World Alignment: unpaired cross-modal correspondence by relational identifiability

Method: scene states are sets of part states; relation fields are built
within each modality and are invariant to how each side labels its own
features; the cross-modal bridge is a coupling searched under an energy
that is a closed-form functional of one matrix; solving is spectral
initialisation followed by exact local refinement.

Evidence: in a procedurally generated closed world, blind recovery of a
hidden image-caption correspondence reaches 95.3% at 256 scenes against
0.39% chance, and the recovered pairs transfer to 200 held-out scenes at
93.0% exact retrieval with random-pair and shuffled-image controls at or
near chance. Cross-modal value correspondence is derived from disjoint
corpora rather than declared. On Visual Genome the field correlation
reaches 0.656 against the 0.9 that polynomial recovery needs, with the
deficit attributed away from segmentation and discretisation.

Protocol: no image-text pair enters any objective, optimiser,
initialisation, or model selection; hidden pairs score orderings only.

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 2909 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_test1000_orbit.json b/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_test1000_orbit.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..a6d3c26
--- /dev/null
+++ b/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_test1000_orbit.json
@@ -0,0 +1,2909 @@
+{
+  "protocol": "Assignments permute real frozen text states; hidden pairs are used only to place the true assignment in the ranking. The energy terms are the cross-modal relation MSE and conditional KL; the language-only terms of the falsified free-particle energy are permutation-invariant on this space.",
+  "meta": {
+    "dataset": "flickr30k",
+    "split": "test",
+    "samples": 1000,
+    "text_mode": "orbit_mean",
+    "rows": [
+      25,
+      34,
+      51,
+      89,
+      97,
+      124,
+      133,
+      134,
+      137,
+      199,
+      219,
+      222,
+      228,
+      246,
+      259,
+      279,
+      304,
+      318,
+      340,
+      395,
+      434,
+      472,
+      487,
+      520,
+      539,
+      565,
+      615,
+      654,
+      661,
+      670,
+      734,
+      748,
+      754,
+      760,
+      828,
+      856,
+      887,
+      906,
+      917,
+      972,
+      973,
+      1023,
+      1030,
+      1044,
+      1072,
+      1117,
+      1196,
+      1202,
+      1206,
+      1284,
+      1305,
+      1306,
+      1310,
+      1343,
+      1358,
+      1390,
+      1401,
+      1417,
+      1480,
+      1576,
+      1594,
+      1610,
+      1646,
+      1723,
+      1771,
+      1821,
+      1833,
+      1895,
+      1981,
+      1983,
+      1984,
+      1987,
+      2044,
+      2054,
+      2103,
+      2112,
+      2113,
+      2124,
+      2130,
+      2131,
+      2139,
+      2161,
+      2180,
+      2197,
+      2260,
+      2265,
+      2319,
+      2330,
+      2410,
+      2412,
+      2429,
+      2433,
+      2458,
+      2523,
+      2551,
+      2572,
+      2600,
+      2615,
+      2678,
+      2690,
+      2788,
+      2803,
+      2848,
+      2851,
+      2906,
+      2909,
+      2955,
+      2956,
+      3008,
+      3078,
+      3082,
+      3087,
+      3097,
+      3109,
+      3130,
+      3162,
+      3245,
+      3412,
+      3437,
+      3451,
+      3459,
+      3476,
+      3500,
+      3539,
+      3648,
+      3701,
+      3703,
+      3724,
+      3771,
+      3774,
+      3826,
+      3834,
+      3951,
+      3972,
+      4007,
+      4027,
+      4028,
+      4041,
+      4313,
+      4317,
+      4343,
+      4367,
+      4402,
+      4452,
+      4501,
+      4510,
+      4556,
+      4562,
+      4663,
+      4686,
+      4748,
+      4801,
+      4816,
+      4879,
+      4881,
+      4882,
+      4902,
+      4942,
+      4981,
+      5016,
+      5056,
+      5160,
+      5171,
+      5240,
+      5261,
+      5327,
+      5330,
+      5343,
+      5441,
+      5541,
+      5580,
+      5581,
+      5595,
+      5618,
+      5621,
+      5701,
+      5724,
+      5743,
+      5760,
+      5763,
+      5767,
+      5807,
+      5835,
+      5854,
+      5867,
+      5881,
+      5947,
+      5964,
+      5970,
+      5989,
+      6002,
+      6005,
+      6008,
+      6031,
+      6067,
+      6068,
+      6078,
+      6127,
+      6192,
+      6242,
+      6250,
+      6258,
+      6283,
+      6300,
+      6306,
+      6334,
+      6376,
+      6486,
+      6532,
+      6549,
+      6645,
+      6661,
+      6694,
+      6733,
+      6781,
+      6796,
+      6830,
+      6921,
+      7153,
+      7170,
+      7263,
+      7492,
+      7507,
+      7542,
+      7549,
+      7581,
+      7584,
+      7597,
+      7631,
+      7639,
+      7682,
+      7702,
+      7739,
+      7750,
+      7791,
+      7874,
+      7881,
+      7909,
+      7912,
+      7921,
+      7962,
+      7973,
+      7986,
+      7996,
+      8015,
+      8023,
+      8054,
+      8070,
+      8079,
+      8084,
+      8175,
+      8185,
+      8199,
+      8225,
+      8267,
+      8274,
+      8280,
+      8322,
+      8337,
+      8362,
+      8364,
+      8412,
+      8427,
+      8486,
+      8519,
+      8528,
+      8554,
+      8561,
+      8611,
+      8631,
+      8654,
+      8674,
+      8708,
+      8740,
+      8766,
+      8776,
+      8811,
+      8831,
+      8870,
+      8872,
+      8903,
+      8940,
+      8982,
+      8993,
+      9013,
+      9039,
+      9042,
+      9058,
+      9065,
+      9074,
+      9088,
+      9223,
+      9241,
+      9242,
+      9266,
+      9274,
+      9285,
+      9308,
+      9323,
+      9328,
+      9342,
+      9354,
+      9492,
+      9502,
+      9506,
+      9519,
+      9531,
+      9572,
+      9579,
+      9592,
+      9598,
+      9609,
+      9673,
+      9736,
+      9776,
+      9797,
+      9803,
+      9885,
+      9888,
+      9908,
+      9911,
+      9959,
+      9978,
+      9979,
+      10005,
+      10010,
+      10088,
+      10097,
+      10106,
+      10124,
+      10171,
+      10235,
+      10239,
+      10242,
+      10287,
+      10330,
+      10376,
+      10379,
+      10390,
+      10469,
+      10490,
+      10499,
+      10575,
+      10577,
+      10620,
+      10629,
+      10663,
+      10666,
+      10691,
+      10692,
+      10693,
+      10732,
+      10788,
+      10858,
+      10920,
+      10925,
+      11086,
+      11124,
+      11137,
+      11152,
+      11207,
+      11219,
+      11234,
+      11239,
+      11278,
+      11283,
+      11363,
+      11374,
+      11400,
+      11423,
+      11466,
+      11514,
+      11516,
+      11618,
+      11624,
+      11656,
+      11747,
+      11890,
+      11897,
+      11906,
+      11914,
+      11939,
+      11963,
+      11979,
+      12030,
+      12053,
+      12058,
+      12077,
+      12084,
+      12133,
+      12178,
+      12184,
+      12212,
+      12245,
+      12293,
+      12305,
+      12334,
+      12356,
+      12366,
+      12375,
+      12402,
+      12417,
+      12427,
+      12441,
+      12475,
+      12486,
+      12508,
+      12542,
+      12706,
+      12757,
+      12782,
+      12813,
+      12853,
+      12865,
+      12902,
+      12927,
+      12947,
+      12949,
+      12969,
+      12994,
+      13085,
+      13135,
+      13170,
+      13197,
+      13276,
+      13302,
+      13388,
+      13417,
+      13516,
+      13543,
+      13566,
+      13580,
+      13629,
+      13648,
+      13650,
+      13724,
+      13744,
+      13770,
+      13785,
+      13837,
+      13916,
+      13977,
+      13990,
+      13992,
+      14042,
+      14048,
+      14072,
+      14117,
+      14134,
+      14164,
+      14221,
+      14231,
+      14260,
+      14316,
+      14332,
+      14333,
+      14337,
+      14434,
+      14453,
+      14479,
+      14490,
+      14495,
+      14558,
+      14570,
+      14582,
+      14596,
+      14599,
+      14626,
+      14690,
+      14721,
+      14736,
+      14773,
+      14786,
+      14796,
+      14832,
+      14841,
+      14941,
+      14974,
+      14989,
+      15004,
+      15020,
+      15047,
+      15061,
+      15067,
+      15077,
+      15138,
+      15176,
+      15186,
+      15219,
+      15309,
+      15358,
+      15374,
+      15410,
+      15412,
+      15448,
+      15457,
+      15556,
+      15588,
+      15592,
+      15650,
+      15674,
+      15759,
+      15774,
+      15792,
+      15809,
+      15834,
+      15875,
+      15878,
+      15974,
+      16004,
+      16010,
+      16018,
+      16048,
+      16049,
+      16063,
+      16070,
+      16090,
+      16124,
+      16191,
+      16199,
+      16347,
+      16381,
+      16395,
+      16416,
+      16421,
+      16455,
+      16458,
+      16532,
+      16600,
+      16631,
+      16638,
+      16715,
+      16739,
+      16773,
+      16810,
+      16871,
+      16880,
+      16888,
+      16938,
+      16989,
+      16992,
+      16996,
+      17031,
+      17037,
+      17045,
+      17057,
+      17071,
+      17109,
+      17121,
+      17177,
+      17194,
+      17202,
+      17208,
+      17250,
+      17338,
+      17346,
+      17347,
+      17376,
+      17468,
+      17483,
+      17497,
+      17510,
+      17533,
+      17573,
+      17603,
+      17615,
+      17630,
+      17652,
+      17655,
+      17661,
+      17669,
+      17673,
+      17708,
+      17714,
+      17731,
+      17733,
+      17750,
+      17772,
+      17822,
+      17823,
+      17903,
+      17933,
+      17940,
+      17945,
+      17963,
+      17978,
+      17983,
+      17997,
+      18028,
+      18061,
+      18146,
+      18155,
+      18250,
+      18310,
+      18318,
+      18418,
+      18419,
+      18425,
+      18426,
+      18448,
+      18499,
+      18532,
+      18584,
+      18666,
+      18723,
+      18731,
+      18764,
+      18820,
+      18979,
+      18994,
+      18998,
+      19005,
+      19027,
+      19037,
+      19071,
+      19075,
+      19122,
+      19162,
+      19174,
+      19247,
+      19263,
+      19277,
+      19348,
+      19354,
+      19356,
+      19373,
+      19384,
+      19435,
+      19471,
+      19478,
+      19508,
+      19523,
+      19545,
+      19555,
+      19609,
+      19624,
+      19639,
+      19643,
+      19724,
+      19738,
+      19772,
+      19830,
+      19834,
+      19838,
+      19857,
+      19867,
+      19896,
+      19910,
+      19929,
+      20005,
+      20016,
+      20071,
+      20103,
+      20139,
+      20154,
+      20229,
+      20240,
+      20248,
+      20297,
+      20302,
+      20390,
+      20448,
+      20457,
+      20459,
+      20507,
+      20562,
+      20592,
+      20640,
+      20656,
+      20682,
+      20709,
+      20740,
+      20821,
+      20832,
+      20858,
+      20891,
+      20898,
+      20932,
+      20934,
+      20946,
+      20981,
+      21067,
+      21105,
+      21121,
+      21127,
+      21187,
+      21219,
+      21222,
+      21301,
+      21335,
+      21381,
+      21423,
+      21498,
+      21510,
+      21530,
+      21544,
+      21580,
+      21597,
+      21635,
+      21696,
+      21725,
+      21764,
+      21778,
+      21799,
+      21900,
+      21996,
+      22042,
+      22067,
+      22078,
+      22098,
+      22115,
+      22118,
+      22145,
+      22163,
+      22193,
+      22223,
+      22254,
+      22258,
+      22317,
+      22327,
+      22334,
+      22339,
+      22341,
+      22383,
+      22387,
+      22389,
+      22419,
+      22425,
+      22440,
+      22476,
+      22478,
+      22548,
+      22554,
+      22594,
+      22613,
+      22651,
+      22678,
+      22751,
+      22755,
+      22776,
+      22778,
+      22788,
+      22835,
+      22847,
+      22860,
+      22865,
+      22870,
+      22886,
+      22892,
+      22953,
+      22956,
+      22968,
+      22994,
+      22998,
+      23006,
+      23065,
+      23070,
+      23091,
+      23098,
+      23099,
+      23107,
+      23115,
+      23128,
+      23144,
+      23164,
+      23205,
+      23240,
+      23252,
+      23280,
+      23345,
+      23346,
+      23351,
+      23502,
+      23509,
+      23560,
+      23617,
+      23686,
+      23713,
+      23724,
+      23756,
+      23758,
+      23790,
+      23827,
+      23850,
+      23863,
+      23957,
+      23965,
+      23986,
+      24043,
+      24071,
+      24095,
+      24145,
+      24169,
+      24181,
+      24244,
+      24271,
+      24277,
+      24315,
+      24327,
+      24350,
+      24425,
+      24457,
+      24476,
+      24495,
+      24517,
+      24521,
+      24535,
+      24545,
+      24624,
+      24777,
+      24806,
+      24829,
+      24836,
+      24846,
+      24863,
+      24974,
+      25058,
+      25069,
+      25133,
+      25149,
+      25188,
+      25235,
+      25315,
+      25316,
+      25376,
+      25456,
+      25470,
+      25479,
+      25494,
+      25516,
+      25525,
+      25541,
+      25554,
+      25583,
+      25626,
+      25637,
+      25753,
+      25763,
+      25776,
+      25795,
+      25819,
+      25820,
+      25918,
+      25952,
+      25986,
+      25987,
+      26015,
+      26039,
+      26049,
+      26050,
+      26084,
+      26094,
+      26133,
+      26142,
+      26160,
+      26256,
+      26352,
+      26366,
+      26370,
+      26377,
+      26393,
+      26407,
+      26411,
+      26419,
+      26440,
+      26446,
+      26512,
+      26536,
+      26598,
+      26615,
+      26618,
+      26645,
+      26682,
+      26697,
+      26806,
+      26843,
+      26846,
+      26906,
+      26922,
+      26946,
+      26969,
+      26982,
+      26984,
+      26998,
+      27025,
+      27048,
+      27168,
+      27238,
+      27240,
+      27250,
+      27303,
+      27321,
+      27391,
+      27457,
+      27495,
+      27636,
+      27671,
+      27682,
+      27726,
+      27733,
+      27804,
+      27817,
+      27830,
+      27863,
+      27872,
+      27988,
+      28005,
+      28026,
+      28041,
+      28042,
+      28057,
+      28063,
+      28066,
+      28067,
+      28068,
+      28113,
+      28123,
+      28139,
+      28142,
+      28240,
+      28246,
+      28328,
+      28389,
+      28470,
+      28480,
+      28570,
+      28582,
+      28605,
+      28661,
+      28662,
+      28694,
+      28767,
+      28819,
+      28827,
+      28873,
+      28879,
+      28885,
+      28893,
+      28923,
+      28955,
+      28966,
+      28978,
+      29010,
+      29043,
+      29084,
+      29087,
+      29108,
+      29177,
+      29185,
+      29197,
+      29250,
+      29301,
+      29323,
+      29352,
+      29354,
+      29357,
+      29364,
+      29380,
+      29424,
+      29480,
+      29489,
+      29508,
+      29608,
+      29629,
+      29632,
+      29636,
+      29754,
+      29772,
+      29791,
+      29830,
+      29862,
+      29916,
+      29944,
+      29952,
+      30065,
+      30105,
+      30111,
+      30201,
+      30236,
+      30283,
+      30285,
+      30384,
+      30456,
+      30480,
+      30494,
+      30503,
+      30542,
+      30549,
+      30557,
+      30619,
+      30652,
+      30660,
+      30664,
+      30665,
+      30674,
+      30781,
+      30843,
+      30893,
+      30942,
+      30943
+    ]
+  },
+  "args": {
+    "dataset": "flickr",
+    "text_orbits": "artifacts/text_orbits_qwen0p5b.pt",
+    "text_mode": "orbit_mean",
+    "vg_vision": "artifacts/vg_5k/vision_features.pt",
+    "vg_text": "artifacts/vg_5k/text_features.pt",
+    "vg_ground_truth": "artifacts/vg_5k/ground_truth.private.jsonl",
+    "vg_bundle_channels": false,
+    "split": "test",
+    "samples": 1000,
+    "subset_seed": 0,
+    "random_perms": 1000,
+    "derangement_samples": 200,
+    "descent_restarts": 2,
+    "descent_max_steps": 200000,
+    "descent_objective": "m30_total",
+    "descent_verify_top": 64,
+    "device": "cpu",
+    "seed": 20260729,
+    "output": "artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_test1000_orbit.json",
+    "trajectory_output": null
+  },
+  "channel_names": [
+    "mean"
+  ],
+  "gate_a_global_ranking": {
+    "true": {
+      "mse": 1.4181541165023395,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        1.4181541165023395
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 1.4181541165023395,
+      "conditional_kl": 7.303621430403564,
+      "m30_total": 4.297032519085391
+    },
+    "similarity_shift": {
+      "mse": 1.7524232502697978,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        1.7524232502697978
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 1.7524232502697978,
+      "conditional_kl": 8.055903734465232,
+      "m30_total": 5.116027247432642
+    },
+    "random": {
+      "mse": {
+        "mean": 1.9993809461593628,
+        "std": 0.02299228124320507,
+        "min": 1.9282969236373901,
+        "true_z": 25.27921485900879,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "mse_channel_mean": {
+        "mean": 1.9993809461593628,
+        "std": 0.02299228124320507,
+        "min": 1.9282969236373901,
+        "true_z": 25.27921485900879,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "conditional_kl": {
+        "mean": 8.068471908569336,
+        "std": 0.015005611814558506,
+        "min": 8.015178680419922,
+        "true_z": 50.970970153808594,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "m30_total": {
+        "mean": 5.612456798553467,
+        "std": 0.04651624709367752,
+        "min": 5.462587833404541,
+        "true_z": 28.27881622314453,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  "gate_b_transpositions": {
+    "pairs": 499500,
+    "improving_pairs": 36354,
+    "improving_fraction": 0.07278078078078078,
+    "delta_mean": 0.0018503485803867197,
+    "delta_min": -0.010426752737885799,
+    "identity_is_local_min_mse": false,
+    "worst_improving_swaps": [
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          7,
+          887
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.010426752737885799,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9112697119287383,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.012999432491695342,
+        "captions": [
+          "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi",
+          "A small white car is stuck on the track, while the train car that hit it at a slow speed, "
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          912
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009977160226987076,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9186392206840316,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.12189675787950585,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A mother in blue and child walk down a sidewalk next to a brick street."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          7,
+          620
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009572153312812727,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9091739942624605,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.11518513167659843,
+        "captions": [
+          "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi",
+          "A young man wearing a blue, yellow, and white striped polo plays rugby on a green grass fi"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          119,
+          887
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.00951008419037142,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8583824651899804,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.03486489149216182,
+        "captions": [
+          "Two brown dogs run across a large snowy yard.",
+          "A small white car is stuck on the track, while the train car that hit it at a slow speed, "
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          112,
+          119
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009373189141166026,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9037848844166759,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.10057322407848752,
+        "captions": [
+          "Black dog paddles through the water with a bright ball in its mouth.",
+          "Two brown dogs run across a large snowy yard."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          124,
+          353
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009337327585576254,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9356184031383584,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.04395308917744514,
+        "captions": [
+          "A man in a brown jacket holding a red bag is speaking to another man with a white beard an",
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          711
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009309806487737143,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9353961651998521,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.21049132984996302,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A woman in a red shirt raising her arm to the passing crowd below."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          814
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009302473701978911,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9503749750376366,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.05902332143098782,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "View of a Victorian building in the background with various people walking in the foregrou"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          598
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009187930982977965,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9253927632361363,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.04472085752883089,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A group of five dark-skinned people sitting at what looks to be a farmer's market right be"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          139,
+          353
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009184219843979989,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9368068986190529,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.06421594963687959,
+        "captions": [
+          "A man dressed in all black is wearing shades and standing in snow and there is a red vehic",
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          38,
+          353
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.009107006232139244,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9287309606348609,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.03619221265132004,
+        "captions": [
+          "A girl wearing a black t-shirt is holding a small pizza in a kitchen setting.",
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          485
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008928643513675345,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9169712791076585,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.09770033346759531,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A woman in a blue shirt is walking across the street of an older looking district."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          7,
+          814
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008705416038757248,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8594920467806633,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.06152192565965657,
+        "captions": [
+          "A baseball player in red leaps into the air to avoid a player in blue, who is shortly behi",
+          "View of a Victorian building in the background with various people walking in the foregrou"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          637
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008698074602965674,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9204155751797897,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.18417737911640408,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "Man taking picture of church while the american flag blows in the wind"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          857,
+          912
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008630598677762053,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9485110774745427,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.15742457821032282,
+        "captions": [
+          "A man wearing a red t-shirt sweeps the sidewalk in front of a brick building.",
+          "A mother in blue and child walk down a sidewalk next to a brick street."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          173,
+          353
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.00834796133748083,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9055003896110118,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.03926777550622213,
+        "captions": [
+          "A well-dressed man plays a grand piano during an art exhibit.",
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          139,
+          857
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008312040922027506,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9478876890190026,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.034838581189204694,
+        "captions": [
+          "A man dressed in all black is wearing shades and standing in snow and there is a red vehic",
+          "A man wearing a red t-shirt sweeps the sidewalk in front of a brick building."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          620
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008310476299143216,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9211233763419764,
+        "visual_cosine": -3.737601427457512e-05,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A young man wearing a blue, yellow, and white striped polo plays rugby on a green grass fi"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          280,
+          353
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008292779368278127,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9360765627588535,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.11861060016570629,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people sit near a large red brick building in the grass.",
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          353,
+          545
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.008242990152866564,
+        "text_cosine": 0.9297933809347412,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.1354597419537468,
+        "captions": [
+          "A group of people at a protest to stop the building of the Kingsworth coal power plant.",
+          "A man smiles, while clinking ale bottles, with an unseen person, at a public establishment"
+        ]
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "derangement_curve": [
+    {
+      "k": 2,
+      "delta_mean": 0.0020294501446187496,
+      "delta_std": 0.0019611273892223835,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.065
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 4,
+      "delta_mean": 0.0037164243403822184,
+      "delta_std": 0.00235636904835701,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.02
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 8,
+      "delta_mean": 0.007854697294533253,
+      "delta_std": 0.0033502227161079645,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.005
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 16,
+      "delta_mean": 0.01491572055965662,
+      "delta_std": 0.0056511457078158855,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.005
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 32,
+      "delta_mean": 0.029481416568160057,
+      "delta_std": 0.007464383728802204,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 64,
+      "delta_mean": 0.05770965665578842,
+      "delta_std": 0.010395304299890995,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 128,
+      "delta_mean": 0.11144812405109406,
+      "delta_std": 0.013801022432744503,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 256,
+      "delta_mean": 0.2150510996580124,
+      "delta_std": 0.018227186053991318,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 512,
+      "delta_mean": 0.383868932723999,
+      "delta_std": 0.021471111103892326,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    }
+  ],
+  "gate_c_descent_from_true": {
+    "start_accuracy": 1.0,
+    "final_accuracy": 0.11,
+    "final_objective": 3.405150311192098,
+    "final_energy": {
+      "mse": 0.9789151563996484,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        0.9789151563996484
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 0.9789151563996484,
+      "conditional_kl": 7.236599991964006,
+      "m30_total": 3.405150311192098
+    },
+    "accepted_moves": 1068,
+    "moved_fraction": 0.89,
+    "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+    "trajectory": [
+      {
+        "step": 0,
+        "objective": 4.277498153865173,
+        "accuracy": 0.998
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 50,
+        "objective": 3.919446604438576,
+        "accuracy": 0.898
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 100,
+        "objective": 3.7878258677339405,
+        "accuracy": 0.799
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 150,
+        "objective": 3.7133583802543875,
+        "accuracy": 0.709
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 200,
+        "objective": 3.658219070149186,
+        "accuracy": 0.63
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 250,
+        "objective": 3.6174599672729513,
+        "accuracy": 0.555
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 300,
+        "objective": 3.58595309307303,
+        "accuracy": 0.497
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 350,
+        "objective": 3.559678032582238,
+        "accuracy": 0.446
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 400,
+        "objective": 3.5348517578172833,
+        "accuracy": 0.399
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 450,
+        "objective": 3.5145857169628534,
+        "accuracy": 0.358
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 500,
+        "objective": 3.498124476262949,
+        "accuracy": 0.325
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 550,
+        "objective": 3.4831418374605816,
+        "accuracy": 0.291
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 600,
+        "objective": 3.4679514945606065,
+        "accuracy": 0.262
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 650,
+        "objective": 3.4581062516765226,
+        "accuracy": 0.235
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 700,
+        "objective": 3.4484287599269337,
+        "accuracy": 0.214
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 750,
+        "objective": 3.4398340133968057,
+        "accuracy": 0.193
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 800,
+        "objective": 3.4332483430785663,
+        "accuracy": 0.173
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 850,
+        "objective": 3.428467211382965,
+        "accuracy": 0.155
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 900,
+        "objective": 3.4233100283625335,
+        "accuracy": 0.146
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 950,
+        "objective": 3.416486796112691,
+        "accuracy": 0.13
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 1000,
+        "objective": 3.4107746547593427,
+        "accuracy": 0.123
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 1050,
+        "objective": 3.406421229045149,
+        "accuracy": 0.113
+      }
+    ],
+    "final_permutation": [
+      236,
+      263,
+      778,
+      3,
+      135,
+      302,
+      96,
+      933,
+      208,
+      170,
+      918,
+      552,
+      832,
+      88,
+      218,
+      227,
+      49,
+      661,
+      346,
+      50,
+      57,
+      446,
+      712,
+      998,
+      530,
+      423,
+      657,
+      100,
+      605,
+      601,
+      988,
+      79,
+      845,
+      247,
+      237,
+      35,
+      847,
+      37,
+      75,
+      4,
+      40,
+      41,
+      42,
+      492,
+      631,
+      999,
+      46,
+      47,
+      84,
+      278,
+      883,
+      872,
+      767,
+      488,
+      741,
+      939,
+      116,
+      334,
+      548,
+      507,
+      45,
+      61,
+      770,
+      813,
+      64,
+      822,
+      285,
+      67,
+      627,
+      69,
+      70,
+      194,
+      72,
+      452,
+      213,
+      497,
+      749,
+      77,
+      269,
+      541,
+      823,
+      82,
+      172,
+      11,
+      993,
+      838,
+      20,
+      87,
+      24,
+      250,
+      852,
+      284,
+      43,
+      641,
+      94,
+      95,
+      728,
+      710,
+      98,
+      174,
+      256,
+      866,
+      899,
+      472,
+      708,
+      785,
+      80,
+      971,
+      66,
+      972,
+      862,
+      737,
+      119,
+      29,
+      923,
+      707,
+      293,
+      280,
+      588,
+      454,
+      962,
+      925,
+      368,
+      123,
+      784,
+      421,
+      564,
+      510,
+      147,
+      760,
+      375,
+      474,
+      326,
+      133,
+      620,
+      874,
+      350,
+      304,
+      549,
+      214,
+      232,
+      141,
+      846,
+      849,
+      282,
+      108,
+      146,
+      344,
+      983,
+      433,
+      746,
+      340,
+      559,
+      430,
+      154,
+      450,
+      156,
+      10,
+      332,
+      776,
+      160,
+      249,
+      573,
+      618,
+      994,
+      230,
+      442,
+      161,
+      850,
+      169,
+      764,
+      171,
+      656,
+      694,
+      981,
+      132,
+      397,
+      519,
+      144,
+      149,
+      411,
+      574,
+      365,
+      165,
+      196,
+      865,
+      400,
+      812,
+      188,
+      201,
+      317,
+      331,
+      362,
+      984,
+      90,
+      292,
+      487,
+      880,
+      676,
+      740,
+      168,
+      461,
+      763,
+      644,
+      607,
+      733,
+      206,
+      207,
+      536,
+      859,
+      594,
+      882,
+      876,
+      182,
+      53,
+      468,
+      473,
+      81,
+      702,
+      873,
+      150,
+      869,
+      801,
+      223,
+      224,
+      765,
+      151,
+      493,
+      766,
+      191,
+      528,
+      966,
+      184,
+      274,
+      731,
+      48,
+      751,
+      483,
+      186,
+      688,
+      257,
+      241,
+      769,
+      388,
+      730,
+      345,
+      868,
+      950,
+      727,
+      112,
+      609,
+      376,
+      692,
+      253,
+      679,
+      412,
+      456,
+      299,
+      806,
+      525,
+      772,
+      788,
+      262,
+      167,
+      105,
+      427,
+      758,
+      696,
+      589,
+      71,
+      343,
+      842,
+      272,
+      596,
+      234,
+      36,
+      562,
+      273,
+      74,
+      162,
+      926,
+      1,
+      220,
+      393,
+      91,
+      369,
+      267,
+      301,
+      755,
+      674,
+      447,
+      92,
+      811,
+      391,
+      110,
+      295,
+      296,
+      99,
+      934,
+      720,
+      624,
+      777,
+      789,
+      717,
+      235,
+      560,
+      904,
+      370,
+      932,
+      638,
+      372,
+      311,
+      848,
+      478,
+      114,
+      335,
+      494,
+      504,
+      550,
+      744,
+      915,
+      377,
+      684,
+      324,
+      911,
+      830,
+      9,
+      553,
+      314,
+      387,
+      527,
+      275,
+      126,
+      27,
+      6,
+      19,
+      187,
+      18,
+      338,
+      300,
+      175,
+      211,
+      222,
+      279,
+      33,
+      76,
+      243,
+      669,
+      885,
+      289,
+      242,
+      626,
+      561,
+      451,
+      664,
+      355,
+      356,
+      209,
+      97,
+      930,
+      690,
+      619,
+      251,
+      470,
+      364,
+      479,
+      286,
+      836,
+      863,
+      579,
+      309,
+      181,
+      956,
+      373,
+      30,
+      357,
+      480,
+      979,
+      402,
+      380,
+      569,
+      672,
+      308,
+      974,
+      628,
+      735,
+      386,
+      961,
+      277,
+      221,
+      390,
+      210,
+      312,
+      341,
+      967,
+      992,
+      523,
+      233,
+      860,
+      288,
+      964,
+      781,
+      809,
+      819,
+      794,
+      405,
+      406,
+      106,
+      179,
+      705,
+      990,
+      283,
+      965,
+      951,
+      102,
+      415,
+      597,
+      199,
+      825,
+      419,
+      648,
+      600,
+      913,
+      695,
+      131,
+      183,
+      491,
+      153,
+      608,
+      671,
+      291,
+      643,
+      32,
+      722,
+      815,
+      255,
+      663,
+      437,
+      313,
+      245,
+      217,
+      726,
+      428,
+      637,
+      444,
+      270,
+      861,
+      800,
+      410,
+      449,
+      495,
+      713,
+      462,
+      453,
+      166,
+      895,
+      545,
+      457,
+      828,
+      408,
+      606,
+      216,
+      738,
+      463,
+      352,
+      354,
+      466,
+      378,
+      103,
+      469,
+      140,
+      152,
+      383,
+      698,
+      396,
+      195,
+      706,
+      783,
+      176,
+      155,
+      498,
+      603,
+      204,
+      63,
+      851,
+      353,
+      113,
+      750,
+      668,
+      840,
+      824,
+      379,
+      351,
+      15,
+      699,
+      310,
+      485,
+      616,
+      424,
+      604,
+      349,
+      782,
+      759,
+      856,
+      425,
+      481,
+      621,
+      796,
+      508,
+      989,
+      935,
+      512,
+      413,
+      636,
+      318,
+      514,
+      987,
+      465,
+      996,
+      662,
+      44,
+      521,
+      101,
+      85,
+      524,
+      417,
+      107,
+      121,
+      622,
+      857,
+      774,
+      739,
+      532,
+      645,
+      816,
+      581,
+      122,
+      361,
+      982,
+      576,
+      58,
+      647,
+      659,
+      414,
+      104,
+      86,
+      557,
+      28,
+      486,
+      407,
+      328,
+      700,
+      490,
+      716,
+      761,
+      177,
+      650,
+      853,
+      460,
+      884,
+      163,
+      180,
+      276,
+      646,
+      439,
+      958,
+      854,
+      797,
+      31,
+      633,
+      614,
+      612,
+      834,
+      826,
+      501,
+      817,
+      459,
+      542,
+      578,
+      238,
+      977,
+      158,
+      582,
+      52,
+      143,
+      2,
+      348,
+      754,
+      39,
+      821,
+      921,
+      591,
+      592,
+      593,
+      117,
+      623,
+      509,
+      254,
+      805,
+      757,
+      125,
+      271,
+      572,
+      516,
+      499,
+      189,
+      68,
+      294,
+      762,
+      780,
+      384,
+      540,
+      467,
+      613,
+      654,
+      893,
+      148,
+      595,
+      363,
+      65,
+      359,
+      709,
+      666,
+      687,
+      55,
+      59,
+      190,
+      464,
+      130,
+      818,
+      327,
+      839,
+      139,
+      366,
+      203,
+      398,
+      945,
+      496,
+      897,
+      244,
+      115,
+      506,
+      786,
+      431,
+      976,
+      239,
+      729,
+      520,
+      420,
+      513,
+      178,
+      858,
+      917,
+      653,
+      23,
+      374,
+      336,
+      963,
+      611,
+      888,
+      747,
+      877,
+      949,
+      436,
+      947,
+      792,
+      808,
+      634,
+      901,
+      202,
+      670,
+      367,
+      83,
+      673,
+      266,
+      678,
+      448,
+      677,
+      129,
+      563,
+      940,
+      34,
+      434,
+      305,
+      701,
+      685,
+      787,
+      215,
+      924,
+      908,
+      587,
+      401,
+      120,
+      937,
+      128,
+      721,
+      890,
+      697,
+      630,
+      844,
+      555,
+      118,
+      319,
+      795,
+      704,
+      240,
+      489,
+      229,
+      952,
+      978,
+      124,
+      252,
+      986,
+      927,
+      714,
+      814,
+      775,
+      929,
+      718,
+      719,
+      137,
+      665,
+      831,
+      571,
+      535,
+      54,
+      145,
+      625,
+      683,
+      577,
+      640,
+      281,
+      568,
+      438,
+      734,
+      639,
+      78,
+      768,
+      127,
+      551,
+      347,
+      632,
+      655,
+      743,
+      193,
+      745,
+      752,
+      56,
+      748,
+      997,
+      219,
+      342,
+      403,
+      753,
+      138,
+      537,
+      791,
+      173,
+      159,
+      136,
+      689,
+      889,
+      441,
+      798,
+      17,
+      385,
+      829,
+      691,
+      912,
+      502,
+      290,
+      771,
+      539,
+      575,
+      725,
+      711,
+      471,
+      886,
+      246,
+      779,
+      458,
+      265,
+      371,
+      916,
+      615,
+      920,
+      14,
+      973,
+      531,
+      810,
+      790,
+      773,
+      649,
+      793,
+      723,
+      157,
+      742,
+      803,
+      389,
+      799,
+      642,
+      534,
+      26,
+      878,
+      418,
+      0,
+      922,
+      198,
+      894,
+      5,
+      533,
+      567,
+      62,
+      337,
+      938,
+      802,
+      404,
+      598,
+      682,
+      500,
+      602,
+      879,
+      260,
+      570,
+      995,
+      941,
+      526,
+      900,
+      429,
+      395,
+      518,
+      667,
+      835,
+      833,
+      185,
+      475,
+      330,
+      93,
+      248,
+      435,
+      959,
+      358,
+      323,
+      936,
+      566,
+      287,
+      529,
+      329,
+      142,
+      556,
+      867,
+      980,
+      681,
+      25,
+      225,
+      843,
+      503,
+      322,
+      13,
+      8,
+      231,
+      841,
+      660,
+      855,
+      864,
+      546,
+      522,
+      804,
+      617,
+      586,
+      870,
+      871,
+      339,
+      515,
+      268,
+      875,
+      599,
+      756,
+      258,
+      212,
+      333,
+      543,
+      675,
+      360,
+      426,
+      325,
+      580,
+      7,
+      21,
+      192,
+      73,
+      891,
+      892,
+      409,
+      60,
+      321,
+      953,
+      484,
+      827,
+      22,
+      898,
+      394,
+      303,
+      903,
+      943,
+      905,
+      455,
+      307,
+      629,
+      511,
+      910,
+      89,
+      583,
+      422,
+      914,
+      948,
+      477,
+      259,
+      703,
+      919,
+      955,
+      820,
+      445,
+      12,
+      505,
+      658,
+      482,
+      228,
+      590,
+      887,
+      909,
+      200,
+      736,
+      538,
+      381,
+      226,
+      896,
+      724,
+      51,
+      440,
+      715,
+      432,
+      942,
+      985,
+      944,
+      610,
+      392,
+      517,
+      320,
+      652,
+      38,
+      584,
+      807,
+      315,
+      954,
+      382,
+      16,
+      957,
+      565,
+      547,
+      960,
+      881,
+      476,
+      837,
+      205,
+      680,
+      416,
+      399,
+      585,
+      969,
+      970,
+      261,
+      109,
+      111,
+      928,
+      975,
+      554,
+      264,
+      946,
+      306,
+      906,
+      907,
+      732,
+      298,
+      316,
+      968,
+      134,
+      197,
+      686,
+      297,
+      544,
+      991,
+      931,
+      651,
+      164,
+      902,
+      443,
+      693,
+      558,
+      635
+    ]
+  },
+  "gate_c_descent_from_random": [
+    {
+      "start_accuracy": 0.0,
+      "final_accuracy": 0.007,
+      "final_objective": 3.4390894907477456,
+      "final_energy": {
+        "mse": 0.9895618197693262,
+        "mse_channels": [
+          0.9895618197693262
+        ],
+        "mse_channel_mean": 0.9895618197693262,
+        "conditional_kl": 7.2998292560454665,
+        "m30_total": 3.4390894907477456
+      },
+      "accepted_moves": 1570,
+      "moved_fraction": 0.997,
+      "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+      "trajectory": [
+        {
+          "step": 0,
+          "objective": 5.597609347319356,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 50,
+          "objective": 4.946372313171372,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 100,
+          "objective": 4.654184850246987,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 150,
+          "objective": 4.463813106952113,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 200,
+          "objective": 4.314262503480761,
+          "accuracy": 0.003
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 250,
+          "objective": 4.195773832430993,
+          "accuracy": 0.003
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 300,
+          "objective": 4.0941040480389015,
+          "accuracy": 0.004
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 350,
+          "objective": 4.01164989296559,
+          "accuracy": 0.004
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 400,
+          "objective": 3.935606736377906,
+          "accuracy": 0.006
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 450,
+          "objective": 3.871490581163375,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 500,
+          "objective": 3.8127381772193747,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 550,
+          "objective": 3.7651033285919775,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 600,
+          "objective": 3.721924656197852,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 650,
+          "objective": 3.683580682424319,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 700,
+          "objective": 3.651839503301641,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 750,
+          "objective": 3.624898919721512,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 800,
+          "objective": 3.598634243046188,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 850,
+          "objective": 3.5762127826221315,
+          "accuracy": 0.006
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 900,
+          "objective": 3.5567511336898123,
+          "accuracy": 0.005
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 950,
+          "objective": 3.5407558065949307,
+          "accuracy": 0.006
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1000,
+          "objective": 3.5260970845329753,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1050,
+          "objective": 3.513192698733376,
+          "accuracy": 0.01
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1100,
+          "objective": 3.5014664336230354,
+          "accuracy": 0.01
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1150,
+          "objective": 3.4898559480379627,
+          "accuracy": 0.009
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1200,
+          "objective": 3.480066425914335,
+          "accuracy": 0.009
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1250,
+          "objective": 3.471920968021096,
+          "accuracy": 0.009
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1300,
+          "objective": 3.465659972450599,
+          "accuracy": 0.009
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1350,
+          "objective": 3.4593446393329126,
+          "accuracy": 0.009
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1400,
+          "objective": 3.452995267194754,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1450,
+          "objective": 3.4486890076891026,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1500,
+          "objective": 3.4452994916715776,
+          "accuracy": 0.007
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1550,
+          "objective": 3.4403541330265277,
+          "accuracy": 0.008
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "start_accuracy": 0.0,
+      "final_accuracy": 0.003,
+      "final_objective": 3.415587757343612,
+      "final_energy": {
+        "mse": 0.9780128775843049,
+        "mse_channels": [
+          0.9780128775843049
+        ],
+        "mse_channel_mean": 0.9780128775843049,
+        "conditional_kl": 7.29781001087501,
+        "m30_total": 3.415587757343612
+      },
+      "accepted_moves": 1533,
+      "moved_fraction": 0.999,
+      "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+      "trajectory": [
+        {
+          "step": 0,
+          "objective": 5.552746933395847,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 50,
+          "objective": 4.932615684601798,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 100,
+          "objective": 4.622246346984176,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 150,
+          "objective": 4.429738094320414,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 200,
+          "objective": 4.280313440567166,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 250,
+          "objective": 4.159440750123266,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 300,
+          "objective": 4.049590289624388,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 350,
+          "objective": 3.955685464731336,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 400,
+          "objective": 3.8767857344026937,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 450,
+          "objective": 3.8111240445779524,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 500,
+          "objective": 3.757118912041849,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 550,
+          "objective": 3.710246848387948,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 600,
+          "objective": 3.669528231884107,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 650,
+          "objective": 3.6320682331077636,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 700,
+          "objective": 3.601386190719876,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 750,
+          "objective": 3.576336842533314,
+          "accuracy": 0.003
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 800,
+          "objective": 3.5562407748493827,
+          "accuracy": 0.003
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 850,
+          "objective": 3.5360567539121037,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 900,
+          "objective": 3.520007579076145,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 950,
+          "objective": 3.5036578191686054,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1000,
+          "objective": 3.4908761959728194,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1050,
+          "objective": 3.478616327847004,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1100,
+          "objective": 3.467597011450415,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1150,
+          "objective": 3.458198373072019,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1200,
+          "objective": 3.4502041312846305,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1250,
+          "objective": 3.442524855805853,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1300,
+          "objective": 3.43552730001292,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1350,
+          "objective": 3.4309810567793724,
+          "accuracy": 0.001
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1400,
+          "objective": 3.42582373008698,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1450,
+          "objective": 3.421249800948337,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 1500,
+          "objective": 3.419015840292782,
+          "accuracy": 0.002
+        }
+      ]
+    }
+  ],
+  "verdict": {
+    "true_m30_total": 4.297032519085391,
+    "identity_is_local_min_mse": false,
+    "descent_from_true_stays": 0.11,
+    "on_manifold_counterfeit_found": true,
+    "best_random_descent_m30_total": 3.415587757343612
+  }
+}
\ No newline at end of file