Add extended sparsity analysis: A4 per-layer, B1 snapshots, B2 active subset, C1/C2

A4: Per-layer support — DFA/SB/CB layers 1-3 have 0% support at τ=1e-6
    Only BP has ~95% support; only SB layer 0 has 53%
B1: Snapshot evolution — old snapshot checkpoints have near-zero grads (data issue)
B2: Active subset — with τ=1e-6, no active samples for non-BP methods
C1: Active vs inactive cosine — only inactive subset exists for non-BP
C2: Energy concentration — near-zero for non-BP methods

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 241 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A4_perlayer_support.csv b/results/confirmatory/A4_perlayer_support.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..ace5a19
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A4_perlayer_support.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,241 @@
+method,seed,layer,threshold,support_fraction,mean_norm,median_norm

+bp,42,0,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.420379941118881e-05,4.757100032293238e-05

+bp,42,0,1e-07,0.998046875,6.420379941118881e-05,4.757100032293238e-05

+bp,42,0,1e-06,0.9443359375,6.420379941118881e-05,4.757100032293238e-05

+bp,42,0,1e-05,0.78125,6.420379941118881e-05,4.757100032293238e-05

+bp,42,0,0.0001,0.2548828125,6.420379941118881e-05,4.757100032293238e-05

+bp,42,1,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.868089258205146e-05,5.125039388076402e-05

+bp,42,1,1e-07,0.998046875,6.868089258205146e-05,5.125039388076402e-05

+bp,42,1,1e-06,0.9482421875,6.868089258205146e-05,5.125039388076402e-05

+bp,42,1,1e-05,0.79296875,6.868089258205146e-05,5.125039388076402e-05

+bp,42,1,0.0001,0.2861328125,6.868089258205146e-05,5.125039388076402e-05

+bp,42,2,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.030378037597984e-05,5.254471398075111e-05

+bp,42,2,1e-07,0.998046875,7.030378037597984e-05,5.254471398075111e-05

+bp,42,2,1e-06,0.9501953125,7.030378037597984e-05,5.254471398075111e-05

+bp,42,2,1e-05,0.8017578125,7.030378037597984e-05,5.254471398075111e-05

+bp,42,2,0.0001,0.3056640625,7.030378037597984e-05,5.254471398075111e-05

+bp,42,3,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.579310866072774e-05,5.176133709028363e-05

+bp,42,3,1e-07,0.998046875,6.579310866072774e-05,5.176133709028363e-05

+bp,42,3,1e-06,0.9501953125,6.579310866072774e-05,5.176133709028363e-05

+bp,42,3,1e-05,0.7939453125,6.579310866072774e-05,5.176133709028363e-05

+bp,42,3,0.0001,0.2763671875,6.579310866072774e-05,5.176133709028363e-05

+bp,123,0,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.826331082265824e-05,5.234080526861362e-05

+bp,123,0,1e-07,0.9921875,6.826331082265824e-05,5.234080526861362e-05

+bp,123,0,1e-06,0.9345703125,6.826331082265824e-05,5.234080526861362e-05

+bp,123,0,1e-05,0.7724609375,6.826331082265824e-05,5.234080526861362e-05

+bp,123,0,0.0001,0.27734375,6.826331082265824e-05,5.234080526861362e-05

+bp,123,1,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.233803626149893e-05,5.5852517107268795e-05

+bp,123,1,1e-07,0.9931640625,7.233803626149893e-05,5.5852517107268795e-05

+bp,123,1,1e-06,0.939453125,7.233803626149893e-05,5.5852517107268795e-05

+bp,123,1,1e-05,0.77734375,7.233803626149893e-05,5.5852517107268795e-05

+bp,123,1,0.0001,0.306640625,7.233803626149893e-05,5.5852517107268795e-05

+bp,123,2,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.557235949207097e-05,5.8344197896076366e-05

+bp,123,2,1e-07,0.994140625,7.557235949207097e-05,5.8344197896076366e-05

+bp,123,2,1e-06,0.94140625,7.557235949207097e-05,5.8344197896076366e-05

+bp,123,2,1e-05,0.7900390625,7.557235949207097e-05,5.8344197896076366e-05

+bp,123,2,0.0001,0.3251953125,7.557235949207097e-05,5.8344197896076366e-05

+bp,123,3,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.112986349966377e-05,5.571585279540159e-05

+bp,123,3,1e-07,0.9931640625,7.112986349966377e-05,5.571585279540159e-05

+bp,123,3,1e-06,0.9375,7.112986349966377e-05,5.571585279540159e-05

+bp,123,3,1e-05,0.783203125,7.112986349966377e-05,5.571585279540159e-05

+bp,123,3,0.0001,0.3193359375,7.112986349966377e-05,5.571585279540159e-05

+bp,456,0,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.796819070586935e-05,5.103028888697736e-05

+bp,456,0,1e-07,0.9931640625,6.796819070586935e-05,5.103028888697736e-05

+bp,456,0,1e-06,0.94921875,6.796819070586935e-05,5.103028888697736e-05

+bp,456,0,1e-05,0.802734375,6.796819070586935e-05,5.103028888697736e-05

+bp,456,0,0.0001,0.2705078125,6.796819070586935e-05,5.103028888697736e-05

+bp,456,1,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.196342630777508e-05,5.5566310038557276e-05

+bp,456,1,1e-07,0.9931640625,7.196342630777508e-05,5.5566310038557276e-05

+bp,456,1,1e-06,0.9501953125,7.196342630777508e-05,5.5566310038557276e-05

+bp,456,1,1e-05,0.80859375,7.196342630777508e-05,5.5566310038557276e-05

+bp,456,1,0.0001,0.294921875,7.196342630777508e-05,5.5566310038557276e-05

+bp,456,2,1e-08,0.9990234375,7.424073555739596e-05,5.7587629271438345e-05

+bp,456,2,1e-07,0.994140625,7.424073555739596e-05,5.7587629271438345e-05

+bp,456,2,1e-06,0.953125,7.424073555739596e-05,5.7587629271438345e-05

+bp,456,2,1e-05,0.8173828125,7.424073555739596e-05,5.7587629271438345e-05

+bp,456,2,0.0001,0.3173828125,7.424073555739596e-05,5.7587629271438345e-05

+bp,456,3,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.964454951230437e-05,5.580891956924461e-05

+bp,456,3,1e-07,0.994140625,6.964454951230437e-05,5.580891956924461e-05

+bp,456,3,1e-06,0.951171875,6.964454951230437e-05,5.580891956924461e-05

+bp,456,3,1e-05,0.8115234375,6.964454951230437e-05,5.580891956924461e-05

+bp,456,3,0.0001,0.302734375,6.964454951230437e-05,5.580891956924461e-05

+dfa,42,0,1e-08,1.0,7.445955674256766e-08,6.033278054928815e-08

+dfa,42,0,1e-07,0.21484375,7.445955674256766e-08,6.033278054928815e-08

+dfa,42,0,1e-06,0.0,7.445955674256766e-08,6.033278054928815e-08

+dfa,42,0,1e-05,0.0,7.445955674256766e-08,6.033278054928815e-08

+dfa,42,0,0.0001,0.0,7.445955674256766e-08,6.033278054928815e-08

+dfa,42,1,1e-08,0.0,6.029913235394702e-10,5.467529207159316e-10

+dfa,42,1,1e-07,0.0,6.029913235394702e-10,5.467529207159316e-10

+dfa,42,1,1e-06,0.0,6.029913235394702e-10,5.467529207159316e-10

+dfa,42,1,1e-05,0.0,6.029913235394702e-10,5.467529207159316e-10

+dfa,42,1,0.0001,0.0,6.029913235394702e-10,5.467529207159316e-10

+dfa,42,2,1e-08,0.0,5.976069639146431e-10,5.441311290432793e-10

+dfa,42,2,1e-07,0.0,5.976069639146431e-10,5.441311290432793e-10

+dfa,42,2,1e-06,0.0,5.976069639146431e-10,5.441311290432793e-10

+dfa,42,2,1e-05,0.0,5.976069639146431e-10,5.441311290432793e-10

+dfa,42,2,0.0001,0.0,5.976069639146431e-10,5.441311290432793e-10

+dfa,42,3,1e-08,0.0,5.973174732609721e-10,5.436861516550096e-10

+dfa,42,3,1e-07,0.0,5.973174732609721e-10,5.436861516550096e-10

+dfa,42,3,1e-06,0.0,5.973174732609721e-10,5.436861516550096e-10

+dfa,42,3,1e-05,0.0,5.973174732609721e-10,5.436861516550096e-10

+dfa,42,3,0.0001,0.0,5.973174732609721e-10,5.436861516550096e-10

+dfa,123,0,1e-08,1.0,8.558982500517232e-08,6.690434872780315e-08

+dfa,123,0,1e-07,0.2802734375,8.558982500517232e-08,6.690434872780315e-08

+dfa,123,0,1e-06,0.0,8.558982500517232e-08,6.690434872780315e-08

+dfa,123,0,1e-05,0.0,8.558982500517232e-08,6.690434872780315e-08

+dfa,123,0,0.0001,0.0,8.558982500517232e-08,6.690434872780315e-08

+dfa,123,1,1e-08,0.0,3.885574917372736e-10,3.6982170104060685e-10

+dfa,123,1,1e-07,0.0,3.885574917372736e-10,3.6982170104060685e-10

+dfa,123,1,1e-06,0.0,3.885574917372736e-10,3.6982170104060685e-10

+dfa,123,1,1e-05,0.0,3.885574917372736e-10,3.6982170104060685e-10

+dfa,123,1,0.0001,0.0,3.885574917372736e-10,3.6982170104060685e-10

+dfa,123,2,1e-08,0.0,3.82178039215475e-10,3.643452484158871e-10

+dfa,123,2,1e-07,0.0,3.82178039215475e-10,3.643452484158871e-10

+dfa,123,2,1e-06,0.0,3.82178039215475e-10,3.643452484158871e-10

+dfa,123,2,1e-05,0.0,3.82178039215475e-10,3.643452484158871e-10

+dfa,123,2,0.0001,0.0,3.82178039215475e-10,3.643452484158871e-10

+dfa,123,3,1e-08,0.0,3.82106263296933e-10,3.6438793649118395e-10

+dfa,123,3,1e-07,0.0,3.82106263296933e-10,3.6438793649118395e-10

+dfa,123,3,1e-06,0.0,3.82106263296933e-10,3.6438793649118395e-10

+dfa,123,3,1e-05,0.0,3.82106263296933e-10,3.6438793649118395e-10

+dfa,123,3,0.0001,0.0,3.82106263296933e-10,3.6438793649118395e-10

+dfa,456,0,1e-08,0.9990234375,6.62804069406775e-08,5.096582356145518e-08

+dfa,456,0,1e-07,0.1728515625,6.62804069406775e-08,5.096582356145518e-08

+dfa,456,0,1e-06,0.0,6.62804069406775e-08,5.096582356145518e-08

+dfa,456,0,1e-05,0.0,6.62804069406775e-08,5.096582356145518e-08

+dfa,456,0,0.0001,0.0,6.62804069406775e-08,5.096582356145518e-08

+dfa,456,1,1e-08,0.0,2.723611336463705e-10,2.5308924400668786e-10

+dfa,456,1,1e-07,0.0,2.723611336463705e-10,2.5308924400668786e-10

+dfa,456,1,1e-06,0.0,2.723611336463705e-10,2.5308924400668786e-10

+dfa,456,1,1e-05,0.0,2.723611336463705e-10,2.5308924400668786e-10

+dfa,456,1,0.0001,0.0,2.723611336463705e-10,2.5308924400668786e-10

+dfa,456,2,1e-08,0.0,2.684660826979268e-10,2.498188322874739e-10

+dfa,456,2,1e-07,0.0,2.684660826979268e-10,2.498188322874739e-10

+dfa,456,2,1e-06,0.0,2.684660826979268e-10,2.498188322874739e-10

+dfa,456,2,1e-05,0.0,2.684660826979268e-10,2.498188322874739e-10

+dfa,456,2,0.0001,0.0,2.684660826979268e-10,2.498188322874739e-10

+dfa,456,3,1e-08,0.0,2.68405991876719e-10,2.499166429359434e-10

+dfa,456,3,1e-07,0.0,2.68405991876719e-10,2.499166429359434e-10

+dfa,456,3,1e-06,0.0,2.68405991876719e-10,2.499166429359434e-10

+dfa,456,3,1e-05,0.0,2.68405991876719e-10,2.499166429359434e-10

+dfa,456,3,0.0001,0.0,2.68405991876719e-10,2.499166429359434e-10

+state_bridge,42,0,1e-08,0.9951171875,1.5461689599760575e-06,1.046195166054531e-06

+state_bridge,42,0,1e-07,0.94140625,1.5461689599760575e-06,1.046195166054531e-06

+state_bridge,42,0,1e-06,0.5283203125,1.5461689599760575e-06,1.046195166054531e-06

+state_bridge,42,0,1e-05,0.0048828125,1.5461689599760575e-06,1.046195166054531e-06

+state_bridge,42,0,0.0001,0.0,1.5461689599760575e-06,1.046195166054531e-06

+state_bridge,42,1,1e-08,0.0,2.511534313853758e-10,2.357372075323383e-10

+state_bridge,42,1,1e-07,0.0,2.511534313853758e-10,2.357372075323383e-10

+state_bridge,42,1,1e-06,0.0,2.511534313853758e-10,2.357372075323383e-10

+state_bridge,42,1,1e-05,0.0,2.511534313853758e-10,2.357372075323383e-10

+state_bridge,42,1,0.0001,0.0,2.511534313853758e-10,2.357372075323383e-10

+state_bridge,42,2,1e-08,0.0,2.4734042591845196e-10,2.313833846745439e-10

+state_bridge,42,2,1e-07,0.0,2.4734042591845196e-10,2.313833846745439e-10

+state_bridge,42,2,1e-06,0.0,2.4734042591845196e-10,2.313833846745439e-10

+state_bridge,42,2,1e-05,0.0,2.4734042591845196e-10,2.313833846745439e-10

+state_bridge,42,2,0.0001,0.0,2.4734042591845196e-10,2.313833846745439e-10

+state_bridge,42,3,1e-08,0.0,2.3524043823996976e-10,2.1822209317345909e-10

+state_bridge,42,3,1e-07,0.0,2.3524043823996976e-10,2.1822209317345909e-10

+state_bridge,42,3,1e-06,0.0,2.3524043823996976e-10,2.1822209317345909e-10

+state_bridge,42,3,1e-05,0.0,2.3524043823996976e-10,2.1822209317345909e-10

+state_bridge,42,3,0.0001,0.0,2.3524043823996976e-10,2.1822209317345909e-10

+state_bridge,123,0,1e-08,1.0,3.0364531085069757e-06,2.199241635025828e-06

+state_bridge,123,0,1e-07,0.9814453125,3.0364531085069757e-06,2.199241635025828e-06

+state_bridge,123,0,1e-06,0.7802734375,3.0364531085069757e-06,2.199241635025828e-06

+state_bridge,123,0,1e-05,0.0283203125,3.0364531085069757e-06,2.199241635025828e-06

+state_bridge,123,0,0.0001,0.0,3.0364531085069757e-06,2.199241635025828e-06

+state_bridge,123,1,1e-08,0.0,3.445063123663772e-10,3.0412453111416937e-10

+state_bridge,123,1,1e-07,0.0,3.445063123663772e-10,3.0412453111416937e-10

+state_bridge,123,1,1e-06,0.0,3.445063123663772e-10,3.0412453111416937e-10

+state_bridge,123,1,1e-05,0.0,3.445063123663772e-10,3.0412453111416937e-10

+state_bridge,123,1,0.0001,0.0,3.445063123663772e-10,3.0412453111416937e-10

+state_bridge,123,2,1e-08,0.0,3.406872561839691e-10,2.9890334651838657e-10

+state_bridge,123,2,1e-07,0.0,3.406872561839691e-10,2.9890334651838657e-10

+state_bridge,123,2,1e-06,0.0,3.406872561839691e-10,2.9890334651838657e-10

+state_bridge,123,2,1e-05,0.0,3.406872561839691e-10,2.9890334651838657e-10

+state_bridge,123,2,0.0001,0.0,3.406872561839691e-10,2.9890334651838657e-10

+state_bridge,123,3,1e-08,0.0,3.3725344739110596e-10,2.9520974553776114e-10

+state_bridge,123,3,1e-07,0.0,3.3725344739110596e-10,2.9520974553776114e-10

+state_bridge,123,3,1e-06,0.0,3.3725344739110596e-10,2.9520974553776114e-10

+state_bridge,123,3,1e-05,0.0,3.3725344739110596e-10,2.9520974553776114e-10

+state_bridge,123,3,0.0001,0.0,3.3725344739110596e-10,2.9520974553776114e-10

+state_bridge,456,0,1e-08,0.9921875,3.4133063309127465e-06,1.421034198756388e-06

+state_bridge,456,0,1e-07,0.947265625,3.4133063309127465e-06,1.421034198756388e-06

+state_bridge,456,0,1e-06,0.6044921875,3.4133063309127465e-06,1.421034198756388e-06

+state_bridge,456,0,1e-05,0.044921875,3.4133063309127465e-06,1.421034198756388e-06

+state_bridge,456,0,0.0001,0.001953125,3.4133063309127465e-06,1.421034198756388e-06

+state_bridge,456,1,1e-08,0.0107421875,2.6507986916612936e-09,3.6186914575964124e-10

+state_bridge,456,1,1e-07,0.0048828125,2.6507986916612936e-09,3.6186914575964124e-10

+state_bridge,456,1,1e-06,0.0,2.6507986916612936e-09,3.6186914575964124e-10

+state_bridge,456,1,1e-05,0.0,2.6507986916612936e-09,3.6186914575964124e-10

+state_bridge,456,1,0.0001,0.0,2.6507986916612936e-09,3.6186914575964124e-10

+state_bridge,456,2,1e-08,0.0,3.456599451112652e-10,3.0120325678062443e-10

+state_bridge,456,2,1e-07,0.0,3.456599451112652e-10,3.0120325678062443e-10

+state_bridge,456,2,1e-06,0.0,3.456599451112652e-10,3.0120325678062443e-10

+state_bridge,456,2,1e-05,0.0,3.456599451112652e-10,3.0120325678062443e-10

+state_bridge,456,2,0.0001,0.0,3.456599451112652e-10,3.0120325678062443e-10

+state_bridge,456,3,1e-08,0.0,3.452579333540484e-10,3.0106017678832586e-10

+state_bridge,456,3,1e-07,0.0,3.452579333540484e-10,3.0106017678832586e-10

+state_bridge,456,3,1e-06,0.0,3.452579333540484e-10,3.0106017678832586e-10

+state_bridge,456,3,1e-05,0.0,3.452579333540484e-10,3.0106017678832586e-10

+state_bridge,456,3,0.0001,0.0,3.452579333540484e-10,3.0106017678832586e-10

+credit_bridge,42,0,1e-08,0.982421875,1.573595085346824e-07,9.742006312762896e-08

+credit_bridge,42,0,1e-07,0.4921875,1.573595085346824e-07,9.742006312762896e-08

+credit_bridge,42,0,1e-06,0.0048828125,1.573595085346824e-07,9.742006312762896e-08

+credit_bridge,42,0,1e-05,0.0,1.573595085346824e-07,9.742006312762896e-08

+credit_bridge,42,0,0.0001,0.0,1.573595085346824e-07,9.742006312762896e-08

+credit_bridge,42,1,1e-08,0.0,1.8079358843348103e-10,1.3712213309258203e-10

+credit_bridge,42,1,1e-07,0.0,1.8079358843348103e-10,1.3712213309258203e-10

+credit_bridge,42,1,1e-06,0.0,1.8079358843348103e-10,1.3712213309258203e-10

+credit_bridge,42,1,1e-05,0.0,1.8079358843348103e-10,1.3712213309258203e-10

+credit_bridge,42,1,0.0001,0.0,1.8079358843348103e-10,1.3712213309258203e-10

+credit_bridge,42,2,1e-08,0.0,1.2228654200363565e-10,1.16817375217515e-10

+credit_bridge,42,2,1e-07,0.0,1.2228654200363565e-10,1.16817375217515e-10

+credit_bridge,42,2,1e-06,0.0,1.2228654200363565e-10,1.16817375217515e-10

+credit_bridge,42,2,1e-05,0.0,1.2228654200363565e-10,1.16817375217515e-10

+credit_bridge,42,2,0.0001,0.0,1.2228654200363565e-10,1.16817375217515e-10

+credit_bridge,42,3,1e-08,0.0,1.2209952493513754e-10,1.168843077881121e-10

+credit_bridge,42,3,1e-07,0.0,1.2209952493513754e-10,1.168843077881121e-10

+credit_bridge,42,3,1e-06,0.0,1.2209952493513754e-10,1.168843077881121e-10

+credit_bridge,42,3,1e-05,0.0,1.2209952493513754e-10,1.168843077881121e-10

+credit_bridge,42,3,0.0001,0.0,1.2209952493513754e-10,1.168843077881121e-10

+credit_bridge,123,0,1e-08,1.0,1.822186845856777e-07,1.3197313819546252e-07

+credit_bridge,123,0,1e-07,0.6630859375,1.822186845856777e-07,1.3197313819546252e-07

+credit_bridge,123,0,1e-06,0.0087890625,1.822186845856777e-07,1.3197313819546252e-07

+credit_bridge,123,0,1e-05,0.0,1.822186845856777e-07,1.3197313819546252e-07

+credit_bridge,123,0,0.0001,0.0,1.822186845856777e-07,1.3197313819546252e-07

+credit_bridge,123,1,1e-08,0.0,5.901329425128665e-10,5.348693710161001e-10

+credit_bridge,123,1,1e-07,0.0,5.901329425128665e-10,5.348693710161001e-10

+credit_bridge,123,1,1e-06,0.0,5.901329425128665e-10,5.348693710161001e-10

+credit_bridge,123,1,1e-05,0.0,5.901329425128665e-10,5.348693710161001e-10

+credit_bridge,123,1,0.0001,0.0,5.901329425128665e-10,5.348693710161001e-10

+credit_bridge,123,2,1e-08,0.0,5.687246784624733e-10,5.182918538793047e-10

+credit_bridge,123,2,1e-07,0.0,5.687246784624733e-10,5.182918538793047e-10

+credit_bridge,123,2,1e-06,0.0,5.687246784624733e-10,5.182918538793047e-10

+credit_bridge,123,2,1e-05,0.0,5.687246784624733e-10,5.182918538793047e-10

+credit_bridge,123,2,0.0001,0.0,5.687246784624733e-10,5.182918538793047e-10

+credit_bridge,123,3,1e-08,0.0,5.659206436803288e-10,5.167046790433005e-10

+credit_bridge,123,3,1e-07,0.0,5.659206436803288e-10,5.167046790433005e-10

+credit_bridge,123,3,1e-06,0.0,5.659206436803288e-10,5.167046790433005e-10

+credit_bridge,123,3,1e-05,0.0,5.659206436803288e-10,5.167046790433005e-10

+credit_bridge,123,3,0.0001,0.0,5.659206436803288e-10,5.167046790433005e-10

+credit_bridge,456,0,1e-08,1.0,1.1763398788389168e-07,8.743072044126166e-08

+credit_bridge,456,0,1e-07,0.43359375,1.1763398788389168e-07,8.743072044126166e-08

+credit_bridge,456,0,1e-06,0.0,1.1763398788389168e-07,8.743072044126166e-08

+credit_bridge,456,0,1e-05,0.0,1.1763398788389168e-07,8.743072044126166e-08

+credit_bridge,456,0,0.0001,0.0,1.1763398788389168e-07,8.743072044126166e-08

+credit_bridge,456,1,1e-08,0.0,3.321813102363791e-10,3.178909635526139e-10

+credit_bridge,456,1,1e-07,0.0,3.321813102363791e-10,3.178909635526139e-10

+credit_bridge,456,1,1e-06,0.0,3.321813102363791e-10,3.178909635526139e-10

+credit_bridge,456,1,1e-05,0.0,3.321813102363791e-10,3.178909635526139e-10

+credit_bridge,456,1,0.0001,0.0,3.321813102363791e-10,3.178909635526139e-10

+credit_bridge,456,2,1e-08,0.0,3.2246236236765924e-10,3.0897787106631824e-10

+credit_bridge,456,2,1e-07,0.0,3.2246236236765924e-10,3.0897787106631824e-10

+credit_bridge,456,2,1e-06,0.0,3.2246236236765924e-10,3.0897787106631824e-10

+credit_bridge,456,2,1e-05,0.0,3.2246236236765924e-10,3.0897787106631824e-10

+credit_bridge,456,2,0.0001,0.0,3.2246236236765924e-10,3.0897787106631824e-10

+credit_bridge,456,3,1e-08,0.0,3.219113864361134e-10,3.0849234278207405e-10

+credit_bridge,456,3,1e-07,0.0,3.219113864361134e-10,3.0849234278207405e-10

+credit_bridge,456,3,1e-06,0.0,3.219113864361134e-10,3.0849234278207405e-10

+credit_bridge,456,3,1e-05,0.0,3.219113864361134e-10,3.0849234278207405e-10

+credit_bridge,456,3,0.0001,0.0,3.219113864361134e-10,3.0849234278207405e-10