shia-Sunni divide) - No single Islamic caliphate recognized universally - Islamic legal/scholarly authority fragments: Al-Azhar (Cairo, Sunni but under Shia rulers), Qarawiyyin (Fez), Samarkand - No equivalent of the historical Ottoman Empire as unified Islamic superpower #### SE Asian Religious Geography (~1400) | Zone | Dominant Religion | Notes | |---|---|---| | Song direct provinces (Vietnam, Burma, Malacca) | Buddhist/Confucian/Daoist | Chinese administration | | Chinese settler polities (Borneo, parts of Sumatra/Philippines) | Buddhist/Confucian/folk religion | Chinese cultural sphere | | Aceh + Malay coast (non-Song) | **Shia Islam** | Ilkhanate trade influence | | Siam, Khmer, mainland interior | Theravada Buddhism | Historical pattern continues | | Island interiors, Papua, remote areas | Animist/traditional | Unchanged | | Southern Philippines (Mindanao) | Islam (Shia?) | Spreading via trade | ### Song China - Buddhism, Daoism, Confucianism (historical pattern) - No significant change from baseline --- ## 1300 Snapshot: COMPLETE All major regions defined at the 1300 checkpoint. Summary of world powers: | Power | Center | Nature | |---|---|---| | Song Dynasty | China (Kaifeng/Hangzhou) | Industrial superpower, expanding into SE Asia | | Great Khanate (Yeke Ulus) | Volga River | Largest land empire, Orthodox, Mongol-Slavic hybrid | | Ilkhanate | Tabriz | Islamicized Mongol-Persian empire, controls Middle East + Egypt | | Chagatai Khanate | Samarkand | Central Asian, Islamicizing | | Mongol Khanate (Mongol Ulus) | Mongolia/Siberia | Peripheral, poor, strategic position | | Plantagenet France | Paris | Atlantic power, cross-Channel, rising | | Greater Germany | Hanseatic cities | Commercial power, emerging from Mongol vassalage | | Crown of Aragon | Barcelona | Mediterranean + Languedoc | | Castile-León | Toledo/Burgos | Atlantic Iberia | | Portugal | Lisbon | Small Atlantic state | | Burgundy | Dijon | Independent French-speaking buffer state | | Bohemia | Prague | Independent, mountain-protected | | Kalmar Union | Forming | Scandinavian defensive alliance | | Byzantine Empire | Constantinople | Mongol vassal, Balkans/Anatolia manager | | Hafsid Tunisia | Tunis | Potential new center of Sunni Islam | | Marinid Morocco | Fez | Independent Islamic state | | Italy | Various | City-states, no divergence yet | | Poland | Krakow | Mongol vassal (Korean model) | | Granada | Granada | Last European Muslim state, Castilian tributary | --- ## 1350 Checkpoint: Black Death and its Consequences ### Black Death Transmission and Impact (~1346-1360) Plague travels via Silk Road trade routes. More active trade in this timeline means potentially faster spread. | Region | Impact | Notes | |---|---|---| | Great Khanate (Rus cities) | Severe (30-50%) | Urban populations devastated | | Western Europe | Severe (30-60%) | Similar to our timeline | | Ilkhanate / Middle East | Severe (30-40%) | Cairo hit especially hard | | Song Dynasty | Moderate (10-20%) | Better sanitation, historical plague resistance. But political impact severe: "loss of Mandate" narrative | | Southeast Asia | **Catastrophic (50-80%)** | No previous exposure. Song maritime trade carries plague to colonial ports. New World-style demographic collapse. Chinese settlers fill vacuum. | | Mongol Khanate | Minimal | Population too sparse for epidemic transmission | | Steppe/pastoral zones | Low-moderate | Low density provides natural social distancing | ### Key Consequences by Region **Song Dynasty**: Plague + "Mandate of Heaven" crisis. Population decline temporarily eases North-South economic tension (fewer workers → higher wages in south). But land consolidation already completed by landlord class — structural problems not resolved, merely postponed. Northern military officials use crisis to expand autonomy. Surface unity, deepening internal fracture. **Great Khanate**: Economic crisis → disastrous policy responses (tribute hikes, transit fee increases, currency inflation) → northern Silk Road dies → Novgorod collapses economically → forced agricultural pivot to Ukraine/Hungary → serfdom deepens → German vassals break away. See "Post-Black Death Economic Transformation" section above. **Greater Germany**: Black Death + Great Khanate tribute demands = final trigger for independence movement (~1350-1380). Hanseatic cities lead formal break from Mongol vassalage. Great Khanate too weakened to enforce compliance militarily. **Ilkhanate**: Hit hard but survives. Trade revenue temporarily drops but infrastructure intact — recovers as plague passes. Egypt's governor uses chaos to expand autonomy → semi-independent by ~1375. Ilkhanate remains wealthiest successor state due to trade monopoly position. **Southeast Asia**: Demographic catastrophe transforms the region. Song colonial presence shifts from trading posts to territorial control as local populations collapse. By ~1400, coastal SE Asia increasingly Chinese-settled. **Bohemia**: Relatively protected by mountain geography. Stable, wealthy (silver mines). Positions itself as key ally of emerging independent Germany. **Kalmar Union**: Scandinavian kingdoms severely weakened (Norway especially). Accelerates union formation — possibly 1360s-1370s instead of historical 1397. **Italy**: Hit hard by plague (historical). Venice and Genoa trade networks disrupted but recover. As trade shifts to southern Silk Road routes, Italian city-states become **Europe's new gateway** to Eastern goods via Mediterranean → Ilkhanate connection, replacing collapsed Novgorod route. **Trade Route Revolution**: Northern Silk Road (Great Khanate) effectively dies. Southern routes (Chagatai → Ilkhanate → Mediterranean) become dominant. Sea routes grow. Winners: Ilkhanate, Italian city-states, Chagatai. Losers: Great Khanate, Novgorod. --- ## 1375 Checkpoint ### Post-Black Death Industrialization Spectrum Labor scarcity after plague drives mechanization interest worldwide, but capacity varies enormously: | Tier | Powers | Status | |---|---|---| | Already industrial | Song (north) | 200+ year head start | | Importing Song tech | Ilkhanate, Greater Germany, Italian city-states | Trade wealth / commercial capital funds technology acquisition | | Conditions exist but not started | Plantagenet France, Aragon, Bohemia | Capital and motivation present, but scale/focus lacking | | Structurally blocked | Great Khanate | **Serfdom prevents industrialization** — forced labor eliminates incentive for machines | | Too poor/small | Mongol Khanate, Granada | No capital, no infrastructure | | Being de-industrialized | India | Song factory goods destroying native handicraft industry | ### Novgorod Crushed (~1360s) - Novgorod attempts greater autonomy, citing economic collapse and religious differences - Great Khanate seizes the opportunity: needs internal victory to restore prestige after losing Germany - Veche (popular assembly) abolished, veche bell removed as symbol - Hanseatic trading posts closed and merchants expelled - Mongol prince (Great Khan's son) installed as ruler — city becomes princely fief - Novgorod's commercial elite dispersed or killed - **Consequence**: Great Khanate destroys its last commercially capable city, cementing agricultural-only economy - Novgorodian resentment goes underground — V3 era separatist potential remains ### Greater Germany: Independent (~1360s-1370s) - Formal break from Great Khanate vassalage - Hanseatic-led **confederal structure** forming — but deepest internal tension is **monarchy vs. republic** - Hanseatic north: wants merchant republic / confederation with no monarch - Southern nobility (Austria, Bavaria): wants hereditary or elected monarchy - Eastern Germany weakened by Mongol devastation → power balance favors Hanseatic north - Constitutional debate may last decades/centuries (parallels: Dutch Republic stadtholder controversy) - V3 core event chain: government reform / constitutional crisis - Alliance with Bohemia formalized - Begins importing Song technology via Italian Mediterranean trade routes - Early proto-industrial development in Hanseatic cities ### Timur's Rise and the Chagatai Breakaway (~1370-1405) - Timur rises in Transoxiana, seizes control of Chagatai Khanate (~1370) - Declares full independence from Great Khanate (no resistance — Great Khanate too weak to project power to Central Asia) - **Cannot conquer the Ilkhanate** — Ilkhanate is too wealthy, too modernized, fire-weapon equipped, Persian bureaucratic system too robust. Border stabilizes in eastern Khorasan. - **Conquers/raids India**: Delhi Sultanate already weakened by Song economic penetration. Timur sacks Delhi (~1398) and occupies northern territories. - **Expands north**: Takes western Siberia from undefended Great Khanate territory - **Vassalizes Mongol Khanate**: Too weak to resist. Timur gains Genghisid legitimacy claim through this. - **Tibet alliance**: Partners with independent Tibet to harass Song's southwestern border. Light raiding, not full war — positive return without provoking Song's industrial military. - **Alliance with Egypt**: Supports Egypt's semi-independence to create two-front pressure on Ilkhanate. Egypt remains semi-autonomous within Ilkhanate but is a thorn in its side. - **After Timur's death (~1405)**: Empire fragments (historical pattern). Timurid successor states in Central Asia and possibly India. ### Ilkhanate: Strongest Period - Near-100-year Silk Road trade monopoly → enormous wealth - **Approaching industrialization**: Persian bureaucratic system + Song technology imports + trade capital + Shia centralization = closest to industrial revolution outside Song - Defends successfully against Timur in the east - Managing Egypt's semi-autonomy (cannot fully break away but increasingly self-governing) - Syrian cold war with Byzantium continues - **Maritime expansion beginning**: Trading posts on Indian western coast (Gujarat, Malabar) via Persian Gulf. Not territorial conquest but economic presence. - V3 trajectory: major industrial power, Song's primary global competitor ### Levant Triangle: Byzantium vs. Ilkhanate vs. Egypt - Syria/Palestine remains three-way influence zone: - **Byzantium** (Great Khanate proxy): claims Levantine coast, manages Crusader remnants - **Ilkhanate** (Tabriz): Syria is direct territory, resists Byzantine/Great Khanate encroachment - **Egypt** (semi-independent, Timur-backed): pushes into Palestine/Sinai as buffer zone - Cold war / proxy conflict, not open warfare - V3 event chain material: diplomatic plays over Syrian territory ### Plantagenet France - Recovering from plague - Paris court consolidated over northern/western France + England - Scotland likely achieved de facto independence (Plantagenet focus entirely continental) - Burgundy rivalry continues as cold war over French legitimacy - **Potential tension with Papacy** developing: cross-Channel empire resists Rome's interference in Church appointments and taxation. Seeds of later Gallican-style independence or even break from Rome. ### Kalmar Union - Formally established (~1360s-1370s, earlier than historical 1397) - Defensive alliance against Greater Germany and Great Khanate - Norway retains Atlantic possessions (Iceland, Greenland) ### Bohemia: Religious Reform - Independent, stable, wealthy (silver mines) - **Hussite-type religious reform movement** emerges but WITHOUT nationalist component (Bohemia already independent) - Purely religious: challenges Church corruption, indulgences, clerical wealth - Without nationalist packaging, reform ideas **spread more easily across borders** — to Germany, Burgundy, even Plantagenet France - Papacy (stable in Rome, no Great Schism to deal with) responds with conservative crackdown - **Seeds of broader Reformation** planted — may erupt more forcefully in 1400s-1500s - V3 era: religious tension as event chain across Catholic Europe ### Western Schism: Does NOT Happen - Avignon Captivity never occurred (Capetian France that caused it doesn't exist) - Pope remains in Rome throughout - Papacy more stable but also more conservative (no crisis to force reform) - Catholic world geographically smaller (lost Eastern Europe to Volga Orthodoxy, Poland is isolated Catholic enclave) ### Iberian Peninsula - **Castile**: Pedro I ("the Cruel") survives — no Trastámara usurpation (no Hundred Years' War = no French intervention to depose him). Pedro's Castile is more centralist, more tolerant of Jewish and Muslim minorities. Granada survives comfortably as tributary. - **Portugal**: Avis dynasty crisis (~1383-1385) proceeds as in history. John I of Avis takes power, defeats Castilian invasion. Portugal begins Atlantic orientation → future exploration. - **Aragon**: Consolidating Languedoc + Mediterranean expansion (Sicily, Sardinia). Absorbing Navarre. ### Song Dynasty - North-South fracture deepening but no open break yet - SE Asian colonization accelerating (post-plague depopulation of local peoples) - Burma Road developing, connecting Yunnan to Bengal - Mandate of Heaven narrative simmering — religious movements in the south - Timur-Tibet alliance creating southwestern border harassment (manageable but draining) - Timeline for crisis: pressure building toward ~1450-1500 range --- ## 1400-1425 Checkpoint ### Timur's Death and Central Asian Partition (~1405-1430) See "Post-Timur Central Asian Partition" table in Trade Routes section for territorial details. - Great Khanate recovers Kazakhstan steppe (to Syr Darya) + western Siberia - Ilkhanate absorbs Khorasan + western Afghanistan - Khoqand Khanate (Timurid remnant) retains Transoxiana - Mongol Khanate regains independence (poor, isolated) - **Timurid-Indian Empire**: Timur conquered entire northeastern India (Delhi + Gangetic plain + Bengal). After his death, Timurid successor establishes massive North Indian kingdom. Preparing for eventual Indian unification. Faces: Vijayanagara (south), Rajputs (west), Song economic penetration via Burma Road (east), Ilkhanate trading posts on western coast. ### Northern Ulus (Novgorod Khanate): Expansionist Turn - Mongol prince, needing revenue after commercial collapse, pivots to **fur trade + territorial expansion** - **Northward**: Into Lapland/Kola Peninsula for furs (minimal resistance from Sami peoples) - **Westward into Finland/Karelia**: Direct conflict with Kalmar Union (Sweden) - Forest warfare, seasonal raids, fort-building, competing for Finnic/Karelian tribal allegiance - Neither side can deliver decisive blow in taiga terrain - **Baltic coast**: Northern Ulus inherits Novgorod's former Baltic proxy territories (Estonia, Latvia) - Now treats them as direct possessions, not Great Khanate proxy management - Cuts into Hanseatic/German commercial space - **Baltic Sea returns as a commercial opportunity** — Northern Ulus may partially recover trade income through Baltic fur/timber exports, replacing the lost Silk Road transit role - Creates **four-way Baltic rivalry**: Kalmar Union (north/west), Northern Ulus (east), Greater Germany/Hanseatic (south), with Plantagenet France as indirect participant via English North Sea interests ### Greater Germany: Internal Crisis + Italian Rivalry - **Constitutional crisis**: Monarchy vs. republic debate intensifies - Likely resolved through compromise: **elected federal leader with limited powers** (Dutch stadtholder-style) - Short internal conflict possible but external pressures prevent prolonged civil war - **Italian rivalry with Aragon**: Both powers compete for influence over Italian city-states - Germany pushes from the north (Alps → Milan, Venice) - Aragon pushes from Mediterranean (already holds Sicily, Sardinia → wants Naples) - Italian city-states play both sides (Venice leans German, Naples leans Aragon, Florence/Papacy try to stay independent) - Proxy wars and diplomatic maneuvering, not full-scale conquest ### Plantagenet France: Consolidation + British Isles Campaigns - Continental position now stable → turns attention to the islands - **Scotland campaign**: Attempts to reconquer de facto independent Scotland. Highland terrain makes it difficult — likely prolonged war of attrition, not quick conquest. - **Ireland**: Strengthens coastal garrison control, but full conquest of Gaelic interior unlikely. Pale expands somewhat. - **Wales**: Already under control (historical conquest in 13th century). - **Burgundy friction**: Ongoing cold war over French legitimacy. Border skirmishes, diplomatic rivalry. ### Ilkhanate and Song: Early Indian Ocean Competition - **Ilkhanate**: Trading posts on Indian western coast (Gujarat, Malabar) via Persian Gulf. Economic presence, not territorial conquest. - **Song**: Trading posts developing on Indian eastern coast via Burma Road connection to Bengal. Plus maritime network from SE Asian colonies. - **East Africa**: Song's Zheng He-equivalent explorer (~1405-1430s) maps East African coast, establishes early contact. Ilkhanate has existing connections via Oman/Yemen → Swahili coast. Both powers beginning to establish presence. **East Africa becomes a future Song-Ilkhanate competition zone.** - Neither side confronts the other directly yet — Indian Ocean is big enough for both. But the seeds of maritime rivalry are planted. ### Zheng He-Equivalent Explorer (~1405-1430s) - Northwestern Muslim origin (homeland in Hexi/Western Protectorate area, family displaced by frontier expansion) - Works in Song's interior, becomes merchant-navigator - **Private/semi-official expeditions** (Song's commercial culture, not Ming-style state pageantry) - Achievements: detailed mapping of East African coast (Somalia → Mozambique), confirms Australia as continent, possibly reaches Madagascar, opens direct Song → East Africa trade route bypassing Ilkhanate middlemen - **Strategic significance**: If this East African route matures, Song can access African gold/ivory without paying Ilkhanate transit fees ### Portugal: Atlantic Pivot and Columbus - **1415**: Conquest of Ceuta (Morocco) — proceeds as in history - **~1420**: Madeira discovered. **~1427**: Azores discovered. - Portuguese explorers sailing down African west coast encounter Swahili/Arab merchants who report that the **Indian Ocean is already dominated by Song and Ilkhanate** → intelligence reaches Lisbon by 1480s - **Realization**: The African route to India leads to an already-occupied market, not virgin trading territory - **~1484**: Columbus (Genoese navigator) proposes westward voyage to reach Asia. **Portugal accepts** (unlike history where they rejected him) - Historical Portugal rejected Columbus because they believed the African route was better - In this timeline: African route = dead end → western route becomes attractive - **~1490s**: Columbus sails west under Portuguese flag → discovers the Caribbean / Americas - **The Americas become Portuguese**, not Spanish. Massive divergence from our timeline. - Castile (Pedro I's line, more internally focused) is left behind in the Atlantic race. ### Americas: Colonial Landscape Emerging | Discoverer | Route | Territory | Timing | |---|---|---|---| | Kalmar Union | Iceland → Greenland → Vinland (Norse route) | Newfoundland / NE North America | ~1400-1420s (rediscovery of Vinland) | | Portugal (Columbus) | Atlantic crossing (Canaries → Caribbean) | Caribbean, Central America, Brazil | ~1490s | | Plantagenet France | English Atlantic ports → North Atlantic | Mid-Atlantic North America? | ~1500s | | Castile | Late Atlantic entry | Whatever Portugal didn't claim | ~1510s+ | | Song | Pacific too wide | Cannot reach Americas | N/A | ### Kalmar Union: Vinland Rediscovery - Norway (within Kalmar) retains Iceland + Greenland settlements - Norse knowledge of Vinland (Newfoundland) persists in Icelandic sagas - Motivations to go further: cod fishing (Grand Banks), timber for treeless Greenland, escaping Kalmar internal politics - ~1400-1420s: Norse/Kalmar fishermen and settlers reach Newfoundland, establish seasonal camps - Not yet full colonization — fishing stations and timber camps, not conquest - Contact with Beothuk/Mi'kmaq peoples ### Bohemia: Reform Movement Continues - Hussite-type religious reform spreading across Catholic Europe borders (no nationalist wrapper → ideas travel more freely) - Papacy attempts crackdown but reform sentiment reaches Germany, Burgundy, even France - No full Reformation yet, but pressure building --- ## 1450 Checkpoint ### Portugal: Expanded African + Spice Islands Presence - **West African coast**: Deeper penetration than historical. Gold, slaves, sugar plantations. - **Cape Colony**: Portuguese establish permanent settlement at Cape of Good Hope (earlier than Dutch 1652 in our timeline). Essential waypoint for the Spice Islands route. - **East African coast**: Multiple trading posts (beyond historical Mozambique). Competing with Song's Zheng He-equivalent explorer's network. - **Spice Islands (Moluccas)**: Portuguese reach Moluccas via route bypassing Malacca: - Cape → Mozambique Channel → Indian Ocean south → Timor Sea / Sunda Strait → Moluccas - Exploit gaps in Song's control (Moluccas = Song Tier 5, minimal presence) - Establish trading posts at Ternate, Tidore — direct access to cloves, nutmeg - Song tolerates this: Moluccas are peripheral, Portuguese buying spices enriches the market, small European presence isn't threatening - **Overall**: Portugal's eastern empire is smaller than historical (no Goa, no Malacca, no Hormuz) but compensated by more extensive African colonization and Moluccas backdoor access. - **Columbus expedition**: Building toward ~1490s westward voyage under Portuguese flag. ### Aragon Wins Italy (~1440s-1460) - **Aragon's advantages in the Italian War**: - Mediterranean naval superiority (largest fleet in western Mediterranean) - Operating from nearby bases (Sicily, Sardinia) — short supply lines - Italian allies in the south (pro-Aragon Neapolitan factions) - **Germany's disadvantages**: - Alps logistics nightmare (moving armies over mountain passes) - Internal constitutional crisis (monarchy vs. republic) diverts attention - Hanseatic cities reluctant to fund distant Italian wars (commercial, not military, culture) - **Result**: Aragon conquers Naples (~1442, as in history), then extends influence further: - **Aragon sphere**: Naples, Sicily, Sardinia, parts of southern Papal States - **German sphere shrinks**: Milan remains influenced but Germany can't sustain Italian campaigns - **Venice**: Stays independent, pragmatically trades with everyone - **Florence + Papal States**: Maintain independence but lean toward Aragon or neutrality - **Aragon becomes a genuine Mediterranean great power**: Catalonia-Aragon-Valencia-Languedoc-Navarre + Sicily + Sardinia + Naples = controls western Mediterranean from Barcelona to Naples - **Renaissance continues**: War stimulates rather than suppresses cultural flourishing. Military competition drives Song technology adoption. Political chaos inspires Machiavelli-type political philosophy. ### Northern Ulus vs Kalmar: Finnish Frontier War - Ongoing low-intensity conflict in Finnish/Karelian forests - Neither side achieves decisive breakthrough (taiga terrain prevents it) - Northern Ulus pushes into eastern Finland/Karelia; Kalmar holds western Finland - Baltic coast: Northern Ulus consolidates control of Estonian/Latvian coast, reviving some Baltic trade (furs, timber to German/Scandinavian buyers) - Kalmar Union strengthened by external threat — internal Scandinavian unity improves ### Great Khanate: Temporary Stabilization - Kazakhstan recovery provides some economic/territorial boost - Agricultural serfdom system in Ukraine/Hungary deepening - But fundamental problems unresolved: no industrialization, internal ethnic fractures, trade isolation - The Kazakhstan campaign bought time but didn't solve anything ### Ilkhanate: Industrialization Advancing - Post-Timur expansion (Khorasan, western Afghanistan) consolidated - Persian bureaucracy driving economic modernization - Song technology imports (via Silk Road + maritime trade) being systematically adopted - Early factories in Isfahan, Tabriz? Textile production modernizing? - **Approaching a tipping point**: the Ilkhanate may achieve genuine industrialization by ~1500-1550 - Egypt increasingly autonomous but still economically tied to the Ilkhanate system ### Song Dynasty: Crisis Approaching - **Second cold wave (Spörer Minimum) begins ~1460** — agricultural crisis returns - This hits the SAME structural weaknesses that the first wave exposed: - Southern agriculture declining again - Northern industry relatively unaffected - But now: land consolidation already completed by landlords (from first wave) - Southern peasants have no buffer left - Western Protectorate generals have built independent power bases - **Mandate of Heaven narrative intensifies**: folk religious movements, prophecies of dynastic change - **Timeline for open crisis: ~1460-1500** - Southeast Asian colonies provide some pressure relief (emigration outlet) but not enough ### Timurid-Indian Empire - Consolidating control over Gangetic plain + Bengal - Preparing southern expansion (Deccan campaigns against Vijayanagara?) - Song economic penetration via Burma Road reaching Bengal — complex relationship (trade dependency + political independence) - Fire weapons acquired from Song → military modernization --- ## Open Questions (Post-1450 Chronological Development) 1. **Song's North-South crisis (~1460-1500)**: How does it play out? Civil war? Peaceful restructuring? Western generals' role? 2. **Columbus discovers Americas (~1490s)**: Portuguese colonization of the New World — what develops? 3. **Reformation**: Hussite movement → when does it become a full break from Rome? 4. **Ilkhanate industrialization**: Does it succeed? How does it change the global power balance? 5. **Aragon as great power**: How far does it expand? North Africa? More of Italy? 6. **Timurid-India unification**: Does it succeed? How does Song respond? 7. **Great Khanate**: Stabilization or continued decline? 8. **East Africa**: Song vs Portugal vs Ilkhanate — three-way colonial competition?