Add clean sparsity results: 168 JSONs from independent processes on GPU 1

CIFAR: 24 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds), BP s(1e-6)=98% confirmed
Synthetic: 144 JSONs (4 methods × 6 seeds × 3 alphas × 2 depths)
All data reliable — each method+seed in separate Python process.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 640 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s789.json b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s789.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..f3998e6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/clean_sparsity/cifar_bp_s789.json
@@ -0,0 +1,640 @@
+{
+  "dataset": "cifar",
+  "method": "bp",
+  "seed": 789,
+  "alpha": null,
+  "depth": 4,
+  "batch": 256,
+  "loss": 1.1959092617034912,
+  "acc": 0.6015625,
+  "per_layer": [
+    {
+      "layer": 0,
+      "mean_norm": 0.00028067140374332666,
+      "median_norm": 0.00022387152421288192,
+      "max_norm": 0.0014396437909454107,
+      "min_norm": 1.2112440117562073e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9140625,
+        "0.0001": 0.6953125
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -6.02036190032959,
+        "5": -5.359379768371582,
+        "10": -4.888999938964844,
+        "25": -4.109874725341797,
+        "50": -3.6487112045288086,
+        "75": -3.371954917907715,
+        "90": -3.190140962600708,
+        "95": -3.1323633193969727,
+        "99": -3.00270938873291
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        3,
+        1,
+        4,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        4,
+        5,
+        2,
+        7,
+        2,
+        2,
+        5,
+        2,
+        1,
+        7,
+        5,
+        9,
+        9,
+        13,
+        12,
+        10,
+        11,
+        14,
+        21,
+        18,
+        24,
+        19,
+        15,
+        11,
+        5,
+        1,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.916768550872803,
+        -6.835268020629883,
+        -6.753767490386963,
+        -6.672266960144043,
+        -6.590766906738281,
+        -6.509266376495361,
+        -6.427765846252441,
+        -6.3462653160095215,
+        -6.264764785766602,
+        -6.183264255523682,
+        -6.101763725280762,
+        -6.020263195037842,
+        -5.938762664794922,
+        -5.85726261138916,
+        -5.77576208114624,
+        -5.69426155090332,
+        -5.6127610206604,
+        -5.5312604904174805,
+        -5.4497599601745605,
+        -5.368259429931641,
+        -5.286759376525879,
+        -5.205258369445801,
+        -5.123758316040039,
+        -5.042257785797119,
+        -4.960757255554199,
+        -4.879256725311279,
+        -4.797756195068359,
+        -4.716256141662598,
+        -4.6347551345825195,
+        -4.553255081176758,
+        -4.471754550933838,
+        -4.390254020690918,
+        -4.308753490447998,
+        -4.227252960205078,
+        -4.145752429962158,
+        -4.064251899719238,
+        -3.9827516078948975,
+        -3.9012510776519775,
+        -3.8197507858276367,
+        -3.738250255584717,
+        -3.656749725341797,
+        -3.575249195098877,
+        -3.493748664855957,
+        -3.412248373031616,
+        -3.3307478427886963,
+        -3.2492473125457764,
+        -3.1677470207214355,
+        -3.0862464904785156,
+        -3.0047459602355957,
+        -2.923245429992676,
+        -2.841745138168335
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.2022503912448883,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19767150282859802,
+      "pr_mean": 0.31656718254089355,
+      "pr_median": 0.316478967666626,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6247317790985107,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6247317790985107,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07417921721935272,
+        "5": 0.27950015664100647,
+        "10": 0.44713467359542847,
+        "25": 0.7337011694908142
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.01112345140427351,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.01112345140427351,
+        "1e-07": 0.01112345140427351,
+        "1e-06": 0.011600557714700699,
+        "1e-05": 0.012413593009114265,
+        "0.0001": 0.007392453961074352
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.005966945589315746,
+        "1e-07": 0.005966945589315746,
+        "1e-06": 0.005966945589315746,
+        "1e-05": 0.005966945589315746,
+        "0.0001": 0.005966945589315746
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 1,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0002925734734162688,
+      "median_norm": 0.00023836617765482515,
+      "max_norm": 0.0012911149533465505,
+      "min_norm": 1.3068931536963646e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9140625,
+        "0.0001": 0.71484375
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -5.967471122741699,
+        "5": -5.337117671966553,
+        "10": -4.8699631690979,
+        "25": -4.074970245361328,
+        "50": -3.6214611530303955,
+        "75": -3.327561855316162,
+        "90": -3.1779749393463135,
+        "95": -3.117979049682617,
+        "99": -2.987438917160034
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        1,
+        1,
+        4,
+        0,
+        3,
+        3,
+        1,
+        5,
+        1,
+        8,
+        2,
+        3,
+        3,
+        2,
+        5,
+        3,
+        6,
+        9,
+        14,
+        10,
+        16,
+        9,
+        9,
+        14,
+        23,
+        16,
+        23,
+        19,
+        16,
+        9,
+        4,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.88375997543335,
+        -6.803865432739258,
+        -6.723970890045166,
+        -6.644076347351074,
+        -6.564181804656982,
+        -6.484287261962891,
+        -6.404393196105957,
+        -6.324498653411865,
+        -6.244604110717773,
+        -6.164709568023682,
+        -6.08481502532959,
+        -6.004920482635498,
+        -5.925025939941406,
+        -5.8451313972473145,
+        -5.765236854553223,
+        -5.685342788696289,
+        -5.605447769165039,
+        -5.5255537033081055,
+        -5.445659160614014,
+        -5.365764617919922,
+        -5.28587007522583,
+        -5.205975532531738,
+        -5.1260809898376465,
+        -5.046186447143555,
+        -4.966291904449463,
+        -4.886397361755371,
+        -4.8065032958984375,
+        -4.7266082763671875,
+        -4.646714210510254,
+        -4.566819190979004,
+        -4.48692512512207,
+        -4.4070305824279785,
+        -4.327136039733887,
+        -4.247241497039795,
+        -4.167346954345703,
+        -4.0874528884887695,
+        -4.0075578689575195,
+        -3.927663564682007,
+        -3.847769021987915,
+        -3.7678744792938232,
+        -3.6879801750183105,
+        -3.6080856323242188,
+        -3.528191089630127,
+        -3.448296546936035,
+        -3.3684020042419434,
+        -3.2885074615478516,
+        -3.208613157272339,
+        -3.128718614578247,
+        -3.0488240718841553,
+        -2.9689295291900635,
+        -2.889035224914551
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19709953665733337,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.1936415135860443,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3245930075645447,
+      "pr_median": 0.3270953595638275,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6305568814277649,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6305569410324097,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07112988829612732,
+        "5": 0.2739437222480774,
+        "10": 0.44088008999824524,
+        "25": 0.7278479933738708
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.0016345944022759795,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.0016345944022759795,
+        "1e-07": -0.0016345944022759795,
+        "1e-06": -0.0020876768976449966,
+        "1e-05": -0.0036659182514995337,
+        "0.0001": -0.00418903399258852
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.0028893697038074317,
+        "1e-07": 0.0028893697038074317,
+        "1e-06": 0.0028893697038074317,
+        "1e-05": 0.0028893697038074317,
+        "0.0001": 0.0028893697038074317
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 2,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0003066453500650823,
+      "median_norm": 0.00025122781516984105,
+      "max_norm": 0.0014200826408341527,
+      "min_norm": 1.347635958381943e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.9140625,
+        "0.0001": 0.7265625
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -5.975029468536377,
+        "5": -5.285638809204102,
+        "10": -4.848055362701416,
+        "25": -4.066932678222656,
+        "50": -3.5946204662323,
+        "75": -3.306928873062134,
+        "90": -3.183922290802002,
+        "95": -3.1095449924468994,
+        "99": -2.9618325233459473
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        2,
+        0,
+        2,
+        1,
+        3,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        2,
+        5,
+        1,
+        7,
+        3,
+        3,
+        2,
+        4,
+        4,
+        4,
+        7,
+        8,
+        18,
+        7,
+        13,
+        11,
+        11,
+        17,
+        24,
+        14,
+        21,
+        24,
+        13,
+        4,
+        4,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.87042760848999,
+        -6.78997278213501,
+        -6.709517955780029,
+        -6.629063129425049,
+        -6.548608303070068,
+        -6.468153476715088,
+        -6.387698650360107,
+        -6.307243824005127,
+        -6.2267889976501465,
+        -6.146334171295166,
+        -6.0658793449401855,
+        -5.985424518585205,
+        -5.904969692230225,
+        -5.824514865875244,
+        -5.744060039520264,
+        -5.663605213165283,
+        -5.583150386810303,
+        -5.502695560455322,
+        -5.422240734100342,
+        -5.341785907745361,
+        -5.261331081390381,
+        -5.1808762550354,
+        -5.10042142868042,
+        -5.0199666023254395,
+        -4.939511775970459,
+        -4.8590569496154785,
+        -4.778602123260498,
+        -4.698147296905518,
+        -4.617692470550537,
+        -4.537237644195557,
+        -4.456782817840576,
+        -4.376327991485596,
+        -4.295873165130615,
+        -4.215418338775635,
+        -4.134963512420654,
+        -4.054508686065674,
+        -3.9740538597106934,
+        -3.893599033355713,
+        -3.8131442070007324,
+        -3.732689380645752,
+        -3.6522345542907715,
+        -3.571779727935791,
+        -3.4913249015808105,
+        -3.41087007522583,
+        -3.3304152488708496,
+        -3.249960422515869,
+        -3.1695055961608887,
+        -3.089050769805908,
+        -3.0085959434509277,
+        -2.9281411170959473,
+        -2.847686529159546
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19689123332500458,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19023509323596954,
+      "pr_mean": 0.32564595341682434,
+      "pr_median": 0.3298186957836151,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6308340430259705,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6308339834213257,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07042770087718964,
+        "5": 0.27348217368125916,
+        "10": 0.44026315212249756,
+        "25": 0.7291648387908936
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": -0.0010653927456587553,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": -0.0010653927456587553,
+        "1e-07": -0.0010653927456587553,
+        "1e-06": -0.0012874408857896924,
+        "1e-05": -0.0005659000016748905,
+        "0.0001": -0.0010015530278906226
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.011119928425916751,
+        "1e-07": 0.011119928425916751,
+        "1e-06": 0.011119928425916751,
+        "1e-05": 0.011119928425916751,
+        "0.0001": 0.011119928425916751
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "layer": 3,
+      "mean_norm": 0.0002863233967218548,
+      "median_norm": 0.00023740093456581235,
+      "max_norm": 0.0011409452417865396,
+      "min_norm": 1.5537619901806465e-07,
+      "support": {
+        "1e-08": 1.0,
+        "1e-07": 1.0,
+        "1e-06": 0.98828125,
+        "1e-05": 0.91796875,
+        "0.0001": 0.69921875
+      },
+      "log_norms_percentiles": {
+        "1": -5.994113445281982,
+        "5": -5.303839683532715,
+        "10": -4.876305103302002,
+        "25": -4.065118789672852,
+        "50": -3.623880386352539,
+        "75": -3.3434736728668213,
+        "90": -3.2074837684631348,
+        "95": -3.1314401626586914,
+        "99": -3.0686283111572266
+      },
+      "log_norms_histogram": [
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        0,
+        0,
+        0,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        1,
+        2,
+        3,
+        0,
+        3,
+        3,
+        1,
+        2,
+        2,
+        3,
+        2,
+        4,
+        6,
+        3,
+        3,
+        1,
+        4,
+        4,
+        2,
+        5,
+        8,
+        14,
+        13,
+        10,
+        9,
+        10,
+        16,
+        15,
+        19,
+        21,
+        25,
+        17,
+        14,
+        3,
+        2
+      ],
+      "log_norms_bin_edges": [
+        -6.808615684509277,
+        -6.731297969818115,
+        -6.653980255126953,
+        -6.576663017272949,
+        -6.499345302581787,
+        -6.422027587890625,
+        -6.344709873199463,
+        -6.267392158508301,
+        -6.190074920654297,
+        -6.112757205963135,
+        -6.035439491271973,
+        -5.9581217765808105,
+        -5.880804538726807,
+        -5.8034868240356445,
+        -5.726169109344482,
+        -5.64885139465332,
+        -5.571534156799316,
+        -5.494216442108154,
+        -5.416898727416992,
+        -5.33958101272583,
+        -5.262263298034668,
+        -5.184946060180664,
+        -5.107628345489502,
+        -5.03031063079834,
+        -4.952992916107178,
+        -4.875675201416016,
+        -4.798357963562012,
+        -4.72104024887085,
+        -4.6437225341796875,
+        -4.566405296325684,
+        -4.489087104797363,
+        -4.411769866943359,
+        -4.334452152252197,
+        -4.257134437561035,
+        -4.179817199707031,
+        -4.102499008178711,
+        -4.025181770324707,
+        -3.947864055633545,
+        -3.870546579360962,
+        -3.7932288646698,
+        -3.715911388397217,
+        -3.6385936737060547,
+        -3.5612759590148926,
+        -3.4839584827423096,
+        -3.4066407680511475,
+        -3.3293232917785645,
+        -3.2520055770874023,
+        -3.1746881008148193,
+        -3.0973703861236572,
+        -3.020052671432495,
+        -2.942735195159912
+      ],
+      "r_inf_mean": 0.19599288702011108,
+      "r_inf_median": 0.19167673587799072,
+      "pr_mean": 0.3318268656730652,
+      "pr_median": 0.3340936303138733,
+      "hoyer_mean": 0.6355290412902832,
+      "eff_dim_mean": 0.6355290412902832,
+      "topk_energy": {
+        "1": 0.07027983665466309,
+        "5": 0.26859337091445923,
+        "10": 0.43431925773620605,
+        "25": 0.7242317199707031
+      },
+      "gamma_raw": 0.0001563762780278921,
+      "gamma_active": {
+        "1e-08": 0.0001563762780278921,
+        "1e-07": 0.0001563762780278921,
+        "1e-06": -5.2496026910375804e-05,
+        "1e-05": -0.00041599152609705925,
+        "0.0001": -0.0023499750532209873
+      },
+      "gamma_energy_weighted": {
+        "1e-08": 0.002154584402055451,
+        "1e-07": 0.002154584402055451,
+        "1e-06": 0.002154584402055451,
+        "1e-05": 0.002154584402055451,
+        "0.0001": 0.002154584402055451
+      }
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file