Add clean sparsity results: 168 JSONs from independent processes on GPU 1

CIFAR: 24 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds), BP s(1e-6)=98% confirmed
Synthetic: 144 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds × 3 alphas × 2 depths)
All data reliable — each method+seed in separate Python process.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 640 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s456.json b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s456.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..9f19622
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s456.json
@@ -0,0 +1,640 @@
+{
+  "dataset": "cifar",
+  "method": "bp",
+  "seed": 456,
+  "alpha": null,
+  "depth": 4,
+  "batch": 256,
+  "loss": 1.134702205657959,
+  "acc": 0.60546875,
+  "per_layer": [
+    {
+      "layer": 0,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00027655030135065317,
+      "median_norm": 0.0002507986209820956,
+      "max_norm": 0.0012175287120044231,
+      "min_norm": 1.7616598313452414e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.984375,
+        "1e-05": 0.92578125,
+        "0.0001": 0.6796875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.09072732925415,
+        "5": -5.340359210968018,
+        "10": -4.7934980392456055,
+        "25": -4.117383003234863,
+        "50": -3.5990183353424072,
+        "75": -3.395719051361084,
+        "90": -3.2136569023132324,
+        "95": -3.1458280086517334,
+        "99": -3.0226263999938965
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        3,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        3,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        6,
+        3,
+        7,
+        3,
+        5,
+        2,
+        4,
+        5,
+        5,
+        12,
+        10,
+        10,
+        3,
+        9,
+        11,
+        9,
+        19,
+        30,
+        21,
+        18,
+        14,
+        15,
+        7,
+        4,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.754077911376953,
+        -6.677286624908447,
+        -6.6004958152771,
+        -6.523704528808594,
+        -6.446913242340088,
+        -6.37012243270874,
+        -6.293331146240234,
+        -6.2165398597717285,
+        -6.139748573303223,
+        -6.062957763671875,
+        -5.986166477203369,
+        -5.909375190734863,
+        -5.832584381103516,
+        -5.75579309463501,
+        -5.679001808166504,
+        -5.602210998535156,
+        -5.52541971206665,
+        -5.4486284255981445,
+        -5.371837615966797,
+        -5.295046329498291,
+        -5.218255043029785,
+        -5.1414642333984375,
+        -5.064672946929932,
+        -4.987881660461426,
+        -4.911090850830078,
+        -4.834299564361572,
+        -4.757508277893066,
+        -4.680717468261719,
+        -4.603926181793213,
+        -4.527134895324707,
+        -4.450344085693359,
+        -4.373552322387695,
+        -4.296761512756348,
+        -4.219970703125,
+        -4.143178939819336,
+        -4.066388130187988,
+        -3.9895968437194824,
+        -3.9128057956695557,
+        -3.836014747619629,
+        -3.759223461151123,
+        -3.6824324131011963,
+        -3.6056413650512695,
+        -3.5288500785827637,
+        -3.452059030532837,
+        -3.37526798248291,
+        -3.2984766960144043,
+        -3.2216856479644775,
+        -3.1448943614959717,
+        -3.068103313446045,
+        -2.991312265396118,
+        -2.9145209789276123
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.20751555263996124,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.2025705873966217,
+      "pr_mean": 0.30786722898483276,
+      "pr_median": 0.31083884835243225,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6232450604438782,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6232450604438782,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07772163301706314,
+        "5": 0.2858421504497528,
+        "10": 0.4527928829193115,
+        "25": 0.7351163625717163
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.014971199445426464,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.014971199445426464,
+        "1e-07": -0.014971199445426464,
+        "1e-06": -0.014634325169026852,
+        "1e-05": -0.013387474231421947,
+        "0.0001": -0.012127147056162357
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.011096584233506353,
+        "1e-07": -0.011096584233506353,
+        "1e-06": -0.011096584233506353,
+        "1e-05": -0.011096584233506353,
+        "0.0001": -0.011096584233506353
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 1,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0002921682025771588,
+      "median_norm": 0.00026245132903568447,
+      "max_norm": 0.0013142111711204052,
+      "min_norm": 2.0419759039214114e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9296875,
+        "0.0001": 0.69921875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.023776054382324,
+        "5": -5.316246032714844,
+        "10": -4.728536128997803,
+        "25": -4.09047269821167,
+        "50": -3.5748252868652344,
+        "75": -3.364473581314087,
+        "90": -3.1900417804718018,
+        "95": -3.124774217605591,
+        "99": -3.014953374862671
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        0,
+        0,
+        3,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        3,
+        6,
+        4,
+        5,
+        5,
+        3,
+        3,
+        4,
+        6,
+        3,
+        11,
+        12,
+        10,
+        3,
+        10,
+        16,
+        7,
+        19,
+        28,
+        19,
+        22,
+        13,
+        12,
+        7,
+        4,
+        1
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.6899495124816895,
+        -6.613777160644531,
+        -6.537604808807373,
+        -6.461432456970215,
+        -6.385260581970215,
+        -6.309088230133057,
+        -6.232915878295898,
+        -6.15674352645874,
+        -6.080571174621582,
+        -6.004398822784424,
+        -5.928226470947266,
+        -5.852054119110107,
+        -5.775881767272949,
+        -5.699709892272949,
+        -5.623537540435791,
+        -5.547365188598633,
+        -5.471192836761475,
+        -5.395020484924316,
+        -5.318848133087158,
+        -5.24267578125,
+        -5.16650390625,
+        -5.090331077575684,
+        -5.014159202575684,
+        -4.937986850738525,
+        -4.861814498901367,
+        -4.785642147064209,
+        -4.709469795227051,
+        -4.633297920227051,
+        -4.557125091552734,
+        -4.480953216552734,
+        -4.404780864715576,
+        -4.328608512878418,
+        -4.25243616104126,
+        -4.176263809204102,
+        -4.100091457366943,
+        -4.023919105529785,
+        -3.947746992111206,
+        -3.871574640274048,
+        -3.7954025268554688,
+        -3.7192301750183105,
+        -3.6430578231811523,
+        -3.566885471343994,
+        -3.490713119506836,
+        -3.414541006088257,
+        -3.3383686542510986,
+        -3.2621963024139404,
+        -3.1860241889953613,
+        -3.109851837158203,
+        -3.033679485321045,
+        -2.9575071334838867,
+        -2.8813347816467285
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19999593496322632,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19583410024642944,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3200453817844391,
+      "pr_median": 0.32107144594192505,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.628067672252655,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.628067672252655,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07280948758125305,
+        "5": 0.2768515348434448,
+        "10": 0.4443309009075165,
+        "25": 0.7308841943740845
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.0025548292323946953,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.0025548292323946953,
+        "1e-07": -0.0025548292323946953,
+        "1e-06": -0.001630655606277287,
+        "1e-05": -0.0015760527458041906,
+        "0.0001": -0.0029595294035971165
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.0035156105135952004,
+        "1e-07": -0.0035156105135952004,
+        "1e-06": -0.0035156105135952004,
+        "1e-05": -0.0035156105135952004,
+        "0.0001": -0.0035156105135952004
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 2,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00030216804589144886,
+      "median_norm": 0.0002623854670673609,
+      "max_norm": 0.0014048833400011063,
+      "min_norm": 2.0051355420491745e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9296875,
+        "0.0001": 0.72265625
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -5.969611644744873,
+        "5": -5.311683654785156,
+        "10": -4.725646018981934,
+        "25": -4.060149669647217,
+        "50": -3.5725948810577393,
+        "75": -3.345057249069214,
+        "90": -3.192936658859253,
+        "95": -3.125922679901123,
+        "99": -3.0328726768493652
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        3,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        1,
+        0,
+        3,
+        6,
+        5,
+        2,
+        6,
+        4,
+        3,
+        6,
+        4,
+        5,
+        8,
+        14,
+        9,
+        5,
+        7,
+        17,
+        7,
+        22,
+        26,
+        21,
+        21,
+        15,
+        13,
+        6,
+        1,
+        1
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.697856426239014,
+        -6.620946407318115,
+        -6.544036388397217,
+        -6.467126846313477,
+        -6.390216827392578,
+        -6.31330680847168,
+        -6.236396789550781,
+        -6.159486770629883,
+        -6.082576751708984,
+        -6.005667209625244,
+        -5.928757190704346,
+        -5.851847171783447,
+        -5.774937152862549,
+        -5.698027610778809,
+        -5.62111759185791,
+        -5.544207572937012,
+        -5.467297554016113,
+        -5.390387535095215,
+        -5.313477516174316,
+        -5.236567497253418,
+        -5.159657955169678,
+        -5.082747936248779,
+        -5.005837917327881,
+        -4.928927898406982,
+        -4.852018356323242,
+        -4.775108337402344,
+        -4.698198318481445,
+        -4.621288299560547,
+        -4.544378280639648,
+        -4.46746826171875,
+        -4.390558242797852,
+        -4.313648700714111,
+        -4.236738681793213,
+        -4.1598286628723145,
+        -4.082919120788574,
+        -4.006009101867676,
+        -3.9290990829467773,
+        -3.852189064025879,
+        -3.7752790451049805,
+        -3.698369264602661,
+        -3.6214592456817627,
+        -3.5445492267608643,
+        -3.467639446258545,
+        -3.3907294273376465,
+        -3.313819408416748,
+        -3.2369096279144287,
+        -3.1599996089935303,
+        -3.083089828491211,
+        -3.0061798095703125,
+        -2.929269790649414,
+        -2.8523597717285156
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.1971304714679718,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19318580627441406,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3287036716938019,
+      "pr_median": 0.3311604857444763,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6334779858589172,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6334779858589172,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07015401124954224,
+        "5": 0.27118825912475586,
+        "10": 0.43774986267089844,
+        "25": 0.7261644005775452
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.01473689079284668,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.01473689079284668,
+        "1e-07": -0.01473689079284668,
+        "1e-06": -0.014157110825181007,
+        "1e-05": -0.01343219168484211,
+        "0.0001": -0.009055773727595806
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": -0.002927922528887703,
+        "1e-07": -0.002927922528887703,
+        "1e-06": -0.002927922528887703,
+        "1e-05": -0.002927922528887703,
+        "0.0001": -0.002927922528887703
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 3,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00028384485631249845,
+      "median_norm": 0.00024727825075387955,
+      "max_norm": 0.0011319027980789542,
+      "min_norm": 2.407495003353688e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9296875,
+        "0.0001": 0.703125
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -5.98410177230835,
+        "5": -5.36592435836792,
+        "10": -4.73854398727417,
+        "25": -4.090005397796631,
+        "50": -3.6066718101501465,
+        "75": -3.3403420448303223,
+        "90": -3.2262017726898193,
+        "95": -3.174588441848755,
+        "99": -3.0872867107391357
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        2,
+        0,
+        2,
+        2,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        3,
+        2,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        0,
+        4,
+        6,
+        3,
+        4,
+        3,
+        5,
+        3,
+        5,
+        5,
+        5,
+        5,
+        11,
+        13,
+        6,
+        6,
+        12,
+        12,
+        8,
+        26,
+        19,
+        23,
+        24,
+        16,
+        8,
+        4,
+        1
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.618434429168701,
+        -6.544989585876465,
+        -6.4715447425842285,
+        -6.398099899291992,
+        -6.324655055999756,
+        -6.2512102127075195,
+        -6.177765369415283,
+        -6.104320526123047,
+        -6.030875205993652,
+        -5.957430839538574,
+        -5.88398551940918,
+        -5.810540676116943,
+        -5.737095832824707,
+        -5.663650989532471,
+        -5.590206146240234,
+        -5.516761302947998,
+        -5.443316459655762,
+        -5.369871616363525,
+        -5.296426773071289,
+        -5.222981929779053,
+        -5.149537086486816,
+        -5.07609224319458,
+        -5.002647399902344,
+        -4.929202079772949,
+        -4.855757713317871,
+        -4.782312393188477,
+        -4.708868026733398,
+        -4.635422706604004,
+        -4.561977863311768,
+        -4.488533020019531,
+        -4.415088176727295,
+        -4.341643333435059,
+        -4.268198490142822,
+        -4.194753646850586,
+        -4.12130880355835,
+        -4.047863960266113,
+        -3.974419116973877,
+        -3.9009740352630615,
+        -3.827529191970825,
+        -3.754084348678589,
+        -3.6806395053863525,
+        -3.607194662094116,
+        -3.53374981880188,
+        -3.4603049755096436,
+        -3.386859893798828,
+        -3.313415050506592,
+        -3.2399702072143555,
+        -3.166525363922119,
+        -3.093080520629883,
+        -3.0196356773376465,
+        -2.94619083404541
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19234594702720642,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.1885949969291687,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3401693105697632,
+      "pr_median": 0.3379734754562378,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6397303938865662,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6397303938865662,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.06695324182510376,
+        "5": 0.263593852519989,
+        "10": 0.42823532223701477,
+        "25": 0.7192432880401611
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.009588138200342655,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.009588138200342655,
+        "1e-07": 0.009588138200342655,
+        "1e-06": 0.009779800660908222,
+        "1e-05": 0.010010278783738613,
+        "0.0001": 0.015217375941574574
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.017233552218265464,
+        "1e-07": 0.017233552218265464,
+        "1e-06": 0.017233552218265464,
+        "1e-05": 0.017233552218265464,
+        "0.0001": 0.017233552218265464
+      }
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file