Add clean sparsity results: 168 JSONs from independent processes on GPU 1

CIFAR: 24 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds), BP s(1e-6)=98% confirmed
Synthetic: 144 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds × 3 alphas × 2 depths)
All data reliable — each method+seed in separate Python process.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 640 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s123.json b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s123.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5f01e6e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s123.json
@@ -0,0 +1,640 @@
+{
+  "dataset": "cifar",
+  "method": "bp",
+  "seed": 123,
+  "alpha": null,
+  "depth": 4,
+  "batch": 256,
+  "loss": 1.2278447151184082,
+  "acc": 0.58984375,
+  "per_layer": [
+    {
+      "layer": 0,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00028450513491407037,
+      "median_norm": 0.00022855156566947699,
+      "max_norm": 0.0013590023154392838,
+      "min_norm": 2.8673215979324596e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.984375,
+        "1e-05": 0.90234375,
+        "0.0001": 0.70703125
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.134434700012207,
+        "5": -5.509753227233887,
+        "10": -4.9746317863464355,
+        "25": -4.119090557098389,
+        "50": -3.639714479446411,
+        "75": -3.366743326187134,
+        "90": -3.1877975463867188,
+        "95": -3.118372678756714,
+        "99": -3.009988307952881
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        4,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        3,
+        3,
+        4,
+        4,
+        4,
+        1,
+        3,
+        1,
+        8,
+        2,
+        2,
+        2,
+        2,
+        7,
+        8,
+        4,
+        10,
+        15,
+        9,
+        10,
+        15,
+        17,
+        18,
+        17,
+        19,
+        12,
+        14,
+        12,
+        8,
+        1,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.5425238609313965,
+        -6.469008922576904,
+        -6.395493984222412,
+        -6.32197904586792,
+        -6.248464584350586,
+        -6.174949645996094,
+        -6.101434707641602,
+        -6.027919769287109,
+        -5.954404830932617,
+        -5.880889892578125,
+        -5.807374954223633,
+        -5.733860015869141,
+        -5.660345077514648,
+        -5.5868306159973145,
+        -5.513315677642822,
+        -5.43980073928833,
+        -5.366285800933838,
+        -5.292770862579346,
+        -5.2192559242248535,
+        -5.1457414627075195,
+        -5.072226524353027,
+        -4.998711585998535,
+        -4.925196647644043,
+        -4.851681709289551,
+        -4.778166770935059,
+        -4.704651832580566,
+        -4.631136894226074,
+        -4.557621955871582,
+        -4.48410701751709,
+        -4.410592079162598,
+        -4.337077617645264,
+        -4.2635626792907715,
+        -4.190047740936279,
+        -4.116532802581787,
+        -4.043017864227295,
+        -3.969503164291382,
+        -3.8959882259368896,
+        -3.8224732875823975,
+        -3.7489585876464844,
+        -3.675443649291992,
+        -3.6019287109375,
+        -3.528413772583008,
+        -3.4548988342285156,
+        -3.3813841342926025,
+        -3.3078691959381104,
+        -3.234354257583618,
+        -3.160839557647705,
+        -3.087324619293213,
+        -3.0138096809387207,
+        -2.9402947425842285,
+        -2.8667800426483154
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19932274520397186,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19578371942043304,
+      "pr_mean": 0.31977659463882446,
+      "pr_median": 0.3213789463043213,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6277211904525757,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6277210712432861,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07279124855995178,
+        "5": 0.278098464012146,
+        "10": 0.4454660415649414,
+        "25": 0.7315179109573364
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.008091344498097897,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.008091344498097897,
+        "1e-07": 0.008091344498097897,
+        "1e-06": 0.00732202036306262,
+        "1e-05": 0.007081781979650259,
+        "0.0001": 0.0005258761812001467
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.00987889593599409,
+        "1e-07": -0.00987889593599409,
+        "1e-06": -0.00987889593599409,
+        "1e-05": -0.00987889593599409,
+        "0.0001": -0.00987889593599409
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 1,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00030184671049937606,
+      "median_norm": 0.00023769863764755428,
+      "max_norm": 0.001208685920573771,
+      "min_norm": 3.1506317554885754e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.90625,
+        "0.0001": 0.71875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.092222690582275,
+        "5": -5.492038726806641,
+        "10": -4.953402519226074,
+        "25": -4.072449684143066,
+        "50": -3.6149144172668457,
+        "75": -3.337055206298828,
+        "90": -3.168731689453125,
+        "95": -3.0973267555236816,
+        "99": -2.975595235824585
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        4,
+        4,
+        2,
+        5,
+        2,
+        3,
+        2,
+        4,
+        5,
+        2,
+        2,
+        3,
+        2,
+        4,
+        8,
+        8,
+        14,
+        11,
+        8,
+        11,
+        14,
+        18,
+        16,
+        18,
+        17,
+        8,
+        20,
+        10,
+        6,
+        5
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.5016021728515625,
+        -6.429924011230469,
+        -6.358245372772217,
+        -6.286567211151123,
+        -6.214889049530029,
+        -6.143210411071777,
+        -6.071532249450684,
+        -5.99985408782959,
+        -5.928175926208496,
+        -5.856497287750244,
+        -5.78481912612915,
+        -5.713140487670898,
+        -5.641462326049805,
+        -5.569784164428711,
+        -5.498106002807617,
+        -5.426427364349365,
+        -5.3547492027282715,
+        -5.283071041107178,
+        -5.211392402648926,
+        -5.139714241027832,
+        -5.068036079406738,
+        -4.9963579177856445,
+        -4.924679279327393,
+        -4.853001117706299,
+        -4.781322479248047,
+        -4.709644317626953,
+        -4.637966156005859,
+        -4.566287994384766,
+        -4.494609355926514,
+        -4.42293119430542,
+        -4.351252555847168,
+        -4.279574394226074,
+        -4.2078962326049805,
+        -4.136218070983887,
+        -4.064539909362793,
+        -3.992861270904541,
+        -3.9211831092834473,
+        -3.8495047092437744,
+        -3.7778263092041016,
+        -3.706148147583008,
+        -3.634469747543335,
+        -3.562791347503662,
+        -3.4911131858825684,
+        -3.4194347858428955,
+        -3.3477563858032227,
+        -3.276078224182129,
+        -3.204399824142456,
+        -3.1327216625213623,
+        -3.0610432624816895,
+        -2.9893648624420166,
+        -2.917686700820923
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1956845223903656,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19191423058509827,
+      "pr_mean": 0.32563915848731995,
+      "pr_median": 0.3224400579929352,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6296026706695557,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6296026706695557,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.0700303167104721,
+        "5": 0.2744002342224121,
+        "10": 0.441372811794281,
+        "25": 0.7295328378677368
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.00795608852058649,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.00795608852058649,
+        "1e-07": 0.00795608852058649,
+        "1e-06": 0.00863230787217617,
+        "1e-05": 0.010981490835547447,
+        "0.0001": 0.006701463833451271
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.00026937501098460513,
+        "1e-07": 0.00026937501098460513,
+        "1e-06": 0.00026937501098460513,
+        "1e-05": 0.00026937501098460513,
+        "0.0001": 0.00026937501098460513
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 2,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0003135820443276316,
+      "median_norm": 0.0002543467271607369,
+      "max_norm": 0.0011772668221965432,
+      "min_norm": 3.356943807375501e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9140625,
+        "0.0001": 0.72265625
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.022266387939453,
+        "5": -5.486436367034912,
+        "10": -4.916165351867676,
+        "25": -4.059142112731934,
+        "50": -3.5942130088806152,
+        "75": -3.3095245361328125,
+        "90": -3.142878770828247,
+        "95": -3.080014228820801,
+        "99": -2.9782094955444336
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        3,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        3,
+        3,
+        3,
+        5,
+        3,
+        3,
+        1,
+        3,
+        3,
+        5,
+        2,
+        3,
+        2,
+        3,
+        10,
+        5,
+        10,
+        14,
+        11,
+        10,
+        14,
+        13,
+        14,
+        19,
+        18,
+        15,
+        15,
+        15,
+        5,
+        6
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.474055767059326,
+        -6.4031572341918945,
+        -6.332258701324463,
+        -6.261360168457031,
+        -6.190461158752441,
+        -6.11956262588501,
+        -6.048664093017578,
+        -5.9777655601501465,
+        -5.906867027282715,
+        -5.835968017578125,
+        -5.765069484710693,
+        -5.694170951843262,
+        -5.62327241897583,
+        -5.552373886108398,
+        -5.481475353240967,
+        -5.410576820373535,
+        -5.339677810668945,
+        -5.268779277801514,
+        -5.197880744934082,
+        -5.12698221206665,
+        -5.056083679199219,
+        -4.985184669494629,
+        -4.914286136627197,
+        -4.843387603759766,
+        -4.772489070892334,
+        -4.701590538024902,
+        -4.6306915283203125,
+        -4.559792995452881,
+        -4.488894462585449,
+        -4.417995929718018,
+        -4.347097396850586,
+        -4.276198387145996,
+        -4.205300331115723,
+        -4.134401321411133,
+        -4.063502788543701,
+        -3.9926042556762695,
+        -3.921705722808838,
+        -3.850806951522827,
+        -3.7799084186553955,
+        -3.709009885787964,
+        -3.638111114501953,
+        -3.5672125816345215,
+        -3.49631404876709,
+        -3.425415277481079,
+        -3.3545167446136475,
+        -3.283618211746216,
+        -3.212719440460205,
+        -3.1418209075927734,
+        -3.070922374725342,
+        -3.000023603439331,
+        -2.9291250705718994
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19659769535064697,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19407156109809875,
+      "pr_mean": 0.32775190472602844,
+      "pr_median": 0.325853168964386,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6314839720726013,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6314840316772461,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06999526172876358,
+        "5": 0.27125284075737,
+        "10": 0.4386821687221527,
+        "25": 0.7279925346374512
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.021253487095236778,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.021253487095236778,
+        "1e-07": -0.021253487095236778,
+        "1e-06": -0.021729107946157455,
+        "1e-05": -0.021009434014558792,
+        "0.0001": -0.02308928221464157
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.016939791060805443,
+        "1e-07": -0.016939791060805443,
+        "1e-06": -0.016939791060805443,
+        "1e-05": -0.016939791060805443,
+        "0.0001": -0.016939791060805443
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 3,
+      "mean_norm": 0.000297254096949473,
+      "median_norm": 0.00024099259462673217,
+      "max_norm": 0.0011388171697035432,
+      "min_norm": 3.1686695933785813e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.91015625,
+        "0.0001": 0.71875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.051245212554932,
+        "5": -5.475461959838867,
+        "10": -4.922177314758301,
+        "25": -4.0708909034729,
+        "50": -3.611677408218384,
+        "75": -3.325131893157959,
+        "90": -3.1709394454956055,
+        "95": -3.112522602081299,
+        "99": -3.0375943183898926
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        2,
+        4,
+        4,
+        4,
+        3,
+        1,
+        2,
+        5,
+        3,
+        1,
+        5,
+        1,
+        5,
+        9,
+        3,
+        11,
+        14,
+        11,
+        10,
+        15,
+        12,
+        16,
+        17,
+        19,
+        17,
+        17,
+        13,
+        7,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.4991230964660645,
+        -6.428011417388916,
+        -6.356900215148926,
+        -6.285788536071777,
+        -6.214676856994629,
+        -6.1435651779174805,
+        -6.07245397567749,
+        -6.001342296600342,
+        -5.930230617523193,
+        -5.859119415283203,
+        -5.788007736206055,
+        -5.716896057128906,
+        -5.645784378051758,
+        -5.574673175811768,
+        -5.503561496734619,
+        -5.432450294494629,
+        -5.3613386154174805,
+        -5.290226936340332,
+        -5.219115257263184,
+        -5.148004055023193,
+        -5.076892375946045,
+        -5.0057806968688965,
+        -4.934669494628906,
+        -4.863557815551758,
+        -4.792446136474609,
+        -4.721334457397461,
+        -4.650223255157471,
+        -4.579111576080322,
+        -4.507999897003174,
+        -4.436888694763184,
+        -4.365777015686035,
+        -4.294665336608887,
+        -4.223553657531738,
+        -4.152442455291748,
+        -4.0813307762146,
+        -4.010219573974609,
+        -3.939107656478882,
+        -3.8679962158203125,
+        -3.796884775161743,
+        -3.7257730960845947,
+        -3.6546616554260254,
+        -3.583549976348877,
+        -3.5124385356903076,
+        -3.4413270950317383,
+        -3.37021541595459,
+        -3.2991039752960205,
+        -3.227992296218872,
+        -3.1568808555603027,
+        -3.0857691764831543,
+        -3.014657735824585,
+        -2.9435460567474365
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1926463544368744,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.18907807767391205,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3364142179489136,
+      "pr_median": 0.3373374044895172,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6366024017333984,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6366024017333984,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06730996072292328,
+        "5": 0.264831006526947,
+        "10": 0.4318138360977173,
+        "25": 0.7223255634307861
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.032496366649866104,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.032496366649866104,
+        "1e-07": 0.032496366649866104,
+        "1e-06": 0.032468751072883606,
+        "1e-05": 0.030892575159668922,
+        "0.0001": 0.03325022757053375
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.02745312077202487,
+        "1e-07": 0.02745312077202487,
+        "1e-06": 0.02745312077202487,
+        "1e-05": 0.02745312077202487,
+        "0.0001": 0.02745312077202487
+      }
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file