summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
Diffstat (limited to 'results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json')
-rw-r--r--results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json1182
1 files changed, 1182 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json b/results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..d925e2f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_scaling_analysis.json
@@ -0,0 +1,1182 @@
+{
+ "analysis": "overclamped_digital_coupled_ladder_scaling",
+ "confirmatory": true,
+ "bootstrap": {
+ "unit": "task; three component draws averaged within task",
+ "task_clusters": 40,
+ "component_draws_per_task_size": 3,
+ "replicates": 20000,
+ "seed": 20260829,
+ "interval": "percentile 95%"
+ },
+ "sizes": [
+ 4,
+ 8,
+ 12,
+ 16,
+ 24,
+ 32
+ ],
+ "summaries": {
+ "4": {
+ "learnable_edges": 32,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.08125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.046875,
+ 0.121875
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.12231770833333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.08546744791666668,
+ 0.162421875
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.55,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.4,
+ 0.7
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 325.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 242.75,
+ 406.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2204.1,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1613.571875,
+ 2792.2581249999994
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 70531.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 51905.439999999995,
+ 89672.82
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 70531.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 51851.9,
+ 89208.9
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 6.694091762066566,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4.843300584881907,
+ 8.637111274578398
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.33125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.27291666666666664,
+ 0.3875
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.3322482638888889,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.2749479166666667,
+ 0.38772634548611107
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.10833333333333332,
+ 0.3
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 493.33333333333337,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 434.5833333333333,
+ 546.1666666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2836.9666666666662,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2456.41625,
+ 3190.2262499999997
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 90782.93333333332,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 78459.52666666667,
+ 102126.42666666665
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 90782.93333333332,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 78492.72666666668,
+ 102031.26
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 11.322735346286258,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 9.668668177363983,
+ 12.854332706727966
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.08020833333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.046875,
+ 0.11979166666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.12251736111111111,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.08586805555555556,
+ 0.1628914930555555
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.55,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.4,
+ 0.7
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 326.41666666666663,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 245.24791666666667,
+ 406.66666666666663
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2211.7,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1627.9312499999999,
+ 2797.1129166666665
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 70774.4,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 52070.50666666667,
+ 89738.68666666663
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 141548.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 104315.17333333335,
+ 179502.6933333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 6.706841827408098,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4.855938048841957,
+ 8.602373322590896
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0041666666666667
+ },
+ "8": {
+ "learnable_edges": 128,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.00625,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.015625
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.05901041666666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.040156250000000004,
+ 0.08049479166666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.95,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.875,
+ 1.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 175.5,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 129.75,
+ 226.00624999999945
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1396.625,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1035.1225,
+ 1810.6568749999994
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 178768.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 131506.80000000002,
+ 230954.63999999993
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 178768.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 131526.32,
+ 230561.35999999987
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 4.830059691735569,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 3.4644031059106157,
+ 6.415083058794295
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.3572916666666667,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.3052083333333333,
+ 0.4072916666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.3455295138888889,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.29606770833333335,
+ 0.3943682725694443
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.11666666666666665,
+ 0.29166666666666663
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 496.5,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 447.6666666666667,
+ 540.0833333333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 3512.325,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 3130.9231250000003,
+ 3873.138749999999
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 449577.6,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 400346.29333333333,
+ 495696.90666666656
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 449577.6,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 400729.30666666664,
+ 495790.0266666667
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 12.382452183371704,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 10.841769207163392,
+ 13.852293614151728
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.00625,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.015625
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.05963541666666668,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.04057291666666667,
+ 0.08153710937499994
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.95,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.875,
+ 1.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 176.58333333333331,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 130.58333333333334,
+ 228.33333333333331
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1405.4416666666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1031.9054166666667,
+ 1820.7799999999997
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 179896.53333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 132331.70666666667,
+ 233217.35999999996
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 359793.06666666665,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 264248.48,
+ 465636.4799999999
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 4.855381836348128,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 3.458883266552342,
+ 6.427283350714492
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0
+ },
+ "12": {
+ "learnable_edges": 288,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.00625,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.015625
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.042395833333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.031640625,
+ 0.05377669270833329
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.95,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.875,
+ 1.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 175.25,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 124.5,
+ 229.75
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1402.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 996.0,
+ 1842.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 403776.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 286272.0,
+ 529934.3999999987
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 403776.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 288561.60000000003,
+ 530496.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 5.71628421156082,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4.017529676130967,
+ 7.586845066013982
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.3375,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.2885416666666667,
+ 0.38544270833333105
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.3404513888888889,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.2936803385416667,
+ 0.38732725694444436
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.15833333333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.09166666666666665,
+ 0.2333333333333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 518.5,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 478.6666666666667,
+ 554.4166666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 4075.9,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 3747.130833333333,
+ 4371.935833333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1173859.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1077991.56,
+ 1259126.5199999998
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1173859.2,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1078756.2,
+ 1259905.02
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 16.42190842273961,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 14.747728850822176,
+ 17.996643115248986
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.009375,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0010416666666666667,
+ 0.019791666666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.042942708333333336,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0321875,
+ 0.05434027777777778
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.925,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8416666666666666,
+ 0.9916666666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 181.91666666666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 130.0,
+ 236.91874999999985
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1455.3,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1034.6412500000001,
+ 1906.6743749999987
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 419126.4,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 298163.94,
+ 547192.8
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 838252.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 600945.6,
+ 1094769.6
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 5.931565613030159,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4.2101947700965345,
+ 7.846432153455605
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 0.990566037735849
+ },
+ "16": {
+ "learnable_edges": 512,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.0125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.003125,
+ 0.025
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.03703125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.019348958333333336,
+ 0.05817708333333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.9,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8,
+ 0.975
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 127.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 66.75,
+ 196.25
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1015.4,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 532.463125,
+ 1565.40125
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 519884.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 272076.8,
+ 798733.1199999988
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 519884.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 274432.0,
+ 801043.8399999994
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 34.82084931528862,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 18.659156051735636,
+ 53.63843481787298
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.4020833333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.3552083333333333,
+ 0.44791666666666663
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.4027604166666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.35742968750000004,
+ 0.44797764756944447
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.06666666666666667,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.016666666666666666,
+ 0.125
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 562.5833333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 529.75,
+ 590.3333333333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 4349.65,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4063.0483333333336,
+ 4596.210625000001
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2227020.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2080149.5466666669,
+ 2352291.0933333337
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2227020.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2079853.333333333,
+ 2352661.44
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 173.64791361740978,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 159.73144830014044,
+ 186.21539449604305
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.0125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.003125,
+ 0.025
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.03586805555555556,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.018697699652777778,
+ 0.05558159722222222
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.9,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8,
+ 0.975
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 126.75,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 65.5,
+ 196.3354166666665
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1013.5,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 530.3795833333334,
+ 1550.3849999999998
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 518912.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 272503.4666666667,
+ 793489.0666666667
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1037824.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 544085.3333333333,
+ 1605232.2133333324
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 34.82653674711452,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 18.724034659901402,
+ 53.433058498483156
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0
+ },
+ "24": {
+ "learnable_edges": 1152,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.0125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.003125,
+ 0.025
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.038125000000000006,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.02421875,
+ 0.05388020833333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.9,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8,
+ 0.975
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 157.75,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 102.5,
+ 219.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1262.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 811.95,
+ 1744.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1453824.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 944640.0,
+ 2022912.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1453824.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 935424.0,
+ 2029881.599999995
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 49.95834978711372,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 32.33328414289582,
+ 70.0759598991163
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.453125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.4208333333333333,
+ 0.484375
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.456171875,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.42444422743055554,
+ 0.48767361111111107
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.03333333333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.008333333333333333,
+ 0.06666666666666667
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 580.6666666666667,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 561.1666666666667,
+ 595.25
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 4584.733333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4402.86625,
+ 4733.825208333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 5281612.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 5076786.96,
+ 5451187.44
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 5281612.8,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 5069529.12,
+ 5454472.5600000005
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 198.5021026034656,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 187.6982941297391,
+ 208.31642221697527
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.0125,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.003125,
+ 0.025
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.038888888888888896,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.02424435763888889,
+ 0.05529513888888889
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.9,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8,
+ 0.975
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 157.41666666666669,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 101.91666666666666,
+ 220.66666666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1259.3333333333335,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 814.0,
+ 1753.3499999999988
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1450752.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 931584.0,
+ 2026752.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 2901504.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1858560.0,
+ 4045862.3999999966
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 49.81015013120395,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 31.962821779374543,
+ 69.58022406475615
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 1.0
+ },
+ "32": {
+ "learnable_edges": 2048,
+ "methods": {
+ "overclamp_clean": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.00625,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.015625
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.04739583333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.033489583333333336,
+ 0.06263020833333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.95,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.875,
+ 1.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 201.75,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 148.5,
+ 258.5
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1614.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1194.0,
+ 2068.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 3305472.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2441216.0,
+ 4218880.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 3305472.0,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2433024.0,
+ 4222976.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 66.55174631846694,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 48.39995966640773,
+ 86.3040386186875
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.46875,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.4395833333333334,
+ 0.496875
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.47010416666666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.4415625,
+ 0.49762196180555546
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.025,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.05833333333333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 586.3333333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 568.6666666666667,
+ 600.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 4686.083333333334,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4551.416666666667,
+ 4795.416666666667
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 9597098.666666668,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 9317034.666666668,
+ 9821013.333333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 9597098.666666668,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 9321301.333333334,
+ 9821013.333333334
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 206.34409836292394,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 197.4930763843621,
+ 214.19155388584946
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "overclamp_sdil": {
+ "classification_error": {
+ "mean": 0.008333333333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.0010416666666666667,
+ 0.017708333333333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "classification_error_auc": {
+ "mean": 0.0475,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.033402560763888894,
+ 0.06287326388888889
+ ]
+ },
+ "reached_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 0.9333333333333332,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 0.8583333333333332,
+ 0.9916666666666666
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_epochs_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 199.41666666666666,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 146.66666666666666,
+ 257.33333333333337
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 1595.3333333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 1167.3333333333335,
+ 2066.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_edge_updates_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 3267242.6666666665,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 2389333.333333333,
+ 4224341.333333333
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_teaching_signal_reads_to_stable_zero_error": {
+ "mean": 6534485.333333333,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 4778666.666666667,
+ 8426905.599999994
+ ]
+ },
+ "restricted_learning_time_to_stable_zero_seconds": {
+ "mean": 65.86935077626708,
+ "task_bootstrap_95ci": [
+ 47.67382711660665,
+ 86.11764160301927
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "raw_to_clean_gap_closed": 0.9954954954954954
+ }
+ },
+ "excess_error_scaling": {
+ "x_axis": "log10 learnable edges",
+ "metric": "classification_error",
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope": 0.1144387597373537,
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ 0.0904045040605388,
+ 0.13792703633905537
+ ],
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope": 0.0011546410806012512,
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.0031168029013794486
+ ],
+ "paired_slope_difference": 0.11328411865675246,
+ "paired_slope_difference_95ci": [
+ 0.08951402205548885,
+ 0.13636007651773577
+ ],
+ "relative_slope_reduction_percent": 98.99104020067044,
+ "relative_slope_reduction_95ci": [
+ 97.35576080093969,
+ 100.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "excess_error_auc_scaling": {
+ "x_axis": "log10 learnable edges",
+ "metric": "classification_error_auc",
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope": 0.12478824245934202,
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ 0.10207053551972274,
+ 0.1474271109891999
+ ],
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope": -0.00010372352909852196,
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ -0.0005465189481836399,
+ 0.00037108693609977654
+ ],
+ "paired_slope_difference": 0.12489196598844055,
+ "paired_slope_difference_95ci": [
+ 0.10205303834844676,
+ 0.14752971026574413
+ ],
+ "relative_slope_reduction_percent": 100.08311963295127,
+ "relative_slope_reduction_95ci": [
+ 99.69456875165118,
+ 100.45472019909722
+ ]
+ },
+ "excess_stable_failure_scaling": {
+ "x_axis": "log10 learnable edges",
+ "metric": "reached_stable_zero_error",
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope": 0.2875158139793967,
+ "imperfect_overclamp_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ 0.21842692750033255,
+ 0.3556975718406047
+ ],
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope": 0.005298244678375035,
+ "overclamp_sdil_excess_slope_95ci": [
+ 0.0,
+ 0.013373452080144503
+ ],
+ "paired_slope_difference": 0.28221756930102165,
+ "paired_slope_difference_95ci": [
+ 0.21145628818531842,
+ 0.351816929173684
+ ],
+ "relative_slope_reduction_percent": 98.15723364741437,
+ "relative_slope_reduction_95ci": [
+ 94.86538193683744,
+ 100.0
+ ]
+ },
+ "sources": [
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side4.json",
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side8.json",
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side12.json",
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side16.json",
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side24.json",
+ "results/coupled_ladder/p3_overclamp_side32.json"
+ ]
+}