summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/results
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
authorYurenHao0426 <Blackhao0426@gmail.com>2026-03-30 19:25:53 -0500
committerYurenHao0426 <Blackhao0426@gmail.com>2026-03-30 19:25:53 -0500
commit8b21fb32bf0997e3f4266c1c22414e49f1fdcfcc (patch)
tree54e3c678c8d45330c6085b02a27de82cc884e17d /results
parent2a230acd5ee3fa6605892d524badf281ba7e9cfd (diff)
Add confirmatory paper experiments: A1-A4, all 10 seeds complete
A1: Synthetic nonlinearity ladder (240 rows: 3 alpha × 2 depth × 4 methods × 10 seeds) A2: CIFAR state-vs-credit counterexample (30 rows: 3 methods × 10 seeds) A3: Frozen vs online dissociation (60 rows: 2 regimes × 3 methods × 10 seeds) A4: Protocol dependence panel (82 rows: assembled from existing results) All experiments ran on GPU 3. Total runtime: ~20 hours. CSVs in results/confirmatory/. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Diffstat (limited to 'results')
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.csv241
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.json2402
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.csv31
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.json242
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.csv61
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.json542
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.csv83
-rw-r--r--results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.json494
8 files changed, 4096 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.csv b/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..1b00d87
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,241 @@
+alpha,depth,method,seed,StateErr,Gamma,rho,acc
+0.0,4,bp,42,nan,0.7976504862308502,0.9999783337116241,0.94
+0.0,4,dfa,42,nan,0.11274427606258541,0.10713508073240519,0.8635
+0.0,4,state_bridge,42,0.0042416151915676895,0.39959777891635895,0.3636437617242336,0.7995
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.1352396421134472,0.29881402105093,0.7005
+0.0,4,bp,123,nan,0.7471440732479095,0.9999679923057556,0.937
+0.0,4,dfa,123,nan,0.13869959628209472,0.13979829289019108,0.861
+0.0,4,state_bridge,123,0.0025703998249955477,0.41838232427835464,0.36436110362410545,0.7955
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.08274209871888161,0.17103387042880058,0.6365
+0.0,4,bp,456,nan,0.7569544464349747,0.9999799728393555,0.9395
+0.0,4,dfa,456,nan,0.061981291277334094,0.10030700685456395,0.8725
+0.0,4,state_bridge,456,0.007971026756800711,0.3831471260637045,0.3577818237245083,0.793
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.14599335379898548,0.263176042586565,0.671
+0.0,4,bp,789,nan,0.7442700117826462,0.999980166554451,0.94
+0.0,4,dfa,789,nan,0.15985053591430187,0.16940528759732842,0.852
+0.0,4,state_bridge,789,0.008546572399325669,0.445812588557601,0.44155239313840866,0.8275
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.11118674091994762,0.2533306097611785,0.683
+0.0,4,bp,1024,nan,0.7894147336483002,0.9999719113111496,0.943
+0.0,4,dfa,1024,nan,0.13776074955239892,0.16881290404126048,0.883
+0.0,4,state_bridge,1024,0.003235291603486985,0.38014374673366547,0.2906125131994486,0.7695
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.10474677011370659,0.20625970140099525,0.6845
+0.0,4,bp,2048,nan,0.7971414774656296,0.9999726265668869,0.945
+0.0,4,dfa,2048,nan,0.12636534194462,0.11639838851988316,0.87
+0.0,4,state_bridge,2048,0.004507227457128465,0.4033546820282936,0.35091163218021393,0.768
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.11602311581373215,0.2716793781146407,0.682
+0.0,4,bp,3000,nan,0.799256831407547,0.9999824911355972,0.9405
+0.0,4,dfa,3000,nan,0.05687434319406748,0.07215175591409206,0.8825
+0.0,4,state_bridge,3000,0.004735227110795676,0.3631715625524521,0.2957744346931577,0.757
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.13282869290560484,0.2609284440986812,0.67
+0.0,4,bp,4000,nan,0.8004499226808548,0.999976709485054,0.94
+0.0,4,dfa,4000,nan,0.1496470280108042,0.11480268160812557,0.853
+0.0,4,state_bridge,4000,0.002814154534600675,0.3866612948477268,0.33644784428179264,0.781
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.08764260355383158,0.14309521671384573,0.704
+0.0,4,bp,5000,nan,0.7971527725458145,0.999970406293869,0.9345
+0.0,4,dfa,5000,nan,0.10718152392655611,0.10537220258265734,0.8605
+0.0,4,state_bridge,5000,0.0008024044685298576,0.4057263322174549,0.3554464727640152,0.8015
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.12732978258281946,0.25282857567071915,0.682
+0.0,4,bp,6000,nan,0.7925817668437958,0.9999643862247467,0.94
+0.0,4,dfa,6000,nan,0.05762777535710484,0.10805956274271011,0.865
+0.0,4,state_bridge,6000,0.0011924138587201013,0.41266462951898575,0.3788386173546314,0.758
+0.0,4,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.10305883921682835,0.22495971526950598,0.6755
+0.0,8,bp,42,nan,0.8518797755241394,0.999953955411911,0.9225
+0.0,8,dfa,42,nan,0.06414316734299064,0.09805193985812366,0.846
+0.0,8,state_bridge,42,0.014238399018533528,0.2220264421775937,0.19422245677560568,0.7575
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.11673698376398534,0.20357689913362265,0.6165
+0.0,8,bp,123,nan,0.8461447432637215,0.9999523237347603,0.92
+0.0,8,dfa,123,nan,0.08495552814565599,0.09764496935531497,0.859
+0.0,8,state_bridge,123,0.008134014961775392,0.20587642956525087,0.19290778459981084,0.774
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.0771957344841212,0.18929401598870754,0.675
+0.0,8,bp,456,nan,0.8679735064506531,0.9999424889683723,0.9095
+0.0,8,dfa,456,nan,0.10550220380537212,0.11999525976716541,0.846
+0.0,8,state_bridge,456,0.01331474657356739,0.23938010726124048,0.21203574631363153,0.759
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.06404305621981621,0.13004278298467398,0.6555
+0.0,8,bp,789,nan,0.8145705312490463,0.9999416694045067,0.9135
+0.0,8,dfa,789,nan,0.07243995321914554,0.09743102500215173,0.8415
+0.0,8,state_bridge,789,0.004964958165772259,0.25941951386630535,0.22139000706374645,0.7625
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.0831079410854727,0.15918657230213284,0.6245
+0.0,8,bp,1024,nan,0.8478909432888031,0.9999396428465843,0.92
+0.0,8,dfa,1024,nan,0.06737133057322353,0.08042471471708268,0.8615
+0.0,8,state_bridge,1024,0.006657648294698447,0.2543684197589755,0.2292898604646325,0.7645
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.08684566424926743,0.1955197062343359,0.6315
+0.0,8,bp,2048,nan,0.8799556866288185,0.9999411776661873,0.9135
+0.0,8,dfa,2048,nan,0.049802992260083556,0.09564788592979312,0.862
+0.0,8,state_bridge,2048,0.005097676486708224,0.26504675671458244,0.2259912956506014,0.7915
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.10936234518885612,0.16827034018933773,0.6145
+0.0,8,bp,3000,nan,0.8378414362668991,0.9999293759465218,0.9255
+0.0,8,dfa,3000,nan,0.11397410440258682,0.1381535604596138,0.847
+0.0,8,state_bridge,3000,0.014880129693076014,0.2201737705618143,0.19643162470310926,0.7825
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.08571063168346882,0.13454539375379682,0.6535
+0.0,8,bp,4000,nan,0.8487726971507072,0.9999396353960037,0.923
+0.0,8,dfa,4000,nan,0.05830177618190646,0.09378852555528283,0.8485
+0.0,8,state_bridge,4000,0.022656571633182465,0.23578881658613682,0.21631191670894623,0.7165
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.07291368849109858,0.1467280697543174,0.623
+0.0,8,bp,5000,nan,0.8527729287743568,0.9999343007802963,0.912
+0.0,8,dfa,5000,nan,0.0880711309146136,0.07768160989508033,0.8435
+0.0,8,state_bridge,5000,0.001290266184194479,0.26903260312974453,0.21923481859266758,0.706
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.08217159216292202,0.15023266337811947,0.6875
+0.0,8,bp,6000,nan,0.8804621174931526,0.9999351277947426,0.9185
+0.0,8,dfa,6000,nan,0.06979017774574459,0.08295673737302423,0.836
+0.0,8,state_bridge,6000,0.003901493979152292,0.2838806174695492,0.23159940354526043,0.7935
+0.0,8,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.1168073476292193,0.21190964989364147,0.6195
+0.5,4,bp,42,nan,0.778934895992279,0.9999890029430389,0.8875
+0.5,4,dfa,42,nan,0.0771798980422318,0.07931134616956115,0.822
+0.5,4,state_bridge,42,0.014639395724982024,0.3877125680446625,0.4016897827386856,0.777
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.18997271731495857,0.37320059537887573,0.653
+0.5,4,bp,123,nan,0.7060435861349106,0.9999908953905106,0.8855
+0.5,4,dfa,123,nan,0.1366678001359105,0.14800320356152952,0.8155
+0.5,4,state_bridge,123,0.00966854555811733,0.3970109149813652,0.34398024156689644,0.7615
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.1873281691223383,0.25071992352604866,0.656
+0.5,4,bp,456,nan,0.712785392999649,0.9999827593564987,0.8955
+0.5,4,dfa,456,nan,0.06838363222777843,0.06962036329787225,0.839
+0.5,4,state_bridge,456,0.008301737054251135,0.3867475911974907,0.36412956193089485,0.76
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.20988117344677448,0.33718378841876984,0.615
+0.5,4,bp,789,nan,0.7440494745969772,0.99999038875103,0.89
+0.5,4,dfa,789,nan,0.08207487314939499,0.12179941032081842,0.8245
+0.5,4,state_bridge,789,0.0079743139334023,0.4024505019187927,0.36630794778466225,0.747
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.1982774008065462,0.3794977590441704,0.68
+0.5,4,bp,1024,nan,0.7264262437820435,0.9999918192625046,0.905
+0.5,4,dfa,1024,nan,0.0874363575130701,0.12305337563157082,0.848
+0.5,4,state_bridge,1024,0.0007635582342045382,0.36391081660985947,0.2906326614320278,0.738
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.17063568718731403,0.2797263041138649,0.687
+0.5,4,bp,2048,nan,0.7792519479990005,0.9999875724315643,0.8935
+0.5,4,dfa,2048,nan,0.08299929136410356,0.07884005922824144,0.819
+0.5,4,state_bridge,2048,0.0069182014418765906,0.4167069047689438,0.38259734585881233,0.785
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.19401324167847633,0.35267358273267746,0.64
+0.5,4,bp,3000,nan,0.7533685863018036,0.9999895542860031,0.8935
+0.5,4,dfa,3000,nan,0.06140868738293648,0.0712057501077652,0.8265
+0.5,4,state_bridge,3000,0.005231155015993864,0.41574693098664284,0.35996725410223007,0.768
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.19257186725735664,0.3234494589269161,0.658
+0.5,4,bp,4000,nan,0.7910260111093521,0.9999895095825195,0.894
+0.5,4,dfa,4000,nan,0.09473285032436252,0.14322808384895325,0.8505
+0.5,4,state_bridge,4000,0.010673340854234993,0.38491013273596764,0.3446698300540447,0.7965
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.1998334638774395,0.3253607787191868,0.6195
+0.5,4,bp,5000,nan,0.7515025287866592,0.9999890476465225,0.885
+0.5,4,dfa,5000,nan,0.08981088036671281,0.10898786783218384,0.8325
+0.5,4,state_bridge,5000,0.008934525582939386,0.4031970761716366,0.35525544732809067,0.764
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.18700676038861275,0.3295666575431824,0.6465
+0.5,4,bp,6000,nan,0.7618523091077805,0.9999861419200897,0.883
+0.5,4,dfa,6000,nan,0.06073849997483194,0.10279720090329647,0.8225
+0.5,4,state_bridge,6000,0.0113879487933591,0.4088409934192896,0.35849119909107685,0.7885
+0.5,4,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.18101266399025917,0.2402007132768631,0.626
+0.5,8,bp,42,nan,0.7800825014710426,0.9999619349837303,0.874
+0.5,8,dfa,42,nan,0.0680798904504627,0.07815029704943299,0.8105
+0.5,8,state_bridge,42,0.013940593439154327,0.22329587768763304,0.18133462546393275,0.775
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.16422098223119974,0.2585284411907196,0.5765
+0.5,8,bp,123,nan,0.741077221930027,0.9999566599726677,0.8835
+0.5,8,dfa,123,nan,0.06835221056826413,0.07870115921832621,0.826
+0.5,8,state_bridge,123,0.01196373869618401,0.2609132928773761,0.22901193983852863,0.732
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.1594983646646142,0.28827742394059896,0.631
+0.5,8,bp,456,nan,0.8024904653429985,0.9999617040157318,0.8605
+0.5,8,dfa,456,nan,0.09767440240830183,0.10227222001412883,0.804
+0.5,8,state_bridge,456,0.007250209745950997,0.308225903660059,0.26882948353886604,0.746
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.17834078380838037,0.28439006581902504,0.607
+0.5,8,bp,789,nan,0.7425128743052483,0.9999456480145454,0.862
+0.5,8,dfa,789,nan,0.07170737814158201,0.10886842722538859,0.795
+0.5,8,state_bridge,789,0.010051667786203325,0.22407432738691568,0.19511110894382,0.755
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.15873884549364448,0.2204220425337553,0.6015
+0.5,8,bp,1024,nan,0.802269235253334,0.9999621286988258,0.889
+0.5,8,dfa,1024,nan,0.07059638481587172,0.09517476172186434,0.844
+0.5,8,state_bridge,1024,0.015034918455407024,0.26445331890136003,0.2382330046966672,0.754
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.14965758845210075,0.22262850403785706,0.5705
+0.5,8,bp,2048,nan,0.7915605679154396,0.9999616295099258,0.876
+0.5,8,dfa,2048,nan,0.054607931757345796,0.0988450946751982,0.831
+0.5,8,state_bridge,2048,0.011838351630140097,0.25473486352711916,0.22712249495089054,0.774
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.18231265805661678,0.23427345044910908,0.623
+0.5,8,bp,3000,nan,0.7524143233895302,0.9999579712748528,0.878
+0.5,8,dfa,3000,nan,0.12144442298449576,0.1239226256730035,0.812
+0.5,8,state_bridge,3000,0.01295656328741461,0.2410168293863535,0.21426095999777317,0.7855
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.13227692258078605,0.1761333434842527,0.5945
+0.5,8,bp,4000,nan,0.7426219433546066,0.9999610707163811,0.867
+0.5,8,dfa,4000,nan,0.061901216860860586,0.09875185182318091,0.8075
+0.5,8,state_bridge,4000,0.0033825204903259872,0.277063325047493,0.2407076209783554,0.7165
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.1314755715429783,0.2386790281161666,0.61
+0.5,8,bp,5000,nan,0.7783375456929207,0.9999541118741035,0.867
+0.5,8,dfa,5000,nan,0.07623820775188506,0.07604160532355309,0.8255
+0.5,8,state_bridge,5000,0.017978039579465987,0.24194164481014013,0.20475764898583293,0.736
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.1662514479830861,0.24278739467263222,0.6285
+0.5,8,bp,6000,nan,0.8337910175323486,0.999962106347084,0.8735
+0.5,8,dfa,6000,nan,0.07081685795856174,0.07124830968677998,0.794
+0.5,8,state_bridge,6000,0.008247435386758298,0.2887079808861017,0.28017569333314896,0.737
+0.5,8,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.1532246011774987,0.24239609204232693,0.546
+1.0,4,bp,42,nan,0.837363988161087,0.9999942779541016,0.796
+1.0,4,dfa,42,nan,0.05314898584038019,0.04739766335114837,0.6945
+1.0,4,state_bridge,42,0.05111445432715118,0.3092905580997467,0.2985522858798504,0.654
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.5798117071390152,0.5770738422870636,0.455
+1.0,4,bp,123,nan,0.7834264636039734,0.9999949932098389,0.7945
+1.0,4,dfa,123,nan,0.03143235971219838,0.04966995166614652,0.6755
+1.0,4,state_bridge,123,0.039300061028450725,0.32962899655103683,0.3271522969007492,0.653
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.5211702585220337,0.5396891608834267,0.4955
+1.0,4,bp,456,nan,0.7738194167613983,0.9999952465295792,0.802
+1.0,4,dfa,456,nan,0.03672327077947557,0.03823344281408936,0.687
+1.0,4,state_bridge,456,0.041286803239956496,0.3122059181332588,0.3080013431608677,0.6535
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.5516191199421883,0.5655025988817215,0.4575
+1.0,4,bp,789,nan,0.8138538002967834,0.9999965578317642,0.7785
+1.0,4,dfa,789,nan,0.044787557795643806,0.050711866933852434,0.6645
+1.0,4,state_bridge,789,0.047810701571404934,0.321536161005497,0.294049471616745,0.6505
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.498397096991539,0.5393850430846214,0.4785
+1.0,4,bp,1024,nan,0.8156489282846451,0.9999967068433762,0.796
+1.0,4,dfa,1024,nan,0.05224289372563362,0.051481935661286116,0.7
+1.0,4,state_bridge,1024,0.03910857268422842,0.32806089147925377,0.3095804899930954,0.659
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.4827726259827614,0.5368957445025444,0.5295
+1.0,4,bp,2048,nan,0.8019291013479233,0.999995157122612,0.789
+1.0,4,dfa,2048,nan,0.04420588002540171,0.054026867961511016,0.693
+1.0,4,state_bridge,2048,0.04625624809600413,0.31831347569823265,0.30145254731178284,0.6415
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.6112141609191895,0.6130285188555717,0.49
+1.0,4,bp,3000,nan,0.8269992768764496,0.9999961256980896,0.8055
+1.0,4,dfa,3000,nan,0.031051788479089737,0.04200031189247966,0.68
+1.0,4,state_bridge,3000,0.03373044667486101,0.33542975783348083,0.3166932016611099,0.6695
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.5547316148877144,0.574584349989891,0.4775
+1.0,4,bp,4000,nan,0.8469432443380356,0.9999967068433762,0.7985
+1.0,4,dfa,4000,nan,0.05680405022576451,0.058447605930268764,0.6885
+1.0,4,state_bridge,4000,0.05037181778624654,0.31409140303730965,0.3157280907034874,0.661
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.5717481672763824,0.5648023337125778,0.4815
+1.0,4,bp,5000,nan,0.7843969911336899,0.9999955743551254,0.7815
+1.0,4,dfa,5000,nan,0.05237697158008814,0.05225806776434183,0.696
+1.0,4,state_bridge,5000,0.020391553843859583,0.3294149599969387,0.32860465347766876,0.6545
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.5680579468607903,0.5536182671785355,0.4935
+1.0,4,bp,6000,nan,0.8201684504747391,0.9999956488609314,0.777
+1.0,4,dfa,6000,nan,0.043721775291487575,0.053218568209558725,0.6775
+1.0,4,state_bridge,6000,0.03792587007582188,0.3274501822888851,0.3072219528257847,0.6375
+1.0,4,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.5522571504116058,0.566972091794014,0.4445
+1.0,8,bp,42,nan,0.7569558992981911,0.9999850168824196,0.7715
+1.0,8,dfa,42,nan,0.04026596760377288,0.0463115515303798,0.6555
+1.0,8,state_bridge,42,0.024733127796091138,0.21983085572719574,0.21069114468991756,0.636
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,42,nan,0.42342473939061165,0.46175311505794525,0.501
+1.0,8,bp,123,nan,0.7589660733938217,0.9999836310744286,0.775
+1.0,8,dfa,123,nan,0.052690219948999584,0.04398861777735874,0.6655
+1.0,8,state_bridge,123,0.00904931088979356,0.23909619636833668,0.21755888871848583,0.6665
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,123,nan,0.4901758562773466,0.5194796472787857,0.499
+1.0,8,bp,456,nan,0.8152446746826172,0.9999835714697838,0.7615
+1.0,8,dfa,456,nan,0.06644452596083283,0.07211897929664701,0.6595
+1.0,8,state_bridge,456,0.027026508945971726,0.17726875049993396,0.14926194958388805,0.634
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,456,nan,0.4374451842159033,0.469217861071229,0.471
+1.0,8,bp,789,nan,0.7641392648220062,0.9999837800860405,0.77
+1.0,8,dfa,789,nan,0.06174341728910804,0.08079314092174172,0.663
+1.0,8,state_bridge,789,0.005507162362337112,0.27462095208466053,0.25958841666579247,0.6305
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,789,nan,0.4231471223756671,0.49050698801875114,0.5545
+1.0,8,bp,1024,nan,0.8173553571105003,0.9999844655394554,0.7665
+1.0,8,dfa,1024,nan,0.05211032921215519,0.04730354994535446,0.657
+1.0,8,state_bridge,1024,0.03733631442394108,0.24442856572568417,0.2330861296504736,0.651
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,1024,nan,0.43784002028405666,0.45684560760855675,0.4465
+1.0,8,bp,2048,nan,0.7980030849575996,0.9999835342168808,0.778
+1.0,8,dfa,2048,nan,0.03056039405055344,0.019816300831735134,0.6515
+1.0,8,state_bridge,2048,0.019828419615048914,0.21816869638860226,0.2006466817110777,0.639
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,2048,nan,0.44690870121121407,0.49068378657102585,0.491
+1.0,8,bp,3000,nan,0.8051622360944748,0.9999843910336494,0.774
+1.0,8,dfa,3000,nan,0.039206627872772515,0.04525771760381758,0.666
+1.0,8,state_bridge,3000,0.0073138324548490345,0.23834207840263844,0.22312144935131073,0.6255
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,3000,nan,0.48071201518177986,0.4987096134573221,0.494
+1.0,8,bp,4000,nan,0.7561301067471504,0.9999867826700211,0.7555
+1.0,8,dfa,4000,nan,0.046561805153032765,0.04669333342462778,0.651
+1.0,8,state_bridge,4000,0.021662812023889273,0.24263181537389755,0.23203729651868343,0.625
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,4000,nan,0.5189926661550999,0.5291757248342037,0.4825
+1.0,8,bp,5000,nan,0.8032103478908539,0.9999829307198524,0.769
+1.0,8,dfa,5000,nan,0.04911017371341586,0.044786704413127154,0.6785
+1.0,8,state_bridge,5000,0.0282969608604908,0.2040038648992777,0.2028592685237527,0.6355
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,5000,nan,0.4662684202194214,0.48669758066534996,0.5155
+1.0,8,bp,6000,nan,0.8568788692355156,0.9999835342168808,0.759
+1.0,8,dfa,6000,nan,0.047016877244459465,0.04356467560864985,0.6415
+1.0,8,state_bridge,6000,0.011806304380530491,0.23779606446623802,0.22786595951765776,0.637
+1.0,8,credit_bridge,6000,nan,0.45259521529078484,0.4737100824713707,0.4825
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.json b/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..8556809
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A1_synth_ladder.json
@@ -0,0 +1,2402 @@
+[
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7976504862308502,
+ "rho": 0.9999783337116241,
+ "acc": 0.94
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11274427606258541,
+ "rho": 0.10713508073240519,
+ "acc": 0.8635
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.0042416151915676895,
+ "Gamma": 0.39959777891635895,
+ "rho": 0.3636437617242336,
+ "acc": 0.7995
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1352396421134472,
+ "rho": 0.29881402105093,
+ "acc": 0.7005
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7471440732479095,
+ "rho": 0.9999679923057556,
+ "acc": 0.937
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.13869959628209472,
+ "rho": 0.13979829289019108,
+ "acc": 0.861
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.0025703998249955477,
+ "Gamma": 0.41838232427835464,
+ "rho": 0.36436110362410545,
+ "acc": 0.7955
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08274209871888161,
+ "rho": 0.17103387042880058,
+ "acc": 0.6365
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7569544464349747,
+ "rho": 0.9999799728393555,
+ "acc": 0.9395
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.061981291277334094,
+ "rho": 0.10030700685456395,
+ "acc": 0.8725
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.007971026756800711,
+ "Gamma": 0.3831471260637045,
+ "rho": 0.3577818237245083,
+ "acc": 0.793
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.14599335379898548,
+ "rho": 0.263176042586565,
+ "acc": 0.671
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7442700117826462,
+ "rho": 0.999980166554451,
+ "acc": 0.94
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.15985053591430187,
+ "rho": 0.16940528759732842,
+ "acc": 0.852
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.008546572399325669,
+ "Gamma": 0.445812588557601,
+ "rho": 0.44155239313840866,
+ "acc": 0.8275
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11118674091994762,
+ "rho": 0.2533306097611785,
+ "acc": 0.683
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7894147336483002,
+ "rho": 0.9999719113111496,
+ "acc": 0.943
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.13776074955239892,
+ "rho": 0.16881290404126048,
+ "acc": 0.883
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.003235291603486985,
+ "Gamma": 0.38014374673366547,
+ "rho": 0.2906125131994486,
+ "acc": 0.7695
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10474677011370659,
+ "rho": 0.20625970140099525,
+ "acc": 0.6845
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7971414774656296,
+ "rho": 0.9999726265668869,
+ "acc": 0.945
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.12636534194462,
+ "rho": 0.11639838851988316,
+ "acc": 0.87
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.004507227457128465,
+ "Gamma": 0.4033546820282936,
+ "rho": 0.35091163218021393,
+ "acc": 0.768
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11602311581373215,
+ "rho": 0.2716793781146407,
+ "acc": 0.682
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.799256831407547,
+ "rho": 0.9999824911355972,
+ "acc": 0.9405
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05687434319406748,
+ "rho": 0.07215175591409206,
+ "acc": 0.8825
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.004735227110795676,
+ "Gamma": 0.3631715625524521,
+ "rho": 0.2957744346931577,
+ "acc": 0.757
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.13282869290560484,
+ "rho": 0.2609284440986812,
+ "acc": 0.67
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8004499226808548,
+ "rho": 0.999976709485054,
+ "acc": 0.94
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1496470280108042,
+ "rho": 0.11480268160812557,
+ "acc": 0.853
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.002814154534600675,
+ "Gamma": 0.3866612948477268,
+ "rho": 0.33644784428179264,
+ "acc": 0.781
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08764260355383158,
+ "rho": 0.14309521671384573,
+ "acc": 0.704
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7971527725458145,
+ "rho": 0.999970406293869,
+ "acc": 0.9345
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10718152392655611,
+ "rho": 0.10537220258265734,
+ "acc": 0.8605
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0008024044685298576,
+ "Gamma": 0.4057263322174549,
+ "rho": 0.3554464727640152,
+ "acc": 0.8015
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.12732978258281946,
+ "rho": 0.25282857567071915,
+ "acc": 0.682
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7925817668437958,
+ "rho": 0.9999643862247467,
+ "acc": 0.94
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05762777535710484,
+ "rho": 0.10805956274271011,
+ "acc": 0.865
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0011924138587201013,
+ "Gamma": 0.41266462951898575,
+ "rho": 0.3788386173546314,
+ "acc": 0.758
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10305883921682835,
+ "rho": 0.22495971526950598,
+ "acc": 0.6755
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8518797755241394,
+ "rho": 0.999953955411911,
+ "acc": 0.9225
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06414316734299064,
+ "rho": 0.09805193985812366,
+ "acc": 0.846
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.014238399018533528,
+ "Gamma": 0.2220264421775937,
+ "rho": 0.19422245677560568,
+ "acc": 0.7575
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11673698376398534,
+ "rho": 0.20357689913362265,
+ "acc": 0.6165
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8461447432637215,
+ "rho": 0.9999523237347603,
+ "acc": 0.92
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08495552814565599,
+ "rho": 0.09764496935531497,
+ "acc": 0.859
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.008134014961775392,
+ "Gamma": 0.20587642956525087,
+ "rho": 0.19290778459981084,
+ "acc": 0.774
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0771957344841212,
+ "rho": 0.18929401598870754,
+ "acc": 0.675
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8679735064506531,
+ "rho": 0.9999424889683723,
+ "acc": 0.9095
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10550220380537212,
+ "rho": 0.11999525976716541,
+ "acc": 0.846
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.01331474657356739,
+ "Gamma": 0.23938010726124048,
+ "rho": 0.21203574631363153,
+ "acc": 0.759
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06404305621981621,
+ "rho": 0.13004278298467398,
+ "acc": 0.6555
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8145705312490463,
+ "rho": 0.9999416694045067,
+ "acc": 0.9135
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07243995321914554,
+ "rho": 0.09743102500215173,
+ "acc": 0.8415
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.004964958165772259,
+ "Gamma": 0.25941951386630535,
+ "rho": 0.22139000706374645,
+ "acc": 0.7625
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0831079410854727,
+ "rho": 0.15918657230213284,
+ "acc": 0.6245
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8478909432888031,
+ "rho": 0.9999396428465843,
+ "acc": 0.92
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06737133057322353,
+ "rho": 0.08042471471708268,
+ "acc": 0.8615
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.006657648294698447,
+ "Gamma": 0.2543684197589755,
+ "rho": 0.2292898604646325,
+ "acc": 0.7645
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08684566424926743,
+ "rho": 0.1955197062343359,
+ "acc": 0.6315
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8799556866288185,
+ "rho": 0.9999411776661873,
+ "acc": 0.9135
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.049802992260083556,
+ "rho": 0.09564788592979312,
+ "acc": 0.862
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.005097676486708224,
+ "Gamma": 0.26504675671458244,
+ "rho": 0.2259912956506014,
+ "acc": 0.7915
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10936234518885612,
+ "rho": 0.16827034018933773,
+ "acc": 0.6145
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8378414362668991,
+ "rho": 0.9999293759465218,
+ "acc": 0.9255
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11397410440258682,
+ "rho": 0.1381535604596138,
+ "acc": 0.847
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.014880129693076014,
+ "Gamma": 0.2201737705618143,
+ "rho": 0.19643162470310926,
+ "acc": 0.7825
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08571063168346882,
+ "rho": 0.13454539375379682,
+ "acc": 0.6535
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8487726971507072,
+ "rho": 0.9999396353960037,
+ "acc": 0.923
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05830177618190646,
+ "rho": 0.09378852555528283,
+ "acc": 0.8485
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.022656571633182465,
+ "Gamma": 0.23578881658613682,
+ "rho": 0.21631191670894623,
+ "acc": 0.7165
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07291368849109858,
+ "rho": 0.1467280697543174,
+ "acc": 0.623
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8527729287743568,
+ "rho": 0.9999343007802963,
+ "acc": 0.912
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0880711309146136,
+ "rho": 0.07768160989508033,
+ "acc": 0.8435
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.001290266184194479,
+ "Gamma": 0.26903260312974453,
+ "rho": 0.21923481859266758,
+ "acc": 0.706
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08217159216292202,
+ "rho": 0.15023266337811947,
+ "acc": 0.6875
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8804621174931526,
+ "rho": 0.9999351277947426,
+ "acc": 0.9185
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06979017774574459,
+ "rho": 0.08295673737302423,
+ "acc": 0.836
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.003901493979152292,
+ "Gamma": 0.2838806174695492,
+ "rho": 0.23159940354526043,
+ "acc": 0.7935
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1168073476292193,
+ "rho": 0.21190964989364147,
+ "acc": 0.6195
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.778934895992279,
+ "rho": 0.9999890029430389,
+ "acc": 0.8875
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0771798980422318,
+ "rho": 0.07931134616956115,
+ "acc": 0.822
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.014639395724982024,
+ "Gamma": 0.3877125680446625,
+ "rho": 0.4016897827386856,
+ "acc": 0.777
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.18997271731495857,
+ "rho": 0.37320059537887573,
+ "acc": 0.653
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7060435861349106,
+ "rho": 0.9999908953905106,
+ "acc": 0.8855
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1366678001359105,
+ "rho": 0.14800320356152952,
+ "acc": 0.8155
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.00966854555811733,
+ "Gamma": 0.3970109149813652,
+ "rho": 0.34398024156689644,
+ "acc": 0.7615
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1873281691223383,
+ "rho": 0.25071992352604866,
+ "acc": 0.656
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.712785392999649,
+ "rho": 0.9999827593564987,
+ "acc": 0.8955
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06838363222777843,
+ "rho": 0.06962036329787225,
+ "acc": 0.839
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.008301737054251135,
+ "Gamma": 0.3867475911974907,
+ "rho": 0.36412956193089485,
+ "acc": 0.76
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.20988117344677448,
+ "rho": 0.33718378841876984,
+ "acc": 0.615
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7440494745969772,
+ "rho": 0.99999038875103,
+ "acc": 0.89
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08207487314939499,
+ "rho": 0.12179941032081842,
+ "acc": 0.8245
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.0079743139334023,
+ "Gamma": 0.4024505019187927,
+ "rho": 0.36630794778466225,
+ "acc": 0.747
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1982774008065462,
+ "rho": 0.3794977590441704,
+ "acc": 0.68
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7264262437820435,
+ "rho": 0.9999918192625046,
+ "acc": 0.905
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0874363575130701,
+ "rho": 0.12305337563157082,
+ "acc": 0.848
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.0007635582342045382,
+ "Gamma": 0.36391081660985947,
+ "rho": 0.2906326614320278,
+ "acc": 0.738
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.17063568718731403,
+ "rho": 0.2797263041138649,
+ "acc": 0.687
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7792519479990005,
+ "rho": 0.9999875724315643,
+ "acc": 0.8935
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08299929136410356,
+ "rho": 0.07884005922824144,
+ "acc": 0.819
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.0069182014418765906,
+ "Gamma": 0.4167069047689438,
+ "rho": 0.38259734585881233,
+ "acc": 0.785
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.19401324167847633,
+ "rho": 0.35267358273267746,
+ "acc": 0.64
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7533685863018036,
+ "rho": 0.9999895542860031,
+ "acc": 0.8935
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06140868738293648,
+ "rho": 0.0712057501077652,
+ "acc": 0.8265
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.005231155015993864,
+ "Gamma": 0.41574693098664284,
+ "rho": 0.35996725410223007,
+ "acc": 0.768
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.19257186725735664,
+ "rho": 0.3234494589269161,
+ "acc": 0.658
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7910260111093521,
+ "rho": 0.9999895095825195,
+ "acc": 0.894
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09473285032436252,
+ "rho": 0.14322808384895325,
+ "acc": 0.8505
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.010673340854234993,
+ "Gamma": 0.38491013273596764,
+ "rho": 0.3446698300540447,
+ "acc": 0.7965
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1998334638774395,
+ "rho": 0.3253607787191868,
+ "acc": 0.6195
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7515025287866592,
+ "rho": 0.9999890476465225,
+ "acc": 0.885
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.08981088036671281,
+ "rho": 0.10898786783218384,
+ "acc": 0.8325
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.008934525582939386,
+ "Gamma": 0.4031970761716366,
+ "rho": 0.35525544732809067,
+ "acc": 0.764
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.18700676038861275,
+ "rho": 0.3295666575431824,
+ "acc": 0.6465
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7618523091077805,
+ "rho": 0.9999861419200897,
+ "acc": 0.883
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06073849997483194,
+ "rho": 0.10279720090329647,
+ "acc": 0.8225
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0113879487933591,
+ "Gamma": 0.4088409934192896,
+ "rho": 0.35849119909107685,
+ "acc": 0.7885
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.18101266399025917,
+ "rho": 0.2402007132768631,
+ "acc": 0.626
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7800825014710426,
+ "rho": 0.9999619349837303,
+ "acc": 0.874
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.0680798904504627,
+ "rho": 0.07815029704943299,
+ "acc": 0.8105
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.013940593439154327,
+ "Gamma": 0.22329587768763304,
+ "rho": 0.18133462546393275,
+ "acc": 0.775
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.16422098223119974,
+ "rho": 0.2585284411907196,
+ "acc": 0.5765
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.741077221930027,
+ "rho": 0.9999566599726677,
+ "acc": 0.8835
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06835221056826413,
+ "rho": 0.07870115921832621,
+ "acc": 0.826
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.01196373869618401,
+ "Gamma": 0.2609132928773761,
+ "rho": 0.22901193983852863,
+ "acc": 0.732
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1594983646646142,
+ "rho": 0.28827742394059896,
+ "acc": 0.631
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8024904653429985,
+ "rho": 0.9999617040157318,
+ "acc": 0.8605
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09767440240830183,
+ "rho": 0.10227222001412883,
+ "acc": 0.804
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.007250209745950997,
+ "Gamma": 0.308225903660059,
+ "rho": 0.26882948353886604,
+ "acc": 0.746
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.17834078380838037,
+ "rho": 0.28439006581902504,
+ "acc": 0.607
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7425128743052483,
+ "rho": 0.9999456480145454,
+ "acc": 0.862
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07170737814158201,
+ "rho": 0.10886842722538859,
+ "acc": 0.795
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.010051667786203325,
+ "Gamma": 0.22407432738691568,
+ "rho": 0.19511110894382,
+ "acc": 0.755
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.15873884549364448,
+ "rho": 0.2204220425337553,
+ "acc": 0.6015
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.802269235253334,
+ "rho": 0.9999621286988258,
+ "acc": 0.889
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07059638481587172,
+ "rho": 0.09517476172186434,
+ "acc": 0.844
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.015034918455407024,
+ "Gamma": 0.26445331890136003,
+ "rho": 0.2382330046966672,
+ "acc": 0.754
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.14965758845210075,
+ "rho": 0.22262850403785706,
+ "acc": 0.5705
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7915605679154396,
+ "rho": 0.9999616295099258,
+ "acc": 0.876
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.054607931757345796,
+ "rho": 0.0988450946751982,
+ "acc": 0.831
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.011838351630140097,
+ "Gamma": 0.25473486352711916,
+ "rho": 0.22712249495089054,
+ "acc": 0.774
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.18231265805661678,
+ "rho": 0.23427345044910908,
+ "acc": 0.623
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7524143233895302,
+ "rho": 0.9999579712748528,
+ "acc": 0.878
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.12144442298449576,
+ "rho": 0.1239226256730035,
+ "acc": 0.812
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.01295656328741461,
+ "Gamma": 0.2410168293863535,
+ "rho": 0.21426095999777317,
+ "acc": 0.7855
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.13227692258078605,
+ "rho": 0.1761333434842527,
+ "acc": 0.5945
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7426219433546066,
+ "rho": 0.9999610707163811,
+ "acc": 0.867
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.061901216860860586,
+ "rho": 0.09875185182318091,
+ "acc": 0.8075
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0033825204903259872,
+ "Gamma": 0.277063325047493,
+ "rho": 0.2407076209783554,
+ "acc": 0.7165
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1314755715429783,
+ "rho": 0.2386790281161666,
+ "acc": 0.61
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7783375456929207,
+ "rho": 0.9999541118741035,
+ "acc": 0.867
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07623820775188506,
+ "rho": 0.07604160532355309,
+ "acc": 0.8255
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.017978039579465987,
+ "Gamma": 0.24194164481014013,
+ "rho": 0.20475764898583293,
+ "acc": 0.736
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1662514479830861,
+ "rho": 0.24278739467263222,
+ "acc": 0.6285
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8337910175323486,
+ "rho": 0.999962106347084,
+ "acc": 0.8735
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.07081685795856174,
+ "rho": 0.07124830968677998,
+ "acc": 0.794
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.008247435386758298,
+ "Gamma": 0.2887079808861017,
+ "rho": 0.28017569333314896,
+ "acc": 0.737
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 0.5,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1532246011774987,
+ "rho": 0.24239609204232693,
+ "acc": 0.546
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.837363988161087,
+ "rho": 0.9999942779541016,
+ "acc": 0.796
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05314898584038019,
+ "rho": 0.04739766335114837,
+ "acc": 0.6945
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.05111445432715118,
+ "Gamma": 0.3092905580997467,
+ "rho": 0.2985522858798504,
+ "acc": 0.654
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5798117071390152,
+ "rho": 0.5770738422870636,
+ "acc": 0.455
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7834264636039734,
+ "rho": 0.9999949932098389,
+ "acc": 0.7945
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.03143235971219838,
+ "rho": 0.04966995166614652,
+ "acc": 0.6755
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.039300061028450725,
+ "Gamma": 0.32962899655103683,
+ "rho": 0.3271522969007492,
+ "acc": 0.653
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5211702585220337,
+ "rho": 0.5396891608834267,
+ "acc": 0.4955
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7738194167613983,
+ "rho": 0.9999952465295792,
+ "acc": 0.802
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.03672327077947557,
+ "rho": 0.03823344281408936,
+ "acc": 0.687
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.041286803239956496,
+ "Gamma": 0.3122059181332588,
+ "rho": 0.3080013431608677,
+ "acc": 0.6535
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5516191199421883,
+ "rho": 0.5655025988817215,
+ "acc": 0.4575
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8138538002967834,
+ "rho": 0.9999965578317642,
+ "acc": 0.7785
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.044787557795643806,
+ "rho": 0.050711866933852434,
+ "acc": 0.6645
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.047810701571404934,
+ "Gamma": 0.321536161005497,
+ "rho": 0.294049471616745,
+ "acc": 0.6505
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.498397096991539,
+ "rho": 0.5393850430846214,
+ "acc": 0.4785
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8156489282846451,
+ "rho": 0.9999967068433762,
+ "acc": 0.796
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05224289372563362,
+ "rho": 0.051481935661286116,
+ "acc": 0.7
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.03910857268422842,
+ "Gamma": 0.32806089147925377,
+ "rho": 0.3095804899930954,
+ "acc": 0.659
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.4827726259827614,
+ "rho": 0.5368957445025444,
+ "acc": 0.5295
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8019291013479233,
+ "rho": 0.999995157122612,
+ "acc": 0.789
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.04420588002540171,
+ "rho": 0.054026867961511016,
+ "acc": 0.693
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.04625624809600413,
+ "Gamma": 0.31831347569823265,
+ "rho": 0.30145254731178284,
+ "acc": 0.6415
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.6112141609191895,
+ "rho": 0.6130285188555717,
+ "acc": 0.49
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8269992768764496,
+ "rho": 0.9999961256980896,
+ "acc": 0.8055
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.031051788479089737,
+ "rho": 0.04200031189247966,
+ "acc": 0.68
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.03373044667486101,
+ "Gamma": 0.33542975783348083,
+ "rho": 0.3166932016611099,
+ "acc": 0.6695
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5547316148877144,
+ "rho": 0.574584349989891,
+ "acc": 0.4775
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8469432443380356,
+ "rho": 0.9999967068433762,
+ "acc": 0.7985
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05680405022576451,
+ "rho": 0.058447605930268764,
+ "acc": 0.6885
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.05037181778624654,
+ "Gamma": 0.31409140303730965,
+ "rho": 0.3157280907034874,
+ "acc": 0.661
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5717481672763824,
+ "rho": 0.5648023337125778,
+ "acc": 0.4815
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7843969911336899,
+ "rho": 0.9999955743551254,
+ "acc": 0.7815
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05237697158008814,
+ "rho": 0.05225806776434183,
+ "acc": 0.696
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.020391553843859583,
+ "Gamma": 0.3294149599969387,
+ "rho": 0.32860465347766876,
+ "acc": 0.6545
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5680579468607903,
+ "rho": 0.5536182671785355,
+ "acc": 0.4935
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8201684504747391,
+ "rho": 0.9999956488609314,
+ "acc": 0.777
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.043721775291487575,
+ "rho": 0.053218568209558725,
+ "acc": 0.6775
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.03792587007582188,
+ "Gamma": 0.3274501822888851,
+ "rho": 0.3072219528257847,
+ "acc": 0.6375
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 4,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5522571504116058,
+ "rho": 0.566972091794014,
+ "acc": 0.4445
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7569558992981911,
+ "rho": 0.9999850168824196,
+ "acc": 0.7715
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.04026596760377288,
+ "rho": 0.0463115515303798,
+ "acc": 0.6555
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 0.024733127796091138,
+ "Gamma": 0.21983085572719574,
+ "rho": 0.21069114468991756,
+ "acc": 0.636
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.42342473939061165,
+ "rho": 0.46175311505794525,
+ "acc": 0.501
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7589660733938217,
+ "rho": 0.9999836310744286,
+ "acc": 0.775
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.052690219948999584,
+ "rho": 0.04398861777735874,
+ "acc": 0.6655
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 0.00904931088979356,
+ "Gamma": 0.23909619636833668,
+ "rho": 0.21755888871848583,
+ "acc": 0.6665
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.4901758562773466,
+ "rho": 0.5194796472787857,
+ "acc": 0.499
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8152446746826172,
+ "rho": 0.9999835714697838,
+ "acc": 0.7615
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06644452596083283,
+ "rho": 0.07211897929664701,
+ "acc": 0.6595
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 0.027026508945971726,
+ "Gamma": 0.17726875049993396,
+ "rho": 0.14926194958388805,
+ "acc": 0.634
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.4374451842159033,
+ "rho": 0.469217861071229,
+ "acc": 0.471
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7641392648220062,
+ "rho": 0.9999837800860405,
+ "acc": 0.77
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.06174341728910804,
+ "rho": 0.08079314092174172,
+ "acc": 0.663
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.005507162362337112,
+ "Gamma": 0.27462095208466053,
+ "rho": 0.25958841666579247,
+ "acc": 0.6305
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.4231471223756671,
+ "rho": 0.49050698801875114,
+ "acc": 0.5545
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8173553571105003,
+ "rho": 0.9999844655394554,
+ "acc": 0.7665
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.05211032921215519,
+ "rho": 0.04730354994535446,
+ "acc": 0.657
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 0.03733631442394108,
+ "Gamma": 0.24442856572568417,
+ "rho": 0.2330861296504736,
+ "acc": 0.651
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.43784002028405666,
+ "rho": 0.45684560760855675,
+ "acc": 0.4465
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7980030849575996,
+ "rho": 0.9999835342168808,
+ "acc": 0.778
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.03056039405055344,
+ "rho": 0.019816300831735134,
+ "acc": 0.6515
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 0.019828419615048914,
+ "Gamma": 0.21816869638860226,
+ "rho": 0.2006466817110777,
+ "acc": 0.639
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.44690870121121407,
+ "rho": 0.49068378657102585,
+ "acc": 0.491
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8051622360944748,
+ "rho": 0.9999843910336494,
+ "acc": 0.774
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.039206627872772515,
+ "rho": 0.04525771760381758,
+ "acc": 0.666
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0073138324548490345,
+ "Gamma": 0.23834207840263844,
+ "rho": 0.22312144935131073,
+ "acc": 0.6255
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.48071201518177986,
+ "rho": 0.4987096134573221,
+ "acc": 0.494
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.7561301067471504,
+ "rho": 0.9999867826700211,
+ "acc": 0.7555
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.046561805153032765,
+ "rho": 0.04669333342462778,
+ "acc": 0.651
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 0.021662812023889273,
+ "Gamma": 0.24263181537389755,
+ "rho": 0.23203729651868343,
+ "acc": 0.625
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.5189926661550999,
+ "rho": 0.5291757248342037,
+ "acc": 0.4825
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8032103478908539,
+ "rho": 0.9999829307198524,
+ "acc": 0.769
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.04911017371341586,
+ "rho": 0.044786704413127154,
+ "acc": 0.6785
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.0282969608604908,
+ "Gamma": 0.2040038648992777,
+ "rho": 0.2028592685237527,
+ "acc": 0.6355
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.4662684202194214,
+ "rho": 0.48669758066534996,
+ "acc": 0.5155
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "bp",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.8568788692355156,
+ "rho": 0.9999835342168808,
+ "acc": 0.759
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.047016877244459465,
+ "rho": 0.04356467560864985,
+ "acc": 0.6415
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.011806304380530491,
+ "Gamma": 0.23779606446623802,
+ "rho": 0.22786595951765776,
+ "acc": 0.637
+ },
+ {
+ "alpha": 1.0,
+ "depth": 8,
+ "method": "credit_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.45259521529078484,
+ "rho": 0.4737100824713707,
+ "acc": 0.4825
+ }
+] \ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.csv b/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..68156b5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+method,seed,StateErr,Gamma,rho,acc
+dfa,42,nan,0.10076353600015864,-0.00476757250726223,0.3116
+state_bridge,42,9.164297834395258e-07,0.02469697833294049,-0.012663604691624641,0.1737
+credit_bridge_eT,42,nan,0.17921950668096542,0.008699589408934116,0.283
+dfa,123,nan,0.11738517042249441,0.005885639227926731,0.3106
+state_bridge,123,4.6238185521913695e-05,0.17851687408983707,0.11297287911293097,0.2115
+credit_bridge_eT,123,nan,0.17617796920239925,0.0019302130676805973,0.2753
+dfa,456,nan,0.09892195643624291,-0.004888533148914576,0.297
+state_bridge,456,8.734992210497147e-05,0.26485365629196167,0.11413963884115219,0.2607
+credit_bridge_eT,456,nan,0.23417379707098007,-0.002338360995054245,0.2893
+dfa,789,nan,0.09602321637794375,-0.012195338495075703,0.3051
+state_bridge,789,0.0001798719183267094,0.219103729352355,0.1035128419753164,0.2542
+credit_bridge_eT,789,nan,0.1968853361904621,0.009125714423134923,0.2825
+dfa,1024,nan,0.10625142272328958,0.007073512766510248,0.3083
+state_bridge,1024,3.6692365324357524e-05,0.1903094481676817,0.08768247324042022,0.2338
+credit_bridge_eT,1024,nan,0.1989332279190421,0.006513587199151516,0.2975
+dfa,2048,nan,0.10264200350502506,0.0015445498283952475,0.3102
+state_bridge,2048,5.471739053819328e-05,0.1533527011051774,0.021173154236748815,0.2015
+credit_bridge_eT,2048,nan,0.21371350064873695,0.01922372356057167,0.2862
+dfa,3000,nan,0.09254411532310769,-0.0020813816227018833,0.3054
+state_bridge,3000,1.4380053736007537e-05,0.11326553428079933,0.03250931575894356,0.197
+credit_bridge_eT,3000,nan,0.19290144089609385,0.0142808947712183,0.2705
+dfa,4000,nan,0.09669098260928877,-0.006473553366959095,0.3016
+state_bridge,4000,2.7812045817612668e-05,0.09340349677950144,0.0637101479806006,0.2155
+credit_bridge_eT,4000,nan,0.15450781304389238,0.0030927499756217003,0.2966
+dfa,5000,nan,0.1122395604616031,0.0056443302892148495,0.3139
+state_bridge,5000,0.00019077022730000314,0.11574495000240859,0.15696023870259523,0.1957
+credit_bridge_eT,5000,nan,0.18241790123283863,0.007469391683116555,0.3002
+dfa,6000,nan,0.09259073645807803,0.0021172836422920227,0.282
+state_bridge,6000,0.00011229384421696886,0.2289915308356285,0.14905795291997492,0.2964
+credit_bridge_eT,6000,nan,0.20601818710565567,-0.0038647495675832033,0.2882
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.json b/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..e994d03
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A2_cifar_state_vs_credit.json
@@ -0,0 +1,242 @@
+[
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10076353600015864,
+ "rho": -0.00476757250726223,
+ "acc": 0.3116
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": 9.164297834395258e-07,
+ "Gamma": 0.02469697833294049,
+ "rho": -0.012663604691624641,
+ "acc": 0.1737
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.17921950668096542,
+ "rho": 0.008699589408934116,
+ "acc": 0.283
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.11738517042249441,
+ "rho": 0.005885639227926731,
+ "acc": 0.3106
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": 4.6238185521913695e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.17851687408983707,
+ "rho": 0.11297287911293097,
+ "acc": 0.2115
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.17617796920239925,
+ "rho": 0.0019302130676805973,
+ "acc": 0.2753
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09892195643624291,
+ "rho": -0.004888533148914576,
+ "acc": 0.297
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": 8.734992210497147e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.26485365629196167,
+ "rho": 0.11413963884115219,
+ "acc": 0.2607
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.23417379707098007,
+ "rho": -0.002338360995054245,
+ "acc": 0.2893
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09602321637794375,
+ "rho": -0.012195338495075703,
+ "acc": 0.3051
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": 0.0001798719183267094,
+ "Gamma": 0.219103729352355,
+ "rho": 0.1035128419753164,
+ "acc": 0.2542
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1968853361904621,
+ "rho": 0.009125714423134923,
+ "acc": 0.2825
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10625142272328958,
+ "rho": 0.007073512766510248,
+ "acc": 0.3083
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": 3.6692365324357524e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.1903094481676817,
+ "rho": 0.08768247324042022,
+ "acc": 0.2338
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1989332279190421,
+ "rho": 0.006513587199151516,
+ "acc": 0.2975
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.10264200350502506,
+ "rho": 0.0015445498283952475,
+ "acc": 0.3102
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": 5.471739053819328e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.1533527011051774,
+ "rho": 0.021173154236748815,
+ "acc": 0.2015
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.21371350064873695,
+ "rho": 0.01922372356057167,
+ "acc": 0.2862
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09254411532310769,
+ "rho": -0.0020813816227018833,
+ "acc": 0.3054
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": 1.4380053736007537e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.11326553428079933,
+ "rho": 0.03250931575894356,
+ "acc": 0.197
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.19290144089609385,
+ "rho": 0.0142808947712183,
+ "acc": 0.2705
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09669098260928877,
+ "rho": -0.006473553366959095,
+ "acc": 0.3016
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": 2.7812045817612668e-05,
+ "Gamma": 0.09340349677950144,
+ "rho": 0.0637101479806006,
+ "acc": 0.2155
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.15450781304389238,
+ "rho": 0.0030927499756217003,
+ "acc": 0.2966
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.1122395604616031,
+ "rho": 0.0056443302892148495,
+ "acc": 0.3139
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": 0.00019077022730000314,
+ "Gamma": 0.11574495000240859,
+ "rho": 0.15696023870259523,
+ "acc": 0.1957
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.18241790123283863,
+ "rho": 0.007469391683116555,
+ "acc": 0.3002
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.09259073645807803,
+ "rho": 0.0021172836422920227,
+ "acc": 0.282
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "state_bridge",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": 0.00011229384421696886,
+ "Gamma": 0.2289915308356285,
+ "rho": 0.14905795291997492,
+ "acc": 0.2964
+ },
+ {
+ "method": "credit_bridge_eT",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "StateErr": NaN,
+ "Gamma": 0.20601818710565567,
+ "rho": -0.0038647495675832033,
+ "acc": 0.2882
+ }
+] \ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.csv b/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..60ef6ad
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
+regime,method,seed,Gamma,rho,nudge,acc
+frozen,dfa,42,0.004505785531364381,0.008119155652821064,-9.162341120827477e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,42,0.11589984688907862,0.18948250077664852,-0.001349875790765509,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,42,0.3822024315595627,0.3902328796684742,-0.004724124912172556,nan
+online,dfa,42,0.10076353600015864,-0.00476757250726223,-1.0885996744036674e-06,0.3116
+online,scalar_cb,42,0.17921950668096542,0.008699589408934116,-2.653570845723152e-06,0.283
+online,vec_eT_M4,42,0.002346692723222077,-0.000655805692076683,4.1443854570388794e-08,0.3116
+frozen,dfa,123,0.006769153871573508,0.006851167418062687,-4.7400368202943355e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,123,0.12154238484799862,0.20577848330140114,-0.0014780515775782987,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,123,0.3757530301809311,0.3804876245558262,-0.004601294989697635,nan
+online,dfa,123,0.11738517042249441,0.005885639227926731,-1.4995457604527473e-06,0.3106
+online,scalar_cb,123,0.17617796920239925,0.0019302130676805973,-2.4832552298903465e-06,0.2753
+online,vec_eT_M4,123,-0.003648026817245409,0.008452285081148148,2.468004822731018e-08,0.3106
+frozen,dfa,456,-0.0022321121068671346,-0.025214229593984783,9.127522389462683e-06,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,456,0.14351800736039877,0.13401155546307564,-0.0015096227143658325,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,456,0.37154657021164894,0.3922838978469372,-0.004483302065636963,nan
+online,dfa,456,0.09892195643624291,-0.004888533148914576,-9.865034371614456e-07,0.297
+online,scalar_cb,456,0.23417379707098007,-0.002338360995054245,-1.8764985725283623e-06,0.2893
+online,vec_eT_M4,456,8.133021765388548e-05,0.0004630112089216709,-3.562308847904205e-08,0.297
+frozen,dfa,789,0.0010723177110776305,-9.368173778057098e-06,-3.215731521777343e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,789,0.116337139159441,0.1693769097328186,-0.0013340917212190107,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,789,0.3803345151245594,0.40245913714170456,-0.00463068817043677,nan
+online,dfa,789,0.09602321637794375,-0.012195338495075703,-1.2458767741918564e-06,0.3051
+online,scalar_cb,789,0.1968853361904621,0.009125714423134923,-2.344953827559948e-06,0.2825
+online,vec_eT_M4,789,-0.0013487973556038924,-0.0010448158718645573,1.5133991837501526e-09,0.3051
+frozen,dfa,1024,0.004047981696203351,-0.004657504265196621,-5.443185364129022e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,1024,0.13928020559251308,0.17055200971662998,-0.00163848337251693,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,1024,0.3866974972188473,0.3883730284869671,-0.0044556696666404605,nan
+online,dfa,1024,0.10625142272328958,0.007073512766510248,-1.2062955647706985e-06,0.3083
+online,scalar_cb,1024,0.1989332279190421,0.006513587199151516,-2.512824721634388e-06,0.2975
+online,vec_eT_M4,1024,-0.0008005678537301719,0.0017584874294698238,-2.60770320892334e-08,0.3083
+frozen,dfa,2048,-0.01007436728104949,-0.022396742831915617,9.364452944282675e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,2048,0.11622164957225323,0.09785426966845989,-0.001329392776824534,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,2048,0.37112750113010406,0.4292800724506378,-0.004542236507404596,nan
+online,dfa,2048,0.10264200350502506,0.0015445498283952475,-1.2172386050224304e-06,0.3102
+online,scalar_cb,2048,0.21371350064873695,0.01922372356057167,-1.786043867468834e-06,0.2862
+online,vec_eT_M4,2048,-0.0013046257517999038,-0.0022081234492361546,2.7939677238464355e-09,0.3102
+frozen,dfa,3000,0.012637533247470856,-0.003309569787234068,-0.0001136179780587554,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,3000,0.12735093012452126,0.16207957826554775,-0.0014450718881562352,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,3000,0.3722042217850685,0.4153371751308441,-0.005018443625885993,nan
+online,dfa,3000,0.09254411532310769,-0.0020813816227018833,-8.647330105304718e-07,0.3054
+online,scalar_cb,3000,0.19290144089609385,0.0142808947712183,-1.846812665462494e-06,0.2705
+online,vec_eT_M4,3000,0.0027015579398721457,0.0031934939324855804,-4.7497451305389404e-08,0.3054
+frozen,dfa,4000,0.012827006517909467,-0.022367039695382118,-0.00015865873137954623,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,4000,0.14385110139846802,0.1320151798427105,-0.001822189544327557,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,4000,0.37244511023163795,0.4071832448244095,-0.004847258620429784,nan
+online,dfa,4000,0.09669098260928877,-0.006473553366959095,-1.225038431584835e-06,0.3016
+online,scalar_cb,4000,0.15450781304389238,0.0030927499756217003,-2.410844899713993e-06,0.2966
+online,vec_eT_M4,4000,-0.0019520780188031495,-0.0038583979476243258,1.885928213596344e-08,0.3016
+frozen,dfa,5000,0.0013664336875081062,0.006194833666086197,-4.495742837207217e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,5000,0.11013340763747692,0.1481193359941244,-0.0015028833877295256,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,5000,0.3717799335718155,0.38883912563323975,-0.004724961589090526,nan
+online,dfa,5000,0.1122395604616031,0.0056443302892148495,-1.3115350157022476e-06,0.3139
+online,scalar_cb,5000,0.18241790123283863,0.007469391683116555,-2.3095635697245598e-06,0.3002
+online,vec_eT_M4,5000,-0.0025941856001736596,-0.005957933608442545,6.891787052154541e-08,0.3139
+frozen,dfa,6000,0.0008208117797039449,-0.004433086141943932,-5.1620487283798866e-05,nan
+frozen,scalar_cb,6000,0.11223629210144281,0.1833980716764927,-0.0013175156782381237,nan
+frozen,vec_eT_M4,6000,0.37406010553240776,0.3813984990119934,-0.004561110574286431,nan
+online,dfa,6000,0.09259073645807803,0.0021172836422920227,-7.421476766467094e-07,0.282
+online,scalar_cb,6000,0.20601818710565567,-0.0038647495675832033,-1.5320256352424622e-06,0.2882
+online,vec_eT_M4,6000,-0.003383698291145265,-0.00234654126688838,-1.234002411365509e-08,0.282
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.json b/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..f88a7c6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A3_frozen_vs_online.json
@@ -0,0 +1,542 @@
+[
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.004505785531364381,
+ "rho": 0.008119155652821064,
+ "nudge": -9.162341120827477e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.11589984688907862,
+ "rho": 0.18948250077664852,
+ "nudge": -0.001349875790765509,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.3822024315595627,
+ "rho": 0.3902328796684742,
+ "nudge": -0.004724124912172556,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.10076353600015864,
+ "rho": -0.00476757250726223,
+ "nudge": -1.0885996744036674e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3116
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.17921950668096542,
+ "rho": 0.008699589408934116,
+ "nudge": -2.653570845723152e-06,
+ "acc": 0.283
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 42,
+ "Gamma": 0.002346692723222077,
+ "rho": -0.000655805692076683,
+ "nudge": 4.1443854570388794e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3116
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": 0.006769153871573508,
+ "rho": 0.006851167418062687,
+ "nudge": -4.7400368202943355e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": 0.12154238484799862,
+ "rho": 0.20577848330140114,
+ "nudge": -0.0014780515775782987,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": 0.3757530301809311,
+ "rho": 0.3804876245558262,
+ "nudge": -0.004601294989697635,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": 0.11738517042249441,
+ "rho": 0.005885639227926731,
+ "nudge": -1.4995457604527473e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3106
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": 0.17617796920239925,
+ "rho": 0.0019302130676805973,
+ "nudge": -2.4832552298903465e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2753
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 123,
+ "Gamma": -0.003648026817245409,
+ "rho": 0.008452285081148148,
+ "nudge": 2.468004822731018e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3106
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": -0.0022321121068671346,
+ "rho": -0.025214229593984783,
+ "nudge": 9.127522389462683e-06,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": 0.14351800736039877,
+ "rho": 0.13401155546307564,
+ "nudge": -0.0015096227143658325,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": 0.37154657021164894,
+ "rho": 0.3922838978469372,
+ "nudge": -0.004483302065636963,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": 0.09892195643624291,
+ "rho": -0.004888533148914576,
+ "nudge": -9.865034371614456e-07,
+ "acc": 0.297
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": 0.23417379707098007,
+ "rho": -0.002338360995054245,
+ "nudge": -1.8764985725283623e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2893
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 456,
+ "Gamma": 8.133021765388548e-05,
+ "rho": 0.0004630112089216709,
+ "nudge": -3.562308847904205e-08,
+ "acc": 0.297
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": 0.0010723177110776305,
+ "rho": -9.368173778057098e-06,
+ "nudge": -3.215731521777343e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": 0.116337139159441,
+ "rho": 0.1693769097328186,
+ "nudge": -0.0013340917212190107,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": 0.3803345151245594,
+ "rho": 0.40245913714170456,
+ "nudge": -0.00463068817043677,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": 0.09602321637794375,
+ "rho": -0.012195338495075703,
+ "nudge": -1.2458767741918564e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3051
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": 0.1968853361904621,
+ "rho": 0.009125714423134923,
+ "nudge": -2.344953827559948e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2825
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 789,
+ "Gamma": -0.0013487973556038924,
+ "rho": -0.0010448158718645573,
+ "nudge": 1.5133991837501526e-09,
+ "acc": 0.3051
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": 0.004047981696203351,
+ "rho": -0.004657504265196621,
+ "nudge": -5.443185364129022e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": 0.13928020559251308,
+ "rho": 0.17055200971662998,
+ "nudge": -0.00163848337251693,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": 0.3866974972188473,
+ "rho": 0.3883730284869671,
+ "nudge": -0.0044556696666404605,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": 0.10625142272328958,
+ "rho": 0.007073512766510248,
+ "nudge": -1.2062955647706985e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3083
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": 0.1989332279190421,
+ "rho": 0.006513587199151516,
+ "nudge": -2.512824721634388e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2975
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 1024,
+ "Gamma": -0.0008005678537301719,
+ "rho": 0.0017584874294698238,
+ "nudge": -2.60770320892334e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3083
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": -0.01007436728104949,
+ "rho": -0.022396742831915617,
+ "nudge": 9.364452944282675e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": 0.11622164957225323,
+ "rho": 0.09785426966845989,
+ "nudge": -0.001329392776824534,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": 0.37112750113010406,
+ "rho": 0.4292800724506378,
+ "nudge": -0.004542236507404596,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": 0.10264200350502506,
+ "rho": 0.0015445498283952475,
+ "nudge": -1.2172386050224304e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3102
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": 0.21371350064873695,
+ "rho": 0.01922372356057167,
+ "nudge": -1.786043867468834e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2862
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 2048,
+ "Gamma": -0.0013046257517999038,
+ "rho": -0.0022081234492361546,
+ "nudge": 2.7939677238464355e-09,
+ "acc": 0.3102
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.012637533247470856,
+ "rho": -0.003309569787234068,
+ "nudge": -0.0001136179780587554,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.12735093012452126,
+ "rho": 0.16207957826554775,
+ "nudge": -0.0014450718881562352,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.3722042217850685,
+ "rho": 0.4153371751308441,
+ "nudge": -0.005018443625885993,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.09254411532310769,
+ "rho": -0.0020813816227018833,
+ "nudge": -8.647330105304718e-07,
+ "acc": 0.3054
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.19290144089609385,
+ "rho": 0.0142808947712183,
+ "nudge": -1.846812665462494e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2705
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 3000,
+ "Gamma": 0.0027015579398721457,
+ "rho": 0.0031934939324855804,
+ "nudge": -4.7497451305389404e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3054
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": 0.012827006517909467,
+ "rho": -0.022367039695382118,
+ "nudge": -0.00015865873137954623,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": 0.14385110139846802,
+ "rho": 0.1320151798427105,
+ "nudge": -0.001822189544327557,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": 0.37244511023163795,
+ "rho": 0.4071832448244095,
+ "nudge": -0.004847258620429784,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": 0.09669098260928877,
+ "rho": -0.006473553366959095,
+ "nudge": -1.225038431584835e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3016
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": 0.15450781304389238,
+ "rho": 0.0030927499756217003,
+ "nudge": -2.410844899713993e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2966
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 4000,
+ "Gamma": -0.0019520780188031495,
+ "rho": -0.0038583979476243258,
+ "nudge": 1.885928213596344e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3016
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": 0.0013664336875081062,
+ "rho": 0.006194833666086197,
+ "nudge": -4.495742837207217e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": 0.11013340763747692,
+ "rho": 0.1481193359941244,
+ "nudge": -0.0015028833877295256,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": 0.3717799335718155,
+ "rho": 0.38883912563323975,
+ "nudge": -0.004724961589090526,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": 0.1122395604616031,
+ "rho": 0.0056443302892148495,
+ "nudge": -1.3115350157022476e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3139
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": 0.18241790123283863,
+ "rho": 0.007469391683116555,
+ "nudge": -2.3095635697245598e-06,
+ "acc": 0.3002
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 5000,
+ "Gamma": -0.0025941856001736596,
+ "rho": -0.005957933608442545,
+ "nudge": 6.891787052154541e-08,
+ "acc": 0.3139
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": 0.0008208117797039449,
+ "rho": -0.004433086141943932,
+ "nudge": -5.1620487283798866e-05,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": 0.11223629210144281,
+ "rho": 0.1833980716764927,
+ "nudge": -0.0013175156782381237,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "frozen",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": 0.37406010553240776,
+ "rho": 0.3813984990119934,
+ "nudge": -0.004561110574286431,
+ "acc": NaN
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": 0.09259073645807803,
+ "rho": 0.0021172836422920227,
+ "nudge": -7.421476766467094e-07,
+ "acc": 0.282
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": 0.20601818710565567,
+ "rho": -0.0038647495675832033,
+ "nudge": -1.5320256352424622e-06,
+ "acc": 0.2882
+ },
+ {
+ "regime": "online",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "seed": 6000,
+ "Gamma": -0.003383698291145265,
+ "rho": -0.00234654126688838,
+ "nudge": -1.234002411365509e-08,
+ "acc": 0.282
+ }
+] \ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.csv b/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..509e51f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
+slice,method,metric,value
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,gamma,0.008470005544950254
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,rho,-0.022525018197484314
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,nudge,-2.3932622525535407e-05
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,loss_before,1.1802499413490295
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,loss_after_1step,1.1798909544944762
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,delta_loss_1step,-0.00035898685455326707
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,dfa,delta_acc_1step,0.002343749999999978
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,gamma,0.12223921716213226
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,rho,0.09000759199261665
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,nudge,-0.00036903251748299226
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,loss_before,1.1802499413490295
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,loss_after_1step,1.1835142850875855
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,delta_loss_1step,0.003264343738555997
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,scalar_cb,delta_acc_1step,0.0007812499999999556
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,gamma,0.37760399281978607
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,rho,0.41141805797815323
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,nudge,-0.0013705549063161016
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,loss_before,1.1802499413490295
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,loss_after_1step,1.1832772016525268
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,delta_loss_1step,0.0030272603034973145
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,vec_eT_M4,delta_acc_1step,-0.0031250000000000444
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,gamma,1.0
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,rho,0.9979714304208755
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,nudge,-0.0031722619314678013
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,loss_before,1.1802499413490295
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,loss_after_1step,1.1796290874481201
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,delta_loss_1step,-0.0006208539009093794
+snapshot_exploit_ep100,oracle_bp,delta_acc_1step,0.005468750000000022
+snapshot_ep5,dfa,dl_held_1,6.842613220214844e-05
+snapshot_ep5,dfa,dl_same_1,-0.011249661445617676
+snapshot_ep5,dfa,dl_held_5,0.0032531023025512695
+snapshot_ep5,dfa,dl_same_5,-0.004767775535583496
+snapshot_ep5,vec_eT_M4,dl_held_1,-0.0002554655075073242
+snapshot_ep5,vec_eT_M4,dl_same_1,-0.011568784713745117
+snapshot_ep5,vec_eT_M4,dl_held_5,-0.005142092704772949
+snapshot_ep5,vec_eT_M4,dl_same_5,-0.007385373115539551
+snapshot_ep5,oracle_bp,dl_held_1,-0.0002244710922241211
+snapshot_ep5,oracle_bp,dl_same_1,-0.011359930038452148
+snapshot_ep5,oracle_bp,dl_held_5,-0.008973956108093262
+snapshot_ep5,oracle_bp,dl_same_5,-0.008551597595214844
+snapshot_ep20,dfa,dl_held_1,0.0006439685821533203
+snapshot_ep20,dfa,dl_same_1,-0.0050983428955078125
+snapshot_ep20,dfa,dl_held_5,0.0009417533874511719
+snapshot_ep20,dfa,dl_same_5,-0.001807570457458496
+snapshot_ep20,vec_eT_M4,dl_held_1,4.982948303222656e-05
+snapshot_ep20,vec_eT_M4,dl_same_1,-0.005342721939086914
+snapshot_ep20,vec_eT_M4,dl_held_5,0.0015401840209960938
+snapshot_ep20,vec_eT_M4,dl_same_5,-0.00039839744567871094
+snapshot_ep20,oracle_bp,dl_held_1,6.651878356933594e-05
+snapshot_ep20,oracle_bp,dl_same_1,-0.004968762397766113
+snapshot_ep20,oracle_bp,dl_held_5,0.0003821849822998047
+snapshot_ep20,oracle_bp,dl_same_5,-0.0005745887756347656
+scaffold_3seed,dfa,final_mean,0.30593333333333333
+scaffold_3seed,dfa,final_std,0.006104825049818285
+scaffold_3seed,dfa,acc20_mean,0.30383333333333334
+scaffold_3seed,dfa,acc20_std,0.007825741001478518
+scaffold_3seed,perlayer,final_mean,0.30396666666666666
+scaffold_3seed,perlayer,final_std,0.006049977043115317
+scaffold_3seed,perlayer,acc20_mean,0.2874666666666667
+scaffold_3seed,perlayer,acc20_std,0.011382540235914942
+scaffold_3seed,vec,final_mean,0.3133333333333333
+scaffold_3seed,vec,final_std,0.007196912918436331
+scaffold_3seed,vec,acc20_mean,0.30333333333333334
+scaffold_3seed,vec,acc20_std,0.007024401912065005
+online_3seed,dfa_s42,test_acc,0.3116
+online_3seed,dfa_s42,mean_gamma,0.10076353600015864
+online_3seed,dfa_s42,mean_rho,-0.00476757250726223
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s42,test_acc,0.283
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s42,mean_gamma,0.17921950668096542
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s42,mean_rho,0.008699589408934116
+online_3seed,dfa_s123,test_acc,0.3106
+online_3seed,dfa_s123,mean_gamma,0.11738517042249441
+online_3seed,dfa_s123,mean_rho,0.005885639227926731
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s123,test_acc,0.2753
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s123,mean_gamma,0.17617796920239925
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s123,mean_rho,0.0019302130676805973
+online_3seed,dfa_s456,test_acc,0.297
+online_3seed,dfa_s456,mean_gamma,0.09892195643624291
+online_3seed,dfa_s456,mean_rho,-0.004888533148914576
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s456,test_acc,0.2893
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s456,mean_gamma,0.23417379707098007
+online_3seed,cb_eT_s456,mean_rho,-0.002338360995054245
diff --git a/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.json b/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..59671d4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/confirmatory/A4_protocol_dependence.json
@@ -0,0 +1,494 @@
+[
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "gamma",
+ "value": 0.008470005544950254
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "rho",
+ "value": -0.022525018197484314
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "nudge",
+ "value": -2.3932622525535407e-05
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "loss_before",
+ "value": 1.1802499413490295
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "loss_after_1step",
+ "value": 1.1798909544944762
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "delta_loss_1step",
+ "value": -0.00035898685455326707
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "delta_acc_1step",
+ "value": 0.002343749999999978
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "gamma",
+ "value": 0.12223921716213226
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "rho",
+ "value": 0.09000759199261665
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "nudge",
+ "value": -0.00036903251748299226
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "loss_before",
+ "value": 1.1802499413490295
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "loss_after_1step",
+ "value": 1.1835142850875855
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "delta_loss_1step",
+ "value": 0.003264343738555997
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "scalar_cb",
+ "metric": "delta_acc_1step",
+ "value": 0.0007812499999999556
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "gamma",
+ "value": 0.37760399281978607
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "rho",
+ "value": 0.41141805797815323
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "nudge",
+ "value": -0.0013705549063161016
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "loss_before",
+ "value": 1.1802499413490295
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "loss_after_1step",
+ "value": 1.1832772016525268
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "delta_loss_1step",
+ "value": 0.0030272603034973145
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "delta_acc_1step",
+ "value": -0.0031250000000000444
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "gamma",
+ "value": 1.0
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "rho",
+ "value": 0.9979714304208755
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "nudge",
+ "value": -0.0031722619314678013
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "loss_before",
+ "value": 1.1802499413490295
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "loss_after_1step",
+ "value": 1.1796290874481201
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "delta_loss_1step",
+ "value": -0.0006208539009093794
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_exploit_ep100",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "delta_acc_1step",
+ "value": 0.005468750000000022
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": 6.842613220214844e-05
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.011249661445617676
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": 0.0032531023025512695
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.004767775535583496
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": -0.0002554655075073242
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.011568784713745117
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": -0.005142092704772949
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.007385373115539551
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": -0.0002244710922241211
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.011359930038452148
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": -0.008973956108093262
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep5",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.008551597595214844
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": 0.0006439685821533203
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.0050983428955078125
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": 0.0009417533874511719
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.001807570457458496
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": 4.982948303222656e-05
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.005342721939086914
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": 0.0015401840209960938
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "vec_eT_M4",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.00039839744567871094
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_held_1",
+ "value": 6.651878356933594e-05
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_same_1",
+ "value": -0.004968762397766113
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_held_5",
+ "value": 0.0003821849822998047
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "snapshot_ep20",
+ "method": "oracle_bp",
+ "metric": "dl_same_5",
+ "value": -0.0005745887756347656
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "final_mean",
+ "value": 0.30593333333333333
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "final_std",
+ "value": 0.006104825049818285
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "acc20_mean",
+ "value": 0.30383333333333334
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa",
+ "metric": "acc20_std",
+ "value": 0.007825741001478518
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "perlayer",
+ "metric": "final_mean",
+ "value": 0.30396666666666666
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "perlayer",
+ "metric": "final_std",
+ "value": 0.006049977043115317
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "perlayer",
+ "metric": "acc20_mean",
+ "value": 0.2874666666666667
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "perlayer",
+ "metric": "acc20_std",
+ "value": 0.011382540235914942
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "vec",
+ "metric": "final_mean",
+ "value": 0.3133333333333333
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "vec",
+ "metric": "final_std",
+ "value": 0.007196912918436331
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "vec",
+ "metric": "acc20_mean",
+ "value": 0.30333333333333334
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "scaffold_3seed",
+ "method": "vec",
+ "metric": "acc20_std",
+ "value": 0.007024401912065005
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s42",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.3116
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s42",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.10076353600015864
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s42",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": -0.00476757250726223
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s42",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.283
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s42",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.17921950668096542
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s42",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": 0.008699589408934116
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s123",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.3106
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s123",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.11738517042249441
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s123",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": 0.005885639227926731
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s123",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.2753
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s123",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.17617796920239925
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s123",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": 0.0019302130676805973
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s456",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.297
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s456",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.09892195643624291
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "dfa_s456",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": -0.004888533148914576
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s456",
+ "metric": "test_acc",
+ "value": 0.2893
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s456",
+ "metric": "mean_gamma",
+ "value": 0.23417379707098007
+ },
+ {
+ "slice": "online_3seed",
+ "method": "cb_eT_s456",
+ "metric": "mean_rho",
+ "value": -0.002338360995054245
+ }
+] \ No newline at end of file
generated by cgit v1.2.3 (git 2.25.1) at 2026-06-15 00:24:17 +0000