Add clean sparsity results: 168 JSONs from independent processes on GPU 1

CIFAR: 24 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds), BP s(1e-6)=98% confirmed
Synthetic: 144 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds × 3 alphas × 2 depths)
All data reliable — each method+seed in separate Python process.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 640 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s42.json b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s42.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5a4a7bf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s42.json
@@ -0,0 +1,640 @@
+{
+  "dataset": "cifar",
+  "method": "bp",
+  "seed": 42,
+  "alpha": null,
+  "depth": 4,
+  "batch": 256,
+  "loss": 1.1766504049301147,
+  "acc": 0.61328125,
+  "per_layer": [
+    {
+      "layer": 0,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0002583038294687867,
+      "median_norm": 0.00021287477284204215,
+      "max_norm": 0.0010169680463150144,
+      "min_norm": 4.002587843388028e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98046875,
+        "1e-05": 0.92578125,
+        "0.0001": 0.6796875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.191201686859131,
+        "5": -5.410096645355225,
+        "10": -4.846468925476074,
+        "25": -4.185210227966309,
+        "50": -3.6713600158691406,
+        "75": -3.414608955383301,
+        "90": -3.267821788787842,
+        "95": -3.159428834915161,
+        "99": -3.0218911170959473
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        3,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        3,
+        2,
+        1,
+        5,
+        2,
+        2,
+        5,
+        7,
+        2,
+        2,
+        4,
+        3,
+        6,
+        8,
+        10,
+        4,
+        3,
+        11,
+        12,
+        11,
+        8,
+        10,
+        21,
+        12,
+        25,
+        20,
+        15,
+        9,
+        5,
+        7,
+        5
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.3976593017578125,
+        -6.329559803009033,
+        -6.261460781097412,
+        -6.193361282348633,
+        -6.1252617835998535,
+        -6.057162761688232,
+        -5.989063262939453,
+        -5.920963764190674,
+        -5.852864742279053,
+        -5.784765243530273,
+        -5.716666221618652,
+        -5.648566722869873,
+        -5.580467224121094,
+        -5.512368202209473,
+        -5.444268703460693,
+        -5.376169204711914,
+        -5.308070182800293,
+        -5.239970684051514,
+        -5.171871185302734,
+        -5.103772163391113,
+        -5.035672664642334,
+        -4.967573165893555,
+        -4.899474143981934,
+        -4.831374645233154,
+        -4.763275146484375,
+        -4.695176124572754,
+        -4.627076625823975,
+        -4.558977127075195,
+        -4.490878105163574,
+        -4.422778606414795,
+        -4.354679107666016,
+        -4.2865800857543945,
+        -4.218480587005615,
+        -4.150381088256836,
+        -4.082282066345215,
+        -4.0141825675964355,
+        -3.9460833072662354,
+        -3.877983808517456,
+        -3.809884548187256,
+        -3.7417852878570557,
+        -3.6736860275268555,
+        -3.605586528778076,
+        -3.537487268447876,
+        -3.469388008117676,
+        -3.4012885093688965,
+        -3.3331892490386963,
+        -3.265089988708496,
+        -3.196990489959717,
+        -3.1288912296295166,
+        -3.0607919692993164,
+        -2.992692708969116
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.20032858848571777,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19896194338798523,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3203713893890381,
+      "pr_median": 0.3194621503353119,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6286087036132812,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6286086440086365,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07293599843978882,
+        "5": 0.2773609757423401,
+        "10": 0.4439087510108948,
+        "25": 0.730988085269928
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.007419188041239977,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.007419188041239977,
+        "1e-07": 0.007419188041239977,
+        "1e-06": 0.007683352567255497,
+        "1e-05": 0.007463833317160606,
+        "0.0001": 0.007877446711063385
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.0004358875191889989,
+        "1e-07": 0.0004358875191889989,
+        "1e-06": 0.0004358875191889989,
+        "1e-05": 0.0004358875191889989,
+        "0.0001": 0.0004358875191889989
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 1,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00027934598620049655,
+      "median_norm": 0.00023581851564813405,
+      "max_norm": 0.0011342121288180351,
+      "min_norm": 4.5549370497610653e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98046875,
+        "1e-05": 0.9296875,
+        "0.0001": 0.6796875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.128386497497559,
+        "5": -5.304507255554199,
+        "10": -4.774336814880371,
+        "25": -4.128973007202148,
+        "50": -3.625448226928711,
+        "75": -3.370743751525879,
+        "90": -3.2285523414611816,
+        "95": -3.141850471496582,
+        "99": -2.987013339996338
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        3,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        3,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        0,
+        3,
+        3,
+        4,
+        4,
+        7,
+        2,
+        3,
+        3,
+        4,
+        4,
+        9,
+        8,
+        6,
+        6,
+        11,
+        11,
+        8,
+        10,
+        15,
+        14,
+        13,
+        27,
+        22,
+        12,
+        11,
+        5,
+        5,
+        4
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.341517925262451,
+        -6.273593902587891,
+        -6.205669403076172,
+        -6.137745380401611,
+        -6.069820880889893,
+        -6.001896858215332,
+        -5.933972358703613,
+        -5.866048336029053,
+        -5.798123836517334,
+        -5.730199813842773,
+        -5.662275314331055,
+        -5.594351291656494,
+        -5.526427268981934,
+        -5.458502769470215,
+        -5.390578746795654,
+        -5.3226542472839355,
+        -5.254730224609375,
+        -5.186805725097656,
+        -5.118881702423096,
+        -5.050957679748535,
+        -4.983033180236816,
+        -4.915108680725098,
+        -4.847184658050537,
+        -4.779260635375977,
+        -4.711336135864258,
+        -4.643412113189697,
+        -4.5754876136779785,
+        -4.507563591003418,
+        -4.439639091491699,
+        -4.371715068817139,
+        -4.303791046142578,
+        -4.235866546630859,
+        -4.167942047119141,
+        -4.10001802444458,
+        -4.0320940017700195,
+        -3.964169502258301,
+        -3.896245241165161,
+        -3.8283209800720215,
+        -3.760396957397461,
+        -3.6924726963043213,
+        -3.6245484352111816,
+        -3.556624174118042,
+        -3.4886999130249023,
+        -3.4207756519317627,
+        -3.352851390838623,
+        -3.2849271297454834,
+        -3.2170028686523438,
+        -3.149078607559204,
+        -3.0811543464660645,
+        -3.013230323791504,
+        -2.945305824279785
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1956656575202942,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19191943109035492,
+      "pr_mean": 0.32908809185028076,
+      "pr_median": 0.3305799067020416,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6329350471496582,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6329350471496582,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06997253000736237,
+        "5": 0.2709628939628601,
+        "10": 0.4380391836166382,
+        "25": 0.7270048260688782
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.002222827635705471,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.002222827635705471,
+        "1e-07": 0.002222827635705471,
+        "1e-06": 0.002488299971446395,
+        "1e-05": 0.0029638304840773344,
+        "0.0001": 0.0015200951602309942
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.011483831463457413,
+        "1e-07": 0.011483831463457413,
+        "1e-06": 0.011483831463457413,
+        "1e-05": 0.011483831463457413,
+        "0.0001": 0.011483831463457413
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 2,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00028562924126163125,
+      "median_norm": 0.0002295597514603287,
+      "max_norm": 0.0013789449585601687,
+      "min_norm": 4.723476649814984e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.984375,
+        "1e-05": 0.93359375,
+        "0.0001": 0.703125
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.102329254150391,
+        "5": -5.302539348602295,
+        "10": -4.720612525939941,
+        "25": -4.116630554199219,
+        "50": -3.629791021347046,
+        "75": -3.3551669120788574,
+        "90": -3.2235240936279297,
+        "95": -3.1311984062194824,
+        "99": -2.9967100620269775
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        4,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        3,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        3,
+        2,
+        2,
+        1,
+        5,
+        4,
+        5,
+        4,
+        3,
+        5,
+        2,
+        5,
+        9,
+        5,
+        8,
+        8,
+        12,
+        5,
+        11,
+        12,
+        13,
+        14,
+        19,
+        22,
+        21,
+        16,
+        8,
+        7,
+        5,
+        2,
+        1
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.325738430023193,
+        -6.25643253326416,
+        -6.187127113342285,
+        -6.117821216583252,
+        -6.048515796661377,
+        -5.979209899902344,
+        -5.9099040031433105,
+        -5.8405985832214355,
+        -5.771292686462402,
+        -5.701987266540527,
+        -5.632681369781494,
+        -5.563375473022461,
+        -5.494070053100586,
+        -5.424764156341553,
+        -5.355458736419678,
+        -5.2861528396606445,
+        -5.2168474197387695,
+        -5.147541522979736,
+        -5.078235626220703,
+        -5.008930206298828,
+        -4.939624309539795,
+        -4.870318412780762,
+        -4.801012992858887,
+        -4.7317070960998535,
+        -4.6624016761779785,
+        -4.593095779418945,
+        -4.52379035949707,
+        -4.454484462738037,
+        -4.385178565979004,
+        -4.315873146057129,
+        -4.246567249298096,
+        -4.1772613525390625,
+        -4.1079559326171875,
+        -4.0386505126953125,
+        -3.9693446159362793,
+        -3.900038719177246,
+        -3.830733060836792,
+        -3.761427402496338,
+        -3.692121744155884,
+        -3.6228160858154297,
+        -3.5535101890563965,
+        -3.4842045307159424,
+        -3.4148988723754883,
+        -3.345593214035034,
+        -3.27628755569458,
+        -3.206981897354126,
+        -3.1376760005950928,
+        -3.0683703422546387,
+        -2.9990646839141846,
+        -2.9297590255737305,
+        -2.8604531288146973
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1923454999923706,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.18653415143489838,
+      "pr_mean": 0.33524906635284424,
+      "pr_median": 0.3367668390274048,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6359347105026245,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6359347105026245,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06719520688056946,
+        "5": 0.26662012934684753,
+        "10": 0.4335557818412781,
+        "25": 0.7242363095283508
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.001922080060467124,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.001922080060467124,
+        "1e-07": -0.001922080060467124,
+        "1e-06": -0.0019928705878555775,
+        "1e-05": -0.001829057466238737,
+        "0.0001": 0.0024331293534487486
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.0003414634227752114,
+        "1e-07": 0.0003414634227752114,
+        "1e-06": 0.0003414634227752114,
+        "1e-05": 0.0003414634227752114,
+        "0.0001": 0.0003414634227752114
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 3,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0002658877638168633,
+      "median_norm": 0.00022341191652230918,
+      "max_norm": 0.000979505362920463,
+      "min_norm": 4.890844138571993e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.984375,
+        "1e-05": 0.9296875,
+        "0.0001": 0.69140625
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.087945938110352,
+        "5": -5.347776889801025,
+        "10": -4.776177406311035,
+        "25": -4.148471832275391,
+        "50": -3.6476974487304688,
+        "75": -3.379814624786377,
+        "90": -3.2494993209838867,
+        "95": -3.1640782356262207,
+        "99": -3.0749166011810303
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        3,
+        3,
+        3,
+        4,
+        4,
+        6,
+        2,
+        5,
+        1,
+        4,
+        9,
+        8,
+        5,
+        4,
+        9,
+        14,
+        6,
+        12,
+        12,
+        14,
+        15,
+        21,
+        21,
+        16,
+        12,
+        11,
+        7,
+        3
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.310616493225098,
+        -6.244584083557129,
+        -6.17855167388916,
+        -6.112519264221191,
+        -6.046486854553223,
+        -5.980453968048096,
+        -5.914421558380127,
+        -5.848389148712158,
+        -5.7823567390441895,
+        -5.716324329376221,
+        -5.650291919708252,
+        -5.584259510040283,
+        -5.5182271003723145,
+        -5.452194690704346,
+        -5.386161804199219,
+        -5.32012939453125,
+        -5.254096984863281,
+        -5.1880645751953125,
+        -5.122032165527344,
+        -5.055999755859375,
+        -4.989967346191406,
+        -4.9239349365234375,
+        -4.857902526855469,
+        -4.7918701171875,
+        -4.725837707519531,
+        -4.659804821014404,
+        -4.5937724113464355,
+        -4.527740001678467,
+        -4.461707592010498,
+        -4.395675182342529,
+        -4.3296427726745605,
+        -4.263609886169434,
+        -4.197577476501465,
+        -4.131545066833496,
+        -4.065512657165527,
+        -3.9994802474975586,
+        -3.93344783782959,
+        -3.867415428161621,
+        -3.8013830184936523,
+        -3.7353503704071045,
+        -3.6693179607391357,
+        -3.603285551071167,
+        -3.5372531414031982,
+        -3.4712207317352295,
+        -3.4051880836486816,
+        -3.339155673980713,
+        -3.273123264312744,
+        -3.2070908546447754,
+        -3.1410584449768066,
+        -3.075025796890259,
+        -3.00899338722229
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1918967068195343,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.18914012610912323,
+      "pr_mean": 0.34012287855148315,
+      "pr_median": 0.3411962687969208,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6396616697311401,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6396616697311401,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06688753515481949,
+        "5": 0.26281508803367615,
+        "10": 0.42837053537368774,
+        "25": 0.7193521857261658
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.009083976969122887,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.009083976969122887,
+        "1e-07": 0.009083976969122887,
+        "1e-06": 0.009226549416780472,
+        "1e-05": 0.0097868163138628,
+        "0.0001": 0.00949579942971468
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.0011287236125428752,
+        "1e-07": -0.0011287236125428752,
+        "1e-06": -0.0011287236125428752,
+        "1e-05": -0.0011287236125428752,
+        "0.0001": -0.0011287236125428752
+      }
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file