Add P3 protocol panel: method ranking across 5 protocol slices

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

1 files changed, 20 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/results/confirmatory/P3_protocol_panel.csv b/results/confirmatory/P3_protocol_panel.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..4714553
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/P3_protocol_panel.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+slice,method,Gamma,rho,acc,rank_Gamma,rank_rho,rank_acc

+synth_a1.0_L4,bp,0.810±0.023,1.000±0.000,0.792±0.009,1,,

+synth_a1.0_L4,dfa,0.045±0.009,0.050±0.006,0.686±0.011,4,,

+synth_a1.0_L4,state_bridge,0.323±0.008,0.311±0.011,0.653±0.009,3,,

+synth_a1.0_L4,credit_bridge,0.549±0.037,0.563±0.022,0.480±0.023,2,,

+synth_a0.0_L4,bp,0.782±0.022,1.000±0.000,0.940±0.003,1,,

+synth_a0.0_L4,dfa,0.111±0.037,0.120±0.029,0.866±0.010,4,,

+synth_a0.0_L4,state_bridge,0.400±0.022,0.354±0.040,0.785±0.021,2,,

+synth_a0.0_L4,credit_bridge,0.115±0.020,0.235±0.046,0.679±0.018,3,,

+cifar_online,bp,1.000±0.000,0.998±0.000,0.614±0.003,1,,

+cifar_online,dfa,0.102±0.008,-0.001±0.006,0.305±0.009,4,,

+cifar_online,state_bridge,0.158±0.069,0.083±0.053,0.224±0.035,3,,

+cifar_online,credit_bridge,0.193±0.021,0.006±0.007,0.287±0.009,2,,

+cifar_frozen,dfa,0.003±0.006,-0.006±0.012,N/A,3,,

+cifar_frozen,scalar_cb,0.125±0.012,0.159±0.030,N/A,2,,

+cifar_frozen,vec_eT_M4,0.376±0.005,0.398±0.015,N/A,1,,

+cifar_bp_support,bp,s(1e-6)=0.987,norm=2.9e-04,r_inf=0.198,1,,

+cifar_bp_support,dfa,s(1e-6)=0.004,norm=7.3e-08,r_inf=0.481,4,,

+cifar_bp_support,state_bridge,s(1e-6)=0.213,norm=2.6e-06,r_inf=0.294,2,,

+cifar_bp_support,credit_bridge,s(1e-6)=0.032,norm=1.4e-07,r_inf=0.356,3,,