docs: register frozen oral B confirmation

1 files changed, 7 insertions, 1 deletions

diff --git a/PAPER_PLAN.md b/PAPER_PLAN.md
index e6c2465..483630f 100644
--- a/PAPER_PLAN.md
+++ b/PAPER_PLAN.md
@@ -149,6 +149,12 @@ numbering.
 - Residual decorrelation, decoder, and plasticity-lesion positives.
 - Wrong sign-inversion, error-magnitude dominance, and weak acute online
   lesion; desired velocity is unsupported.
+- Keep the original failed screen intact. The separately frozen recovery
+  factorizes learned causal role from within-episode performance innovation;
+  report it only if both its D4-gated development screen and untouched
+  6-task-by-5-model confirmation pass.
+- Even a complete recovery pass supports innovation-guided plasticity, not
+  online neural control: the recovery fixes `kappa=0` by construction.
 
 ### 7. Limitations and discussion
 
@@ -167,7 +173,7 @@ numbering.
 | “Depth does not help this task.” | Claim says preservation; C2 reports the learned-vectorizer failure; Oral-A A3 is retained as a failed standard-scale test | Fatal to a broad scaling claim; the paper must remain mechanism-focused |
 | “Local methods hide enormous extra work.” | Logical queries, MACs, peak memory, wall time, C3 confirmation, EP/native protocols | Hardware implementations are not all equally optimized |
 | “Weak baselines define the win.” | BP/FA/DFA/direct NP/FF/PEPITA/EP plus native BurstCCN and Dual Prop | Native reproductions are one seed and method-native, not equal compute |
-| “Harnett already proves the biological story.” | Oral-B preregistration and complete negative result | Biological contribution is limited without new data or a new passed prediction |
+| “Harnett already proves the biological story.” | Original oral-B negative result plus the separately frozen role/velocity recovery and untouched 30-record confirmation | No biological claim changes unless the recovery passes; `kappa=0` cannot support desired velocity |
 | “The fast controller is just an unreported contrastive phase.” | Paired neutral observation count and elementwise/wall cost are explicit; no task-nudged state, loss query, or reverse pass is used | The instruction-off microphase is a real assumption and weakens the single-phase biological claim |
 | “The gates were selected after results.” | Git-frozen protocols, untouched confirmation seeds, failed branches retained | Early inherited pilots predate the strict boundary and must remain labeled |