World Alignment: unpaired cross-modal correspondence by relational identifiability

Method: scene states are sets of part states; relation fields are built
within each modality and are invariant to how each side labels its own
features; the cross-modal bridge is a coupling searched under an energy
that is a closed-form functional of one matrix; solving is spectral
initialisation followed by exact local refinement.

Evidence: in a procedurally generated closed world, blind recovery of a
hidden image-caption correspondence reaches 95.3% at 256 scenes against
0.39% chance, and the recovered pairs transfer to 200 held-out scenes at
93.0% exact retrieval with random-pair and shuffled-image controls at or
near chance. Cross-modal value correspondence is derived from disjoint
corpora rather than declared. On Visual Genome the field correlation
reaches 0.656 against the 0.9 that polynomial recovery needs, with the
deficit attributed away from segmentation and discretisation.

Protocol: no image-text pair enters any objective, optimiser,
initialisation, or model selection; hidden pairs score orderings only.

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 1832 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_val512_orbit.json b/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_val512_orbit.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..253dec5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_val512_orbit.json
@@ -0,0 +1,1832 @@
+{
+  "protocol": "Assignments permute real frozen text states; hidden pairs are used only to place the true assignment in the ranking. The energy terms are the cross-modal relation MSE and conditional KL; the language-only terms of the falsified free-particle energy are permutation-invariant on this space.",
+  "meta": {
+    "dataset": "flickr30k",
+    "split": "val",
+    "samples": 512,
+    "text_mode": "orbit_mean",
+    "rows": [
+      67,
+      99,
+      100,
+      109,
+      118,
+      161,
+      170,
+      200,
+      203,
+      257,
+      280,
+      282,
+      293,
+      301,
+      322,
+      370,
+      377,
+      382,
+      387,
+      390,
+      419,
+      422,
+      462,
+      478,
+      511,
+      608,
+      610,
+      628,
+      630,
+      669,
+      681,
+      694,
+      762,
+      816,
+      843,
+      900,
+      949,
+      1052,
+      1074,
+      1081,
+      1089,
+      1102,
+      1103,
+      1107,
+      1144,
+      1145,
+      1155,
+      1162,
+      1168,
+      1182,
+      1209,
+      1212,
+      1271,
+      1286,
+      1293,
+      1351,
+      1365,
+      1371,
+      1378,
+      1382,
+      1478,
+      1513,
+      1516,
+      1520,
+      1523,
+      1532,
+      1616,
+      1636,
+      1716,
+      1727,
+      1740,
+      1746,
+      1754,
+      1782,
+      1892,
+      1902,
+      1933,
+      1943,
+      1995,
+      2006,
+      2089,
+      2145,
+      2147,
+      2177,
+      2179,
+      2256,
+      2274,
+      2283,
+      2312,
+      2324,
+      2326,
+      2388,
+      2434,
+      2476,
+      2522,
+      2527,
+      2605,
+      2662,
+      2737,
+      2749,
+      2968,
+      3032,
+      3085,
+      3096,
+      3104,
+      3105,
+      3115,
+      3175,
+      3180,
+      3197,
+      3203,
+      3204,
+      3304,
+      3375,
+      3393,
+      3410,
+      3423,
+      3425,
+      3434,
+      3461,
+      3493,
+      3498,
+      3510,
+      3529,
+      3547,
+      3566,
+      3631,
+      3681,
+      3756,
+      3821,
+      3836,
+      3848,
+      3953,
+      3960,
+      3969,
+      3975,
+      3977,
+      3979,
+      3995,
+      4011,
+      4053,
+      4054,
+      4072,
+      4077,
+      4141,
+      4271,
+      4280,
+      4351,
+      4463,
+      4480,
+      4486,
+      4494,
+      4561,
+      4605,
+      4616,
+      4641,
+      4734,
+      4743,
+      4768,
+      4808,
+      4840,
+      4860,
+      4906,
+      4917,
+      4960,
+      5013,
+      5062,
+      5073,
+      5108,
+      5162,
+      5204,
+      5214,
+      5224,
+      5270,
+      5274,
+      5300,
+      5304,
+      5371,
+      5387,
+      5447,
+      5477,
+      5479,
+      5515,
+      5516,
+      5522,
+      5550,
+      5553,
+      5576,
+      5680,
+      5711,
+      5752,
+      5808,
+      5950,
+      6043,
+      6049,
+      6055,
+      6063,
+      6089,
+      6110,
+      6143,
+      6151,
+      6167,
+      6171,
+      6209,
+      6230,
+      6248,
+      6257,
+      6278,
+      6282,
+      6304,
+      6318,
+      6377,
+      6425,
+      6505,
+      6533,
+      6542,
+      6554,
+      6557,
+      6582,
+      6586,
+      6666,
+      6767,
+      6791,
+      6890,
+      6896,
+      6902,
+      6977,
+      6990,
+      6992,
+      7016,
+      7044,
+      7151,
+      7156,
+      7203,
+      7228,
+      7283,
+      7317,
+      7330,
+      7355,
+      7376,
+      7382,
+      7409,
+      7414,
+      7421,
+      7454,
+      7575,
+      7608,
+      7610,
+      7646,
+      7723,
+      7843,
+      7900,
+      7974,
+      7978,
+      7979,
+      8039,
+      8107,
+      8115,
+      8117,
+      8194,
+      8238,
+      8268,
+      8303,
+      8339,
+      8371,
+      8375,
+      8405,
+      8507,
+      8555,
+      8605,
+      8777,
+      8913,
+      9017,
+      9038,
+      9079,
+      9137,
+      9151,
+      9154,
+      9174,
+      9272,
+      9273,
+      9280,
+      9291,
+      9380,
+      9451,
+      9488,
+      9496,
+      9578,
+      9724,
+      9734,
+      9747,
+      9758,
+      9774,
+      9778,
+      9819,
+      9858,
+      9862,
+      9895,
+      9896,
+      9907,
+      9985,
+      10014,
+      10033,
+      10061,
+      10078,
+      10081,
+      10084,
+      10133,
+      10164,
+      10214,
+      10219,
+      10221,
+      10244,
+      10266,
+      10291,
+      10321,
+      10356,
+      10363,
+      10364,
+      10392,
+      10436,
+      10449,
+      10458,
+      10479,
+      10497,
+      10530,
+      10557,
+      10724,
+      10741,
+      10746,
+      10752,
+      10792,
+      10793,
+      10801,
+      10810,
+      10871,
+      10885,
+      10923,
+      10932,
+      10947,
+      10963,
+      10982,
+      11032,
+      11036,
+      11056,
+      11076,
+      11162,
+      11190,
+      11208,
+      11218,
+      11244,
+      11293,
+      11401,
+      11424,
+      11437,
+      11497,
+      11539,
+      11541,
+      11561,
+      11564,
+      11570,
+      11680,
+      11710,
+      11727,
+      11827,
+      11838,
+      11911,
+      11929,
+      11945,
+      11960,
+      12004,
+      12018,
+      12075,
+      12137,
+      12202,
+      12275,
+      12280,
+      12386,
+      12399,
+      12446,
+      12449,
+      12467,
+      12483,
+      12507,
+      12509,
+      12521,
+      12554,
+      12559,
+      12595,
+      12614,
+      12684,
+      12708,
+      12714,
+      12718,
+      12719,
+      12784,
+      12801,
+      12811,
+      12812,
+      12846,
+      12861,
+      12879,
+      12895,
+      12903,
+      12906,
+      12931,
+      12968,
+      12984,
+      12993,
+      13059,
+      13094,
+      13114,
+      13136,
+      13261,
+      13265,
+      13278,
+      13285,
+      13311,
+      13323,
+      13325,
+      13332,
+      13347,
+      13351,
+      13420,
+      13447,
+      13477,
+      13495,
+      13583,
+      13597,
+      13654,
+      13668,
+      13670,
+      13671,
+      13673,
+      13760,
+      13779,
+      13788,
+      13796,
+      13861,
+      13876,
+      13892,
+      13895,
+      13943,
+      13956,
+      13978,
+      14001,
+      14029,
+      14059,
+      14065,
+      14098,
+      14118,
+      14199,
+      14210,
+      14222,
+      14247,
+      14258,
+      14275,
+      14291,
+      14303,
+      14388,
+      14392,
+      14430,
+      14585,
+      14686,
+      14743,
+      14763,
+      14766,
+      14821,
+      14824,
+      14836,
+      14842,
+      14861,
+      14887,
+      14896,
+      14898,
+      14904,
+      14913,
+      14918,
+      14938,
+      14998,
+      15037,
+      15129,
+      15136,
+      15159,
+      15204,
+      15223,
+      15246,
+      15291,
+      15296,
+      15329,
+      15465,
+      15481,
+      15506,
+      15547,
+      15574,
+      15582,
+      15596,
+      15610,
+      15616,
+      15633,
+      15636,
+      15638,
+      15693,
+      15701,
+      15710,
+      15716,
+      15733,
+      15795,
+      15800,
+      15825,
+      15851,
+      15889
+    ]
+  },
+  "args": {
+    "dataset": "flickr",
+    "text_orbits": "artifacts/text_orbits_qwen0p5b.pt",
+    "text_mode": "orbit_mean",
+    "vg_vision": "artifacts/vg_5k/vision_features.pt",
+    "vg_text": "artifacts/vg_5k/text_features.pt",
+    "vg_ground_truth": "artifacts/vg_5k/ground_truth.private.jsonl",
+    "vg_bundle_channels": false,
+    "split": "val",
+    "samples": 512,
+    "subset_seed": 0,
+    "random_perms": 1000,
+    "derangement_samples": 200,
+    "descent_restarts": 3,
+    "descent_max_steps": 200000,
+    "descent_objective": "m30_total",
+    "descent_verify_top": 64,
+    "device": "cpu",
+    "seed": 20260729,
+    "output": "artifacts/manifold_gate/flickr_val512_orbit.json",
+    "trajectory_output": null
+  },
+  "channel_names": [
+    "mean"
+  ],
+  "gate_a_global_ranking": {
+    "true": {
+      "mse": 1.4042444210155525,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        1.4042444210155525
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 1.4042444210155525,
+      "conditional_kl": 6.4543248639561135,
+      "m30_total": 4.099353814822328
+    },
+    "similarity_shift": {
+      "mse": 1.7334319226264598,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        1.7334319226264598
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 1.7334319226264598,
+      "conditional_kl": 7.20528543367145,
+      "m30_total": 4.90792093198721
+    },
+    "random": {
+      "mse": {
+        "mean": 1.9996733665466309,
+        "std": 0.03308570384979248,
+        "min": 1.8877284526824951,
+        "true_z": 17.996562957763672,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "mse_channel_mean": {
+        "mean": 1.9996733665466309,
+        "std": 0.03308570384979248,
+        "min": 1.8877284526824951,
+        "true_z": 17.996562957763672,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "conditional_kl": {
+        "mean": 7.238322734832764,
+        "std": 0.022568004205822945,
+        "min": 7.1590142250061035,
+        "true_z": 34.73936080932617,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      },
+      "m30_total": {
+        "mean": 5.447010517120361,
+        "std": 0.06747408211231232,
+        "min": 5.222931861877441,
+        "true_z": 19.97295379638672,
+        "true_rank_among_random": 0,
+        "count": 1000
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  "gate_b_transpositions": {
+    "pairs": 130816,
+    "improving_pairs": 8841,
+    "improving_fraction": 0.06758347602739725,
+    "delta_mean": 0.00371884311612938,
+    "delta_min": -0.03444656536739881,
+    "identity_is_local_min_mse": false,
+    "worst_improving_swaps": [
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          159,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.03444656536739881,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8804604109045187,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.009551670702255625,
+        "captions": [
+          "There are two men and a woman in church, the woman is in the back and the men are next to ",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          479,
+          487
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.030204825675823062,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8652142993787264,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.013044274857742125,
+        "captions": [
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt.",
+          "Many people are sitting in a street side cafe at red clothed tables in front of a tall old"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          452,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.028873950352483534,
+        "text_cosine": 0.844144838371495,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.012639602557717311,
+        "captions": [
+          "A couple of industrial construction workers appear to be trying to place something on a cr",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          392,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02624368601465625,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8273815421390986,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.0029532020425696312,
+        "captions": [
+          "The magnificant bird flies low over the water.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          36,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.026075856404495352,
+        "text_cosine": 0.837988426646629,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.02276713967220626,
+        "captions": [
+          "Pedestrians walk through an open area between several traditional-style Japanese or Chines",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          149,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.025992421044758608,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8728702698841788,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.0491941223719248,
+        "captions": [
+          "A man, in what looks like a firefighter suit, standing in the street with a large vehicles",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          364,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.025392694460629823,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8736657963930408,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.006018191892594723,
+        "captions": [
+          "A person in black is coming out of a window of a tan and red building.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          382,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02486530327471264,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8611658086831445,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.015896193584674242,
+        "captions": [
+          "A person in an orange jacket walking in front of a building with glass doors.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          111,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.024810990718373244,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8830242585783776,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.004232237763893905,
+        "captions": [
+          "An elderly gentleman sits on a couch while holding a small dog as another small dog invest",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          319,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.024500140269164136,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8711216611921513,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.04526523817812019,
+        "captions": [
+          "Two mothers stroll their children in the park, during the beginning of Autumn.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          89,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.023962731191809437,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8724662329096468,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.08280296395743245,
+        "captions": [
+          "A brown and white dog exiting a yellow and blue ramp in a grassy area.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          471,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02347924001511952,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8805895493212769,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.004731466099593737,
+        "captions": [
+          "Man in white shirt and striped shorts playing organ being observed by man wearing yellow s",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          100,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02312855901141914,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8723207853012979,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.016602449184265778,
+        "captions": [
+          "A large bearded man flips a crepe or omelet in midair with his frying pan.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          479,
+          482
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02302496657528011,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8359027412761237,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.07499350070914855,
+        "captions": [
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt.",
+          "A man gliding in the sky with the sunset on the horizon in the background."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          48,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.022232075642268746,
+        "text_cosine": 0.865296170421438,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.09192536946131406,
+        "captions": [
+          "Two people are wearing a Chinese dragon costume in front of an ornate Chinese gazebo with ",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          28,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.022198097518094623,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8614804281314444,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.04479811083190678,
+        "captions": [
+          "Someone parasailing with a green parachute that has a face on the top of it",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          314,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02201058686721134,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8711598208113011,
+        "visual_cosine": -0.027320648419757714,
+        "captions": [
+          "The white and brown dog is running quickly through the grass.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          450,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02153712076832385,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8684515484362562,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.011108628808307965,
+        "captions": [
+          "A white dog with brown ears is running on the sidewalk.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          416,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02128713676846557,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8594741277841824,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.0025890515811312414,
+        "captions": [
+          "A woman wearing a red and yellow silk scarf plays the cello.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "pair": [
+          306,
+          479
+        ],
+        "delta_mse": -0.02065930937350901,
+        "text_cosine": 0.8703441412666861,
+        "visual_cosine": 0.027435042306462917,
+        "captions": [
+          "A black and white dog stares up into the sky on a sunny day.",
+          "A rodeo clown ties a rope around an older rodeo clown as he sits in the dirt."
+        ]
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "derangement_curve": [
+    {
+      "k": 2,
+      "delta_mean": 0.0036581719759851694,
+      "delta_std": 0.003777132136747241,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.045
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 4,
+      "delta_mean": 0.007963678799569607,
+      "delta_std": 0.005166951566934586,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.015
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 8,
+      "delta_mean": 0.014666836708784103,
+      "delta_std": 0.007081033196300268,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.005
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 16,
+      "delta_mean": 0.030254699289798737,
+      "delta_std": 0.009759636595845222,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.005
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 32,
+      "delta_mean": 0.058493103832006454,
+      "delta_std": 0.01311691477894783,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 64,
+      "delta_mean": 0.11451101303100586,
+      "delta_std": 0.0184929259121418,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 128,
+      "delta_mean": 0.21465423703193665,
+      "delta_std": 0.025921281427145004,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 256,
+      "delta_mean": 0.388163298368454,
+      "delta_std": 0.031001534312963486,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "k": 512,
+      "delta_mean": 0.5943191051483154,
+      "delta_std": 0.03246152028441429,
+      "improving_fraction": 0.0
+    }
+  ],
+  "gate_c_descent_from_true": {
+    "start_accuracy": 1.0,
+    "final_accuracy": 0.119140625,
+    "final_objective": 3.2401756909966486,
+    "final_energy": {
+      "mse": 0.9814799520153564,
+      "mse_channels": [
+        0.9814799520153564
+      ],
+      "mse_channel_mean": 0.9814799520153564,
+      "conditional_kl": 6.386078934829678,
+      "m30_total": 3.2401756909966486
+    },
+    "accepted_moves": 584,
+    "moved_fraction": 0.880859375,
+    "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+    "trajectory": [
+      {
+        "step": 0,
+        "objective": 4.029606227958813,
+        "accuracy": 0.99609375
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 50,
+        "objective": 3.606296830907065,
+        "accuracy": 0.80078125
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 100,
+        "objective": 3.482993228306878,
+        "accuracy": 0.630859375
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 150,
+        "objective": 3.414196079047716,
+        "accuracy": 0.50390625
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 200,
+        "objective": 3.3697646224491327,
+        "accuracy": 0.396484375
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 250,
+        "objective": 3.337663910668106,
+        "accuracy": 0.318359375
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 300,
+        "objective": 3.3095674799509016,
+        "accuracy": 0.265625
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 350,
+        "objective": 3.2915901390018023,
+        "accuracy": 0.21875
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 400,
+        "objective": 3.2732708199246527,
+        "accuracy": 0.185546875
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 450,
+        "objective": 3.260949283286323,
+        "accuracy": 0.158203125
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 500,
+        "objective": 3.2534936349334265,
+        "accuracy": 0.142578125
+      },
+      {
+        "step": 550,
+        "objective": 3.243726458594035,
+        "accuracy": 0.126953125
+      }
+    ],
+    "final_permutation": [
+      217,
+      116,
+      466,
+      96,
+      79,
+      81,
+      219,
+      465,
+      8,
+      506,
+      73,
+      462,
+      269,
+      424,
+      388,
+      473,
+      157,
+      408,
+      337,
+      263,
+      293,
+      71,
+      34,
+      383,
+      0,
+      256,
+      26,
+      218,
+      177,
+      179,
+      105,
+      303,
+      226,
+      33,
+      210,
+      35,
+      120,
+      159,
+      422,
+      266,
+      92,
+      41,
+      101,
+      88,
+      250,
+      163,
+      449,
+      460,
+      458,
+      231,
+      381,
+      3,
+      338,
+      59,
+      131,
+      55,
+      468,
+      240,
+      448,
+      489,
+      91,
+      143,
+      104,
+      215,
+      213,
+      428,
+      304,
+      69,
+      196,
+      170,
+      208,
+      482,
+      98,
+      351,
+      115,
+      185,
+      24,
+      454,
+      452,
+      12,
+      80,
+      110,
+      461,
+      336,
+      90,
+      48,
+      358,
+      149,
+      164,
+      339,
+      209,
+      109,
+      40,
+      43,
+      271,
+      95,
+      4,
+      493,
+      128,
+      202,
+      121,
+      112,
+      415,
+      291,
+      268,
+      488,
+      106,
+      397,
+      144,
+      371,
+      308,
+      139,
+      395,
+      113,
+      44,
+      280,
+      245,
+      392,
+      324,
+      235,
+      17,
+      100,
+      441,
+      327,
+      499,
+      125,
+      509,
+      65,
+      252,
+      129,
+      62,
+      282,
+      132,
+      418,
+      405,
+      38,
+      257,
+      1,
+      457,
+      85,
+      49,
+      102,
+      133,
+      401,
+      344,
+      295,
+      11,
+      387,
+      178,
+      156,
+      135,
+      42,
+      119,
+      151,
+      382,
+      52,
+      364,
+      276,
+      158,
+      479,
+      320,
+      305,
+      117,
+      472,
+      162,
+      53,
+      314,
+      167,
+      122,
+      182,
+      400,
+      146,
+      230,
+      325,
+      342,
+      390,
+      340,
+      28,
+      148,
+      114,
+      183,
+      181,
+      169,
+      498,
+      281,
+      154,
+      207,
+      316,
+      152,
+      5,
+      348,
+      511,
+      455,
+      193,
+      194,
+      459,
+      504,
+      192,
+      51,
+      37,
+      54,
+      341,
+      72,
+      300,
+      413,
+      274,
+      18,
+      403,
+      298,
+      442,
+      384,
+      368,
+      186,
+      136,
+      221,
+      87,
+      190,
+      214,
+      248,
+      140,
+      433,
+      63,
+      238,
+      223,
+      297,
+      249,
+      255,
+      500,
+      299,
+      84,
+      160,
+      197,
+      445,
+      474,
+      414,
+      355,
+      19,
+      267,
+      31,
+      289,
+      47,
+      464,
+      386,
+      243,
+      145,
+      471,
+      70,
+      247,
+      329,
+      244,
+      301,
+      191,
+      64,
+      253,
+      367,
+      7,
+      391,
+      284,
+      376,
+      77,
+      417,
+      246,
+      262,
+      365,
+      279,
+      200,
+      490,
+      294,
+      484,
+      439,
+      469,
+      111,
+      272,
+      130,
+      310,
+      175,
+      134,
+      495,
+      236,
+      67,
+      187,
+      398,
+      150,
+      9,
+      61,
+      285,
+      286,
+      287,
+      277,
+      239,
+      290,
+      450,
+      23,
+      362,
+      58,
+      505,
+      296,
+      429,
+      224,
+      203,
+      206,
+      68,
+      229,
+      189,
+      16,
+      172,
+      50,
+      302,
+      174,
+      103,
+      374,
+      420,
+      312,
+      313,
+      345,
+      315,
+      227,
+      318,
+      317,
+      74,
+      108,
+      141,
+      195,
+      242,
+      123,
+      171,
+      265,
+      241,
+      176,
+      396,
+      379,
+      99,
+      332,
+      32,
+      334,
+      440,
+      201,
+      409,
+      36,
+      309,
+      237,
+      212,
+      470,
+      259,
+      260,
+      410,
+      453,
+      363,
+      56,
+      222,
+      385,
+      27,
+      330,
+      353,
+      354,
+      137,
+      438,
+      491,
+      86,
+      205,
+      416,
+      361,
+      155,
+      326,
+      216,
+      75,
+      57,
+      307,
+      436,
+      350,
+      357,
+      475,
+      138,
+      93,
+      366,
+      359,
+      380,
+      375,
+      487,
+      352,
+      21,
+      232,
+      225,
+      66,
+      168,
+      407,
+      127,
+      147,
+      20,
+      389,
+      94,
+      306,
+      82,
+      393,
+      394,
+      153,
+      107,
+      292,
+      180,
+      399,
+      483,
+      45,
+      402,
+      270,
+      404,
+      278,
+      406,
+      421,
+      377,
+      199,
+      166,
+      411,
+      251,
+      456,
+      220,
+      486,
+      188,
+      165,
+      83,
+      360,
+      311,
+      497,
+      89,
+      423,
+      323,
+      451,
+      426,
+      427,
+      419,
+      372,
+      430,
+      322,
+      477,
+      463,
+      434,
+      333,
+      481,
+      437,
+      356,
+      234,
+      335,
+      204,
+      97,
+      444,
+      443,
+      425,
+      446,
+      447,
+      211,
+      228,
+      25,
+      2,
+      412,
+      346,
+      142,
+      6,
+      261,
+      494,
+      349,
+      118,
+      347,
+      15,
+      369,
+      508,
+      283,
+      22,
+      264,
+      467,
+      60,
+      370,
+      378,
+      161,
+      485,
+      29,
+      343,
+      321,
+      476,
+      258,
+      478,
+      275,
+      435,
+      510,
+      198,
+      13,
+      319,
+      14,
+      46,
+      78,
+      39,
+      331,
+      328,
+      480,
+      492,
+      233,
+      10,
+      373,
+      496,
+      254,
+      184,
+      124,
+      273,
+      501,
+      502,
+      503,
+      431,
+      76,
+      30,
+      288,
+      507,
+      126,
+      432,
+      173
+    ]
+  },
+  "gate_c_descent_from_random": [
+    {
+      "start_accuracy": 0.001953125,
+      "final_accuracy": 0.001953125,
+      "final_objective": 3.2832847544332147,
+      "final_energy": {
+        "mse": 0.9926672532953029,
+        "mse_channels": [
+          0.9926672532953029
+        ],
+        "mse_channel_mean": 0.9926672532953029,
+        "conditional_kl": 6.489751239213044,
+        "m30_total": 3.2832847544332147
+      },
+      "accepted_moves": 800,
+      "moved_fraction": 0.986328125,
+      "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+      "trajectory": [
+        {
+          "step": 0,
+          "objective": 5.330438299721495,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 50,
+          "objective": 4.487639729646215,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 100,
+          "objective": 4.144918996990719,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 150,
+          "objective": 3.9240300931535996,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 200,
+          "objective": 3.759513098368613,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 250,
+          "objective": 3.6399468928808254,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 300,
+          "objective": 3.548200228698504,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 350,
+          "objective": 3.48329467287731,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 400,
+          "objective": 3.4338552218236544,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 450,
+          "objective": 3.3937528227005567,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 500,
+          "objective": 3.363136054633903,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 550,
+          "objective": 3.3390310567854,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 600,
+          "objective": 3.3245853532710514,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 650,
+          "objective": 3.3112566709886377,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 700,
+          "objective": 3.302527631967803,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 750,
+          "objective": 3.29150145600871,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "start_accuracy": 0.0,
+      "final_accuracy": 0.0,
+      "final_objective": 3.2789112061183916,
+      "final_energy": {
+        "mse": 0.9943571452625832,
+        "mse_channels": [
+          0.9943571452625832
+        ],
+        "mse_channel_mean": 0.9943571452625832,
+        "conditional_kl": 6.450984577966124,
+        "m30_total": 3.2789112061183916
+      },
+      "accepted_moves": 838,
+      "moved_fraction": 0.9921875,
+      "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+      "trajectory": [
+        {
+          "step": 0,
+          "objective": 5.3564973264964895,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 50,
+          "objective": 4.474548595401178,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 100,
+          "objective": 4.119518447110261,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 150,
+          "objective": 3.9072352832244843,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 200,
+          "objective": 3.7584665581873358,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 250,
+          "objective": 3.643437125765005,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 300,
+          "objective": 3.555604699843888,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 350,
+          "objective": 3.488414336831098,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 400,
+          "objective": 3.43519623110524,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 450,
+          "objective": 3.3960352931790694,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 500,
+          "objective": 3.3628103710563497,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 550,
+          "objective": 3.340901950400065,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 600,
+          "objective": 3.321788553992798,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 650,
+          "objective": 3.308771897645319,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 700,
+          "objective": 3.297867135519247,
+          "accuracy": 0.001953125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 750,
+          "objective": 3.29132036644969,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 800,
+          "objective": 3.285342657961832,
+          "accuracy": 0.0
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "start_accuracy": 0.00390625,
+      "final_accuracy": 0.013671875,
+      "final_objective": 3.2592372362705184,
+      "final_energy": {
+        "mse": 0.9823815289231346,
+        "mse_channels": [
+          0.9823815289231346
+        ],
+        "mse_channel_mean": 0.9823815289231346,
+        "conditional_kl": 6.472370892121246,
+        "m30_total": 3.2592372362705184
+      },
+      "accepted_moves": 781,
+      "moved_fraction": 0.98828125,
+      "mse_local_min_certificate": false,
+      "trajectory": [
+        {
+          "step": 0,
+          "objective": 5.3568786772789325,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 50,
+          "objective": 4.425733650226907,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 100,
+          "objective": 4.084275148634184,
+          "accuracy": 0.00390625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 150,
+          "objective": 3.8899144902500034,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 200,
+          "objective": 3.730366518035159,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 250,
+          "objective": 3.604445001639795,
+          "accuracy": 0.0078125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 300,
+          "objective": 3.5079353393274486,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 350,
+          "objective": 3.434439604545887,
+          "accuracy": 0.005859375
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 400,
+          "objective": 3.384426501223037,
+          "accuracy": 0.0078125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 450,
+          "objective": 3.3498877863563146,
+          "accuracy": 0.009765625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 500,
+          "objective": 3.325998980151843,
+          "accuracy": 0.009765625
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 550,
+          "objective": 3.304341309078155,
+          "accuracy": 0.01171875
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 600,
+          "objective": 3.289274897844929,
+          "accuracy": 0.01171875
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 650,
+          "objective": 3.2763582416038517,
+          "accuracy": 0.0078125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 700,
+          "objective": 3.2676531427274385,
+          "accuracy": 0.0078125
+        },
+        {
+          "step": 750,
+          "objective": 3.2615385668217782,
+          "accuracy": 0.01171875
+        }
+      ]
+    }
+  ],
+  "verdict": {
+    "true_m30_total": 4.099353814822328,
+    "identity_is_local_min_mse": false,
+    "descent_from_true_stays": 0.119140625,
+    "on_manifold_counterfeit_found": true,
+    "best_random_descent_m30_total": 3.2592372362705184
+  }
+}
\ No newline at end of file