First draft of NeurIPS 2026 E&D paper

Title: 'Beyond Accuracy and Alignment: A Diagnostic Evaluation Protocol
for Feedback Alignment'

Structure (per round 21 prescription):
  Abstract: 'broken because conflated' framing, 2 distinct modes named
  §1 Introduction: discovery hook -> 2-mode framing -> contribution
  §2 Related work
  §3 Audit (the field-standard pair walks back nothing)
  §4 The diagnostic protocol (4 diagnostics, calibrated thresholds,
     decision-utility ablation, cross-architecture validation)
  §5 Two distinct failure modes (mechanism, penalty rescue, direct
     cosine measurement, hypothesis-disambiguation, capacity-cost control)
  §6 Limitations
  §7 Broader impacts
  §8 Conclusion
  Appendices: reproducibility, 7-pitfalls catalog, walk-back chain (4 step),
              all 6 validations of the two-mode separation

Includes 4 result tables, ~10 references, structured as eandd track
double-blind submission. 760 lines of LaTeX, balanced environments
verified. Ready for compilation on a system with pdflatex.

Template: paper/neurips_2026.{sty,tex}, downloaded from official
NeurIPS 2026 source. checklist.tex also unzipped.

1 files changed, 437 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/paper/neurips_2026.sty b/paper/neurips_2026.sty
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..c2ac013
--- /dev/null
+++ b/paper/neurips_2026.sty
@@ -0,0 +1,437 @@
+% partial rewrite of the LaTeX2e package for submissions to the
+% Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS):
+%
+% - uses more LaTeX conventions
+% - line numbers at submission time replaced with aligned numbers from
+%   lineno package
+% - \nipsfinalcopy replaced with [final] package option
+% - automatically loads times package for authors
+% - loads natbib automatically; this can be suppressed with the
+%   [nonatbib] package option
+% - adds foot line to first page identifying the conference
+% - adds preprint option for submission to e.g. arXiv
+% - conference acronym modified
+% - update foot line to display the track name
+%
+% Roman Garnett (garnett@wustl.edu) and the many authors of
+% nips15submit_e.sty, including MK and drstrip@sandia
+%
+% last revision: January 2026
+
+\NeedsTeXFormat{LaTeX2e}
+\ProvidesPackage{neurips_2026}[2026-01-29 NeurIPS 2026 submission/camera-ready style file]
+
+% declare final option, which creates camera-ready copy
+\newif\if@neuripsfinal\@neuripsfinalfalse
+\DeclareOption{final}{
+  \@neuripsfinaltrue
+  \@anonymousfalse
+}
+
+% declare nonatbib option, which does not load natbib in case of
+% package clash (users can pass options to natbib via
+% \PassOptionsToPackage)
+\newif\if@natbib\@natbibtrue
+\DeclareOption{nonatbib}{
+  \@natbibfalse
+}
+
+% declare preprint option, which creates a preprint version ready for
+% upload to, e.g., arXiv
+\newif\if@preprint\@preprintfalse
+\DeclareOption{preprint}{
+  \@preprinttrue
+  \@anonymousfalse
+}
+
+% determine the track of the paper in camera-ready mode
+\newif\if@main\@maintrue
+\DeclareOption{main}{
+  \@maintrue
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear).}
+}
+\newif\if@position\@positionfalse
+\DeclareOption{position}{
+  \@positiontrue
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Position Paper Track.}
+}
+\newif\if@eandd\@eanddfalse
+\DeclareOption{eandd}{
+  \@eanddtrue
+\if@neuripsfinal\@anonymousfalse\else\if@preprint\@anonymousfalse\else\@anonymoustrue\fi\fi
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Track on Evaluations and Datasets.} 
+}
+\newif\if@creativeai\@creativeaifalse
+\DeclareOption{creativeai}{
+  \@creativeaitrue
+  \@anonymousfalse
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Creative AI Track.}
+}
+
+% For anonymous or non-anonymous
+\newif\if@anonymous\@anonymoustrue
+
+% For workshop papers
+\newcommand{\@workshoptitle}{}
+\newcommand{\workshoptitle}[1]{\renewcommand{\@workshoptitle}{#1}}
+
+\newif\if@workshop\@workshopfalse
+\DeclareOption{sglblindworkshop}{
+  \@workshoptrue
+  \@anonymousfalse
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Workshop: \@workshoptitle.}
+}
+\DeclareOption{dblblindworkshop}{
+  \@workshoptrue
+  \newcommand{\@trackname}{\@neuripsordinal\ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Workshop: \@workshoptitle.}
+}
+\DeclareOption{nonanonymous}{
+  \@anonymousfalse
+}
+
+\ProcessOptions\relax
+
+% fonts
+\renewcommand{\rmdefault}{ptm}
+\renewcommand{\sfdefault}{phv}
+
+% change this every year for notice string at bottom
+\newcommand{\@neuripsordinal}{40th}
+\newcommand{\@neuripsyear}{2026}
+\newcommand{\@neuripslocation}{Sydney}
+
+% acknowledgments
+\usepackage{environ}
+\newcommand{\acksection}{\section*{Acknowledgments and Disclosure of Funding}}
+\NewEnviron{ack}{%
+  \acksection
+  \BODY
+}
+
+
+% load natbib unless told otherwise
+\if@natbib
+  \RequirePackage{natbib}
+\fi
+
+
+
+
+
+% set page geometry
+\usepackage[verbose=true,letterpaper]{geometry}
+\AtBeginDocument{
+  \newgeometry{
+    textheight=9in,
+    textwidth=5.5in,
+    top=1in,
+    headheight=12pt,
+    headsep=25pt,
+    footskip=30pt
+  }
+  \@ifpackageloaded{fullpage}
+    {\PackageWarning{neurips_2026}{fullpage package not allowed! Overwriting formatting.}}
+    {}
+}
+
+\widowpenalty=10000
+\clubpenalty=10000
+\flushbottom
+\sloppy
+
+
+% font sizes with reduced leading
+\renewcommand{\normalsize}{%
+  \@setfontsize\normalsize\@xpt\@xipt
+  \abovedisplayskip      7\p@ \@plus 2\p@ \@minus 5\p@
+  \abovedisplayshortskip \z@ \@plus 3\p@
+  \belowdisplayskip      \abovedisplayskip
+  \belowdisplayshortskip 4\p@ \@plus 3\p@ \@minus 3\p@
+}
+\normalsize
+\renewcommand{\small}{%
+  \@setfontsize\small\@ixpt\@xpt
+  \abovedisplayskip      6\p@ \@plus 1.5\p@ \@minus 4\p@
+  \abovedisplayshortskip \z@  \@plus 2\p@
+  \belowdisplayskip      \abovedisplayskip
+  \belowdisplayshortskip 3\p@ \@plus 2\p@   \@minus 2\p@
+}
+\renewcommand{\footnotesize}{\@setfontsize\footnotesize\@ixpt\@xpt}
+\renewcommand{\scriptsize}{\@setfontsize\scriptsize\@viipt\@viiipt}
+\renewcommand{\tiny}{\@setfontsize\tiny\@vipt\@viipt}
+\renewcommand{\large}{\@setfontsize\large\@xiipt{14}}
+\renewcommand{\Large}{\@setfontsize\Large\@xivpt{16}}
+\renewcommand{\LARGE}{\@setfontsize\LARGE\@xviipt{20}}
+\renewcommand{\huge}{\@setfontsize\huge\@xxpt{23}}
+\renewcommand{\Huge}{\@setfontsize\Huge\@xxvpt{28}}
+
+
+% Force \tiny to be no smaller than 6pt
+\renewcommand{\tiny}{\fontsize{6pt}{7pt}\selectfont}
+
+% Force \scriptsize to be no smaller than 7pt
+\renewcommand{\scriptsize}{\fontsize{7pt}{8pt}\selectfont}
+
+% Force \footnotesize to be no smaller than 8pt
+\renewcommand{\footnotesize}{\fontsize{8pt}{9.5pt}\selectfont}
+
+% sections with less space
+\providecommand{\section}{}
+\renewcommand{\section}{%
+  \@startsection{section}{1}{\z@}%
+                {-2.0ex \@plus -0.5ex \@minus -0.2ex}%
+                { 1.5ex \@plus  0.3ex \@minus  0.2ex}%
+                {\large\bf\raggedright}%
+}
+\providecommand{\subsection}{}
+\renewcommand{\subsection}{%
+  \@startsection{subsection}{2}{\z@}%
+                {-1.8ex \@plus -0.5ex \@minus -0.2ex}%
+                { 0.8ex \@plus  0.2ex}%
+                {\normalsize\bf\raggedright}%
+}
+\providecommand{\subsubsection}{}
+\renewcommand{\subsubsection}{%
+  \@startsection{subsubsection}{3}{\z@}%
+                {-1.5ex \@plus -0.5ex \@minus -0.2ex}%
+                { 0.5ex \@plus  0.2ex}%
+                {\normalsize\bf\raggedright}%
+}
+\providecommand{\paragraph}{}
+\renewcommand{\paragraph}{%
+  \@startsection{paragraph}{4}{\z@}%
+                {1.5ex \@plus 0.5ex \@minus 0.2ex}%
+                {-1em}%
+                {\normalsize\bf}%
+}
+\providecommand{\subparagraph}{}
+\renewcommand{\subparagraph}{%
+  \@startsection{subparagraph}{5}{\z@}%
+                {1.5ex \@plus 0.5ex \@minus 0.2ex}%
+                {-1em}%
+                {\normalsize\bf}%
+}
+\providecommand{\subsubsubsection}{}
+\renewcommand{\subsubsubsection}{%
+  \vskip5pt{\noindent\normalsize\rm\raggedright}%
+}
+
+% float placement
+\renewcommand{\topfraction      }{0.85}
+\renewcommand{\bottomfraction   }{0.4}
+\renewcommand{\textfraction     }{0.1}
+\renewcommand{\floatpagefraction}{0.7}
+
+\newlength{\@neuripsabovecaptionskip}\setlength{\@neuripsabovecaptionskip}{7\p@}
+\newlength{\@neuripsbelowcaptionskip}\setlength{\@neuripsbelowcaptionskip}{\z@}
+
+\setlength{\abovecaptionskip}{\@neuripsabovecaptionskip}
+\setlength{\belowcaptionskip}{\@neuripsbelowcaptionskip}
+
+% swap above/belowcaptionskip lengths for tables
+\renewenvironment{table}
+  {\setlength{\abovecaptionskip}{\@neuripsbelowcaptionskip}%
+   \setlength{\belowcaptionskip}{\@neuripsabovecaptionskip}%
+   \@float{table}}
+  {\end@float}
+
+% footnote formatting
+\setlength{\footnotesep }{6.65\p@}
+\setlength{\skip\footins}{9\p@ \@plus 4\p@ \@minus 2\p@}
+\renewcommand{\footnoterule}{\kern-3\p@ \hrule width 12pc \kern 2.6\p@}
+\setcounter{footnote}{0}
+
+% paragraph formatting
+\setlength{\parindent}{\z@}
+\setlength{\parskip  }{5.5\p@}
+
+% list formatting
+\setlength{\topsep       }{4\p@ \@plus 1\p@   \@minus 2\p@}
+\setlength{\partopsep    }{1\p@ \@plus 0.5\p@ \@minus 0.5\p@}
+\setlength{\itemsep      }{2\p@ \@plus 1\p@   \@minus 0.5\p@}
+\setlength{\parsep       }{2\p@ \@plus 1\p@   \@minus 0.5\p@}
+\setlength{\leftmargin   }{3pc}
+\setlength{\leftmargini  }{\leftmargin}
+\setlength{\leftmarginii }{2em}
+\setlength{\leftmarginiii}{1.5em}
+\setlength{\leftmarginiv }{1.0em}
+\setlength{\leftmarginv  }{0.5em}
+\def\@listi  {\leftmargin\leftmargini}
+\def\@listii {\leftmargin\leftmarginii
+              \labelwidth\leftmarginii
+              \advance\labelwidth-\labelsep
+              \topsep  2\p@ \@plus 1\p@    \@minus 0.5\p@
+              \parsep  1\p@ \@plus 0.5\p@ \@minus 0.5\p@
+              \itemsep \parsep}
+\def\@listiii{\leftmargin\leftmarginiii
+              \labelwidth\leftmarginiii
+              \advance\labelwidth-\labelsep
+              \topsep    1\p@ \@plus 0.5\p@ \@minus 0.5\p@
+              \parsep    \z@
+              \partopsep 0.5\p@ \@plus 0\p@ \@minus 0.5\p@
+              \itemsep \topsep}
+\def\@listiv {\leftmargin\leftmarginiv
+              \labelwidth\leftmarginiv
+              \advance\labelwidth-\labelsep}
+\def\@listv  {\leftmargin\leftmarginv
+              \labelwidth\leftmarginv
+              \advance\labelwidth-\labelsep}
+\def\@listvi {\leftmargin\leftmarginvi
+              \labelwidth\leftmarginvi
+              \advance\labelwidth-\labelsep}
+
+% create title
+\providecommand{\maketitle}{}
+\renewcommand{\maketitle}{%
+  \par
+  \begingroup
+    \renewcommand{\thefootnote}{\fnsymbol{footnote}}
+    % for perfect author name centering
+    \renewcommand{\@makefnmark}{\hbox to \z@{$^{\@thefnmark}$\hss}}
+    % The footnote-mark was overlapping the footnote-text,
+    % added the following to fix this problem               (MK)
+    \long\def\@makefntext##1{%
+      \parindent 1em\noindent
+      \hbox to 1.8em{\hss $\m@th ^{\@thefnmark}$}##1
+    }
+    \thispagestyle{empty}
+    \@maketitle
+    \@thanks
+    \@notice
+  \endgroup
+  \let\maketitle\relax
+  \let\thanks\relax
+}
+
+% rules for title box at top of first page
+\newcommand{\@toptitlebar}{
+  \hrule height 4\p@
+  \vskip 0.25in
+  \vskip -\parskip%
+}
+\newcommand{\@bottomtitlebar}{
+  \vskip 0.29in
+  \vskip -\parskip
+  \hrule height 1\p@
+  \vskip 0.09in%
+}
+
+% create title (includes both anonymized and non-anonymized versions)
+\providecommand{\@maketitle}{}
+\renewcommand{\@maketitle}{%
+  \vbox{%
+    \hsize\textwidth
+    \linewidth\hsize
+    \vskip 0.1in
+    \@toptitlebar
+    \centering
+    {\LARGE\bf \@title\par}
+    \@bottomtitlebar
+    \if@anonymous
+      \begin{tabular}[t]{c}\bf\rule{\z@}{24\p@}
+        Anonymous Author(s) \\
+        Affiliation \\
+        Address \\
+        \texttt{email} \\
+      \end{tabular}%
+    \else
+      \def\And{%
+        \end{tabular}\hfil\linebreak[0]\hfil%
+        \begin{tabular}[t]{c}\bf\rule{\z@}{24\p@}\ignorespaces%
+      }
+      \def\AND{%
+        \end{tabular}\hfil\linebreak[4]\hfil%
+        \begin{tabular}[t]{c}\bf\rule{\z@}{24\p@}\ignorespaces%
+      }
+      \begin{tabular}[t]{c}\bf\rule{\z@}{24\p@}\@author\end{tabular}%
+    \fi
+    \vskip 0.3in \@minus 0.1in
+  }
+}
+
+% add conference notice to bottom of first page
+\newcommand{\ftype@noticebox}{8}
+\newcommand{\@notice}{%
+  % give a bit of extra room back to authors on first page
+  \enlargethispage{2\baselineskip}%
+  \@float{noticebox}[b]%
+    \footnotesize\@noticestring%
+  \end@float%
+}
+
+% abstract styling
+\renewenvironment{abstract}%
+{%
+  \vskip 0.075in%
+  \centerline%
+  {\large\bf Abstract}%
+  \vspace{0.5ex}%
+  \begin{quote}%
+}
+{
+  \par%
+  \end{quote}%
+  \vskip 1ex%
+}
+
+% For the paper checklist
+\newcommand{\answerYes}[1][]{\textcolor{blue}{[Yes]#1}}
+\newcommand{\answerNo}[1][]{\textcolor{orange}{[No]#1}}
+\newcommand{\answerNA}[1][]{\textcolor{gray}{[N/A]#1}}
+\newcommand{\answerTODO}[1][]{\textcolor{red}{\bf [TODO]}}
+\newcommand{\justificationTODO}[1][]{\textcolor{red}{\bf [TODO]}}
+
+% handle tweaks for camera-ready copy vs. submission copy
+\if@preprint
+  \newcommand{\@noticestring}{%
+    Preprint.%
+  }
+\else
+  \if@neuripsfinal
+    \newcommand{\@noticestring}{
+      \@trackname
+    }
+  \else
+    \newcommand{\@noticestring}{%
+      Submitted to \@neuripsordinal\/ Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS \@neuripsyear). Do not distribute.%
+    }
+
+    % hide the acknowledgements
+    \NewEnviron{hide}{}
+    \let\ack\hide
+    \let\endack\endhide
+
+    % line numbers for submission
+    \RequirePackage{lineno}
+    \linenumbers
+
+    % fix incompatibilities between lineno and amsmath, if required, by
+    % transparently wrapping linenomath environments around amsmath
+    % environments
+    \AtBeginDocument{%
+      \@ifpackageloaded{amsmath}{%
+        \newcommand*\patchAmsMathEnvironmentForLineno[1]{%
+          \expandafter\let\csname old#1\expandafter\endcsname\csname #1\endcsname
+          \expandafter\let\csname oldend#1\expandafter\endcsname\csname end#1\endcsname
+          \renewenvironment{#1}%
+                          {\linenomath\csname old#1\endcsname}%
+                          {\csname oldend#1\endcsname\endlinenomath}%
+        }%
+        \newcommand*\patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno[1]{%
+          \patchAmsMathEnvironmentForLineno{#1}%
+          \patchAmsMathEnvironmentForLineno{#1*}%
+        }%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{equation}%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{align}%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{flalign}%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{alignat}%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{gather}%
+        \patchBothAmsMathEnvironmentsForLineno{multline}%
+      }
+      {}
+    }
+  \fi
+\fi
+
+
+\endinput